News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Science is a strong-link problem by DoreenMichele on Friday April 28, 2023 @01:42AM (#35737840)
Good read, though the food bits are trigger-warning worthy.

Science is about describing reality accurately, often describing an aspect of reality not easily and readily seen with the naked eye because it plays out over a long time or it's on a huge scale too large to view directly or a scale too tiny to see directly. It's about testing mental models to see what fits the facts and people want to be cautious about it because betting on an inaccurate model can have serious real world consequences.

Those consequences often cannot be undone.

I don't think it works to view it as one of these two models. I think science needs to both protect against quackery and also allow for innovation, even though those goals somewhat conflict.

Re:Science is a strong-link problem by szundi on Friday April 28, 2023 @01:51AM (#35737892)
Watching Sabine on YT for a time now I get the feeling that science can debunk quackery on the long run, sometimes in decades. Old guards who are gatekeepers of some of these misdirections have to die out. ~30-40 years to drop a major trend. Sooner or later the scientific method and the fallible humans operating it wins.
Re:Science is a strong-link problem by latency-guy2 on Friday April 28, 2023 @02:55AM (#35738309)
> Science is about describing reality accurately

Disagree with how you've generally phrased it. Science is much more about provability, given enough evidence. The evidence could be invented, or not. I would agree that it is about observing reality with many given limitations.

I don't believe science cares that much about being 'accurate', mainly because we use fundamentally flawed models of the universe to justify our research, and then go on to abusing 'p' given the outputs of those models.

I am of course, being a little of a hardass here, but until we invent/discover something better than models, I will always hold this opinion.

Re:Science is a strong-link problem by DoreenMichele on Friday April 28, 2023 @03:13AM (#35738422)
That sounds like you are talking about academia, not science.

Mendel, a man remembered as the father of genetics, was a friar who failed to pass his exams for becoming a certified teacher, so he became an abbot. At that point, his scientific work languished because his duties were too burdensome to allow time for it.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gregor_Mendel

Re:Science is a strong-link problem by latency-guy2 on Friday April 28, 2023 @03:56AM (#35738684)
I don't think I am focusing on academia, really.

I've made two major points, first about evidence or the invention of it, the second about models. I also inserted a smaller point on the usage of 'p'.

Evidence does not need a seal of approval from an institution to be considered 'good', just that statistically, using whatever tools we have, evidence has some semblance of validity that could represent something, potentially reality.

Models are those tools in pretty much all of science. Models are all broken, some fundamentally, others in just the nature of cost to develop one that can represent reality. But that's the crux, representing reality must be done cheaply and efficiently as you can, because accurately representing reality has way too much cost in just discovering all the variables to tweak. There will be no time for experiments if that is all you do. So you only have approximations to work with. Basically, you're never actually dealing with reality.

My smaller point of 'p' is just about how we firmly treat confidence intervals as measures of 'solid' research, which I guess can be extrapolated to academia, but I certainly don't think it's limited to academia.

Re:Science is a strong-link problem by DoreenMichele on Friday April 28, 2023 @04:00AM (#35738711)
Mendel wasn't trying to model reality. He worked with actual plants.

He's likely not the only scientist concerned with actual reality.

Re:Science is a strong-link problem by bhattid on Friday April 28, 2023 @09:32AM (#35741086)
Hopefully I'm not interpreting, but I think latency's point is more epistemological than a comment on "how science is being done". For example, scientists will still use Newtonian mechanics (as opposed to relativistic mechanics) to model reality even though we know it's "wrong". Part of this is pragmatic (tensor arithmetic is computationally expensive), but part of it is also because there's a beauty in the model itself and how it approximates what we observe. Taken to a greater extreme, we can also make Newtonian-like models that don't model observed reality at all, but

Ultimately though, I would say you're right overall - most scientists (in my experience) do want to understand the world/reality, and want to do it accurately.