News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Golf has a problem: people are hitting the ball too far by dagw on Thursday April 06, 2023 @08:00AM (#35467181)
We see this in all kinds of sports. Professional baseball for example use bats that make it harder to hit home runs. Professional swimming limit how long you can swim under water, even though it leads to slower times. Professional sports are first and foremost supposed to be fun to watch, and people find it less fun to watch golf if everybody can hit the ball 'too far', since it removes the need to navigate the trickier parts of the course.
Re:Golf has a problem: people are hitting the ball too far by illiarian on Thursday April 06, 2023 @08:33AM (#35467492)
> Professional sports are first and foremost supposed to be fun to watch, and people find it less fun to watch

There are some sports where they have a similar problem (tennis and table tennis) where the speeds have become ridiculous, but no one wants to limit that (via limits on equipment sizes etc.) because people don't want to see long tedious technical exchanges. They want to see "wack" and "boom 200 kmh"

Re:Golf has a problem: people are hitting the ball too far by barrkel on Thursday April 06, 2023 @08:38AM (#35467540)
I don't think people want to see continuous exchanges of aces in tennis.
Re:Golf has a problem: people are hitting the ball too far by illiarian on Thursday April 06, 2023 @08:40AM (#35467565)
It's a fine line indeed :)
Re:Golf has a problem: people are hitting the ball too far by jaclaz on Thursday April 06, 2023 @09:43AM (#35468203)
Well, many, many years ago in the late 1970's there was the spaghetti racket in tennis that was swiftly outlawed:

https://www.lovetennisblog.com/the-spaghetti-racket-a-docume...

Re:Golf has a problem: people are hitting the ball too far by yowzadave on Thursday April 06, 2023 @09:51AM (#35468299)
In tennis, despite serves being generally faster than they were 30 years ago, the game seems to be less serve-dominated. True, there are still players who are one-dimensional in their ability to hit aces...but the very top players all have well-rounded games. Novak Djokovic has less than half the number of aces as John Isner, despite having played in many more matches.

And for ground strokes, the net and court size restrict how much power you can give a shot--spin and control are more critical. Pro-level racquets are generally less powerful than those used by amateurs. If a company were to come out with a racket that could hit twice as fast, approximately zero pro players would use it.

Re:Golf has a problem: people are hitting the ball too far by illiarian on Thursday April 06, 2023 @12:40PM (#35470931)
I remember discussions in early-to-mid 00s how the game changed from skill to power. There were even calls to return to 80s-era smaller racquets.

I wonder if there was at least some scaleback (I haven't followed tennis in a long time).

Re:Golf has a problem: people are hitting the ball too far by vidanay on Thursday April 06, 2023 @02:33PM (#35472454)
Wasn't/isn't there a player who uses 70's era wooden racquets (new manufactured - old tech)?
Re:Golf has a problem: people are hitting the ball too far by TRiG_Ireland on Thursday April 06, 2023 @08:23AM (#35467382)
It's been fascinating to watch that in a new emerging sport which is still developing rapidly: World Chase Tag.

While it is a professional sport, they can't afford to pay high player salaries, so it has to be fun to play, too, to attract talent. But they definitely do care about how it looks, and have said in interviews that this was their main focus during initial play testing. They've actually changed the rules very little over time (they reduced the rest period between chases from 30 seconds to 25, but that's about it); instead, they've focused their attention on tweaking the quad, the structure on which the game is played. Small tweaks to the positioning of bars can subtly alter the balance of power between chaser and evader. They've deliberately nerfed some developing strategies they decided they didn't like (by adding obstructions behind the Mountain, for example).

Re:Golf has a problem: people are hitting the ball too far by geoduck14 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @08:18AM (#35467338)
>Professional sports are first and foremost supposed to be fun to watch

Are you sure?

Re:Golf has a problem: people are hitting the ball too far by liveoneggs on Thursday April 06, 2023 @08:32AM (#35467474)
they are entertainment
Re:Golf has a problem: people are hitting the ball too far by bombcar on Thursday April 06, 2023 @08:44AM (#35467601)
The “professional” gives it away - someone is paying for it and that is mostly people looking for entertainment these days. There may be a very small amount of “record beating” but even that should be entertaining.

Imagine if MLB used aluminum bats or allowed the pitchers to grease the ball. A game if endless home runs or endless strikeouts would be boring.

Re:Golf has a problem: people are hitting the ball too far by Waterluvian on Thursday April 06, 2023 @08:59AM (#35467760)
Yes. Olympics and other competitive events seek the best. Professional sports seek the most entertaining and therefore most profitable (which usually but not always correlates with skill).
Re:Golf has a problem: people are hitting the ball too far by dagw on Thursday April 06, 2023 @09:10AM (#35467876)
Olympics and other competitive events seek the best.

That's not really true at all. Look at swimming again for example, they have lots of rules related to what you are allowed to wear and how you're allowed to swim that all lead to slower times, but (hopefully) a more fun event to watch. The Olympics keep changing and tweaking the rules of all kinds of sports simply to try to make them more interesting and/or increase their popularity and viewership.