Because I want that apartment on One Central Park that costs $17 million and I want a chauffeur at 50k a year and a PA at 100k a year and someone to take care of my kids for 100k a year (no sketchies). I also want to be able to hire a plane when I want to do I can zoom out to Tripoli or Nigeria when interesting things happen and no private charter will go.
Maybe I'm being the stereotypical New Yorker, but I can see 30, 50, even 100 million dollars whisking away rather fast. You know what traders call $100 million of personal income? A unit. It's the starting point.
Note: CEO pay is not, when done sensibly, where the Board goes "Mark, you look damn handsome today - here is a hundred million. Go wild." It is a structured pay where you try and align incentives, that is, give the CEO upside when he does well and some downside when he doesn't. You want to encourage sensible risk-taking, remove principal-agent issues, and deal with moral hazard. Most pay for CEOs comes in stock grants or via other non-cash instruments. It is also usually not guaranteed up front.
This is the highest voted counter-argument?
CEO pay in Fortune 500s is upper-class back-scratching. Nothing more. It has nothing to do with performance.
My vanity is technology. I also place a premium on having a living space that is aesthetically pleasing. A colleague of mine gets a similar aesthetic thrill from beautiful clothes. I tend to judge people whose vanities are primarily outward facing, e.g. buying an expensive car not because you appreciate the craftmanship but because you want to look snappy in it, but that's for the potential insecurity it alludes to rather than the indulgence itself.
A $17 million purchase is proportionally peanuts to some people. What you and I may call peanuts is a lifetime of difference to someone in the third world. Classifying materialism on such a high level seems absurd.
Paying $50 million for trophy real estate instead of investing it into better transportation (the only long-term solution to the real estate problem in New York and Silicon Valley) makes a person a douche.
Using a private 747 for casual transportation, logging an unconscionable ecological footprint through the unnecessary combustion of hydrocarbons in enormous amounts, makes one a douche.
Developing a tight social network to keep global society exclusive, closed and impoverished is a douche move.
Corrupting the U.S. political system and getting the world's most powerful nation into an unwinnable War of Corporate Enrichment (Iraq) is a douche move.
Morally speaking, the tip-top upper classes of the U.S. owe their lives to us in the cognitive 1 percent. They are deep in moral debt to us, and what keeps us from collecting is that we have more interesting things to do (in technology, where we can make positive-sum contributions to the world). We have the persuasive capability and the technological know-how to rise up and take them out, Paris 1793 style. We don't, because for enough of us, life remains pretty good. We're not "among them", and they constantly remind us of this fact; but we can work in technology, live pretty well, and generally control our own destinies. If that ever changes, though, those people need to watch the fuck out.
That's why there's no correlation between the pay and the results, and that's why what you're defending is perverse.
Also, there is a correlation between pay and performance. You can't just strike out the empirical record for rhetorical convenience. It's closer tied to portion of pay in low-struck options, etc. versus cash pay but statistically significant nonetheless.
TBH, if I heard a CEO of a for-profit didn't try to get a higher pay package, I'd be wondering about this CEO's business skill.
But it's not what his performance or his quality of life is based on.
Rather, fingers should be pointed at Boards who agree to ridiculous compensation packages.
That's because you, like all people, suck at thinking rationally.
:D
In reality, the reverse is often true. You can have too much pizza (though it can be fun to try). You can't have too much in your bank account (or investment portfolio).
If I, for example, were making 1m a year as a software engineer but still had to answer to someone else and deal with bullshit (read anything I didn't want to deal with - politics, TPS reports, writing boring software, limits on vacation), I'd still be as unhappy as I would be at twice the pay. More money wouldn't make the situation any more palatable. Getting a position that lessened the bullshit would. That position could take several forms, and there's many different levers (e.g. paid vacation, a position of substantial autonomy) I can pull besides money to increase my satisfaction.
I can't imagine, though, that most CEO's can move those levers drastically. It's not like you can negotiate for a more reasonable board come hiring time. CEO's don't take vacation in the same way you and I do, and even if they did, I'm not sure a CEO who fought to take time away from his company would be thought of favorably.
But you can't have the best pizza in the world without potentially spending thousands of dollars to get yourself to Naples.
That's an extreme example, but I assume those economists mean that almost any category of good can reach arbitrary levels of consumption. If I had several billion dollars, my pizza acquisition budget might literally be 1000x what it is now.
You're only looking at it from the executive's POV, not the company's. They are looking for the best they can find. It may be worth it to them to pay, $X million more for somebody who scores a 99 on a hypothetical CEO test, compared to somebody who scores only 98. The company wants to get somebody better, and to get that higher quality, they've got to fork over additional compensation.
Of course, companies are frequently wrong in the way that they score their candidates. But that doesn't change the fact that they've bidding on the highest perceived quality.
Anybody who doesn't want the job enough to do it for 10 million but would do it for 100 million is going to SUCK at the job. Period.
I think you're assuming to much in this statement. It's not clear that they would not be willing to do the job for $10 million. But there are 100 different companies who would be willing to pay them that much, and they've got to make a decision somehow. Other things being equal, they'll go with the one that offers the most.
This is exactly what pricing does in a market. It allows the participants to signal the importance of a product to them. That $100million bidder is signalling that it's more important to him to get mister AAA CEO. Is there some reason that we should ignore that bidder's signal?
Was Steve Jobs a $1/year CEO? How about Sergey Brin?
Good leaders typically have different motivations than "I could afford to upgrade my yacht from 10 million to 25 million". I understand that that complicates your economic model, but guess what, it's people we're talking about here.
But they have an important indirect impact: wealth correlates with power; if you're richer, you can control more businesses, and run them the way you'd like. Thus, high marginal income taxes keep the old guard in power longer, and mean that ambitious people with new ideas take longer to take control.
High income taxes and capital gains taxes will mean that proportionately more of the world's companies will be owned and run by Rockefellers and du Ponts rather than Zuckerbergs.
So, what false assertion did I make?
It's interesting to read the first Forbes 400 list; there's a lot of old money there. Not so much lately.
Think about the people you know who are good at their job. Do they give a fuck about money if you give them enough that they're taken care of? No, they probably care a lot more about prestige, interesting problems, other ego-feeders besides a silly 8-digit number.
Of course, CEOs are bound to be good negotiators and will negotiate themselves a higher number because why not. But is anyone going to argue that there's a serious quality of life difference between 20 and 100 million?