But we have this gravitationally contained fusion reactor in the neighbourhood literally radiating energy at us. (I'm talking about the sun, if it is not clear.)
That is the thing which powered the previous capture. How would it be impossible to do it again? (I'm not talking about "practical" or "fast" those are questions after we established that it is possible, which it seems we disagree on.)
Ok, but that means the question is not the energy balance. That is my whole point.
> How much space do you need for plants to capture a gigaton of carbon?
Plants are only one of the possibilities. All I am arguing is that it is not impossible on account of the principle of energy conservation. Not arguing how easy or hard it is.
> Does earth even have that much suitable surface?
Of course. It happened once.
You probably don't.
> human technology is energy intensive, wasteful
I agree.
> and won't save us
In that case we better lay down in the sun and die peacefully. Because human technology is the only thing which can save us. What else there is?
We do technology, and we obviously can't.
> What else there is?
Plants.
Sure it's all (hard) science fiction but I feel like we're giving up on realistic near term solutions anyway.
And of course when we do want to turn CO2 into hydrocarbons we can use solar and nuclear energy sources, in which case the hydrocarbons play the role of a battery rather than primary energy source. We can also use non-fossil energy to concentrate CO2 from the air; in theory at least that takes quite a bit less energy than hydrocarbons release when burned.
And since no technologies exist that can do permanent recapture to undo that at a useful scale (and probably never will because its a conservation of energy problem), its a debt we'll never be able to pay back.