Re:Warren Buffett: Why stocks beat gold and bonds
by shingen on Thursday February 09, 2012 @01:50PM
(#3572435)
The Dow gets to replace GM with another growth vehicle of the modern era. While you take a real beating on the shares, the Dow simply swaps in a new stock (typically one with brighter prospects that can recharge the lost value in the Dow).
You can't swap your dead GM shares for the shares in, say, John Deere when it's added to the index. Your money is gone.
It also represents an average of the market, so the fact that it was hard to mirror it exactly is not particularly relevant. Mirroring it approximately, or buying any other large basket of stocks, would have led to roughly the same result.
While it's true that an investment in Gold was better than an investment in USD, it wasn't better than common stock equities. You said the only way to capture a return better than Gold was to buy a particular stock at IPO, but that's just factually incorrect.