"Dutch clinical guidelines state that a donor should not father more than 25 children in 12 families."
Clinicians have already made the informed estimate for me. 500-600 children with the same parent is a more than the recommended 25.
> a couple to be legally prohibited
There are no couples involved here. There's this donor, a clinic with an ethics board, and their clients. The court are not even looking in the area you're so concerned about, and nobody is thinking of making any laws in that area.
Incest is not illegal in the Netherlands, so have it away with your mother/father/sister/brother if it makes you happy. But if you open a fertility clinic, I would hope that you adhere to clinical best practises, including reducing the risk of inadvertent inbreeding.
If you just want to trust that this number has some kind of evidential basis to it then that’s fair enough on a personal level. If so then I suppose the conversation can’t go any further on this point. You trust the guidance. I would be interested to know if there is any scientific justification for the limit that isn’t simply eugenics in disguise.
> The court are not even looking in the area you're so concerned about, and nobody is thinking of making any laws in that area.
That’s my point. No-one in general is trying (get) to stop particular pairs of humans procreating based on estimates of the chances of birth defects in their children. So what’s the justification for doing it in this case?
(As I said before, there are probably lots of other reasons why what this guy has done is bad. I just don’t think this can be the reason.)
People often wildly overestimate the actual risks of 'inbreeding' because their real objection is either an ethical one or a simple gross out reaction. That is, they're not making an informed estimate of the actual risks and then concluding that these are unacceptably high; they're just searching for a more objective justification for their gut reaction.
Unfortunately, the objective justification that most people reach for (the risk of birth defects) is a very steep slippery slope to eugenics. Once you admit the principle that a higher than average risk of birth defects is sufficient reason for a couple to be legally prohibited from having children, then you are basically there.