It seems a lot of guidance about securing your NAS (eg [1]) starts with "it's bad if it's directly connected to the internet". So if you want to use the internet, it may be a better bet to use a managed service (or maybe look for a more security focused product?).
[1] https://www.backblaze.com/blog/recent-qnap-and-synology-secu...
But I’ve been in a frugal mood lately, I find it hard to spend over $500 on an item like this.
I believe the $249 DS223 does indeed support all of the features I mentioned above.
It does get pretty tight, I probably wouldn't want to be adding any more services, but it's fine for my use cases.
https://xpenology.org/#What_is_Xpenology
having said that i bought the $200 model (220j) with a steep discount with amex points on amazon and it works fine but is a little slower than the others. i just use it for rsync (which never-deletes by default) and as an SMB server.
note the 220j unit doesn't do btrfs.
I did that, and I have to say it does NOT play with linux very nicely. I had to change the UID and GID on my desktop for my default user and all of my files because Ubuntu starts with UID 1 and Synology starts with UID 26, so after you figure out how to mount the disk as nfs it says you don't have permission to access it (because your UID does not match the UID of the device). Solving this was one of those problems where you go back 10 years and so many people have posted forum posts and the answer was always some weird hack, and Synology has never fixed it. Changing the UID of my user on my desktop was the easiest hack. Then I installed another OS to dual boot and had to change the UID for that one too, so I could access my files, and somehow the "easy" NAS option has made me jump through lots of hoops.
Turns out self hosting is not easy even when you buy a Synology.
I'm guessing you saw "your choice ... was the problem", whereas I see "... NFS was the problem".
I just did not find it plug and play. It took a lot of messing with it. And I am a relatively experienced linux user!
For some anecdata, my Synology has always played perfectly with a vast assortment of Windows, Mac, Linux, Android, and iOS for many years, even a Chromebook!
I legitimately don't remember a single error, or ever having to do any debugging around supported services (obviously my own services and dockers have been a bit more involved)
I use SMB though
I’ve been using nfs for years and apparently just got lucky because I only ever have one user on every machine I use.
Even my crazy hacked together Debian running WD My Book Live (or whatever it’s real name is) has given me zero problems over the years.
My only issue with them was when I emailed them to confirm that I could have it connected to my network but not have internet access (people calling "wifi" or "ethernet" internet still drives me up the wall) since I was going to block its internet access on my router.
First I had issues getting support to understand the distinction between "network" and "internet". Second once I finally did get someone who understood I was asked "Why" or "what was I trying to accomplish". It almost put me off purchasing it that I would be asked why I would want a device like a NAS to have zero internet connectivity.
That aside I would agree and it does feel like a very apple like experience (maybe a bit more technical). I mean it isn't as easy as the time capsule was years ago, but its up there.
Granted, it's frustrating when you are a well-informed person that knows exactly what they're looking for. I just accept it as a cost of dealing with other people.
I mean I recognize that they may be dealing with far less technical people and maybe that is a valid question.
I get what your saying but wouldn't "I don't want my NAS to have an internet connection but I want to make sure it still works locally" be mostly self explanatory?
Maybe that is me putting more faith in other people than I should, like obviously it won't be able to update, sync with a cloud, or any other number of things. Maybe thats not obvious?
But also to be clear the bad taste it gave me was seeing products that should have no need for an active internet connection and yet are paper weights without it. So when a company seems to be pushing me to connect something to the internet, especially something as sensitive as a NAS... it sets off alarms.
Synology doesn't update their Kernel. Only the latest release model in 2023 comes with 5.10. The others are on 4.x, and if you bought any before 2020 you may be on 3.x. On the 2023 model You would have thought they would at least be on 5.15, no.
All Entry level model doesn't come with BTRFS.
But apart from that, it is still the best in the market right now.
Buy a Synology DiskStation, and you get an easy-to-use yet customisable OS, that receives security updates for up to a decade.