News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by senttoschool on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:11AM (#35567222)
The vast majority of people DO NOT care about cookies nor do they care about trackers.

However, there is a very real productivity loss with all the cookie prompts - both trying to implement them, getting around them, and the billions of people who have to click on them every single day.

We've got to come up with a better solution.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by submeta on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:40AM (#35567372)
> vast majority of people DO NOT care about cookies nor do they care about trackers

I highly doubt that. Do give people simpler ways to opt-out of all tracking, and they‘d happily chose that. Currently we have two problems: 1) The consent button is one click for cookies, the other is several clicks away. 2) The layman does not now how to choose a setting to always opt-out of tracking.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by illiarian on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:42AM (#35567386)
>The vast majority of people DO NOT care about cookies nor do they care about trackers.

When presented with "Ask app to not track" on iOS, 96% users clicked "do not track" https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/05/96-of-us-users-opt-o...

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by ssss11 on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:58AM (#35567540)
That “most users don’t care” line is tossed around by people all over the place and you righty point out that it isn’t true.

If my job relied on people giving up their data privacy I would probably continue telling everyone that line as well.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by boffinism on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:53AM (#35567490)
These two statements are not incompatible.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by shmde on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:53AM (#35567491)
Having a clear cut "CALL TO ACTION" dialogue option which presents one positive ( don't track me ) and one negative ( track me ) option. People choose the positive one.

Cookies/tracking banners on website completely obfuscates the choice. Negative option ( track me ) is presented as the pearly gates to heaven and easy to click. Positive option ( don't track me ) is presented as these mathematical puzzle where you must know what to click or your dog gets executed.

So yeah people care about not being tracked when presented with clear instructions to which one is bad and which one is good.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by illiarian on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:57AM (#35567533)
> Having a clear cut "CALL TO ACTION" dialogue option which presents one positive ( don't track me ) and one negative ( track me ) option.

That is literally the requirement by GDPR

> Cookies/tracking banners on website completely obfuscates the choice.

On purpose. In violation of GDPR.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by dre_bot on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:41AM (#35567380)
Most don't even know what the hell a cookie is or any of the shit in those prompts.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by pelorat on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:07AM (#35567624)
I mean Gen-Z barely knows what an operating system is.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by rapnie on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:32AM (#35567332)
The author states this:

> To make this very clear: user/visitor consent is only needed for data going to 3rd parties. All cookie laws, including GDPR and CCPA, allow essential first-party cookies to be exempt from collecting user consent before performing their actions. So your session tracking cookie on your site DOES NOT need a consent popup AT ALL.

Most consent dialogs can be avoided, were it not that the surveillance capitalist services need your data, and shove these dialogs full of deceptive design in your face. In hopes to have as many people as possible complain about the regulations, and use that pressure to lobby them away again.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by 4ad on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:42AM (#35567394)
My bank doesn't use 3rd party cookies, but they have a modal wall you have to click through anyway that explains that they DO NOT use cookies.

This is insanity. Their explanation is that users are so accustomed to these cookie walls that a site without one would feel suspicious and unsafe.

I very much blame the EU on this, because the EU policy has solved NOTHING, tracking still happens just as before, except now users just have to go through more friction. Of course I am also pissed at the websites and entities that sell my data, but that is irrelevant to my gripe with the EU.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by illiarian on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:46AM (#35567427)
Businesses: want to track users and collect their data with reckless abandon

Businesses: implement rampant dark patterns to trick people into accepting tracking and data collection

Businesses: flood the internet with inane, obnoxious and blatantly illegal cookie dialogs

...

4ad: I blame the EU

(Hint: show me where GDPR says anything about cookies)

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by qtzfz on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:49AM (#35567459)
Most internet businesses need tracking to survive, so it's more like either you click past a cookie banner or you don't get to see the content at all.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by Nextgrid on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:25AM (#35567751)
> Most internet businesses need tracking to survive

Most criminal gangs need to steal/rob/etc to survive too.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by illiarian on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:54AM (#35567506)
> Most internet businesses need tracking to survive

Of course they don't.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by 4ad on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:52AM (#35567480)
I blame the businesses for destroying the social fabric of the internet, and I simultaneously blame the EU for implementing pointless regulations that do not solve the first problem while making life miserable for its subjects.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by illiarian on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:56AM (#35567525)
Businesses: destroy the social fabric of the internet

Regulation, literally: do not collect people's data without their consent if you don't require that data for services you provide. Applies in equal measure to websites, banks, grocery stores, shit processing plants and nuclear power stations.

...

4ad: I still blame the EU, and it's a pointless regulation.

Edit: This comment really says it much better: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35567507

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by 4ad on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:00AM (#35567562)
You seem to think that the EU should be imune from criticism because it tries to do the right thing.

No, when politicians make things worse and absolutely don't solve any problem they promised they will solve then they should be held accountable, removed from positions of power, and replaced with competent people who write better regulation.

Edit to your edit: indeed, the EU is mostly about making people miserable while convincing them it's actually better for them.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by illiarian on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:11AM (#35567657)
> You seem to think that the EU should be immune from criticism

No it shouldn't. But it should be criticism and not blaming it for what is 100% the responsibility of the business.

> he EU is mostly about making people miserable while convincing them it's actually better for them.

See, this is not criticism. This is emotionally-charged whining and demagoguery

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by devnullbrain on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:46AM (#35567894)
Superficially, the banners appeared due to how the law was made and how it's implemented. The noble intention is one thing and the pragmatic reality is another.

It's correct to blame the businesses for creating the banners but also unfair to treat the matter as if the businesses and the EU are on a level playing field. The EU makes laws - it has cheat codes to achieve what it wants.

It's like defensive driving. You may not be at fault if someone crashes into you but you may have had the power to prevent it.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by illiarian on Friday April 14, 2023 @07:05AM (#35568041)
> Superficially, the banners appeared due to how the law was made

So stop being superficial and read this 7-year old law. I wonder if you could point to me where it talks about cookie banners

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by devnullbrain on Friday April 14, 2023 @07:25AM (#35568213)
And yet it's been 7 years and the banners still exist.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by illiarian on Friday April 14, 2023 @07:28AM (#35568232)
Because the industry doesn't want to give up on tracking and siphoning user data.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by devnullbrain on Friday April 14, 2023 @07:32AM (#35568257)
7 years of complaining about it hasn't changed that. Do you think another 7 years will be more effective?

Alternatively, the EU could change the laws. Or enforce the existing ones.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by illiarian on Friday April 14, 2023 @07:58AM (#35568469)
> 7 years of complaining about it hasn't changed that.

Funnily how "7 years of complaining" was, and continues to be, only about the EU. Not about the predatory businesses creating these banners (often in direct violation of GDPR).

> Or enforce the existing ones.

That's definitely the biggest criticism you can level at EU: they are too slow in enforcing this.

I think the tide is very slowly changing. First they started showing reject buttons https://noyb.eu/en/where-did-all-reject-buttons-come There's a report on the cookie banners in the works: https://noyb.eu/en/data-protection-authorities-support-noybs... etc.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by devnullbrain on Friday April 14, 2023 @09:30AM (#35569370)
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by illiarian on Friday April 14, 2023 @10:58AM (#35570266)
I will admit that there's also a slowly grown understanding of where the cookie banners come from, so it's not "100% blame the EU".

This comment from one o the linked discussions sums it up well: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29529190

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by Hermel on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:44AM (#35567407)
So why do even the official website of the European commission and the European parliament have a cookie consent button? One would assume that they are not "capitalist services".
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by illiarian on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:48AM (#35567448)
I mean, you could literally read what their banner says. E.g. Eu Paarliament

"We use analytics cookies to offer you a better browsing experience. You have the choice to refuse or accept them. Reject. Accept".

Those analytic cookies are not required for the functioning of the website, and those web sites are required to ask for your consent to gather any additional data.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by rapnie on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:47AM (#35567443)
Unfortunately big tech surveillance capitalists (which is different than "capitalist services", mind you) are court suppliers of IT services that EU institutions depend upon.

Edit: And as the sibling said, in many cases it may be restricted to analytics and simple 'reject' suffices, which is at least better than some of the intricate dialog designs.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by luckylion on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:45AM (#35567416)
Is he right though? I work with affiliate people a lot, and they hate cookie-consent popups. Even when you do all your analytics inhouse with self-hosted matomo, if you want to use a cookie, you need consent is what the lawyers say unanimously. And these aren't "we want you to ask for consent because we secretly want more privacy" lawyers, these are "I get paid to find a way for you to do your tracking in the easiest way possible and I don't care about privacy" lawyers.

Maybe they're all wrong, but I have doubts.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by gbalduzzi on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:18AM (#35567702)
> Even when you do all your analytics inhouse with self-hosted matomo, if you want to use a cookie, you need consent is what the lawyers say unanimously

If you use a cookie for Matomo tracking than yes, you need consent. You are using a cookie for a non essential service (analytics), so you need to ask consent.

But you can use Matomo as cookieless: https://matomo.org/cookie-consent-banners/

If matomo gathers data without a cookie, you can still use technical / essential cookies without consent.

As an example Github.com, owned by Microsoft, does not have a cookie consent popup and sets at least 5 cookies as soon as you open it:

- color mode (dark / light)

- user timezone

- whether the user is logged or guest

- a session cookie

- _octo, that I don't understand.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by luckylion on Friday April 14, 2023 @07:14AM (#35568120)
But that primarily says that Github doesn't care about cookies (or consent), not that you (not being a multinational corporations with an army of lawyers and millions in lobbying spending) can do the same.

I'm pretty sure those cookies are non-compliant if you look at them closely, because none of them are necessary for the operation of the service. a) a default value doesn't need to be stored in a cookie -- and it has to be a default value, because you haven't selected a color scheme or a timezone b) login-state does not require a cookie: either you're logged in and have a session, or you aren't, and you don't, c) there's no reason for a session on the public facing side that doesn't contain any private/individualized data, unless you want to use these session cookies to track users -- and it's only about users as bots will typically ignore cookies.

My money is on "Microsoft knows that cookie consent is optional if you're not a small European company".

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by nicbou on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:45AM (#35567420)
That's completely false though. Tracking your users without consent is still not allowed, even if you store the data on your own servers.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by shmde on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:39AM (#35567368)
Also accepting them cookies is one single click but rejecting them feels like entering the dark realm with multiple options and not knowing where to click. I am software dev but still have to use just enough mental resources to reject all of the non essential ones. How the fuck is this legal.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by germanier on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:43AM (#35567402)
It's not legal. It's just not rigorously enforced.

It was promised that things get better with the proposed ePrivacy regulation. Let's see.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by Anduia on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:50AM (#35567467)
It is not legal for webs to make rejecting cookies more complicated than accepting them.

In fact, the French data protection authority CNIL has issued orders to around sixty players that do not make refusing cookies as easily as accepting them. They have also fined companies such as Google and Facebook for making it harder to reject cookies than to accept them. The CNIL has ordered these companies to provide a means of refusing cookies as simple as the existing means of accepting them.

Also, under GDPR, it is not legal for websites to make rejecting cookies more complicated than accepting them. In May 2020, the EU updated its GDPR guidance to clarify that cookie walls do not offer users a genuine choice because if you reject cookies you’re blocked from accessing content. It confirms that cookie walls should not be used. Companies such as Google have introduced new options to reject tracking cookies in Europe after their existing dialog boxes were found to be in violation of EU data laws.

Now what I don't know is if users outside of EU get the evil-twin version of those popups when visiting websites. My experience browsing the www is just not as bad as many people describe because I usually get a "reject all" button or when "managing" the cookies, they are all disabled by default and I can simply save the options.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by no_time on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:44AM (#35567405)
>We've got to come up with a better solution.

I've got an easy one for you: stop embedding google analytics and others. You don't need a cookie banner when you only have operational ones or better yet, none at all.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by clnq on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:05AM (#35567608)
You can have GDPR-compliant analytics, like what Fathom does.

I also built my own analytics solution that simply shows me my blog article reads per day, week, month, and year (that is all I care about). It's a simple bit of JS that sends a request to my endpoint when the user spends 30 seconds on a page with an article. I also do some light user agent filtering (no "curl" or "python" in the agent string, for example).

I might start logging the referrer in the future to see where my traffic is coming from. However, I am very far from needing cookies or a GDPR notice. I doubt there's a need for cookies at all for most analytics. Even if you wish to track user flow in your website, you can do it with IPs (or hashed IPs to not store the actual IPs) only. An IP is unlikely to change while a user is browsing the website.

It seems to my mind that we only see so many GDPR notices because many websites use dinosaur software like Google Analytics that hasn't been keeping up with the times.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by Nextgrid on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:14AM (#35567673)
> many websites use dinosaur software like Google Analytics that hasn't been keeping up with the times

Or maybe has a conflict of interest, and its true purpose is to act as spyware on behalf of Google? Google absolutely has the skills to build a GDPR-compliant version if they wanted to.

The problem is that they aren't in the business of giving away free stuff. GA is only free because they need to give you an incentive to deploy their spyware - they'll happily let you in on (some) of the data they collect in exchange for you spreading it.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by clnq on Friday April 14, 2023 @07:08AM (#35568065)
They could probably spy on users in a GDPR-compliant way. GDPR isn't about not tracking users, it is about protecting their personal data. All that analytics providers must do in principle is make sure to never associate certain types of data (phone numbers, names, addresses, and similar) to the user fingerprint they use for advertising.

As far as I understand (and I could be wrong), the cookie notices exist because analytics providers do not guarantee that this personal data won't be associated with the cookie fingerprint in their systems. Cookies themselves are only mentioned once in relation to this in the GDPR text:

> Natural persons may be associated with online identifiers provided by their devices, applications, tools and protocols, such as internet protocol addresses, cookie identifiers or other identifiers such as radio frequency identification tags. This may leave traces which, in particular when combined with unique identifiers and other information received by the servers, may be used to create profiles of the natural persons and identify them.

If the advertising ID/fingerprint was kept unassociated with personal data capable of identifying a natural person, there would be no need for the cookie notice in my understanding. However, I am not a lawyer.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by oneeyedpigeon on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:47AM (#35567438)
Are you sure that out-of-the-box GA requires it? I thought the only info it recorded was anonymised.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by illiarian on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:54AM (#35567500)
GA collects insane amounts of data. And you might have to disable a lot of that collection manually https://support.google.com/analytics/answer/9019185?hl=en#zi...

And even then it might not be strictly compliant due to Schrems II ruling

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by matsemann on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:09AM (#35567640)
Even with consent and configuration, GA might be illegal in the EU. It's currently in a grey area after some latest rulings.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by Nextgrid on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:05AM (#35567602)
Anonymization (if you actually believe Google despite their conflict of interest and previous GDPR breaches) still happens on their server, so the IP address (which counts as personal data) is still transmitted there.

I guess you may actually make it truly anonymous from a GDPR point of view if you proxy all calls through your own server and strip out anything that can be used to reidentify a user - so no IP addresses, session IDs, etc.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by boffinism on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:55AM (#35567511)
Don't confuse cookie laws with data laws
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by progval on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:00AM (#35567556)
According to the French data protection authority, "out-of-the-box" GA requires consent because they aren't anonymised: https://www.cnil.fr/en/google-analytics-and-data-transfers-h...
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by oneeyedpigeon on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:11AM (#35567650)
Well, I'm glad I don't use GA on my personal site, then, even if it means I have no idea what traffic levels it gets. GA is incredibly popular though - I would guess the vast majority of blogs etc. use it and have no consent to do so.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by mabedan on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:44AM (#35567406)
You’re missing the point of the article. The banner is only needed if your business relies on handing over info about the user to 3rd party. And yes, it’s reasonable to make sure user knows about it. The fact that these pop ups are annoying is the fault of the creator, not the regulation.

Try accessing Apple.com or iCloud.com. No cookie pop up, yet one of the most successful businesses in history. You don’t have to be annoying

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by qtzfz on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:48AM (#35567445)
What info? My IP address and the pages I've visited inside their site? By visiting a site I know I'm giving that info to them, they can do whatever they want with it.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by jeltz on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:49AM (#35567455)
Not without breaking the law.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by qtzfz on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:52AM (#35567476)
Which is why it's a stupid law that has made everybody's lives worse, both the businesses and the users.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by hammyhavoc on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:34AM (#35567815)
Why is it a stupid law? Why should businesses be free to look up the IP and figure out who is looking at their page? An IP can reveal a lot of information, especially if there's servers hanging off of it.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by mschild on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:53AM (#35567492)
That's great if youre fine with it. I'm not. I don't want some shitty, 3rd rate, ad slinging company to know what websites I visited.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by illiarian on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:52AM (#35567478)
> What info?

Any personally identifiable information.

GDPR is not a complex law no matter how shady businesses and clueless devs are trying to tell you. It's also been in effect for 7 years. You'd think it's enough time to have at least some clue on what it's about.

And yet we still have these inane threads on HN claiming it's about cookie popups, and people having no idea what info trackers collect.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by wongarsu on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:45AM (#35567419)
At least part of the intent of the law was that websites would reduce the amount of tracking if they have to explicitly ask for consent. You can build your website with just functional cookies (session cookie, storing preferences like dark mode, etc) and cookie-less tracking, and go without any cookie popups.

Somehow the industry decided it's better to annoy your users with consent for 50 different trackers with the most in-your-face popup possible to cause users to reflexively hit consent instead.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by Nextgrid on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:16AM (#35567687)
> Somehow the industry decided it's better to annoy your users with consent for 50 different trackers with the most in-your-face popup possible to cause users to reflexively hit consent instead.

GDPR actually has provisions against this kind of malicious compliance - the problem is a chronic lack of enforcement, despite it being trivial to detect with a web crawler.

Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by datkirby on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:54AM (#35567505)
People are definitely aware of them. The trouble lies with how easy opting-out is. Many websites have included options to just opt for the "compulsory" option. The only concern now is how many of them would willingly provide that option.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by ssss11 on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:55AM (#35567519)
Of course the simple solution that we all know is to not collect the damn data in the first place. But marketing boffins the world over will never willingly do this unless it’s enforced by law, so we’re left with the user’s taking on the burden of clicking deliberately confusing stuff and not knowing whether they’ve ended up consenting or not.
Re:Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve you... by maeln on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:02AM (#35567574)
Most people do not care because they don't really see/understand how it affect them. Just like most people probably don't care about HVAC regulation, welding regulation for system under pressure and other very technical field.

They will see the issue and care about it when something happen. We have a lot of regulation about welding under high pressure because we know from experience what happen when we have no rules (things go boom).

What happen when we have no regulation about tracker ? We get massive data leaks from poorly secured data hoarding company (hello Equifax). This is dangerous in many many ways: Identity theft, scam & spam, identifying people with certain political view, from a minority of some sort, etc... GDPR does not solve all this issue, some company can still hoard massive amount of data about you (it is always scary to ask for a data extraction from Meta, Twitter, ... and how you have a "profile") and have bad security, but it does limit in how many hand this data circulate and how easy it is to gain access to.