News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by DennisP on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @10:53AM (#35614797)
It's basically too late to stay under 1.5 by just cutting emissions. By the time we do eliminate emissions, we're going to need air capture already scaling up.

Fortunately, it's possible for civilization to do more than one thing at a time.

Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by slashdev on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:07AM (#35614966)
Staying under 1.5 is a fantasy.

If we want to stay under 3 we’d better get some real effort behind ending coal as soon as possible.

While it is possible to do more than one thing at a time, our politicians are trying to plug a leak while ignoring a giant gaping hole just around the corner. It’s like they’re incompetent morons or something.

Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by bryanlarsen on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:54AM (#35615717)
OTOH, I used to have lots of people tell me that it would be almost impossible to stay under 5 degrees of warming. Landing at about 3 degrees of warming is substantially better than many of the scenarios laid out in the past.

I'm still optimistic we can stay below 2 degrees of warming.

Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by DennisP on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @12:27PM (#35616181)
We absolutely should end coal as soon as possible, along with oil and natural gas. We should also develop and scale methods for pulling CO2 back out of the atmosphere. Just ending emissions avoids the worst outcomes but still leaves us with a bad outcome. If politicians were not incompetent morons then we could have solved the problem a lot sooner without having to pull CO2 back out of the air, but here we are.

Also, there are some applications, like long-haul jets, that will be very difficult to electrify, and DAC gives us a way to make liquid hydrocarbons for them without any net emissions. Biofuel is another way in theory, but not always in practice, and it takes a lot more land area.

Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by blueflow on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:02AM (#35614900)
Its not emissions that are the problem, its the extra carbon that we dig out and insert it into the existing capture - emissions cycle.

And since no technologies exist that can do permanent recapture to undo that at a useful scale (and probably never will because its a conservation of energy problem), its a debt we'll never be able to pay back.

Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by krisoft on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:11AM (#35615045)
> probably never will because its a conservation of energy problem

But we have this gravitationally contained fusion reactor in the neighbourhood literally radiating energy at us. (I'm talking about the sun, if it is not clear.)

That is the thing which powered the previous capture. How would it be impossible to do it again? (I'm not talking about "practical" or "fast" those are questions after we established that it is possible, which it seems we disagree on.)

Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by blueflow on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:28AM (#35615292)
The question is the scale. How much space do you need for plants to capture a gigaton of carbon? Does earth even have that much suitable surface? And how do you put it into the ground so it can't decay and be re-processed into carbon dioxide?
Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by krisoft on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:25AM (#35637595)
> The question is the scale.

Ok, but that means the question is not the energy balance. That is my whole point.

> How much space do you need for plants to capture a gigaton of carbon?

Plants are only one of the possibilities. All I am arguing is that it is not impossible on account of the principle of energy conservation. Not arguing how easy or hard it is.

> Does earth even have that much suitable surface?

Of course. It happened once.

Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by blueflow on Thursday April 20, 2023 @07:36AM (#35638556)
I know where you are going, but human technology is energy intensive, wasteful and won't save us.
Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by krisoft on Thursday April 20, 2023 @07:48AM (#35638643)
> I know where you are going

You probably don't.

> human technology is energy intensive, wasteful

I agree.

> and won't save us

In that case we better lay down in the sun and die peacefully. Because human technology is the only thing which can save us. What else there is?

Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by blueflow on Thursday April 20, 2023 @07:55AM (#35638685)
> Because human technology is the only thing which can save us.

We do technology, and we obviously can't.

> What else there is?

Plants.

Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by ben_w on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @07:25AM (#35712026)
Where's the boundary between plants and technology when you have genetic engineering?
Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by Avicebron on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:16AM (#35615103)
If you're referring to planting more biomatter, I fully agree it's not impossible, I think the sticking point really is the scale, can we theoretically leverage this to capture at a rate that matters while simultaneously not giving up our current lifestyles. ( I think the main crux of these solutions imply this even if they don't deliberately state it, the solution has to not impact people's lives "negatively' to be viable).
Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by mrguyorama on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @02:41PM (#35618124)
Plants only capture carbon temporarily. When they die and decompose they release that carbon back into the cycle. Using plants to sequester would require either maintaining significantly more plant mass for the rest of forever, or finding a way to prevent wood from decomposing forever on an industrial scale.
Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by worldsayshi on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:10AM (#35615023)
It should be possible if we gain access to "almost infinite" energy right? It would be absurd to assume it but if we really get fusion energy going and then if we get serious cost reductions in space based solar.

Sure it's all (hard) science fiction but I feel like we're giving up on realistic near term solutions anyway.

Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by mrguyorama on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @02:44PM (#35618164)
As long as electricity generation is a profit making endeavor, it doesn't matter what the source is, generating companies will never build enough of it to significantly drop costs. "Energy too cheap to meter" was always a lie. Capitalism always makes it more profitable to make too little of something rather than too much.
Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by DennisP on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @12:34PM (#35616300)
We can't turn CO2 back into fuel without an input of energy, but we can store CO2 for the long term without turning it back into fuel. For example, we can pump it into deep basalt formations, where it will turn into rock.

And of course when we do want to turn CO2 into hydrocarbons we can use solar and nuclear energy sources, in which case the hydrocarbons play the role of a battery rather than primary energy source. We can also use non-fossil energy to concentrate CO2 from the air; in theory at least that takes quite a bit less energy than hydrocarbons release when burned.

Re:Facing brutal climate math, US bets billions on direct ai... by Zigurd on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:00AM (#35614887)
Some sequences of events make sense: It is not possible to benefit from direct carbon capture cleanly before dirty energy sources are replaced. It would just add to the problem, mainly in the carbon cost of building appropriate energy sources for capture. No free lunch.

In this case doing "more than one thing at a time" amounts to trying to have one's cake while feeling good about baking it with coal-generated electricity.