News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by jchw on Monday April 17, 2023 @10:24AM (#35601171)
Well, regardless of what you think about who is in the right morally and legally, I will say one thing: Nintendo sure knows how to take an opportunity for good PR and turn it into a PR nightmare for essentially no gain. Nintendo definitely manages to succeed in spite of their corporate antics and absolutely not as a result of them.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by bragr on Monday April 17, 2023 @10:34AM (#35601347)
>Nintendo sure knows how to take an opportunity for good PR and turn it into a PR nightmare for essentially no gain. Nintendo definitely manages to succeed in spite of their corporate antics and absolutely not as a result of them.

Counterpoint: maybe none of the people they have drama with are their core customers. Nintendo seems to have a similar "Disney Adult" problem as Disney where you have a population of vocal adults who think they are the core customer, but in reality the company moved on to selling to those people's children or grandchildren years ago.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by viraptor on Monday April 17, 2023 @10:40AM (#35601446)
Pointcrow is not really their customer. He's their free marketing service. Most of his content seems to be based on Nintendo games - and that works for at least some of the actual customer base. Reviews and trailers are fun and all, but I think every game I bought in the last few years was a result of me seeing a stream of someone having fun playing it.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by bragr on Monday April 17, 2023 @10:51AM (#35601628)
>He's their free marketing service.

Is he though? Looking about his top videos, I see lots of "pro gaming" or speedruns, so I circle back to my earlier question of who is their core audience? I suspect this kind of content doesn't move the needle on units sold very much.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by viraptor on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:12AM (#35601972)
Pro gaming and speedruns are still free marketing - there will be people who know the games and come for the challenge content, but there will be others as well who are going to enjoy the show and buy their own copy.

I'm not saying he's bringing in their core demographics. Just that he makes some sales for them.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by edgyquant on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:36AM (#35602335)
I seriously doubt watching a speed run has sold any units at all. Those are the things people watch for games they already love.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by galleywest200 on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:12PM (#35602843)
Maybe not console units, but I am sure it has sold games themselves. Games (and accessories) are where the money is, console units are commonly sold at or below cost
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by sverona on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:15PM (#35602883)
Tetris: The Grand Master, a '90s arcade game that's been out of print for twenty years, was just rereleased for Switch more or less entirely because of its speedrunning community.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by jchw on Monday April 17, 2023 @02:08PM (#35604317)
It's sad what happened to that game. I feel that Arika's take on Tetris would've resonated with a lot of people had it not been forced into obscurity by the bizarre regime of guideline Tetris.

But, the behavior of The Tetris Company is it's own bag of worms, and an even more agitating one than Nintendo. If anyone was looking for an example of how to be worse, I think TTC may very well have the formula down.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by sverona on Monday April 17, 2023 @08:24PM (#35608464)
Nintendo is out of date. TTC verges on being a patent troll.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by sleepybrett on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:15PM (#35602884)
Sure but when your audience tunes in tuesday and you are playing the latest zelda game or whatever because it's the next game you are going to try and speedrun maybe you just sold some copies of that game.

Pointcrow isn't, currently, one of those guys that plays just one game forever or even one game mostly. He's a 'variety streamer', he does have a pretty firm focus on nintendo games both classic and new but that isn't his whole ouvre.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by numpad0 on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:33PM (#35603132)
I think it could be moving some, but IMO more correct thing to say is that "they should be thankful for free advertisement" argument never goes well. It makes no visible changes but seems to silently lock closed doors.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by viraptor on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @01:25AM (#35610277)
I got 2 games after watching a speedrun, so... you're off by at least those. But seriously, events like agdq have enough variety that people do get to see new things there.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by matheusmoreira on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:41PM (#35603232)
> Pro gaming and speedruns are still free marketing

Nintendo hates those. Look at how they treated the Smash community. It shocked me and I don't even like those games. Nintendo sucks and doesn't deserve anyone's money. Don't even try to understand them or their motives, sucking is just a part of their DNA.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by u_name on Monday April 17, 2023 @01:07PM (#35603574)
I never understood that thing around the Smash games. Looking at them from outside, they look like a "cute" beat'em'up fighting game for spending some fun time, not like something for "serious" championships, tournaments and the like.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by matheusmoreira on Monday April 17, 2023 @01:10PM (#35603627)
I don't get it either but they sure as hell didn't deserve what Nintendo did to them.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by jchw on Monday April 17, 2023 @01:55PM (#35604172)
For Super Smash Bros Melee in particular, I think it's just a ridiculously in-depth game, more than it has any right to be. Nintendo essentially invented an entire new sub-genre of the platform fighting game and perfected it in basically two iterations. It's pretty easy to pick up and play, but it has surprising depth. It's challenging to illustrate briefly, but for example, just take a look at what the map of control stick actions looks like from resting state:

https://i.imgur.com/oAROhEq.png

The truth is, even though I don't play video games much at all any more, I played this game when I was younger and kept a pulse on it since, so I know when a character matchup is bad, and I can recognize difficult techniques like ledge dashing or amsah teching. But, I argue as well that even though it's silly and even though you may not be able to pick out all of the ridiculous high-level play going on in a match, the energy of competitive gaming is simply infectious. It's hard to pick just one video, but maybe something here will resonate with folks unfamiliar. Is it a little silly? Yes, definitely. But the energy is infectious. It draws me in.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Im68s2z0AAY

The newest game in the series, Super Smash Bros Ultimate, has a commendable competitive scene, even though Nintendo has kind of nerfed a lot of the things that made Melee so competitively interesting later on in the series (ledge hogging, wave dashing, ...) and focused more on making a party game.

People keep playing Melee though, with tournaments going on pretty much all the time (and getting shut down all the time, too), even though they usually have to run at a financial loss, for the love of the sport, as lacking official blessing, it is hard to attract advertisers and sponsors. But seriously, just take a look at what they've done with Slippi.gg: They've essentially taken this old game and added rollback netcode and matchmaking to it. It's not exactly unheard of amount of dedication, but I find it very impressive nonetheless.

When I look at what happened to this scene, I can't help but feel there is a lot of missed opportunity any way you slice it. But maybe, I'm just out of touch and nostalgic.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by edgyquant on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:35AM (#35602321)
People making videos think they’re free advertising, but that doesn’t mean they’re the kind of ads companies want. Corporations have an image they want to maintain, it’s pretty egregious to think you’re doing them a favor making money off of their products.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by KennyBlanken on Monday April 17, 2023 @01:12PM (#35603646)
In what bizarre reality did the standard for "what you're allowed to publish or engage in public discourse about" become "does not make you money and is preferential to any companies whose products appear in or are discussed in the videos"?
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by yellowapple on Monday April 17, 2023 @01:25PM (#35603758)
As it stands, the only "image" these corporations are maintaining is "suit-wearing hypercapitalist squares who only love money and absolutely despise anything resembling fun or creativity". Issuing takedowns over "the wrong kind" of ad is counterproductive.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by rchaud on Monday April 17, 2023 @04:13PM (#35605943)
Not when the raison d'etre of these channels is basically Nintendo brand worship.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by rickdeckard on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:43AM (#35602416)
> I think every game I bought in the last few years was a result of me seeing a stream of someone having fun playing it. I know others who do the same.

Considering the stable sales of Nintendo products, this still seems to work despite Nintendo policing content for many years now.

So despite smaller blips like this one, one might argue that they're actually quite good in curating the content they want to use for marketing...

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by ajmurmann on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:09PM (#35602808)
> Pointcrow is not really their customer. He's their free marketing service.

That angle actually pushed me closer to Nintendo's reasoning. If people buy games because they see them on these streams, what's the likely buying decision from seeing a super cool new feature for Breath of the Wild that only works on emulator? I'd wager that it increases the likelihood of getting a Steamdeck instead of a Switch and playing the emulated version instead. That seems like an occurrence that Nintendo wants less of.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by jchw on Monday April 17, 2023 @01:05PM (#35603544)
Well, if only there was a way for Nintendo to deal with this kind of issue, right? Like for example, I think it's clear that the experience of running older Nintendo games on emulators was better than bothering with the real thing or re-releases on services like virtual console because you could use features like online multiplayer, rewind/save states, and emulator enhancements.

But of course, Nintendo did kind of start to figure this out; they actually started implementing similar value-adds like multiplayer and save states into their own emulation suites for retro consoles. I think this is good, since you're essentially asking people to buy the same thing again (maybe thrice or more if you're a die hard Nintendo fan who has followed the console lineage since they started doing re-releases like this, back on the Wii and 3DS.); you may as well provide some value-adds.

But, maybe they can't do anything about modding, because nobody has figured that out? Well... except for Valve, who has apparently figured that out. And maybe even SEGA arguably, who also has figured that out, too, considering they have third-party ROM hacks on Steam Workshop.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Of course, I think Nintendo's heritage, history, etc. makes it clear that it would be unlikely for them, any time soon, to take pages out of anyone else's book. Obviously, Valve is just a very different company, and PC gaming is a very different market. I think, though, that a lot of people believe it would be damaging to Nintendo's brand and lose them money if they were more open and fostered this sort of thing, but I think it's hyperbole, I don't see it. In all likelihood, if Nintendo keeps making great video games, people will probably keep buying them, even begrudgingly, just like many people do today, regardless of whether they're dicks to people or they're not.

Stubbornness can be good sometimes, but it definitely leads people and entities to pick fights that are pretty much unwinnable. Eventually, they're going to have to find the line.

(P.S.: I do actually agree though that there is truth, 100%, to the idea that piracy could substantially hurt sales; I think Nintendo is the only company to have experienced tangible evidence of this, with the Nintendo DS and readily available R4 flash cartridge. THAT SAID: If you don't buy a Nintendo Switch and Nintendo Switch cartridges, you can't play online; the console and cartridges/downloaded games have unique IDs online, AFAIK. I think that this is probably effective anti-piracy. Sure, people COULD pirate a single player game from Nintendo, but getting a Steam Deck instead of a Switch seems unlikely; If you're a Nintendo fan, you are not going to get as much value out of running a Steam Deck with emulators. I posit that the majority of people will wind up buying the game, but some of them may also play around with emulation, too. If people really just didn't want to pay for Zelda, a TON of Switch consoles that have the hardware exploit can use the RCM exploit and probably run pirated copies on the real thing with third party modified firmware. The truth is, if backlash from these videos isn't enough to harm their sales, and clearly it isn't, then I suspect the reach of these creators just isn't enough to matter in the first place.)

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by KennyBlanken on Monday April 17, 2023 @01:09PM (#35603591)
You lost me when you started arguing that a corporation's opinion on whether something is beneficial to their sales and marketing should have any bearing whatsoever on what someone is allowed to publish.

You also clearly didn't watch the video. A youtuber shows a modded game being run on an emulator, he's adhering to publicly posted policies on what they consider to be fair use, Nintendo went out of their way to be retaliatory (issuing two separate copyright strikes instead of one, and then when he emailed them asking to resolve the situation, did not respond but instead issues dozens more takedowns...including one of him just playing the regular, unmodded game.)

If you want to see extreme examples of this: "ag-gag" laws in the midwest states where there are criminal penalties for disseminating video from slaughter houses that counters the industry's marketing efforts that portray the process as humane and painless, when the process is neither, and in fact employees go out of their way to be abusive to the animals.

Individual free speech is critical to balance the incredible power corporations now have, especially post Citizens United.

What's next? Car companies being able to take down car review videos where the reviewer doesn't tow the line? Or someone is using their car in a way the car company doesn't like? Or modding it to have more power? Or using a scan tool to turn on a feature it didn't come programmed to do originally? Taking down news videos where someone uses a dorF G-350 pickup truck to ram a bunch of pedestrians, because it might look bad for their company?

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by jchw on Monday April 17, 2023 @10:55AM (#35601723)
Video games still have a reputation for being a children's affair even though less than a quarter of people who play video games are under 18. Granted, the demographic may actually be a little skewed for Nintendo, but frankly, I doubt it's that much different.

Even if this is true, though, I am pretty sure that videos on topics like "Breath of the Wild multiplayer" absolutely appeal to Nintendo consumers, even younger ones. Thinking about all of the schoolyard banter and rumors about video games, I can only imagine how crazy it is that these days, some of the wild "what if?" scenarios are actually made true by skilled, motivated fans. I do not play many video games these days, so admittedly it is hard for me to be sure. However, I have seen the way that kids respond to this DMCA garbage, and I have never gotten any impression other than that it feels like a great injustice and an unfortunate reality.

If Nintendo really didn't care about the demographic of these videos, then it truly begs the question why they care so much to suppress it. They also were doing the same thing when it came to videos of Switch games running on the Valve Steam Deck.

Clearly, they have some motivated interest.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by somsak2 on Monday April 17, 2023 @04:12PM (#35605925)
> less than a quarter of people who play video games are under 18

I think this is deceiving. Sure, in terms of raw numbers there are a good number of adult gamers. But I'd like to see this statistic play-time-weighted.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by birracerveza on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:04AM (#35601883)
Their products are targeted towards the younger demographics and those who buy their product do not mind that much.

This, however, is a completely different problem that has nothing to do with the products themselves, it's Nintendo's legal team showing absolutely no mercy towards their own content creators, which also includes teenagers, for very little gain... Which is a damn shame, because the work these content creators do is amazing. Instead of sending C&Ds and squandering that potential, Nintendo should work with these people.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by edgyquant on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:38AM (#35602359)
These are not nintendos “content creators” they are a business who use nintendos IP for profit. You can argue it’s fair use or that it’s “good marketting” for Nintendo but as a company they have every right to dispute that.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by birracerveza on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:50PM (#35603352)
Oh yes I am not saying they are not entitled to protect their IP, just that they are unnecessarily hostile about it.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by shidoshi on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:43AM (#35602417)
Yeah, this is mostly correct. Source: worked there for 9 years.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by jjeaff on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:47PM (#35603323)
At least as far as the Disney theme park division, it seems like they are actively catering to the adult crowd. These days, the theme parks seem to be mostly adults.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by bastardoperator on Monday April 17, 2023 @01:03PM (#35603525)
How do grandchildren afford park hopper tickets, streaming services, season passes, or vacation clubs? My oldest grandchild is 7 years old for reference.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by djaychela on Monday April 17, 2023 @10:37AM (#35601399)
I spoke to my 16 year old about this the other day. He's pretty laid back, and in a fairly responsible friend group. They all hate Nintendo. Love their products, but hate the company, precisely because of this sort of thing.

A lot of this gains them nothing other than resentment.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by dfxm12 on Monday April 17, 2023 @10:44AM (#35601509)
If they all end up getting new games like Tears of the Kingdom, then I'm not quite sure why Nintendo would change course.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by jchw on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:21AM (#35602107)
I think that's why this sucks, though. I think that people actually do appreciate the products that Nintendo make; they clearly employ and work with some of the best talent in the game dev industry, which is not surprising given their history. In general, this idea of "voting with one's wallet" is romantically appealing, but in practice asking people to make purchasing decisions for things like entertainment media based on things like this doesn't seem to work. And I think it's more complicated than JUST mindshare: I think even people who want to boycott things wind up buying them anyways a lot of the time.

I think it's not apparent that Nintendo actually has to behave this way. There is a general notion that other game developers fall elsewhere on the spectrum, with SEGA falling on the more permissive end (though notably, they are not free of drama from DMCA takedowns, but they have a much better reputation of being lax, working with fans, and generally just having better PR overall. I did receive a DMCA takedown request from SEGA once, and yet I can attest to this all still.)

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by kodt on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:58PM (#35603460)
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by x-complexity on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:32PM (#35609656)
> I spoke to my 16 year old about this the other day. He's pretty laid back, and in a fairly responsible friend group. They all hate Nintendo. Love their products, but hate the company, precisely because of this sort of thing. A lot of this gains them nothing other than resentment.

The hate is worthless in Nintendo's eyes: All that matters is whether or not they'll keep buying <Insert Nintendo product here>. And for most people, they'll continue to buy 'em.

Unless their revenue significantly suffers, it will be business as usual.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by naikrovek on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:23AM (#35602133)
No one hates Nintendo fans more than Nintendo.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by mrguyorama on Monday April 17, 2023 @01:33PM (#35603871)
Nobody spends more on Nintendo products than fans that claim to hate Nintendo.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by jchw on Monday April 17, 2023 @02:52PM (#35604893)
That sort of makes sense, most of the people who care about something are going to be somewhat invested.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by RajT88 on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:29AM (#35602229)
It is a snarky thing to say, and may or may not be true...

But I feel like they took this kind of play from the Sony playbook.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by fauxpause_ on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:50AM (#35602527)
> nightmare PR

It changes nothing. It’s not a nightmare. It’s not even problematic for them.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by jchw on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:50PM (#35603351)
A PR nightmare != a financial problem. Indeed, if your company exists in a vacuum, PR is no issue for you! However, I worked at Google, and I'm telling you right now that negative reception and bad press takes a toll on employee morale, among other things. That's because companies, of course, don't exist in a vacuum where there's never any consequences.

Of course, nobody is suggesting that Nintendo is going to go bankrupt because they were mean to some YouTubers who ostensibly didn't do anything wrong, but just because there's no easy way to quantify the impact does not mean it will never matter. It does matter.

I promise you, they are not sitting there thinking "Alright yeah! A bunch of people are really pissed off at us! High fives all around, this is exactly what we aim to do here at Nintendo!"

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Monday April 17, 2023 @01:23PM (#35603733)
> I promise you, they are not sitting there thinking "Alright yeah! A bunch of people are really pissed off at us! High fives all around, this is exactly what we aim to do here at Nintendo!"

Despite that, there could be a handful of people with influential roles in the company who consider this to be a part of doing business. To your point, those same people would likely still know about this situation (rather, the general situation around copyright / marketing) and understand why they make the decisions they make while still being genuinely concerned with the trade-offs. To your parent commenter's point, that doesn't mean this is any sort of crisis (or "nightmare") to the most influential decision-makers at Nintendo; it's just part of their job.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by jchw on Monday April 17, 2023 @02:11PM (#35604350)
I think maybe the phrasing "PR nightmare" is doing too much work here. All I meant to imply is that this is bad PR for Nintendo, not that it is causing them to go to the war room. Maybe PR nightmare is simply too strong of a term.

I disagree that it is a complete non-issue, though.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Monday April 17, 2023 @04:35PM (#35606249)
I didn't mean to paint it as a non-issue (I guess OP may have), just not a "crisis" issue. I agree that "PR nightmare" is a term which removes much nuance; it's neither a non-issue nor a "war room"-necessary issue.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by fauxpause_ on Monday April 17, 2023 @02:41PM (#35604755)
I didn’t claim it was a financial problem, an existential risk, or something they’re joyous about?

It just doesn’t matter.

Google’s reputation does matter. Because you’re giving them data and relying on their services. If they cancel that service or do something bad with your data you are gonna have a bad time.

If Nintendo shuts down a streamer… whatever. Doesn’t affect 99.99999% of customers. Or employees.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by gs17 on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:59AM (#35602655)
Their fans don't really care in my experience, so there's no actual PR cost. "I can't believe they shut down another Smash tournament! ...but I'll still gladly pay for Ultimate a second time to get the DLC." I know a lot of people who both think they're a terrible company and can't wait to buy the new Zelda from them.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by jchw on Monday April 17, 2023 @01:28PM (#35603796)
I mean, I think this is just something you could generally say about boycotts against video games. Even the most hated companies in the industry still rarely see any problems with PR backlash hurting sales except in rare cases.

For example, not a game I really have any interest in, but I know Hogwarts Legacy had possibly the strongest backlash I've seen in recent memory and yet it sold gangbusters according to media. Then there's Electronic Arts and Activision Blizzard, who are definitely becoming some of the most hated game developers in the industry, and yet, they seem to be doing just fine.

Nintendo is a beloved company in spite of these antics, so I don't ever expect it to matter more for them. I still challenge the notion that this PR backlash doesn't have any cost and will never have more cost. Probably the largest immediate issue with PR backlash like this is simply that it hurts employee morale.

Does it really not matter? Well, speaking of Super Smash Bros, they pretty much killed the Panda Cup and most of the rest of the official events with their antics, and probably guaranteed that the SSBM community will never touch Nintendo sanctioned anything again. Not surprising, really, given that's pretty much how it always has been with them, but on the other hand, isn't it kind of crazy? Nintendo barely has any official competitive tournaments, even though they have at least a couple of games with decently big community scenes world-wide. Compare any other fighting game or even just other large franchises like Fortnite and I can't help like they blew many potential opportunities that could've provided value in at least O(millions) of dollars.

Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by overstay8930 on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:23PM (#35602990)
You can have bad PR but if you have what people want, it doesn't matter. Nintendo won't lose sales, just like how Apple doesn't lose sales when factory workers try to kill themselves.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video] by nickpeterson on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:58PM (#35603464)
I don’t know, Apple definitely had to do damage control around that. Nintendo basically guards against pissing off parents. I think they come down hard on uncontrolled use of IP because to tacitly allow it seems like condoning it. If you just slam everything, parents feel like they can trust the brand.

My main problem with Nintendo is that their game systems are too difficult for young children to actually use.