Re:H. G. Wells interviewing J. V. Stalin (1934)
by RedCondor on Thursday April 06, 2023 @03:43PM
(#35473373)
Look guy, the Archives were opened in the 90s, and literally none of the insane horror stories bore out.
Meanwhile, in that time, Solzhenitsyn was outed as a conspiratorial antisemite.
If you want to opt into a goofy American spy movie, be my guest, but your arbitrary choices of who is believable and who isn't are utterly unconvincing.
Re:H. G. Wells interviewing J. V. Stalin (1934)
by mopsi on Thursday April 06, 2023 @03:55PM
(#35473522)
That was the reality of daily life in the USSR in 1970s, not spy fiction. To anyone from the USSR, the first instinct is to check the date of that quote (pre- or post-1991?) and the rest needs no comments. You made a faux pas that revealed how little you are aware of historic context. The more you deny it, the deeper hole you dig yourself into.
As to the crimes themselves, they've been meticulously documented by human rights organizations like Memorial. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memorial_(society)
Re:H. G. Wells interviewing J. V. Stalin (1934)
by dang on Thursday April 06, 2023 @05:14PM
(#35474557)
Please don't cross into flamewar and personal swipes. As far as I can tell, you've done a pretty good job avoiding that in this thread so far.
Edit: well, not entirely - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35469335 was bad. Please stay within the rules when commenting on HN.
Unlike North Korea, I was born in the USSR and saw all that with my own eyes, and I personally know several dissidents who were imprisoned in the 1980s. To suggest that she had any freedom of speech, particularly to a foreign journalist, is deeply ignorant of the conditions at the time. People were scared to openly talk even with their relatives from the West. In 1974, a foreign journalist heard only what the KGB wanted them to hear.