News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Focus: Executive pay and performance by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday February 08, 2012 @10:41AM (#3566913)
Because I want to have enough money to say hey, people should go to Mars and so I'll start a company that does that. I want to pursue social, medical research, and technological policy on my own terms which needs my own capital.

Because I want that apartment on One Central Park that costs $17 million and I want a chauffeur at 50k a year and a PA at 100k a year and someone to take care of my kids for 100k a year (no sketchies). I also want to be able to hire a plane when I want to do I can zoom out to Tripoli or Nigeria when interesting things happen and no private charter will go.

Maybe I'm being the stereotypical New Yorker, but I can see 30, 50, even 100 million dollars whisking away rather fast. You know what traders call $100 million of personal income? A unit. It's the starting point.

Note: CEO pay is not, when done sensibly, where the Board goes "Mark, you look damn handsome today - here is a hundred million. Go wild." It is a structured pay where you try and align incentives, that is, give the CEO upside when he does well and some downside when he doesn't. You want to encourage sensible risk-taking, remove principal-agent issues, and deal with moral hazard. Most pay for CEOs comes in stock grants or via other non-cash instruments. It is also usually not guaranteed up front.

Re:Focus: Executive pay and performance by jbooth on Wednesday February 08, 2012 @01:38PM (#3567804)
So, corporations should pay CEOs bigger salaries, because it's the most effective way to boost human space travel?

This is the highest voted counter-argument?

Re:Focus: Executive pay and performance by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday February 08, 2012 @06:12PM (#3569040)
It's a broad metaphor for companies giving executives incentives to earn income that comports with the value they produced for shareholders. The incentives drive these executives far beyond where it has material significance for them because there are things beyond the material which money can increase the probability of attaining and that many people aspire towards.
Re:Focus: Executive pay and performance by michaelochurch on Wednesday February 08, 2012 @11:16AM (#3567079)
So are you a douche, a douche sympathizer, or being ironic? Inquiring minds want to know.

CEO pay in Fortune 500s is upper-class back-scratching. Nothing more. It has nothing to do with performance.

Re:Focus: Executive pay and performance by showerst on Wednesday February 08, 2012 @12:15PM (#3567364)
Please keep your comments civil/constructive. Calling someone a douche because you disagree with their materialism does not add to the discussion, and is frowned on here.
Re:Focus: Executive pay and performance by michaelochurch on Wednesday February 08, 2012 @01:06PM (#3567648)
I wasn't calling him a douche. I realized halfway through reading his post that he was being ironic.
Re:Focus: Executive pay and performance by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday February 08, 2012 @06:08PM (#3569026)
It wasn't total hyperbole. I don't think it's fair to demonise one person's vanities over another on the basis of personal preference.

My vanity is technology. I also place a premium on having a living space that is aesthetically pleasing. A colleague of mine gets a similar aesthetic thrill from beautiful clothes. I tend to judge people whose vanities are primarily outward facing, e.g. buying an expensive car not because you appreciate the craftmanship but because you want to look snappy in it, but that's for the potential insecurity it alludes to rather than the indulgence itself.

A $17 million purchase is proportionally peanuts to some people. What you and I may call peanuts is a lifetime of difference to someone in the third world. Classifying materialism on such a high level seems absurd.

Re:Focus: Executive pay and performance by michaelochurch on Wednesday February 08, 2012 @08:55PM (#3569453)
Paying $10 million for artwork and never looking at it makes a person a douche. The person is paying eight figures to deprive someone else of having it-- nothing more. It's not "supporting the arts". It's being a hypercompetitive shitfuck.

Paying $50 million for trophy real estate instead of investing it into better transportation (the only long-term solution to the real estate problem in New York and Silicon Valley) makes a person a douche.

Using a private 747 for casual transportation, logging an unconscionable ecological footprint through the unnecessary combustion of hydrocarbons in enormous amounts, makes one a douche.

Developing a tight social network to keep global society exclusive, closed and impoverished is a douche move.

Corrupting the U.S. political system and getting the world's most powerful nation into an unwinnable War of Corporate Enrichment (Iraq) is a douche move.

Morally speaking, the tip-top upper classes of the U.S. owe their lives to us in the cognitive 1 percent. They are deep in moral debt to us, and what keeps us from collecting is that we have more interesting things to do (in technology, where we can make positive-sum contributions to the world). We have the persuasive capability and the technological know-how to rise up and take them out, Paris 1793 style. We don't, because for enough of us, life remains pretty good. We're not "among them", and they constantly remind us of this fact; but we can work in technology, live pretty well, and generally control our own destinies. If that ever changes, though, those people need to watch the fuck out.

Re:Focus: Executive pay and performance by jbooth on Thursday February 09, 2012 @09:18AM (#3571173)
Someone who's obsessed with silly status-signalling stuff like that is almost guaranteed to be a bad leader.

That's why there's no correlation between the pay and the results, and that's why what you're defending is perverse.

Re:Focus: Executive pay and performance by JumpCrisscross on Monday February 13, 2012 @09:54PM (#3588420)
The point I had was things can be bought for their inherent aesthetic value, independent of status signalling. Status signalling, while a deeply rooted biological behaviour, is a primitive imitation of the former.

Also, there is a correlation between pay and performance. You can't just strike out the empirical record for rhetorical convenience. It's closer tied to portion of pay in low-struck options, etc. versus cash pay but statistically significant nonetheless.