News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Cloudflare verification is breaking the internet by notatoad on Friday April 28, 2023 @02:14PM (#35745057)
there is no alternative. it sucks, and so people complain. the only solution is to just let people complain.

there's no way to solve this problem without having some sort of tracking system to determine who's a legitmate user.

Re:Tell HN: Cloudflare verification is breaking the internet by xcdzvyn on Friday April 28, 2023 @02:39PM (#35745342)
So, if somebody so wishes to take down a website they dislike, we should just put up with it? If a state actor DDoSes a journal documenting war crimes, we just ask them nicely to stop?
Re:Tell HN: Cloudflare verification is breaking the internet by notatoad on Friday April 28, 2023 @03:17PM (#35745840)
that's absolutely not what i'm saying. if somebody wishes to take down a website they dislike, we (as website operators) should block their bot traffic. and we should use whatever reasonable methods we have to detect what traffic comes from bots and what traffic doesn't come from bots. that includes putting cloudflare in front of our sites.

and when some legitimate users really, really look like bot traffic because they circumvent whatever methods we use to determine whether traffic is coming from real people, they might sometimes get blocked along with the bots. they're going to complain about that, and the only thing we can do is listen to their complaints.

Re:Tell HN: Cloudflare verification is breaking the internet by viraptor on Friday April 28, 2023 @08:02PM (#35748643)
That only works for you while you're not involved in the second group. We get to complain and make noise and push on both websites and CF, so that the "non-bot" user group doesn't become "latest chrome user on latest windows in the approved country running proprietary CF extention for id verification" one day in the future when it's an easier solution than dealing with the actual issue.
Re:Tell HN: Cloudflare verification is breaking the internet by notatoad on Saturday April 29, 2023 @12:02AM (#35749920)
sure, you get to complain. but what you don't get is for your complaints to change anything. unless you have a solution for thia? because that would be great.
Re:Tell HN: Cloudflare verification is breaking the internet by viraptor on Saturday April 29, 2023 @02:05AM (#35750449)
Sure. Solution: CF starts interacting with the reports of them blocking users and actually fixing those issues. If they can't achieve that, they can relax the rules and refund their customers for failing to provide the advertised service.

It's not a hard concept. Unless you think you're too big to care, you fix issues you cause.

Re:Tell HN: Cloudflare verification is breaking the internet by mschuster91 on Friday April 28, 2023 @02:53PM (#35745531)
> there's no way to solve this problem without having some sort of tracking system to determine who's a legitmate user.

There is: get the bad actors off of the Internet.

- governments (and basically everyone without a business presence in these countries) should ban interconnections with Russia, China, North Korea and Iran. No more shady Russian hacker forums, no more "bulletproof" botnet c&c hosters where every dumbass kid can buy botnet attacks, no more government-backed or -ran hacking campaigns. These four countries had their chance, we kept them online to allow their citizens free flow of information, but since all four block large parts of the Internet anyway (or don't make it available at all in the case of NK), I don't see any point in continuing making ourselves vulnerable.

- governments have to implement serious fines for makers of IoT products and software that ends up being mass-pwned, at least in cases of gross negligency, and mandate that firmware, tooling and corresponding crypto keys be open sourced after a product is no longer receiving security updates.

- governments have to mandate that providers on the Internet of all kind - ISPs, colos, mail providers, VPN services - should have abuse email contacts and act on reports in no less than 12 hours. "str0s" (servers that are 0wned) are no fun, and so are large providers who deem themselves to be so large that they don't have to give a fuck about abuse from their systems (Google, I'm looking at your Gmail service). And no one gets to claim "we're too big, we can't afford that!!!". Oh yes you can, Google. You rake in billions of dollars in profit a year, hire some customer service agents and stop externalizing the cost of abuse on everyone else.

- Discord should be outright shut down at this point. Absolutely zero moderation happening there, as long as you don't upload CSAM that can be caught by scanners Discord will not do anything proactively. Even if you're uploading TS/SCI classified material, no one gives a fuck until someone uploads the stuff to a public Telegram channel and people start digging.

Without serious, concerted effort among all nations to fight the problem at the source, it will only get worse.

And yes, I'm a bit pissed on how little accountability there is on the Internet. If you're big enough you can do whatever the fuck you want, no one will hold you accountable ever, and it's ruining everything.

Re:Tell HN: Cloudflare verification is breaking the internet by diego_sandoval on Friday April 28, 2023 @06:03PM (#35747663)
Maybe it could get solved by paying a couple of cents to the website administrator, in the form of cryptocurrency, and in exchange you get a few dozens of requests that the website agrees to reply to.
Re:Tell HN: Cloudflare verification is breaking the internet by codedokode on Friday April 28, 2023 @07:23PM (#35748403)
You don't need additional tracking, every user has a unique IP address. What is missing is a protocol that allows to reject traffic from specific IPs. Imagine if someone with IP address 1.1.1.1 sends 100 Gbit traffic to your host; your provider doesn't want to pay for this traffic so they nullroute you to stop the attack. If there was a protocol, you could simply block all those Gigabits on the upstream provider and if it doesn't comply with protocol then it has to cover all your losses. Then Cloudflare would become unnecessary.
Re:Tell HN: Cloudflare verification is breaking the internet by nerdbert on Friday April 28, 2023 @08:33PM (#35748816)
Whenever we get a flood of unwanted traffic dumped on us, it's coming from thousands of different IPs. They hijack everyone's old IoT trash and un-updated printers and wifi routers and Android 3.1 phones and use those to blast traffic. If it were coming from one IP address nobody would be bothered by it, it would be easily solved with rate-limiting rules on the firewall.
Re:Tell HN: Cloudflare verification is breaking the internet by zmgsabst on Friday April 28, 2023 @09:29PM (#35749102)
Push out proof-of-work challenges.
Re:Tell HN: Cloudflare verification is breaking the internet by HumanOstrich on Friday April 28, 2023 @09:54PM (#35749264)
Can you link to some resources where I could learn how to implement this for my sites?
Re:Tell HN: Cloudflare verification is breaking the internet by codedokode on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:39AM (#35763580)
Unless you are a small one-man company it is easy to find those IPs. The problem is how to block them because their traffic can use all your upstream bandwidth and blocking them on your host doesn't change anything.

> If it were coming from one IP address nobody would be bothered by it, it would be easily solved with rate-limiting rules on the firewall.

DDOS works by sending more traffic than your upstream bandwidth can carry (e.g. you have 100 Gbit link and they send 40 Tbit of UDP packets to you). Firewall won't help here. The protocol I am talking in a comment above would solve the problem by blocking this traffic close to its source.

Re:Tell HN: Cloudflare verification is breaking the internet by LocalH on Friday April 28, 2023 @09:13PM (#35749037)
> every user has a unique IP address

Not by any stretch of the imagination.