News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by shingen on Thursday February 09, 2012 @12:17PM (#3571940)
He's wrong. Stocks do not beat gold once inflation outpaces the rate of average market returns, which is exactly where we're at now.

Gold is up 87 fold over 90 years or so. There is no way to capture that kind of return out of stocks, other than to buy one stock, Apple at the absolute bottom, or buy Dell the day it IPO'd or other similar freak scenarios, and then hold all the way through, and then sell at the absolute top. On a long term duration, it becomes increasingly difficult to survive even modest inflation and market changes (you have to constantly shift your investment strategies for all sorts of reasons: age, family, economic conditions, and so on). Few people are skilled enough to do that well.

With gold, you merely need to buy and hold - IF you believe the fiat currency will continue to depreciate due to 'printing' (to pay for entitlements, to devalue national debt, to fund deficits, and so on). There are very few things you could leave for your grandchildren that will retain their value, real estate and gold are two prime options.

If you had bought and held the stocks that make up the Dow over 60 or 70 years, you'd have gotten demolished because the Dow constantly shuffles its index. That is to say, you can't look at the Dow from 70 years ago and compare it to today, because the index is completely different, and the average investor could only easily purchase index ETFs in the last 30 or so years.

In reality, the Dow is not at 13,000 today as we knew 13k to be back in 1998/99 during the huge stock market bubble. Inflation has eroded that nominal value by at least half. The Dow is more likely at 5,000 to 6,500 depending on what you believe real inflation has been over the past 14 years (not the Fed's bogus CPI numbers).

The dollar has lost 97% of its value since the Fed came into existence. There's no way you can outrun that unless you hit homeruns in the stock market, which is what Buffett did, and which is exactly what your average investor cannot do regularly. The majority of people that invest in the stock market lose money. That's tracking since the late 1960s when the US went off the gold standard and inflation skyrocketed (sending oil, gold, and nearly everything radically higher).

Buffett hasn't made most of his wealth in the stock market anyway (nor that of Berkshire). He has made it by using insurance company float cash to purchase other high float companies, and then rolling that ball forward. Nearly all of his big market gains peg to one period of time, the 1970s, when stocks were once-in-a-generation cheap; his timing was brilliant, but it was an exceedingly rare scenario.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by InclinedPlane on Thursday February 09, 2012 @12:48PM (#3572102)
And if you'd bought gold at its peak in 1980 you'd still be down money, even 3 decades later.

Adjusted for inflation gold has gone up by a factor of about 4, but almost all of that has been within the last 10 years.

Anyone who thinks that gold is a dandy long-term investment is just as deluded as all of the fools who thought "this time it's different" about the last speculative real-estate bubble.

Edit: to put a finer point on it, if you would have bought gold in 1850 and sold it at any time recently except for during the speculative bubble of the late 70s or the last decade you would have lost money, around a quarter of your initial investment, or around negative 0.2 percent interest rate. If you would have bought gold at its low point in 1919 and held on to it for 80 years then sold it during some time in the 90s you would have just slightly more than doubled your money, for a whopping return of 1.2% per year.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by shingen on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:29PM (#3572300)
You reveal a huge bias by the fact that you selectively pick only an extreme event that spans about 0.001% of 30 years as a prime example.

The wild peak of gold in 1980 lasted for days, on a temporary burst higher. The average price of gold in 1980 was $615 or so. Your scenario requires that buyers of gold do not cost average over time, but rather that they only buy at very specific points in time and only sell at very specific points in time.

You could have just as easily purchased gold at $55 in 1972. Or $125 in 1977. Or in 1985 at $300. Or at $266 in 2001.

You make my point about gold: it's a wealth protector, not a vehicle for seeking big real returns. If you had bought gold in 1850 and passed it down the generations, that wealth would have been completely protected from the fiat disaster of the green back the past 90 years. You would not have grown the wealth in some spectacular fashion, because that is not what gold does.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by InclinedPlane on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:39PM (#3572365)
Gold is subject to speculative bubbles just as housing and stocks are. Gold is not a wealth protector unless you are lucky, but that's true of anything. If you buy gold during a speculative bubble then gold is more likely to be a wealth destroyer. If you buy gold today, near the peak of a classic and obvious speculative bubble then you are not doing yourself any favors.

Worse yet, gold tends to return to a constant value after speculative crashes. Compare that to property and stocks which tend to end up higher in the long term, regardless of speculation. If someone had invested their money into houses, land, or stocks in 1850 or 1919 they would have seen a vastly superior rate of return than from gold.

People who advocate buying gold right now are giving irresponsible advice that if followed will almost certainly lead to people losing money.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by shingen on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:51PM (#3572439)
You don't have to be lucky with gold.

You could have bought in roughly 88 of the last 90 years and been perfectly well protected over time from the loss of value in the dollar.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by InclinedPlane on Thursday February 09, 2012 @02:50PM (#3572710)
Indeed, it's always good to sell near the peak of a speculative bubble. What is your argument that "this time it's different" for gold? That the current exceptional run-up of gold prices over the last decade is sustainable and the current inflated gold price will be the price floor for the remainder of the 21st century?

If you're lucky enough to buy gold in the doldrums and sell it at the peak of a bubble, you make a killing. If you're unlucky enough to buy gold during a bubble and sell it during the doldrums you lose a lot of money. If you're neither lucky nor unlucky and buy and sell during the doldrums then you end up making a very paltry return on investment that is inferior to the average of other equally popular forms of investment (such as property or stocks).

Buying gold today is just as smart an investment as buying a house in 2006 or buying stock in pets.com in 1999.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by shingen on Thursday February 09, 2012 @03:07PM (#3572795)
No, I'm not making any argument that "this time is different".

I'm making the argument that the dollar is not going to increase in value over the next 10, 20, 30 years. Rather, the dollar is going to continue to lose large amounts of real purchasing power. Gold priced in dollars will rise accordingly.

Just calculating entitlement costs alone, the Fed will be required to massively devalue the dollar over the coming decades to keep a mass social panic from occurring due to defaults by the Feds on paying SS or Medicare et al.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by andylei on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:07PM (#3572196)
> Gold is up 87 fold over 90 years or so

Inflation adjusted, its closer to being up 3 fold:

http://inflationdata.com/inflation/images/charts/Gold/Gold_i...

Meanwhile, inflation adjusted, the S&P500 up more maybe 5 or 8 fold:

http://www.tradersnarrative.com/inflation-adjusted-chart-of-...

>> On a long term duration, it becomes increasingly difficult to survive even modest inflation and market changes

if you look at the gold price chart above, it's pretty clear that holding gold is not exactly smooth sailing either.

> With gold, you merely need to buy and hold - IF you believe the fiat currency will continue to depreciate due to 'printing'.

this is actually also true of stocks. stocks are a real asset in that they are claims on things that aren't directly tied to the money supply. if the fed prints more dollars, dollars are less valuable, but IBM's ability to make money also goes up by the same amount.

also, fundamentally, you're missing buffet's argument:

"this type of investment [(gold)] requires an expanding pool of buyers, who, in turn, are enticed because they believe the buying pool will expand still further. Owners are not inspired by what the asset itself can produce [(unlike stocks)] -- it will remain lifeless forever -- but rather by the belief that others will desire it even more avidly in the future."

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by shingen on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:37PM (#3572350)
Stocks are meant to be an investment vehicle, gold is not. The difference is, in an inflationary environment, stocks get murdered in real terms. That was the first line of my initial post in this thread.

The problem with stocks on the smooth sailing point, is that you can have a company that goes bankrupt, and plenty do over 30 years or more. You should look up the rather shocking numbers on how many publicly traded stocks have been vaporized in the last 30 years.

Gold does not go bankrupt, and it will not go to zero (if the last 2,000 years are any indication). Even more specifically, it won't go anywhere near zero.

With stocks you must constantly manage your holdings. With gold you do not have to manage it at all, assuming you didn't go chasing it on a bubble run (which represents less than 1% of the time duration that you could have bought gold over the last 60 years; 1980 for a few weeks for example).

There is a huge time management cost to stocks, most people simply do not have the time to focus on that. Skilled investors certainly do either have the time or the ability.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by andylei on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:55PM (#3572453)
> in an inflationary environment, stocks get murdered in real terms.

is there any evidence to back this up? is a logical reason why this would be true? i certainly can't think of any

> Gold does not go bankrupt, and it will not go to zero

yes, in this respect, stocks are riskier than gold. if minimizing investment risk is what you want, maybe you should buy gold, or maybe TIPS. however, most people also care about returns.

> There is a huge time management cost to stocks, most people simply do not have the time

this is an argument for ETFs, not an argument for gold

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by shingen on Thursday February 09, 2012 @02:28PM (#3572628)
Sure there is evidence, the 1970s provided lots of it, and the last 15 years have provided even more.

A quick glance at the Dow chart from 1960x to 1983x tells that story very well.

Gold did extremely well during the inflationary late 1960s and the 1970s. Stocks did horrifically terrible in the 1970s (which is where Buffett made a lot of his killing in the market, buying dirt cheap). Right up until the point where Volcker broke the back of inflation in the early 1980s, at which point stocks had a stellar run while inflation was relatively tame.

The reason this happens is: inflation hammers almost every core ingredient of an economy. It kills real savings, because the rate of return on cash can never outrun inflation. It pushes up of the price of commodities that producers need, while eroding wages capabilities for the bottom 90% (the rich can shield their wealth from inflation, poor can't shield their wages). That makes producing things more expensive, while simultaneously limiting the ability to raise prices on consumers that have less real cash to spend. So it squeezes companies, and it erodes real growth.

If you have a 5% to 10% net profit margin, and you're growing at 5% to 10% per year, which are perfectly common rates for most businesses - if you run real inflation at 5%, you're making it radically harder to survive random risk events in the course of business, you're removing critical points of profit and the ability to stick back cash for a rainy day. In effect, that hammers the stock market because it's an inter-connected economy in which IBM or Microsoft or Dell or Cisco all depend on small businesses. And so on and so forth.

There are now a lot of ETFs, you still have to pick among roughly 1,000 of them.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by gibybo on Thursday February 09, 2012 @12:54PM (#3572131)
>Gold is up 87 fold over 90 years or so. There is no way to capture that kind of return out of stocks, other than to buy one stock

$1 in gold 90 years ago: $87 today (by your number anyway)

$1 in a basket of stocks that were traded to match the DOW starting 90 years ago: $174 today (from the article's numbers)

Keep in mind this includes the recent 5 year period where gold has shot up and stocks have performed miserably. If we picked different dates, gold would be even further behind.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by Czarnian on Thursday February 09, 2012 @04:50PM (#3573263)
I must be missing something. The situation described is not a fold. When talking about folding, you're really talking about doubling. For $1 in gold to increase 87-fold, it would have a value of approximately 7.7 times 10 to the 25th power. I'm pretty sure that was not the intent.

What's really being said is that $1 in gold has gone up 8700%. Compared to the same dollar going up 17,400% in stocks.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by shingen on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:12PM (#3572213)
The problem is you could have actually owned gold for 90 years. Average Joe could have bought gold and held it.

You could not have owned the Dow index for 90 years and then left that to your children or grandchildren.

Would you like to still be holding Polaroid or Kodak? Or perhaps just bought and held the classic Dow index perpetual GM? You would have gotten wiped out in the Dow shuffling. The Dow gets to drop something like GM at its convenience, but if you had bought its stocks in a basket format (not an ETF), you'd literally be holding worthless old GM shares, and a lot of other worthless shares that they don't currently count in today's Dow numbers.

The Dow calculation is a theoretical, not an actual. 90 years ago only a very savvy investor could have owned a basket of stocks to mirror and index exactly and constantly traded in and out of the market. In 1920, an exceedingly small % of people owned or had access to equity markets.

Buffet using even 1965 as the reference point is disingenuous because of those reasons. His scenario is not a normal one: he used his father's brokerage firm to commit his first market transactions back in his early days. How many Dow tracking ETFs existed in 1965? How many people owned stocks in 1965? Today you can open an account at Scottrade or wherever, and pay a mere $7 transaction fee to buy stocks.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by gibybo on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:35PM (#3572338)
The Dow doesn't get to drop GM after it goes bankrupt and then not count its losses. The decline of GM hurt the Dow index just as much as it would have hurt anyone else that bought and sold GM stock when the Dow index added/dropped it.

It also represents an average of the market, so the fact that it was hard to mirror it exactly is not particularly relevant. Mirroring it approximately, or buying any other large basket of stocks, would have led to roughly the same result.

While it's true that an investment in Gold was better than an investment in USD, it wasn't better than common stock equities. You said the only way to capture a return better than Gold was to buy a particular stock at IPO, but that's just factually incorrect.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by shingen on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:50PM (#3572435)
The Dow gets to replace GM with another growth vehicle of the modern era. While you take a real beating on the shares, the Dow simply swaps in a new stock (typically one with brighter prospects that can recharge the lost value in the Dow).

You can't swap your dead GM shares for the shares in, say, John Deere when it's added to the index. Your money is gone.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by stouset on Thursday February 09, 2012 @04:55PM (#3573278)
You, simply put, utterly fail to understand how indexes work.
Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by william42 on Thursday February 09, 2012 @04:51PM (#3573267)
There are index funds that swap out exactly the same way the Dow does.
Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by weavejester on Thursday February 09, 2012 @03:14PM (#3572829)
"The problem is you could have actually owned gold for 90 years. Average Joe could have bought gold and held it."

I don't understand why this is a problem.

You seem to be arguing that if you were a person of average wealth, thinking about investment 90 years ago, gold might have been a reasonable choice.

But if I want to invest today, investing in an ETF will almost certainly give me far greater return than gold.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by johngalt on Thursday February 09, 2012 @12:46PM (#3572088)
"In reality, the Dow is not at 13,000 today as we knew 13k to be back in 1998/99 during the huge stock market bubble. Inflation has eroded that nominal value by at least half. The Dow is more likely at 5,000 to 6,500 depending on what you believe real inflation has been over the past 14 years (not the Fed's bogus CPI numbers)."

...

"Nearly all of his big market gains peg to one period of time, the 1970s, when stocks were once-in-a-generation cheap; his timing was brilliant, but it was an exceedingly rare scenario."

You are on to something here, and you don't recognize it.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by fennecfoxen on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:12PM (#3572214)
Many economists believe that the CPI actually overstates inflation, in the long run, for a variety of reasons - quips about how "you can't eat an iPad" notwithstanding.
Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by andjones on Thursday February 09, 2012 @12:59PM (#3572154)
Gold per ounce

1968 $39.31 2012 $1,750.00 (current price give or take)

http://www.nma.org/pdf/gold/his_gold_prices.pdf

Berkshire Hathaway one share

1968 $36.00 2012 $118,000.00 (current price give or take)

http://allfinancialmatters.com/2008/04/02/a-look-at-berkshir...

Which would you rather invest in?

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by brown9-2 on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:31PM (#3572311)
Comparing the price-change in gold to the price-change in just one stock is cherry-picking the data, no matter how correct your main argument is.
Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by sliverstorm on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:13PM (#3572217)
There are very few things you could leave for your grandchildren that will retain their value

How about well-educated and well-raised parents for said grandchildren?

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by brown9-2 on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:34PM (#3572326)
In reality, the Dow is not at 13,000 today as we knew 13k to be back in 1998/99 during the huge stock market bubble. Inflation has eroded that nominal value by at least half. The Dow is more likely at 5,000 to 6,500 depending on what you believe real inflation has been over the past 14 years (not the Fed's bogus CPI numbers).

Am I correct in interpreting this to mean that you believe that inflation has been 100% over the past 12 years (that what you could have gotten for $13 in 1999 would only get you half the same basket of goods today)?

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by shingen on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:42PM (#3572385)
By the 1980 CPI, inflation is running at closer to 9% right now. So yes, I'm saying inflation has been chugging at a brutal pace the past 12 years. When the CPI was that high back then, Volcker had to take extreme measures to tame inflation. When inflation was 3% to 4% in 1970/1971, Nixon installed price and wage controls. Now when it's much higher on our new CPI, we don't even bat an eyelash at the extreme inflation.

You might think, for example, that real estate has gotten cheap? It's up 100% over the last 12 years in real estate disaster zones like Phoenix. How many people have seen their wages climb 100% in the last 12 years? That's pure inflation, as the historical rate of return on real estate is closer to 1% to 2% per year.

You can also blatantly track the huge inflation of the last 12 years in most commodities.

The current Fed CPI, which was altered during the early Clinton years to hide real inflation, says that inflation is around 3%x. It leaves out all sorts of fun inflationary items (because the Fed says they're volatile, har har).

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by Aloisius on Thursday February 09, 2012 @02:06PM (#3572515)
What kind of fun inflationary items? And please don't say gold or oil as it would be an extreme case of cherry picking commodities.
Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by shingen on Thursday February 09, 2012 @02:42PM (#3572683)
The Fed CPI excludes food and energy.

So when milk goes from $1.50 to $3.60 per gallon over 20 years, they pretend that never happened.

Or when gasoline goes from $0.75 to $3.59 over 30 years, they pretend that never happened.

They pretend you don't need to eat food or drive anywhere.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by Aloisius on Thursday February 09, 2012 @03:12PM (#3572819)
Uh, the Fed CPI does include food and energy prices. The government does have a separate "core" inflation number which excludes food and energy prices, but the regular CPI number includes food and energy and has forever.

Specifically, the CPI-U includes food & energy, but economic analysts and policymakers like to use the CPI-U for All Items Less Food and Energy because of the volatility of commodities.

The CPI-U however is still available and was last sitting at 3% for 2011. Again, that's with food & energy. http://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.nr0.htm

Not only that, but the numbers that exclude food and energy make inflation look higher than when they are included.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by guelo on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:04PM (#3572180)
You talk like the price of gold has never gone down or been stagnant for decades at a time. How much of that 87 fold is due to the last decade?
Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by shingen on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:58PM (#3572474)
That's the entire point.

Inflation has been substantial the past decade. Gold would have shielded you from it.

You buy gold for the protection it offers from the devaluation in the dollar (in this case), not because you think you're going to get rich from it.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by dman on Thursday February 09, 2012 @12:22PM (#3571966)
Are you taking dividend yields into account?
Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by shingen on Thursday February 09, 2012 @12:32PM (#3572023)
Yes.

The S&P for example has had a roughly 2% average dividend yield on its basket of stocks over the past several decades. That helps, as without that dividend value the real return for stocks would be even worse the past decade.

For dividends to work in an inflationary environment, you need serious yield. AT&T and Verizon as common stocks would get you close with their 6%x yields. Most people these days of course can't get access to good yield on anything with interest rates on the floor (corporate debt and select few dividends being nearly the sole safe exceptions).

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by william42 on Thursday February 09, 2012 @04:33PM (#3573196)
"If you had bought and held the stocks that make up the Dow over 60 or 70 years, you'd have gotten demolished because the Dow constantly shuffles its index."

No, but if you put your money into an index fund, you'd be shuffling your money exactly when Dow did.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by illumin8 on Thursday February 09, 2012 @12:29PM (#3572012)
Why are you being downvoted? Your comment is spot-on. Look at the market performance of 2011 and you will see why:

Stocks: +0.93% US Treasury Bonds (Long Term): +33% Gold: +10%

He's exactly right about Buffet. Buffet makes all his money because Berkshire Hathaway collects all of these insurance premiums and he can use the cash flow float to make a few extra points of interest (above inflation). Do this with enough $billions for long enough and you will own all of the money in the world.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by lotharbot on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:24PM (#3572270)
Single-year performance is a terrible measure of the value of an investment.
Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by EricDeb on Thursday February 09, 2012 @12:43PM (#3572070)
So what is your investment recommendation then? Avoid the market and invest in Gold?
Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by shingen on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:04PM (#3572177)
Not exactly. If you're asking as a skilled money manager or investor, I'll give you X advice. If you're asking what I think the average Joe should do (someone with limited time and skill when it comes to money management), I'll give you Z advice. A lot of it depends on how hard you're willing to work to protect and grow your wealth.

If the market is near 13k like it is today, with corporate profit margins at all time highs (cyclically impossible that they'll stay up there), I'd say you should be out of the market. Corporations are accumulating debt at the fastest pace in history (which is one of the reasons they're also hoarding cash, as an offset). When rates spike higher as they eventually must, those companies will get demolished. Far better to wait for the next plunge and be opportunistic, than to hope for a few more points on top of this already huge several year run. Buffett's mantra works very well in that case: be greedy when others are fearful, and fearful when others are greedy.

Buy gold on big drops, like when it fell from $1900x to $1530x recently; but never chase it when it runs. Keep it a modest part of your portfolio (10% to 25% depending on your particularly preferences). It's not a growth vehicle, it's a wealth protection device.

Corporate debt is a great place to get good yield right now, but again you have to know what you're buying.

It's perfectly fine to take an annual hit on inflation against liquid dollars (granted that's under, say, 10%); better to have opportunity cash available. Typically people miss big opportunities because of a lack of cash. Really big opportunities are not that rare, they come around every 3 to 5 years, and the returns you can make off of them are extraordinary. You buy the Dow at 7,000 when everybody else is writhing in pain from the ride down from 14k.

Own commodities when they're occasionally cheap. For example, when potash crashed during the global implosion a few years ago, you could have purchased stocks like POT for 80% off. When oil was $10 or $12 circa the late 1990s, the common 'wisdom' was that oil was dead, a terrible investment, and so on. In reality, cheap energy is almost never a terrible long term invest. The human desire / need for cheap energy will continue to be infinite, which ensures that prices will swing up at some point (even if it takes several years).

Right now, I'd tell most people to look around themselves and invest there. Get a strategically better education perhaps; or find a good business to purchase or invest into. Something you can directly apply your sweat equity to with multiplication potential. Shield your wealth until you find the right opportunities; people seem to often undervalue patience. You don't need lots of homeruns, you need very few.

In this environment, it's all about having liquidity to be opportunistic. The volatility in the global economy is almost guaranteed to produce wild swings over time. When people panic, be there with your cash.

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by stouset on Thursday February 09, 2012 @05:09PM (#3573340)
So let me get this straight.

Half of your thesis is that gold is great because you don't have to do anything but sit on it and hold it, unlike stocks (we'll pretend that index funds don't exist in your fairy-tale world). The amateur investor can just buy and hold, no rebalancing necessary.

And then you turn around and, as investment advice, essentially say "The trick is to, without the benefit of hindsight, figure out what each next bull market is going to be, buy it at the bottom and sell it when it's at the top."

Fantastic fucking advice. Mind if I borrow your time machine sometime?

Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds by EricDeb on Thursday February 09, 2012 @03:36PM (#3572937)
Unbelievable response. I am a lowly CS grad student at the moment so investment is not my greatest concern, but hopefully in the near future I will have some money to invest. When that day comes I will take a second look at your advice from a practical perspective. At this point it is fun to fantasize though...