News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by cwmoore on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:06PM (#35527139)
The eagerness to reason from the headline anecdata on this topic is a signal that it is not just the mentally ill who exhibit severe thinking problems.

No, you can't reason with that one person at that moment. Get them sedated, cleaned up, new clothes and a haircut, and then ask them what is going on with them.

For each one like that there are another 10,000 people in various forms of quiet desperation.

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by UncleOxidant on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:40PM (#35527600)
> Get them sedated

Kind of tough to get them to that first step willingly. Got any other ideas?

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by cwmoore on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:47PM (#35527715)
<del>Willingly was your idea.</del> As for other ideas, some are in the comment.

What about the 10,000 who might be willing if society offered them treatment options even a sane person would accept?

EDIT: because sibling comments are willfully ignoring my point

EDIT2: public disturbances are frequently halted with police arrest, not whatever willingness could be brought about ahead of time with better systems in place

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by pc86 on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @01:06PM (#35527991)
Willingly wasn't necessarily their idea, that's the whole point of this thread - getting people into treatment by their own choice vs. forcing them:

> > > ... treatment should be helpful enough and sufficiently respectful of users' rights, that people who need it don't refuse it

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by cwmoore on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @01:23PM (#35528202)
The list of people who need help is so much longer than any one causing an event that makes it into the newspapers or anecdotes.

Why is it such a fantasy that treatment options should be appealing to the people committing themselves to them?

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by smcg on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @03:09PM (#35529856)
presumably, in order to obtain consent. non-consensually committing someone raises issues that must be addressed to prevent abuse.

I live in a state with 72 hour minimum emergency involuntary committal. (further requires a court order) this is a compromise that addresses the above concern. ideally it is enough for the patient to get on a routine of taking meds and making sure there aren't adverse reactions from them.

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by UncleOxidant on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @01:20PM (#35528169)
We used to fairly easily commit people to asylums. There was lots of abuse of this power. Mental institutions were very bad places (see One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest). Finally the pendulum started swinging the other direction starting in about the 50s (in the 60s JFK called for reform) and culminating in the 80s when Reagan effectively emptied the mental institutions (but more for budgetary reasons than any concern for the mentally ill). And now we've reached the other extreme where we're too afraid to violate the civil rights of the mentally ill so we let them stay on the streets because that's what they "want" to do.
Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @01:39PM (#35528448)
> culminating in the 80s when Reagan effectively emptied the mental institutions (but more for budgetary reasons than any concern for the mentally ill).

“Reagan” getting credit or blame for this is largley misleading. There were a number of drivers..

Deinstitutionalizations was an important goal of the Community Mental Health Act of 1963.

Subsequently, a series of federal court rulings in the 1970s which restricted involuntary commitment and required paying patients federal minimum wage for doing work in and for institutions (like the prisons, mental institutions were slave institutions – on top of their myriad other problems – in all but name) undercut both the pipeline and the financial underpinnings of the system of institutionalization.

Re:American Madness: Our Dysfunctional System for Treating M... by cwmoore on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @01:25PM (#35528237)
I think too many basically sane people are close enough to losing their minds at all times that they would fear for their own civil rights. The mentally ill on the streets are only a small sample of a spectrum.

I understand the history well enough to note that a wide swath of (also) expensive alternatives have not been tried yet, or the basically sane people mentioned above would be willing to undergo treatment that works.