News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by cdot2 on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @03:23PM (#35618759)
What would a software developer do that isn't research or development? Maybe my understanding of "research and development" is wrong. Is there a formal definition that I can go by?
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by jdmichal on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @03:41PM (#35619001)
In "research and development", that typically means "research of new ideas and methods, and developing them into commercially viable products". So are there things that software engineers do that fall under R+D? Absolutely! Is adding a sorting feature to a grid in your app one of those things? Probably not!
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by dahfizz on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:23PM (#35619506)
You should never assume legal terms mean what they colloquially mean.

Just like how "work" in physics has a precise definition which doesn't mean what it colloquially means, or "tree" in computer science.

In this case, software development of any kind is explicitly included:

> For purposes of this section, any amount paid or incurred in connection with the development of any software shall be treated as a research or experimental expenditure.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/174

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by kaitai on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @07:18PM (#35621865)
What I find most confounding is that I know some folks who do what I'd call research, in that they do EDA and develop models, but since those aren't necessarily destined for development of software, their hours are not counted in this exercise. It's too, um, researchy to qualify as research, I guess? or it's just classified as fancy analytics.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by zamnos on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @08:13PM (#35622425)
> and develop models

The debate over whether Excel counts as programming and thus software development just got a lot more heated. The question is how is "software" defined in the context of the tax code, in particular in the phrase "development of any software" from above.

https://www.lawinsider.com/dictionary/software gives a couple definitions.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by pclmulqdq on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:33PM (#35623969)
The full IRS clarification on this will helpfully be available in a few months (a few months after the deadline), but it doesn't look like things like maintenance work will qualify, only new software projects. I'm expecting that a lot of savvy companies are going to decide that a lot of software development (using the common term) is not software development in the legal sense.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by anonymouskimmer on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @01:42AM (#35624647)
> I'm expecting that a lot of savvy companies are going to decide that a lot of software development (using the common term) is not software development in the legal sense.

Even if this risks an IRS judgement against them, a savvy company might want to take such a judgement to court, and let a jury decide.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by commandlinefan on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:32PM (#35619651)
> Is adding a sorting feature to a grid in your app one of those things?

Yeah, the love the tax write-off - they don't love paying people to actually research anything.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by sangnoir on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @03:35PM (#35618936)
What would a welder do that isn't research or development? I believe for both jobs certain tasks are journeyman-like, bit others are legit R&D. I don't think software ought to be blanket-exempted because its done on a computer.

Here's the IRS' guidance on software: https://www.irs.gov/businesses/audit-guidelines-on-the-appli...

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by TylerE on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @03:49PM (#35619087)
> What would a welder do that isn't research or development?

Weld stuff?

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by jdmichal on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @03:57PM (#35619189)
Isn't welding just "developing" metal products?

That's why you have to take into account that it's "research and development", and not "research" and "development". As in research and the development of that research, not separately research and development.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by function_seven on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:28PM (#35619582)
Yeah, forcing physical-world norms into technology will always result in weird shit like this.

For the "real" world, Research would be studying different compounds to see which ones work well as anode or cathode.

Development would be creating the industrial processes required to scale up manufacturing, or the ancillary infrastructure to support the new battery, or designing a new package for this awesome new cell. All the things that take the new thing from the lab to a marketable product.

So if you come up with a new method for welding ("My new filler alloy reduces argon requirements by half!" or "My new pulsing methodology results in 23% stronger welds between dissimilar alloys.") That's Research. Then the Development of that might be "How do we manufacture these new filler rods to the exacting specs required?" or "We need to have the EE people incorporate my pulsing algo in our welders. Right now it's running on an Arduino in the lab, we need it included in next year's Welder XL4000 model."

Actually doing the weld is just doing the job.

So, back to software. What kind of coding is considered R&D and what is considered "just doing the job"? I guess creating new algorithms, or new features that you expect to be in the product for years to come; those would be R&D. Whereas fixing bugs, working on Kubernetes stuff, writing database backup routines, etc. would not be?

I don't know. This is just my impression of the difference. I'm no economist.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by 908B64B197 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @11:08AM (#35629084)
> So, back to software. What kind of coding is considered R&D and what is considered "just doing the job"? I guess creating new algorithms, or new features that you expect to be in the product for years to come; those would be R&D. Whereas fixing bugs, working on Kubernetes stuff, writing database backup routines, etc. would not be?

I would still count the later as R&D. It's akin to having an industrial engineer re-design the manufacturing floor to accommodate for the different manufacturing process of the anodes.

As soon as you need to customize something, it becomes R&D (else you would have purchased it). The "just the job" part is invisible because, well, it's the machine who's doing it (applications auto-start, install, send updates).

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by hellojesus on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @03:58PM (#35619202)
Welding stuff is developing a product. Basically the same thing software developers do. It seems like a nonsense differentiation if those are categorized differently for taxes.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by TylerE on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:21PM (#35619486)
As some one who took a welding class.. no it isn’t. It’s production.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by bluGill on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:42PM (#35619783)
It can be development, if you are building a prototype for example. a good welder will notice that a bracket is missing and design one one the spot so the whole can be built for now - while telling the engineers about the problem.

That is a small % of welding though. Most is just straight production work. The % is open to question - if I ask you to put a winch mount on my trailer how much of that is custom R&D, and how much is production of the one off product?

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by maxerickson on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @09:46PM (#35623262)
If you have an off the shelf solution, then close to 0 development.

If you have a clear, standard approach to the installation, then the development is likely to be a small portion of the work.

If neither of those are true then you are in the hard to figure area.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by ikekkdcjkfke on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:06AM (#35627109)
A carpenter building a custom solution for room x

A programmer building a custom abstraction for domain feature x

A plumber laying a new line from the basement to the second floor

All require some surveying and development of a solution, gluing existing parts together in a unique way

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by maxerickson on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:27AM (#35627280)
Sure, I agree, but there are likely standard approaches, especially in the older trades, where the development is making ~1 decision and then measuring.

Like if the carpenter is installing some shelves, they are most likely picking a shelving system or approach they know how to work with and measuring for fit, not coming up with a brand new way to mount shelves. They might come up with a new way, it just isn't all that likely.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by hellojesus on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:13PM (#35632089)
The same can be said for a lot of software developers. How many people spend their days gluing together existing libraries vs. writing their own? This rule seems ridiculous; I fail to understand why they're are different tax write off rates for employees based on what they're doing. Either way they're being paid by the business!

The entirety of the rule seems to exist to punish small players in the market. A barrier to entry to box out competition.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by bluGill on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:05PM (#35632652)
The difference is repetition. Many welders work some form of assembly line, where they constantly are welding the same bracket on and sending the part down the line.

Even if they are not on a line, few welders are designing the bracket, instead they cut it out according to blueprints (this might be a separate person) and then weld it on. Then they look at the next part of the blueprint and put it on.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by darth_avocado on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:26PM (#35619558)
I still don’t understand why it has to be RnD? If I made a million dollars and spent a million in salaries, I made no profit. The government shouldn’t be taxing me on no money made. They already get taxes on the salaries I’m giving out.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by makeitdouble on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:59PM (#35620064)
It comes down to whether these salaries were a sheer cost and not partly an investment.

If you made a million dollar and bought a million in patents, you still would have no money but wouldn't expect to be paying 0 tax, would you ? How RnD should be taxed is up for debate, but at least the logic is that it's not a simple cost (in comparison to paying a janitor to clean the office for instance)

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by bcrosby95 on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @05:37PM (#35620624)
For many small software companies, making software is more like making a custom table rather than an actual investment.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by darth_avocado on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @05:19PM (#35620357)
Fair enough. If you made a million dollars and bought land with it, sure you can tax it. But something as basic as employee salaries that are a cost to any business should definitely be deductible from the profits as cost of running the business. Especially when the company is supposed to pay payroll taxes and the employees themselves pay income tax on their salaries.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by makeitdouble on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @09:25PM (#35623097)
I'm with you in that it probably needs more nuance on what exaclty the developpers are doing (TBF I haven't read the details, so maybe there is already a lot of nuance in all of it.)

I kinda see many cases where a salary isn't as clear cut as a simple cost...for instance comparing two cases:

- we buy for a million dollar an exclusive right on an innovative system from a freelance guy that developed it on his own

- we contract for 10k a month the same guy to design and develop the same innovative system, he takes a year or two to develop it.

In one case it's a purchase of an asset, in the other case it's a salary. The resulting asset is the same though.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by tomrod on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @12:05AM (#35624126)
First one is a product, second is a service.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by makeitdouble on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @02:40AM (#35624992)
Second one you paid a service to get a product.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by galaxyLogic on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @01:07AM (#35624450)
If you buy something for a million dollar you are buying an asset.

But if you make an employment contract with somebody it is totally unknown what is the value you are or will be getting out of the employee. You are not buying an "asset" because you can not own an employee. They can quit any time.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by makeitdouble on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @02:42AM (#35625008)
I'm with you on the unknown part. We could this it as a risk, with the upside that you might have paid less in total by taking the risk and hiring the guy, than buying the proven end result at price reflecting the total value of the asset.

> you can not own an employee.

You own everything the employee produced during the contract, whenever they quit.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by galaxyLogic on Thursday April 20, 2023 @01:02AM (#35636596)
Right but what you paid for was not the outputs of the employee, you paid for the inputs of the employee -- meaning the employee's time spend on the work.

Time spent is NOT an asset, it is consumed, hour by the hour. It is an expense.

It is not an asset also because you can not choose to sell it to someone else and thus recoup the money you have placed on it.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by makeitdouble on Thursday April 20, 2023 @11:52AM (#35641967)
It feels like a distinction without a difference: trying to apply the same logic to something that is material and not just bits in a computer:

You'd be saying you didn't pay for a house, instead you paid an architect to come up with the blueprint and paid the salaries and purchases of a construction team hour by hour for X months to execute on the design, additional work included, until you got a satisfying product. An accountant looking at it afterwards would still tell you you now have an asset estimated at Y thousands on the market.

> you can not choose to sell it to someone else

You can of course sell a developped product or a service to another company. Or even just the research part if it would cost enough to the buyer to reproduce it.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by galaxyLogic on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:46PM (#35646045)
> you paid an architect to come up with the blueprint

You didn't pay the architect to work on the blueprint, you paid FOR the blueprint.

The blueprint is an asset, architect's time is not. You are not the employer of the architect, you are their client. The business transaction is money-for-blueprint. Whereas with an inhouse software developer the business-transaction is salary-for-time-spent.

If the software developer does not come up with a working program you can not take away their already earned salary. Whereas if the architect does not give you the blueprint you don't have to pay for it.

And once you get the blueprint you can sell it to someone else, it is an asset. Once the SW-developer-employee goes home you might or might not be able to sell their work-products to somebody else, because maybe the program does not run. If it does not run you can not sue the employee. If the architect's blueprints do not produce a working house you can sue them.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by jfengel on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @05:47PM (#35620773)
Because it was a way to get the budget "balanced". They declared R&D expenses to be different from operating expenses -- if you have the money to spend on R&D then you have money to spend funding the country.

It's never supposed to be about what's "fair" or what they "should" do. It's about the fact that they want to spend $X, and need to raise $X one way or the other.

In this case, though, it was purely a trick. They were required to balance the budget over the long term, so they spent money now and identified a pot of money they could take from later. They just kicked the can down the road, and now we've arrived where the can landed. They actually don't think it's fair, or reasonable, or productive. But changing it does make somebody responsible for a huge increase in the deficit... and it's the people who spent the money 5 years ago.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by SoftTalker on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @06:42PM (#35621462)
There is no budget, for a long time. Only spending resolutions. And they’re not b balanced.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by jfengel on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @07:48PM (#35622156)
Spending resolutions are more important than budgets. So much more important that they're usually just called "budgets" because nobody cares about the thing that is actually a budget.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by foobarbazetc on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @07:07PM (#35621744)
That’s literally the point of this entire thread.

This change taxes you on profit you never made, and specifically targets software companies.

It’s insane.

Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by sethammons on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:58AM (#35626666)
Kinda like options - you get taxed on imaginary numbers on money you don't have access to. You received zero profits but owe taxes.
Re:Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten s... by aikinai on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @07:13PM (#35621804)
Maintain services. Why was everyone expecting Twitter to go down after the layoffs if software developers only do research and development of new products?