Year 5 is just a steady state of no more phantom profit taxes, but you never really get that extra tax you paid back if you want to keep operating at the same level or grow.
So Musk was following a playbook after all...
After 5 years the first years salaries are considered to be a "finished" R&D project, which means there's nothing left to amortize.
The only thing like that is that if, after a few years, you fire all your devs (or at least, all devs working on adding new features and building new products), then you can keep amortizing the last 4 years of salaries for your now-fired workers over the next few years, which reduces your tax base. But I mean, by that point, who cares? Any software business that has fired all its devs is over.
If you spend is going up, you're pre-paying more and more tax on profits you haven't earned yet. If your spend is constant, you'll stay the same amount behind. If your spend declines you'll start to catch up, and if it drops to 0 and stays there for ~4 years you'll catch up to where you would have been without the law change...but if you start spending again you have to start pre-paying again.
If you buy a building, you can’t depreciate the whole thing instantly, you do it over the life of the building.
The same should hold of course if you buy software.
But if you ask your employee to perform a task like writing a program you are not buying anything. You are paying the employee's salary whether the software they are writing ever gets out of the compiler or not.
So wouldn't there be a way around this by changing the titles of software developers to "software janitors" for instance ?
Feels like this is just a move to stop companies from gaming expenses to avoid profiting. Piercing the corporate veil, if you will.
Office Manager: 100% expense.
Software Engineer: 20% over 5 years (actually only 10% for the first year).
If they’re international then 6.67% over 15 years.
Not only that, but the effect “stacks” over the years.
By the time you get to year 5, you’ve paid tax on $2,000,000 of phantom profits you never had.If you’re a C Corp that’s $420,000 in extra federal taxes (plus whatever state tax).
If you’re a smaller company you’re probably a S Corp and federal and state tax could be ~50% passed through to your personal return.
How any owner survives that, I’m not sure.