News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by gravitronic on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:23PM (#35644081)
What an insane dependency tree, that driving a truck in a field to plant some seeds requires a computer operating in space. I really hope there is a push-back on this unbounded complexity. Mind boggling.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by kube-system on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:33PM (#35644216)
It's only silly if you have an outdated "romanticized" image of farming in your head. Those images are from a time when >50% of the population farmed. Technology is what has enabled the vast majority of people in developed societies to do things other than farming.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by benj111 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:38PM (#35644281)
There's a massive gap between >50% of the population farming and GPS guided tractors that apparently don't need a driver.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by kube-system on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:46PM (#35644395)
Yes, and that divide includes genetic engineering, weather satellites, teams of chemists, million dollar tractors, a finance and logistics infrastructure, and a whole lot of other stuff that doesn't look anything like American Gothic. GPS guided tractors are not remarkable in that continuum.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by mistrial9 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:53PM (#35644493)
this thinking in the previous industrial age created the poison wastelands of Ohio. Mudslinging with the tag "American Gothic Farming" adds to the arrogance of it all. American farming is largely a flaming disaster on top of destruction, with other would-be plantation owners racing to copy it. Plenty of blame to go around, and this contrite endorsement of all and anything futuristic, ain't the cure.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by kube-system on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:55PM (#35644529)
Famine kind of sucks too.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:43PM (#35646011)
Mic drop :-)
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by mardifoufs on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:10PM (#35645626)
The article is about Australia. There's no need to go on a self-loathing rant about where you live.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by benj111 on Friday April 21, 2023 @01:32AM (#35650085)
So why did you jump straight to >50% of the population farming then?

We aren't going back to mediaeval times just because satnav stopped working.

Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by tedunangst on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:45PM (#35644383)
I'm pretty sure we got below the 50% farmer threshold without using GPS. Or has this all happened in the last twenty years?
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by kube-system on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:51PM (#35644465)
I'm sure someone was scoffing at how "ridiculous" it was the first moment a farmer took a Tin Lizzy into the field and it needed a new clutch. Technology "in the field" is so normal that it is an idiom.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by bluSCALE4 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:35PM (#35645087)
Right but they probably had 10x farm hands and no yield contractual agreements.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by bluGill on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:06PM (#35645545)
Your image of the farm is from when >50% of the population farmed though.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by tedunangst on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:46PM (#35646042)
My image of the farm is from when about 2% of the workforce farmed. I don't think self driving tractors have changed it that much.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by bluGill on Thursday April 20, 2023 @05:42PM (#35646766)
You are usual then.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by ChatGTP on Thursday April 20, 2023 @07:09PM (#35647758)
To get replaced by chat bots in the year 2024.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by 6510 on Friday April 21, 2023 @02:14AM (#35650295)
It just struck me that this solves Graebers useless jobs puzzle! If humanity survived and evolved when there was no time for other jobs non of the other jobs are useful. There was a time before farming too! Imagine that! What a paradox!

Reminds me how we technologied all of the fish out of the water and pretended we got more fish that way.

On the other tab I just learn that trusted publishers are a mechanism. Plants are mechanisms too! If you let them struggle without helping them they will figure out a way. Even if you help them you (the human) are not growing the plant. If you open the curtain you are not rising the sun. The plant grows the plant. We've done a great job making it dependent on our nm technology. It's now pampered, weak, lazy and addicted to convenience. We've made food in our own image. If it could talk it would disagree with me and praise socialism.

Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by jasonpeacock on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:30PM (#35644159)
They aren't driving a truck, the truck is driving itself and is guided by a high-resolution GPS-like service.

Providing a high-resolution GPS-like service at affordable scale is not simple.

Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by thebooktocome on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:41PM (#35644333)
I think a more charitable read of OP is that you don’t need a satellite (or even GPS) to provide centimeter-accurate localization over a wide area. Spacebound systems are always going to have worse uptime and less resiliency than ground ones.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by klyrs on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:08PM (#35644724)
One can imagine planting a few posts at the corners of a field with a few dollars worth of radio equipment each, and getting higher resolution without relying on satellite.

Reading other comments here, it seems that these exist, in tandem with GPS, to get absolute positioning. But I don't see why absolute positioning would be needed; relative positioning should suffice.

Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by j16sdiz on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:24PM (#35644952)
It worth a lot more than “a few dollars”

Most technology give you 20+ cm resolution[1], the one farmer are using are at ~4cm resolution .

[1] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11277-021-08209-5

Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by klyrs on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:39PM (#35645151)
I was thinking of component cost when I said a few dollars; of course a commercial product is going to sell for thousands. In the 60GHz band (IEEE 802.11ad), you can plausibly get down to ~.5cm resolution with cheap, COTS network gear.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by bluGill on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:10PM (#35645612)
The labor to make that work is going to be expensive, but yes you can do that. GPS with corrections is the cheap and easy way to ensure everything works and then you get back to the business of farming.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by albatross13 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:27PM (#35644118)
You should start your own farm and scale it to feed tens of millions of people, simply by driving a truck in a field :)
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by salawat on Friday April 21, 2023 @10:15AM (#35654083)
Counterpoint:

10's of millions of people are wandering around with absolutely no conception of where their food comes from, and whether there is anything they need to do to keep it that way.

I see this as a bug, not a feature.

Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by outworlder on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:08PM (#35644718)
> What an insane dependency tree, that driving a truck in a field to plant some seeds requires a computer operating in space.

Well, what if I told you that, if GPS failed, many other (stationary!) operations would be impacted? Including financial.

We rely on space computers for more than position, we also rely on them for accurate timekeeping. If you are connected to the internet you can get time corrections that way, but there's plenty of devices that are gathering time data from space.

Now, the issue here is not so much that they are using satellites, is that they are _only_ using satellites (and, it would seem, they are using them for the entire time they are operating). Land-based stations around the field to provide location information could definitely be used instead. Or other mechanisms.

I don't know if tractors have inertial navigation units but, if not, maybe they should. That would at least allow them to operate after the initial fix was established (which doesn't even require GPS, just a well-known starting point). Basically, the same thing that airliners already do.

EDIT: found this - https://www.digikey.com/en/articles/use-inertial-measurement...

Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by dokem on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:13PM (#35644788)
Everything is already complex. The rubber in the tires, foundries for the metal in the tractor, machining tools and welding equipment, the processes and tools to develop insecticides, water infrastructure. Why is a far away radio a bridge too far? It already takes a nation to build tractors at scale.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by gravitronic on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:25PM (#35645795)
If the tire factory takes a day off, the truck in the field can still drive.

If the rubber factory takes a day off, the truck in the field can still drive.

etc, etc.

Can't talk to a specific single space computer with no fallback? truck in the field might as well be a potato.

Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by politician on Thursday April 20, 2023 @06:27PM (#35647384)
Fuel is complex.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by salawat on Friday April 21, 2023 @10:41AM (#35654472)
So is getting that computer up into space, keeping it there, and running, and returning to service in the inevitable case of failover.

...All of which seems a little silly in comparison to setting up some solar powered, battery backuped wireless radios/beacons, and establishing a localized coordinate grid, no extraterrestrial equipment required.

Or is cutting out a tractors width of field around all beacons enough to render a farmer uncompetitive as well?

I just resent the implication that just because we have GPS satellites, that those are the only form factor such a solution can take. I always saw satellite GPS as A) a quick global win for the public and B) sort of an incentive to keep iterating on rocketry in parallel with establishing similar terrestrial nav gridding.

I don't think it is wise to just not establish terrestrial nav grids because GPS. Always, always, always build redundancies.

Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by politician on Friday April 21, 2023 @11:32AM (#35655272)
It's just that land isn't a flat 2D plain, and plots aren't quadrangles. It's more complicated than driving stakes into the ground at the corners. Then there's the matter of the ground shifting and weather affecting the beacons. I agree that redundancy is good, but if terrestrial nav grids with ~4cm resolution were operationally easy we wouldn't be having this conversation.
Re:Farmers ‘crippled’ by satellite failure as GPS-guided tra... by maccolgan on Friday April 21, 2023 @04:07AM (#35650987)
We are taking the nodejs solution too far.