This is insanity. Their explanation is that users are so accustomed to these cookie walls that a site without one would feel suspicious and unsafe.
I very much blame the EU on this, because the EU policy has solved NOTHING, tracking still happens just as before, except now users just have to go through more friction. Of course I am also pissed at the websites and entities that sell my data, but that is irrelevant to my gripe with the EU.
Businesses: implement rampant dark patterns to trick people into accepting tracking and data collection
Businesses: flood the internet with inane, obnoxious and blatantly illegal cookie dialogs
...
4ad: I blame the EU
(Hint: show me where GDPR says anything about cookies)
Most criminal gangs need to steal/rob/etc to survive too.
Of course they don't.
Regulation, literally: do not collect people's data without their consent if you don't require that data for services you provide. Applies in equal measure to websites, banks, grocery stores, shit processing plants and nuclear power stations.
...
4ad: I still blame the EU, and it's a pointless regulation.
Edit: This comment really says it much better: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35567507
No, when politicians make things worse and absolutely don't solve any problem they promised they will solve then they should be held accountable, removed from positions of power, and replaced with competent people who write better regulation.
Edit to your edit: indeed, the EU is mostly about making people miserable while convincing them it's actually better for them.
No it shouldn't. But it should be criticism and not blaming it for what is 100% the responsibility of the business.
> he EU is mostly about making people miserable while convincing them it's actually better for them.
See, this is not criticism. This is emotionally-charged whining and demagoguery
It's correct to blame the businesses for creating the banners but also unfair to treat the matter as if the businesses and the EU are on a level playing field. The EU makes laws - it has cheat codes to achieve what it wants.
It's like defensive driving. You may not be at fault if someone crashes into you but you may have had the power to prevent it.
So stop being superficial and read this 7-year old law. I wonder if you could point to me where it talks about cookie banners
Alternatively, the EU could change the laws. Or enforce the existing ones.
Funnily how "7 years of complaining" was, and continues to be, only about the EU. Not about the predatory businesses creating these banners (often in direct violation of GDPR).
> Or enforce the existing ones.
That's definitely the biggest criticism you can level at EU: they are too slow in enforcing this.
I think the tide is very slowly changing. First they started showing reject buttons https://noyb.eu/en/where-did-all-reject-buttons-come There's a report on the cookie banners in the works: https://noyb.eu/en/data-protection-authorities-support-noybs... etc.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17679596
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25457469
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30982470
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23090393
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29529062
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19381063
All of these links have comments against this sentiment.
This comment from one o the linked discussions sums it up well: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29529190
"We use analytics cookies to offer you a better browsing experience. You have the choice to refuse or accept them. Reject. Accept".
Those analytic cookies are not required for the functioning of the website, and those web sites are required to ask for your consent to gather any additional data.
Edit: And as the sibling said, in many cases it may be restricted to analytics and simple 'reject' suffices, which is at least better than some of the intricate dialog designs.
Maybe they're all wrong, but I have doubts.
If you use a cookie for Matomo tracking than yes, you need consent. You are using a cookie for a non essential service (analytics), so you need to ask consent.
But you can use Matomo as cookieless: https://matomo.org/cookie-consent-banners/
If matomo gathers data without a cookie, you can still use technical / essential cookies without consent.
As an example Github.com, owned by Microsoft, does not have a cookie consent popup and sets at least 5 cookies as soon as you open it:
- color mode (dark / light)
- user timezone
- whether the user is logged or guest
- a session cookie
- _octo, that I don't understand.
I'm pretty sure those cookies are non-compliant if you look at them closely, because none of them are necessary for the operation of the service. a) a default value doesn't need to be stored in a cookie -- and it has to be a default value, because you haven't selected a color scheme or a timezone b) login-state does not require a cookie: either you're logged in and have a session, or you aren't, and you don't, c) there's no reason for a session on the public facing side that doesn't contain any private/individualized data, unless you want to use these session cookies to track users -- and it's only about users as bots will typically ignore cookies.
My money is on "Microsoft knows that cookie consent is optional if you're not a small European company".
> To make this very clear: user/visitor consent is only needed for data going to 3rd parties. All cookie laws, including GDPR and CCPA, allow essential first-party cookies to be exempt from collecting user consent before performing their actions. So your session tracking cookie on your site DOES NOT need a consent popup AT ALL.
Most consent dialogs can be avoided, were it not that the surveillance capitalist services need your data, and shove these dialogs full of deceptive design in your face. In hopes to have as many people as possible complain about the regulations, and use that pressure to lobby them away again.