News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by foldr on Saturday April 29, 2023 @02:08PM (#35755479)
Indeed. This whole thing is just eugenics through the back door. The court should be aware that there are quite a number of historical examples of men having hundreds and even possibly thousands of children. This isn't any kind of threat to human genetic diversity worth worrying about (however objectionable the actions of the men in question might have been). If there is a reason to ban sperm donors from donating more than n samples, it's not this.

I do find the idea of someone fathering that many children inherently weird and creepy. It appears that this person is also accused of misleading the women who received the donations, which is obviously wrong in itself. There's probably all kinds of reasons to throw the book at this particular individual. I just wish the bullshit eugenic arguments could be left out of it.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by kevviiinn on Saturday April 29, 2023 @02:51PM (#35755870)
It may not be a threat to the genetic diversity of humans at large but when there are so many siblings in a local area who don't know they are siblings then the chance of recessive genetic disorders greatly increases
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by akira2501 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @02:56PM (#35755911)
They know precisely how they were parented and that the actual identity of one of their parents is technically unknown. These people will have to take a single additional genetic testing step in family planning to avoid the problem.
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by kevviiinn on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:20PM (#35756176)
You seem to be making a big assumption, do all recipients of sperm donors explain that to their children? I'm highly skeptical

People shouldn't have to go the route of genetic testing, which apparently has serious privacy implications, just to have kids

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by akira2501 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:35PM (#35756894)
> do all recipients of sperm donors explain that to their children?

I don't have children, so my question may come across as callous, but how would you not?

Aside from the genetic relatives issue there are a host of other medical issues and complications that arise from not having the full identity of the other parent. Considering that this particular part of the issue that can only arise in adulthood, I was sort of assuming that you'd almost certainly explain the situation to them by that point.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by anonymouskimmer on Saturday April 29, 2023 @05:02PM (#35757155)
You're ignoring that many people don't want to rock the boat. And anytime you tell a child that the person they thought was their daddy, isn't, you're rocking the boat. Regardless of the age of the child.

If this is an un-partnered mother and her children, then sure, much less excuse to not tell the kid, and much less reason to not tell them. But for partnered couples there's an inherent friction built in.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by kevviiinn on Saturday April 29, 2023 @06:23PM (#35757846)
You're again making a huge assumption, that which assumes that all people who have children are so responsible or have as much forethought
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by janc_ on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:49PM (#35756485)
He has been doing this for years. It's quite likely that a child born without a donor (and thus unsuspecting) but with a parent born from this donor will fall in love with a later child from this donor. Suddenly you have half-uncle/aunt procreating with half-nie ce/nephew...
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by ncallaway on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:53PM (#35756521)
So your theory is everyone who is a child of this person will be informed of that fact, and that before every one night stand all of these people will do a genetic screening before they fuck?

That just doesn’t sound very plausible to me…

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by eep_social on Saturday April 29, 2023 @05:08PM (#35757218)
from the article

> The donor "deliberately misinformed" prospective parents about the number of children he had already fathered in the past, the district court in The Hague said.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by epicureanideal on Saturday April 29, 2023 @02:53PM (#35755889)
Seems like the sibling network they discuss where people can become aware of who's related to them would solve that problem. What are the odds that 500 out of 5 million people would match with each other?
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by anonymouskimmer on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:41PM (#35756379)
It happens[1]. In part because people tend to find those who look similar to themselves most attractive[2]. There is a countering instinct to be repulsed by the idea of sex with people one was raised with[2], but this countering instinct doesn't happen if one wasn't raised with a family member.

1 - https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1311238/Brother-sis...

> The couple, who hailed from different towns, about 100 miles apart, were both out with friends when they met in a nightclub in a third town several years ago.

> So strong was their mutual attraction that just one week after meeting, they both felt they had known each other for a lifetime.

2 - https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-mysteries-love/2...

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by anonymouskimmer on Sunday April 30, 2023 @03:00PM (#35765532)
> Seems like the sibling network they discuss where people can become aware of who's related to them would solve that problem.

I'll also mention that such a sibling network can actually cause the problem.

https://au.news.yahoo.com/half-siblings-with-two-children-to...

> After tracking down her half-brother on Facebook, Ms Parra eventually met Mr Parra and the pair felt attracted to one another. "We didn't want to realise it, we were angry with ourselves because it was hard to admit and break that taboo: we are siblings even though we didn't feel that way."

> After just a few days, the half-siblings felt they couldn't carry on without seeing each other again. "Imagine liking a girl and, for a moral reason, being forbidden to be with her. It's really hard to deal with," Mr Parra declared.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by foldr on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:18PM (#35756745)
>then the chance of recessive genetic disorders greatly increases

It will increase somewhat, but not 'greatly'. At least, I would be interested to see some actual data on this for the case of the children of half siblings. For cousins the additional risk is very small: https://www.nytimes.com/2002/04/03/health/no-genetic-reason-...

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by amiga386 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:12PM (#35756099)
He's fathering a lot of children in a restricted geographic area, and he's not making clear to prospective mothers that he's doing this.

While incest is legal in the Netherlands, unintended inbreeding and genetic disorders are not good outcomes for a sperm donation service and so they have guardrails. He's well over the guardrails.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by foldr on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:10PM (#35756672)
I'm not sure that the risk of birth defects in the children of half-siblings is actually that high. You have to compare it to the risk when e.g. the couple is older, or one of them has a genetic disorder, one of them is obsese... There are lots of things than can increase the risk of birth defects.

People often wildly overestimate the actual risks of 'inbreeding' because their real objection is either an ethical one or a simple gross out reaction. That is, they're not making an informed estimate of the actual risks and then concluding that these are unacceptably high; they're just searching for a more objective justification for their gut reaction.

Unfortunately, the objective justification that most people reach for (the risk of birth defects) is a very steep slippery slope to eugenics. Once you admit the principle that a higher than average risk of birth defects is sufficient reason for a couple to be legally prohibited from having children, then you are basically there.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by amiga386 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @06:29PM (#35757882)
> they're not making an informed estimate of the actual risks

"Dutch clinical guidelines state that a donor should not father more than 25 children in 12 families."

Clinicians have already made the informed estimate for me. 500-600 children with the same parent is a more than the recommended 25.

> a couple to be legally prohibited

There are no couples involved here. There's this donor, a clinic with an ethics board, and their clients. The court are not even looking in the area you're so concerned about, and nobody is thinking of making any laws in that area.

Incest is not illegal in the Netherlands, so have it away with your mother/father/sister/brother if it makes you happy. But if you open a fertility clinic, I would hope that you adhere to clinical best practises, including reducing the risk of inadvertent inbreeding.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by foldr on Saturday April 29, 2023 @07:38PM (#35758376)
> Clinicians have already made the informed estimate for me.

If you just want to trust that this number has some kind of evidential basis to it then that’s fair enough on a personal level. If so then I suppose the conversation can’t go any further on this point. You trust the guidance. I would be interested to know if there is any scientific justification for the limit that isn’t simply eugenics in disguise.

> The court are not even looking in the area you're so concerned about, and nobody is thinking of making any laws in that area.

That’s my point. No-one in general is trying (get) to stop particular pairs of humans procreating based on estimates of the chances of birth defects in their children. So what’s the justification for doing it in this case?

(As I said before, there are probably lots of other reasons why what this guy has done is bad. I just don’t think this can be the reason.)