News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by resuresu on Thursday April 13, 2023 @06:52AM (#35553553)
The internet is dying.
Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by claritise on Thursday April 13, 2023 @07:33AM (#35553868)
Decentralisation is the key... but no... just blanket hate on anything related crypto/blockchain.
Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by trasz3 on Thursday April 13, 2023 @07:47AM (#35553979)
Anything related to crypto/blockchain tends to be a technically very poor way of doing decentralisation.
Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by nobody9999 on Thursday April 13, 2023 @09:06AM (#35554813)
>Decentralisation is the key... but no... just blanket hate on anything related crypto/blockchain.

Blockchains are not the be all and end all of decentralization. In fact, most decentralized use cases don't require (and performance would suffer significantly if used) blockchains at all.

I'm not hating on blockchains, they have some important uses. But decentralized communications ala the Fediverse[0] wouldn't gain anything from blockchains, and ActivityPub[1] is most certainly decentralized, and while I suppose someone could bolt a blockchain onto it, it's unclear to me what value could be added.

And there's this one weird thing I heard about the other day. It's so outlandish I thought it was somebody's psychotic fever-dream. Supposedly, there are these things called "websites." Not sure what they are, but apparently, just about anyone can set up/own/run one (or more) all by themselves on skinny hardware without any blockchains. I heard about this and just snorted derisively because that's clearly bullshit -- no one could ever do anything like that. /s

[0] https://fediverse.party/

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ActivityPub

Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by doodlesdev on Thursday April 13, 2023 @12:33PM (#35558076)

   > And there's this one weird thing I heard about the other day. It's so outlandish I thought it was somebody's psychotic fever-dream. Supposedly, there are these things called "websites." Not sure what they are, but apparently, just about anyone can set up/own/run one (or more) all by themselves on skinny hardware without any blockchains.
Until someone who doesn't like you sues DNS providers for resolving your hostname, or your nameserver provider decides to kick you, or the FEDs decide to seize the server hosting it, and then you'll wish it was all on IPFS and you were using a Web3 domain (Unstoppable, ENS, etc.). It's not a panacea, but I think it would be step in the right direction.

Before we start talking about Tor (which is awesome) I'd like to remind that onion addresses are absurdly horrible and would never be adopted by mainstream, the only way to have limited domains per physical person (and thus the abillity to choose a somewhat good looking domain) is for them to cost something, and cryptocurrency is the decentralized way we have to do it for now, thus that's where Unstoppable and ENS come from.

Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by mattdesl on Friday April 14, 2023 @02:45AM (#35566286)
The fediverse is not decentralized, it is “federated.” Large portions of the fediverse are censored by a few powerful admins that control the majority of users and speech that flows through the network.

Better examples of decentralized social platforms might be Bluesky or Farcaster. The former relies on DNS (which has some central points of failure) and the latter relies on Ethereum (which does not have the same central points of failure).

Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by nobody9999 on Friday April 14, 2023 @02:21PM (#35572894)
>The fediverse is not decentralized, it is “federated.” Large portions of the fediverse are censored by a few powerful admins that control the majority of users and speech that flows through the network.

Really? No one can force me to post (or not) anything on my Pixelfed[0] instance. And if they wanted to, they'd need to commit felonies (using violence or breaking into my premises physically or over the network) to do so.

You're seem to be under the misapprehension that self-hosting isn't viable. I don't believe so (and self-host many services), but I respect your opinion.

Don't like what "a few powerful admins that control the majority of users and speech that flows through the network?" Don't use or federate with those instances.

As I said, I run several ActivityPub instances and I don't even know who such "powerful admins" might be. Nor do I care.

I get your point, but (not attacking you here, just the idea that you have to interact with "big" sites not under your control, that (might) make moderation decisions you don't like).

If your goal is to reach the largest number of people, presumably for commercial purposes, I suppose that you might feel limited by folks who don't want your unsolicited commercial posts on or federated with their sites.

That could be limiting. But the vast majority of us just want to share and interact with people we know about non-commercial stuff. Setting up you own instance is absolutely decentralized (go ahead -- block my Pixelfed site -- I don't care -- I don't know you and I don't want to interact with you).

There are many use cases and perspectives here, but your assertion that ActivityPub (AP) (as a protocol, not any specific instance, which is why I separated the applications that run on top of AP) isn't decentralized isn't accurate.

The existence of instances with large (relatively speaking) numbers of users is irrelevant to whether or not the protocol and the platforms that rely on it are decentralized or not.

Feel free to disagree -- As I said, I get your point, but it's not relevant to any of my use cases. If the current AP ecosystem doesn't meet your needs, you have other alternatives as you mention -- But AP is definitely decentralized.

[0] https://pixelfed.org/

Edit: Fixed grammar. Clarified my thoughts.

Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by chaxor on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:06AM (#35577519)
Agreed, and it's really frustrating to see how little HN understands that decentralized != 'cryptocurrency' or blockchains. There's such an immense hatred due to laziness in categorizing anything remotely close to blockchains (without regard for how close e.g. git is to these technologies). There is a lot of value in them to solve some of our problems (e.g. the foreseeable closing of Docker hub, huggingface, and many others).
Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by Eddy_Viscosity2 on Thursday April 13, 2023 @07:10AM (#35553692)
It's just Conway's Law asserting itself. The internet is just continuing its transformation to better match the socio-economic-political system -- that of top-down control.
Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by AstixAndBelix on Thursday April 13, 2023 @07:08AM (#35553688)
And using services that need ads to survive by bypassing those ads does not help!
Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by t-3 on Thursday April 13, 2023 @07:41AM (#35553931)
YouTube isn't what's dying, it's the organic, non-monetized, grassroots web that's being killed off. You know, the stuff that's actually interesting and cool and not trying to sell you anything.
Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by pixl97 on Thursday April 13, 2023 @08:54AM (#35554655)
Stop talking to each other and start buying things....

https://catvalente.substack.com/p/stop-talking-to-each-other...

Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by vorticalbox on Thursday April 13, 2023 @07:37AM (#35553907)
this is why i disbale my adblock on reasources that are using them to stay around.
Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by grugagag on Thursday April 13, 2023 @08:23AM (#35554300)
Have you tried disabling adblocks on youtube? It’s only not usable but downright malicious
Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by vorticalbox on Friday April 14, 2023 @03:25AM (#35566522)
I mostly watch YouTube on my phone and ads are reasonable. Usually 2 short ones at the start then nothing else.
Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by pixl97 on Thursday April 13, 2023 @08:52AM (#35554626)
Ads are the reason the internet is dying....
Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by xxs on Thursday April 13, 2023 @10:09AM (#35555698)
I can't think of a single service that 'needs' advertising, and I need it. Youtube has a paid subscription, so does every stream service.
Re:YouTube-Dl Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censor... by digitalsushi on Thursday April 13, 2023 @10:45AM (#35556277)
The Internet is not dying. It's just on pause mode.

The people that built the Internet are not the people that will keep building the Internet. Their hunger was fed long ago by the yields harvested by their contributions to technology.

The Internet will remain on pause mode until someone disrupts it with new technology that cannot be contained by social solutions. Something that outpaces laws, outpaces cease and desists. Technology that is unaffected the current rules but uses the Internet as its substrate.

It sounds like anarchy but it's just what the Internet was one full human generation earlier. (Arguably pushing on two generations now).

If we invented the Internet today, we'd consider it an insidious invention designed to pry control away and redistribute it to institutions that shouldn't own it. Could we do it a second time?