News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by dolmen on Friday April 07, 2023 @10:04AM (#35481683)
Terms of use:

YOU EXPRESSLY ACKNOWLEDGE THAT USE OF THE SERVICES IS AT YOUR SOLE RISK AND THAT THE ENTIRE RISK AS TO SATISFACTORY QUALITY, PERFORMANCE, ACCURACY, AND EFFORT IS WITH YOU. ALL PARTS OFTHE SERVICES ARE PROVIDED BY WESTERN DIGITALON AN “AS IS,” “WITHALL FAULTS,” AND “AS AVAILABLE” BASIS ONLY, WITH ALL FAULTS AND WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND. WESTERNDIGITAL HEREBY EXPRESSLY DISCLAIMS ALL REPRESENTATIONS,WARRANTIES, AND CONDITIONS WITH RESPECT TO THE SERVICES (INCLUDING THE USE, PERFORMANCE, AND SUPPORT THEREOF), WHETHER EXPRESS, IMPLIED, STATUTORY, OR OTHERWISE,INCLUDING ANY IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, MERCHANTABILITY, TITLE, AND NON-INFRINGEMENT.WESTERN DIGITAL DOES NOT MAKE ANY ASSURANCES WITH REGARD TO THE ACCURACY OF THE RESULTS OR OUTPUT THAT DERIVES FROM THE SERVICES.

Source: https://www.westerndigital.com/legal/terms-of-use

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by ferminaut on Friday April 07, 2023 @10:22AM (#35481859)
I asked chatGPT to summarize this like I was a child:

> Imagine you have a toy that you're not sure will work perfectly or not. The people who made the toy say that they're not sure either and that you have to take the risk of using it. They also say that if the toy doesn't work well or isn't accurate, it's not their fault, and they won't promise to fix it or make it better. They also can't promise that the results you get from using the toy will be correct. So, you have to be careful and use it at your own risk!

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by seanw444 on Friday April 07, 2023 @10:35AM (#35481986)
Warning: this product might be the polar opposite of what you want.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by ChuckNorris89 on Friday April 07, 2023 @01:46PM (#35484555)
But we'll take your money anyway.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by j1elo on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:42PM (#35483715)
If ChatGPT is just a glorified autocomplete engine, which doesn't know the context or the meaning of what is being said (as I've read in random discussions here on HN), then how come it is able to process the license text and summarize it in those terms? I would think that it would be needed to "understand" the license text in order to produce that easier to understand version.

So, does chatGPT really know what it's writing about, or not?

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by esafak on Friday April 07, 2023 @01:04PM (#35484020)
We are "glorified" autocomplete engines too. The glory is in the fact that we have a world model underpinning the engine. ChatGPT has a complex model, if not as complex as ours, and it is good enough to perform such tasks. As these models improve, they will compete with and outperform us on more and more tasks, at which point we will stop comparing our abilities to execute tasks.

"Sure, it can do everything, but it's not human."

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by acchow on Friday April 07, 2023 @01:41PM (#35484481)
> We are "glorified" autocomplete engines too

This doesn’t feel intuitive to me or convincing. What evidence do you have to support such a claim? I certainly don’t feel like I’m an autocomplete engine.

Was Gödel also an autocomplete engine? How could an autocomplete engine come up with novel ideas like the incompleteness theorems and understand them?

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by lxgr on Friday April 07, 2023 @02:01PM (#35484741)
> I certainly don’t feel like I’m an autocomplete engine.

Your mind is what you think and feel with, so I'd take that feeling with a grain of salt on multiple levels.

> Was Gödel also an autocomplete engine? How could an autocomplete engine come up with novel ideas like the incompleteness theorems and understand them?

I think you're reading too much value judgement into the (factual, if provocative) claim of "being an autocompletion engine" here.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by flangola7 on Friday April 07, 2023 @02:04PM (#35484781)
>How could an autocomplete engine come up with novel ideas like the incompleteness theorems and understand them?

Increase the temperature to above 0.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by acchow on Friday April 07, 2023 @02:37PM (#35485206)
Sure, you can create new sentences. But you can't recognize which ones are "true" and which are not.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by thewataccount on Friday April 07, 2023 @04:08PM (#35486377)
Neither can we. We have a lot of theorems ourselves that exist because they are what we consider the most likely solution to either extrapolating existing rules or modeling a set of measurements - but it's unknown as to whether the theory is absolutely true.

a child might see that

1 + 2 = 2 + 1 4 * 3 = 4 * 3 7 + 7 = 7 + 7

They might predict this may apply elsewhere, and that:

8 + 0 = 0 + 8

This is the Commutative Law, which the child can predict exists, even if they don't have the specialty to write proofs and understand the theory, etc. They don't know that this is true, but based on their observations this is a theory that holds true to this situation.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by acchow on Friday April 07, 2023 @05:14PM (#35487059)
Sure, children can pattern match. But I was thinking more about seasoned mathematicians, who not only create new theorems but can also understand proofs and thus find errors in proofs and decide they are wrong, or can be correct. They can also construct new mathematical structures, which other people may eventually use in novel ways to solve old problems. None of this seems anything remotely like "pattern matching" in any way.

I don't disagree with the notion that "probably 80% of Americans/humans are just glorified autocomplete engines", but what about the people with proper ingenuity that is either provably correct in the mathematical sense, or can build up a tapestry of understanding from which we can build predictions about reality (in the physics sense).

Pretty much everything else I do in life - riding a bike, cooking food, composing/enjoying music, etc - can be done with estimates and pattern matching. But the "correctness" of math proofs seems to me to not fit the approximation/estimations that language models use.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by maushu on Friday April 07, 2023 @02:14PM (#35484898)
When people say that humans are "autocomplete engines" they are being a little facetious on the fact that we are pattern recognizing machines that require sensory input to function. Basically "autocompleting" the input we receive.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by codethief on Friday April 07, 2023 @02:17PM (#35484928)
> How could an autocomplete engine come up with novel ideas like the incompleteness theorems and understand them?

Depends on your definition of "novel". Ideas like the incompleteness theorems, General Relativity, quantum mechanics, etc. were certainly new/unusual given the status quo in science at the time but they weren't coming out of thin air, either[0]. In fact, could it be that they were inevitable, given the data? Now you're no longer that far away from auto-completion.

[0]: We always ascribe to Einstein this singular genius (which he certainly was in a lot of ways) but one can easily forget over this that there's a clear survivorship bias – many other very smart people were working on unifying gravity with Special Relativity at that time.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by shagie on Friday April 07, 2023 @02:17PM (#35484939)
The question then is "what are you?"

Our Storytelling Minds: Do We Ever Really Know What's Going on Inside? - https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/literally-psyched/our-s...

There's a school of thought that says that "you" (the thing that says "I" when you think) is part of your brain that is making up an ongoing story about the input that it sees from one instant to the next to try to make it into a cohesive story/timeline that is fed back into itself to give it continuity.

This can be seen when there's a severed brain (done to control epilepsy) so that the two halves of the brain are no longer able to communicate... but one half still sees with one eye and the other half sees with the other... and one half has control of one hand and the other half has control of the other hand... and one half can control what is said.

--

So... what are you?

Your Brain Is a ‘Prediction Machine’: It Predicts What the Other Person Is Going to Say - https://www.learning-mind.com/your-brain-is-a-prediction-mac...

You Took the Words Right Out of My Brain https://www.nyu.edu/about/news-publications/news/2014/april/...

The "get the full input, process it, and do something" isn't fast enough for how you think. Your brain is trying to predict what is happening before it happens. Goalies in hokey and batters in baseball are examples of this - they are acting before a full set of information can be processed. They are predicting the future state of the world.

With words, two people can get into the same mental state and be able to predict the word that the other will say next. Twins, spouses... and even strangers in the right circumstance can have this happen. We are "next word predictors" in that sense - and there have been experiments that demonstrate that (the two articles on the same one above).

---

And so while the story that you tell yourself about how you think doesn't match a next word predictor (and mine doesn't either) - that is a model of how the mind and brain work that has... well, predictive power.

The interesting part with GPT (to me) is that as this "next word prediction" gained more abilities to properly predict the next word it also gained a world model.

On the left is GPT-3.5. On the right is GPT-4 :: https://twitter.com/d_feldman/status/1636955260680847361 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35214218

The question of "is there a world model that is contained within the language model that can be used?" is a rather interesting one. I find the image, prompt and response set with the balloons and "what would happen if the strings were cut?" to be rather fascinating.

https://youtu.be/7VSWyghVZIg also goes into this.

I believe you're getting too hung up on the "word" of "next word prediction". But instead consider the question: "does language enable thought?" Consider examples such as Koko the gorilla, Bunny the dog and Billie the cat. Do they think? Were they able to think before they had language? If you've got a program that can manipulate language as convincingly as a human - can it think for some definition of the word "think"?

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by esafak on Friday April 07, 2023 @02:24PM (#35485044)
It's the "intelligence is compression/prediction" paradigm, which is well known in the field, if you want to read about it.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by thewataccount on Friday April 07, 2023 @02:48PM (#35485419)
IDK if it helps but I find these examples interesting, predict the most likely word for the following phrases (whatever immediately comes to mind first):

- hello! How are

- What is 1+1?

- Today is Monday. That means yesterday was

- My favorite color is

Humans will likely estimate these as "you", "2", and "sunday". For the last one, there's not enough context to estimate the next word, but we will almost certainly estimate it as a "color", and might just have to guess at random "red"/"blue"/"orange"/etc, so there can be multiple possible answers. If you've seen enough data you might know that a specific color like blue might be more frequently mentioned in this context, and would be more included to guess "blue" because of that.

1+1 is interesting because most humans can immediately estimate 2. However given the question "What is (3.21^7)/(3+6.4*11)?" we can no longer quickly estimate the answer, we would have to manually (even if mentally) calculate the answer. I think this closely parallels how our current LLMs can do basic math they've seen a lot, but fall apart on more complex math since they aren't able to do the actual calculations and are forced to estimate.

"Today is Monday. That means yesterday was" is interesting because this would appear to imply that there is "logic". That you listed out the days of the week, looked at monday, and chose the day before. However, most likely you "just knew" it was most likely sunday given your previous knowledge. The LLM is unable to actually compute the answer, but it can estimate it based on it's training data.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by _a_a_a_ on Friday April 07, 2023 @01:15PM (#35484156)
> I would think that it would be needed to "understand" the license text in order to produce that easier to understand version.

well IMO it did, so it does. So yes, it 'understands' by your predicate.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by dylan604 on Friday April 07, 2023 @01:01PM (#35483985)
it'll be funny to find some unheard of website where someone wrote something very similar in blog or reply in comment. maybe even in a usenet chat archive or something?
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by andrewstuart2 on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:50PM (#35483863)
The words it autocompleted were the most likely words (chains of word fragments) to come next in a theoretical conversation when the question as context was taken into consideration, given the rest of the context it's been trained on up to EOY 2021.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by vonnieda on Friday April 07, 2023 @03:39PM (#35486067)
I wonder what an LLM would say if it had, say, 2 orders of magnitude more parameters and 46 years of training like I do. And if it was trained up to the millisecond with new inputs from millions of individual sensors. It might say:

> I wonder what an LLM would say if it had...

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by api on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:50PM (#35483849)
A lot of these questions hinge on words like “think” and “understand” for which we do not have precise definitions. It’s really kind of calling bullshit on a lot of the terminology we use to talk about thinking, revealing that most of it is hand wavey anthropocentrism.

It does what it does. We do not know what that means. We do not really know how close what it is doing is to what we do.

It’s also possible that it’s doing similar things to what we do but in some very different way. “Neural network” has always been a term to make biologists cringe as they’re really only the loosest of analogies to how brains work.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by xp84 on Friday April 07, 2023 @01:55PM (#35484657)
So true! We basically define those words almost self-referentially. Understanding is what human brains do, so by definition nothing else but a human can 'understand' complex things (we say).

We make only slight allowances for animals, allowing that they can "understand" but only simple things.

As this tech gets better, those who cling to that definition are going to get more and more uncomfortable, and tie themselves into more and more logical knots trying desperately to explain why it "doesn't count."

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by lxgr on Friday April 07, 2023 @02:04PM (#35484777)
A similar thing has happened (and arguably is still happening) when it comes to animal cognition.

"The only species capable of recognizing itself in the mirror. Ok, recognizing itself in the mirror and object permanence. Ok, all of that and mourning its dead. Ok, hang on for a minute..."

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by nr2x on Friday April 07, 2023 @02:02PM (#35484759)
A lot of human “decision making” literally happens after some pattern recognition system in your brain makes the decisions. We are all just autocompleting all day.

Does ChatGPT “think”? Maybe? Do we “think” as much as we think we do? Maybe not?

https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/unconscious-branding...

https://www.nature.com/articles/news.2008.751

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by sangnoir on Friday April 07, 2023 @04:32PM (#35486607)
> I would think that it would be needed to "understand" the license text in order to produce that easier to understand version.

Have you interacted with Markov chains before? They are surprisingly coherent and how they work is easier to grok (or implement as a weekend project)

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by buggyipadmettoo on Friday April 07, 2023 @08:24PM (#35488991)
I was wondering the same and asked gpt to explain it to me the other day. Basically it’s all one process, there aren’t 2 modules (understand and generate). The “understanding” is perhaps like the generating in reverse. Rather than generating the next word from a statistical process, it’s defining the statistical process from the next words of the input.

But as I explain here, even reviewing that conversation we had, I think maybe gpt and I were both hallucinating and feigning understanding. Cuz I still don’t get it. It still seems far too magical to fit this explanation.

So my next best guess: we’re a simulation, GPT is magic, and our creators are just having fun introducing more and more magic into the system.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by matrix_overload on Saturday April 08, 2023 @12:49AM (#35490626)
Because it can instantly go through countless examples where people were summarizing things on the forums, paper abstracts, documents, etc., and blend it together with a 99% accuracy. Except for that 1% where it will look totally plausible, but will be completely wrong.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by codeflo on Friday April 07, 2023 @02:44PM (#35485337)
When will “I asked ChatGPT” stop being posted in response to every other HN comment?
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by CatWChainsaw on Thursday April 13, 2023 @07:55AM (#35554051)
Never, at this rate.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by Villodre on Friday April 07, 2023 @10:10AM (#35481749)
I'm glad this is the first comment, because there's no way these terms of use would (should?) fly in the EU. I don't know about the USA, but it is plain deception to advertise a service along a product and then proclaim that you're in no way responsible of how it works or if it does at all.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by returningfory2 on Friday April 07, 2023 @11:15AM (#35482435)
> there's no way these terms of use would (should?) fly in the EU

Do you have an actual concrete reason to believe that, or is this just "the EU is morally superior to everywhere else" vibes?

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by germanier on Friday April 07, 2023 @11:43AM (#35482851)
Stuff like that is covered by the Sales of Goods Directive (2019/771)
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by fishywang on Friday April 07, 2023 @11:49AM (#35482943)
does that mean it could fly if it's free? (for example, a lot of OSS license has similar disclaimer)

I don't know wd's case in particular, but just curious:

1. would it fly if the cloud service is also free (no additional subscription fee)?

2. or is it that even if the cloud service itself is "free", they only allow people with wd hardware products to use it, so it's considered part of those hardware products, so it's not really free and is still covered by that directive?

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by germanier on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:43PM (#35483734)
Simplified, the seller is responsible as long as the buyer can reasonably expect the feature to work based on public statements by the seller and their supply chain (including the manufacturer).
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by lukeschlather on Friday April 07, 2023 @01:39PM (#35484446)
As I understand it you can legally create a "sale" without money changing hands.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by CydeWeys on Friday April 07, 2023 @01:50PM (#35484591)
How is it a sale if no money has changed hands? It's not even a barter. It's nothing.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by Am4TIfIsER0ppos on Friday April 07, 2023 @01:00PM (#35483972)
What "goods" do you get from a cloud service? Buy some HW next time someone else's computer fails.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by germanier on Friday April 07, 2023 @02:34PM (#35485171)
The cloud service in question is advertised with the physical hardware. This is referred to as "goods with digital elements" in the regulation.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by switch007 on Saturday April 08, 2023 @03:32AM (#35491358)
Recent (Jan ‘22) EU legislation now also applies to digits services and content

https://commission.europa.eu/business-economy-euro/doing-bus...

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by bberrry on Saturday April 08, 2023 @08:52AM (#35492705)
Europe tends to have good consumer protection and isn't completely captured by lobbyists unlike the US.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by SoftTalker on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:37PM (#35483639)
> proclaim that you're in no way responsible of how it works or if it does at all.

This is pretty much any software license, since they existed.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by xp84 on Friday April 07, 2023 @02:03PM (#35484766)
By contrast, it's the case with nearly all products here. It's part of the standard boilerplate that comes with any software product license to explicitly disclaim all warranties, even the implied one that would otherwise exist. Usually phrased like:

> [Company] specifically disclaims all indirect or implied warranties to the full extent allowed by applicable law, including without limitation all implied warranties of, non-infringement, merchantability, title or fitness for any particular purpose. No oral or written information or advice given by [Company], its agents or employees shall create a warranty.

So, you can sell software with claims that it does anything, and if it does nothing at all, is useless, and actually burns your house down, the standard industry practice is that your TOS should make explicitly clear that that's not your problem.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by KMnO4 on Friday April 07, 2023 @10:09AM (#35481734)
Random question; why are terms written in all caps?
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by Closi on Friday April 07, 2023 @10:17AM (#35481818)
There are legal requirements in the USA to ensure certain parts of an agreement are “conspicuous” (ie should be made so that consumers/customers don’t miss them). Placing the terms in caps is a historical way to achieve the legal bar for this, so is a legal tradition in the USA.

In other legal systems (eg the UK) you don’t get this, it’s a uniquely American phenomenon as far as I know.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by lxgr on Friday April 07, 2023 @02:25PM (#35485060)
I've noticed that too. IRONICALLY IT MAKES THESE PARTS OF A CONTRACT QUITE HARD TO READ, IN MY EXPERIENCE.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by rhaway84773 on Friday April 07, 2023 @10:11AM (#35481754)
To make them harder to read.

Edit: In this case it appears they’re using it for emphasis, since the majority of the ToS is in normal caps, but it was definitely a deliberate dark pattern until very recently to make the ToS hard to read.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by Closi on Friday April 07, 2023 @10:14AM (#35481780)
This isn’t true - caps are a legal standard in the USA to indicate that this section is higher-importance for the reader. It’s actually a legal obligation to make your terms “conspicuous”.

So it’s actually supposed to be the opposite - to meet a legal obligation to highlight to users that they should pay particular notice to certain sections.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by rationalist on Friday April 07, 2023 @10:29AM (#35481933)
PARAGRAPHS OF ALL CAPS is harder to read for some people.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by Closi on Friday April 07, 2023 @10:48AM (#35482109)
It's not supposed to be easier to read, it's supposed to make it clear to the reader that it's important.

(I'm not a fan of it anyway - I'm from the UK and think it's silly, but I've come across this plenty during contract negotiations with American lawyers that will insist on certain sections being in caps)

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by rationalist on Saturday April 08, 2023 @08:26AM (#35492572)
(this isn't necessarily directed at you)

Does that mean the rest is not important? If so, why include it, or why not make it all caps, and if it's all caps, why make it caps at all.

Unfortunately legal things are about rules and laws, not common sense.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by Closi on Saturday April 08, 2023 @11:50AM (#35494459)
Yep, It's silly :)

But let's say that WD doesn't capitalise some bits, that might come back to bite them if there is a class action lawsuit.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by WindyLakeReturn on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:24PM (#35483447)
Something can be legally required but also have been originally made into a requirement as a dark pattern. The idea that something is legally defined as being 'conspicuous' in a way that makes it less conspicuous makes me consider that a dark pattern was the original intent. While I commonly hear to never attribute to malice what can be explained by incompetence, I don't feel that is applicable to the legal system.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by Closi on Friday April 07, 2023 @01:31PM (#35484342)
It's a legal document following precedent about contract law. Lawyers and the companies they represent are usually better served by following established legal precedent than veering off it.

Let's say the lawyers decide to be 'creative' and then bold the text instead, and then it gets copied into a page and some CSS renders it without bold text - suddenly the contract might have legal challenges, and the lawyers will rightly be asked why they decided to not follow established industry and legal norms.

I think it's a bit silly too, but if I was hiring an American lawyer I would want them to follow established norms rather than come up with their own unique and legally-untested interpretation of what is required.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by Villodre on Friday April 07, 2023 @10:11AM (#35481755)
READABILITY AND FRIGHTENING LEGALESE
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by kneebonian on Friday April 07, 2023 @11:26AM (#35482597)
Everytime I see something like this I always think of the dilbert where the PHB says

"It's better than legal we are using the law to keep justice away!"

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by AlexDragusin on Friday April 07, 2023 @11:27AM (#35482614)
I checked on the live version, if WD cannot afford proofreaders, imagine how well they can take care of your data, oh well...
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by SoftTalker on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:36PM (#35483622)
So pretty much exactly the same protections as just storing the data locally on your own computer....
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by jkaptur on Friday April 07, 2023 @01:46PM (#35484546)
I love that the typos ("OFTHE", "WESTERN DIGITALON") are in the original too.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by fathyb on Saturday April 08, 2023 @01:04PM (#35495297)
I've seen this happen after copy pasting text from PDF files lacking proper text data. The reader needs to infer where spaces are based on the distance between characters, which might not be very reliable with some fonts.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by aidenn0 on Friday April 07, 2023 @01:59PM (#35484719)
Had multi day outage at my ISP and checked the TOS. IT had similar language including indemnifying them from secondary/indirect damages caused by negligence or malice on their part.