News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google CEO: “can we change the setting of this group to h... by ranting-moth on Sunday April 16, 2023 @07:37AM (#35589121)
It's very clear-cut. The topic is about deleting data.

There's a massive difference in deleting records that did exists vs. records that never existed in the first place.

The former is deleting data, the second case isn't.

Re:Google CEO: “can we change the setting of this group to h... by auggierose on Sunday April 16, 2023 @08:47AM (#35589569)
I think I explained why it isn't that clear-cut, even when it is about deleting data. I guess that's why there are courts, and not only HN opinions.
Re:Google CEO: “can we change the setting of this group to h... by nolok on Sunday April 16, 2023 @09:09AM (#35589737)
It is clear cut.

Let's give you a concrete exemple we have had rulings on without any computer involved, which are almost a 1:1 situation: you are on litigation hold, and aren't allowed to destroy any records. You do an oral meeting, with no plans to put it on paper.

Unknown to you, someone took notes during the meeting, say your secretary because she didn't feel well that day and wanted to be sure to remember it the next day.

Although those notes were not planned to exist, once they do destroying them is destroying records, and you're in violation of the litigation hold.

You may not notice her take note, and then see her pull the notes our of her bag the next day and at that point it's illegal for you to ask her to destroy them.

Re:Google CEO: “can we change the setting of this group to h... by auggierose on Sunday April 16, 2023 @09:42AM (#35589965)
What if she used the notes, and then destroyed them herself, without me ever noticing anything?
Re:Google CEO: “can we change the setting of this group to h... by nolok on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:26AM (#35599221)
It's still a violation by the company. For obvious reason, otherwise you find a "fall guy" to do just that and "oh I was not aware I shouldn't delete this stack of documents".
Re:Google CEO: “can we change the setting of this group to h... by devrand on Sunday April 16, 2023 @10:18AM (#35590231)
I'm not sure that's a comparable situation as someone explicitly took an action to make a record. In the case of Chat it's all software automation. No one is explicitly taking an action to make a record or destroy a record.

There is the whole situation of people asking to switch to the history mode, but that's not retroactively applied and it's really no different than sending an email that says "let's talk about this over the phone".

The real open question is whether Chats can have a temporary nature to them as they are inherently a written record. But there's also other situations where you can have a written record, for example, if someone uses auto-captions on a video call. They're very short-lived, but they did exist for some duration.

Re:Google CEO: “can we change the setting of this group to h... by nolok on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:29AM (#35599237)
> I'm not sure that's a comparable situation as someone explicitly took an action to make a record. In the case of Chat it's all software automation. No one is explicitly taking an action to make a record or destroy a record.

I am not sure why you are making this distinction when it doesn't exists.

Litigation hold also means stop all software automation that would result in destruction of record, doesn't matter how many people know about it. Case in point: that is what happens to their 30 days old chat. This is the same thing if you trigger a litigation hold on your office365 account or whatever.

And for the rest of your point: not only does the law not accept the "oh but I didn't know", for the obvious reason that then it's an easy out, but even if they did tolerate extreme exemple of it Google cannot in good faith claim lack of knowledge about THEIR OWN system, the litigation hold was not for those specific people who may or may not know it, it was for the company who is then in charge of ensuring their IT team does what the court ordered.

Re:Google CEO: “can we change the setting of this group to h... by devrand on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @12:35PM (#35616313)
I don't see where I stated that anyone was claiming ignorance. My point still holds: users had the option to create a record, but it was not the default. From that perspective the comparison provided does not hold.

The real debate is about whether "off the record" text can exist at all, and if so, under what conditions/duration? Are captions on a video call a text record? Do those need to be retained?

Re:Google CEO: “can we change the setting of this group to h... by nolok on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:00PM (#35633271)
Is this maybe a case where you may be mistakenly confusing record in the technical / computer sense, as opposed to record as meant in the legal sense ? Because your three last questions do not make sense in the legal view.

> The real debate is about whether "off the record" text can exist at all, and if so, under what conditions/duration

This question makes no sense, as you what you are asking is "can i not make a record, when i make a record of something to transmit it to someone else"

> Are captions on a video call a text record? Do those need to be retained?

Yes and yes, of course. It's legally a record. Again, this questions makes very little sense legally.