News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by Vervious on Thursday April 13, 2023 @11:01AM (#35556526)
A ton of people care about property crime and I don't think you should look down on them.

SF has 3-5x the property crime of most major cities in the United States. I imagine most violent crime is targeted (i.e. the victim is not a random person walking down the street), but property crime is scary because it can happen to the best of us, our friends and our family, in even the "safest" neighborhoods. We all know friends whose cars have been broken into. And it's easy to imagine --- what if my kids were at home during one of these home break-ins? (Note that burglaries are not classified as violent crime in SF)

Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by cemerick on Thursday April 13, 2023 @11:24AM (#35556889)
That's great; in general, people should be, and I'm not looking down on them for doing so.

However, property crime is absolutely irrelevant when presented with the news of someone's murder, yet so many people here are quick to conflate them as somehow equivalent vis a vis personal safety, etc.

(Sidenote: I personally don't understand anyone thinking that property crime is "scary". Your car is not your kid. Your wallet is not your body. Your house is not your family. These things are not in the same class, and a loss in one category is not the same as a loss in the other. I'm not sure how one could argue otherwise, but it's apparently a widely-held worldview.)

Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by bigtex88 on Thursday April 13, 2023 @11:34AM (#35557051)
This is a legitimate question - are you autistic? The inability for you to understand why property crime could be equally as scary or emotionally scarring is leading me to believe that you are neuro-divergent because that's just such a weird thing to believe.

Property crimes lead to a generally dangerous living area and people don't like to live in dangerous areas because it necessarily leads to more violent crime.

Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by cemerick on Thursday April 13, 2023 @11:44AM (#35557198)
Your "legitimate question" is insulting to me and to those who actually are autistic. Everyone on HN is so nice.

No, I don't think being pickpocketed (or having my car stolen or whatever) is "equally as scary" as if my daughter were assaulted or kidnapped. I'd be ashamed to think they're equivalent, lest my daughter believe I view her as valuable as a hunk of steel or a wad of cash.

> Property crimes lead to a generally dangerous living area and people don't like to live in dangerous areas because it necessarily leads to more violent crime.

This is deeply incorrect. As has been repeated and cited over and over, violent crime in e.g. SF is not particularly high (lower than most other US cities), while its property crime rate is outrageously high.

Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by bigtex88 on Thursday April 13, 2023 @11:49AM (#35557288)
I really don't understand your viewpoint here. You seem to be implying that property crime is fine and dandy and no one should really be worried about it because "having a child assaulted is worse!". Again, a bizarre world-view, hence the autism question.

Just because they're not emotionally equivalent doesn't mean that property crime isn't bad. SF has a massive issue regarding petty crime. It leads to a more dangerous city overall.

Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by jjulius on Thursday April 13, 2023 @12:42PM (#35558238)
>Just because they're not emotionally equivalent doesn't mean that property crime isn't bad.

In sticking with the autism question - are you? OP has yet to state that "property crime isn't bad" yet you've commented repeatedly to imply that they have, among other things.

"Not as bad as" != "Not bad"

Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by dang on Thursday April 13, 2023 @12:46PM (#35558287)
You've unfortunately been crossing into personal attack and name-calling repeatedly in your HN posts, as well as breaking the site guidelines in other ways. We ban accounts that do this kind of thing, so could you please stop?

If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.

Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by bigtex88 on Friday April 14, 2023 @02:36PM (#35573107)
It was a legitimate question. I truly don't understand how anyone can imagine property crime as "not scary". I was trying to get a better understanding of the person so that I would not be rude if he actually was neurodivergent.

It's extraordinarily hard to differentiate between trolls and non-trolls online anymore so I don't see what's wrong with asking that of someone.

Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by dang on Friday April 14, 2023 @09:01PM (#35576696)
What's wrong is that, whether you intended it to or not, it is inevitably going to land as a personal attack.

If you want additional explanation, here are links to lots of it - not in the most convenient format to read, but it covers the essentials:

the burden is on the commenter to disambiguate their intent - https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

we have to moderate by likely effects, not by intent - https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...

internet psychiatric diagnosis is best avoided - https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&type=comment&dateRange=a...

Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by vkou on Thursday April 13, 2023 @11:33AM (#35557032)
A burglary is much scarier than someone stealing shit from your car, because someone invaded your living space in the latter. It's a much more serious invasion of your privacy than a broken window smash and grab.

The point I made in the sibling point stands, though. At 55th in the nation, SF does not have a high burglary rate. It has a high larceny (stealing from stores, cars, etc) rate.

Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by cemerick on Thursday April 13, 2023 @11:46AM (#35557246)
I'm not comparing e.g. burglaries to car thefts, but the category of property crimes to the category of violent crimes. The former range from unfortunate nuisances to unpleasant material losses (depending on how well you've scoped your insurances); the latter can be life-shattering tragedies.
Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by Vervious on Thursday April 13, 2023 @11:50AM (#35557314)
Btw, I think technically if the car is locked, it's also classified as a burglary
Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by DharmaPolice on Thursday April 13, 2023 @12:05PM (#35557589)
People (on the whole) aren't afraid of losing stuff. They're afraid of someone coming into their home or grabbing them on the street and things going south. If you somehow had a device which 100% guaranteed your personal safety (but somehow still allowed theft) then (for most people) most of these crimes would merely be an inconvenience/irritation on the same level as low level credit card fraud (where you lose no money but have to get a new card).
Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by Jackpillar on Thursday April 13, 2023 @02:37PM (#35560043)
"They're afraid of someone coming into their home or grabbing them on the street and things going south"

Luckily, this isn't a real thing that happens.

Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by vkou on Thursday April 13, 2023 @11:16AM (#35556775)
You're performing a sleight of hand. No city census or national crime analysis categorizes burglary as a violent crime, and I'm not sure why you called SF out on it.

I don't look down on people complaining about property crime, I'd just like them to be honest about what they are complaining about.

SF is 55 out of the biggest 100 cities on burglary rates, by the way.

(It's interesting how all this is apparently a controversial take.)

Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by LawTalkingGuy on Thursday April 13, 2023 @12:15PM (#35557787)
> No city census or national crime analysis categorizes burglary as a violent crime, and I'm not sure why you called SF out on it.

Most other cities aren't wallowing in it the same way, and aren't holier than thou despite their polices clearly having caused the issue. But you're right, it's not just SF. LA and Seattle are pretty much right there too.

The crime cities like SF are worth calling out in a way that other violent cities aren't though because there's a giant epidemic of what we're pressured to call "non-violent crime" like shoplifting and car theft that gets violent instantly whenever the criminal doesn't get their way. I've personally seen people get shoved out of the way of a fleeing thief, and videos of people being attacked when they come back at the wrong time and discover their car being robbed. To say SF isn't violent ignores that the residents are on the edge of violence constantly.

> SF is 55 out of the biggest 100 cities on burglary rates, by the way.

These crime rates are what's reported by the police and they refuse to take reports of anything that hasn't escalated so they ignore most of what the everyday person suffers. These statistics should be seen more as evidence of collusion in the SFPD, not used to prove the safety of the city.

Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by vkou on Thursday April 13, 2023 @01:14PM (#35558759)
> LA and Seattle

That's a strange way of spelling Cleveland, Memphis, Baton Rouge, Tulsa, Baltimore, Albuquerque, Detroit, Mobile, Cincinnati, Toledo, Des Moines, Seattle, Indianapolis, Spokane, St. Louis, San Bernadino, Bakersfield, Kansas City, Oklahoma City, Milwaukee, Buffalo, Minneapolis, Durham, Orlando, Wichita... And I can't be bothered to list the next 30, all of whom also have more burglaries per capita than SF, and most of which also have more assaults, murders, and rapes.

LA is #73 on the burglary index, by the way.

You're making a lot of claims, and providing zero data for them.

> These crime rates are what's reported by the police and they refuse to take reports of anything that hasn't escalated

Please provide a shred of evidence that this doesn't happen in any of the other other cities listed in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_b...

Why even bother arguing this question, if all you have is anecdotes, speculation and just-so stories?

Re:Arrest made in Bob Lee case. Alleged killer also worked i... by LawTalkingGuy on Thursday April 13, 2023 @01:57PM (#35559409)
> Why even bother arguing this question

I live in two of the drug cities and visit others, and pay taxes that support many of these policies specifically. Do you live in one of the west-coast cities in question, or is this an abstract political battle for you? If you live here, do you feel you're a representative resident?

> if all you have is anecdotes, speculation and just-so stories?

Well, there's the crux of it, these are anecdotes that have happened to me personally. Over decades of experience and watching things change. And there's tons of data collected by victims but as has been pointed out, the news often chooses to report on acknowledged crime where a police officer has been sent out and taken a report. FB groups where people log violent street interactions or businesses' windows being broken show a definite uptick that government statistics don't. I know it's true because I walk past enough of those broken windows and stabbing sites to provide a reality check for what I'm seeing published.

We know that there are vastly more actual rapes than reported rapes and punished rapes. Why it is so unreasonable that there are vastly more actual attacks and robberies than reported?

> [other cities] all of whom also have more burglaries per capita than SF, and most of which also have more assaults, murders, and rapes.

Perception of livability despite violent crime has a lot to do with the localization of that crime. If only certain areas, at certain times, are dangerous - and if those areas are ones that can be avoided - then you can generally just go elsewhere with your family and be fine. That's the liberal way SF and such used to work. Sure, there were sleezy places but the street people would even helpfully and quietly warn tourists - "Hey bud, there's a lot of drugs down here, you should really take your kids a few blocks that way."

But once it spills over into random attacks outside that area, such that you can be killed at the busiest coffee shop in the city, the entire veneer of safety goes away.

We're saying two main things: that it got bad really quickly and predictably, and it's being officially downplayed.

> Please provide a shred of evidence that this doesn't happen in any of the other other cities listed in

It's somewhat annoying that what should be an issue of local policy ends up being purity-checked by people trying to decide if we're too partisan in national politics. We're talking about our policies, not trying to claim that other cities can't fail just as hard as we are but with a different set of errors.