I've worked on an inpatient psychiatric unit, and while the doctors might not be "mad", it absolutely is torture. The most obvious example is sleep deprivation, which is definitely torture. This is done in the name of "helping" the person (by checking on them), but makes things so much worse.
> My druthers would be to re-institutionalize and keep a very high legal and regulatory scrutiny on the institutions.
This does not and can not work for reasons outlined in my original comment. The system claims to be helping but shuts down any feedback mechanism that would suggest otherwise. There's just no way to square that circle.
Checking on them how often?
Is it worse than a normal hospital?
Believing that all patients, regardless of their exact illness, cannot be trusted to accurately describe abuse done to them is precisely what enables abuse in the first place. Suicidal thoughts is not a condition where you cannot tell if you're being taken out of bed in the middle of sleep. Suicidal thoughts is not a condition where you cannot understand someone is threatening you.
With the caveat that this is just an anecdote, one of my family members is an extremely intelligent and highly accomplished man. He graduated from Yale law, worked at a very high level in the executive branch, and during his professional career, I don't know anyone who questioned his character. Retired, he is now suffering from severe intractible depression.
Last month, I drove my relative to a doctor's appointment, and due to his own mistake, he showed up at the wrong time. And on the wrong day. Since I had walked him into the office, I heard his conversation with the receptionist, and then with his doctor, who came out to calm things down.
On the ride back to his house, my relative phoned another member of my family and angrily explained what had happened. He blamed everything on the doctor, and made baseless accusations against the doctor and receptionist. My relative's account of the situation wasn't based in reality. And he related his account right in front of me. He truly believed every word he was saying. But it wasn't true. I saw what had happened with my own eyes. I heard it with my own ears. I, fortunately, am well.
It wasn't the doctor's fault, nor was it the receptionist's fault. Quite the opposite, my relative had made a mistake. His illness, however, — depression — blinded him to that reality. And his reaction was to sling baseless accusations at his doctor.
Like I wrote before, this is a really difficult problem. I don't have a solution. I wish I did.
Some wards are noisier than others.
I've heard of a camera in-room as well. Better for disturbance, worse for privacy.
Note that these people in acute inpatient wards are in a serious crisis: attendants _have_ to make sure they aren't hurting themselves.
Lol I was taken involuntarily to the hospital. When they gave up billing me they simply turned it over to collections to let them deal with squeezing the blood from the turnip. (not mental though, fraudulent accusation by federal agents I had drugs up my ass and then dragged there in handcuffs).
Roughly - without the violence - a friend watched this precise scenario last fall in Spokane, WA. If the person had been within hospital grounds, the paramedics & security could have restrained them under grounds of inability to make choice, given them medications, and maybe helped them some. But, since the person was a block away from the hospital, there was no ability to say, "buddy, you have feces all over you and are laying with flies all over. we're gonna take you in, hose you off, launder the clothes, then see what we can do for your mental state". That would have been the kindest thing to do.
The crux is that certain "out of your mind" states require external intervention, and there is no legal way to apply that in many jurisdictions today. Note that some jurisdictions require a trial-like apparatus for involuntary holds after some 24/36? hour period - I don't that's inappropriate at all. Being able to see a guy laying covered in filth and take him in to help should be legal; at least for 24 hours. The indigent will have their debt forgiven - hospitals know they don't get blood from a turnip.
It is true that some medications don't work for everyone, and some medications produce horrific side effects. So there is some % of people for whom the best medication regimes today do not work. That has to be considered and reflected through. It's also true that there's high correlation with addiction and homelessness. That all has to be considered and addressed.
Considering institutions. As I've had a good friend for a long time with mental illness who has been in wards, the quote from the article is very true.
> I disliked the hospital, but even with its heavy locked door, I knew it wasn’t a branch of the “carceral state” devised by a power‑mad society to torment him.
And this has to be understood by everyone who thinks through this. Mental wards in the United States today are not, conventionally, torture chambers for mad doctors. They are restrictive and often frustrating, for reasons that a little thought should reveal. Aberrant nurses and arrogant & high-handed docs exist there, but they are not, systemically, the norm. It is not a horror movie.
TBQH, I don't think the vast majority of mental health writings online by non-experts touch on severe mental illness in anything approximating a realistic way.
The status quo is really quite unacceptable. My druthers would be to re-institutionalize and keep a very high legal and regulatory scrutiny on the institutions. Other solutions might work well too. But a key cornerstone of improvement will have to come to changing the shape of the law for involuntary holds and medication for people in high crisis.