News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by brtkdotse on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:06AM (#35452687)
What has the government done to your city?
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by peyton on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:08AM (#35452712)
Downvoting for flame bait. Come on.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by swasheck on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:15AM (#35452790)
i had the same question. i believe it to be a legitimate inquiry, as someone with low exposure to the politics and results of the area.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by iLoveOncall on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:37AM (#35453073)
My understanding from a European that doesn't follow the news very much is that they did defund the police and what everyone knew would happen happened.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by swasheck on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @11:29AM (#35455845)
except they walked that back last year.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by kdkdk on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:26AM (#35452939)
It‘s not just the government. As SF controls ever larger part of the world, many power hungry people flock to SF. Prices go up and more people want a piece of the action.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by lizardking on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:14AM (#35452775)
It’s a fair question
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by bmelton on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:43AM (#35453163)
Interpreting the question in good faith (since nobody else seems to want to)

I work in SF but don't live there, but over the past few years (especially under Chesa Boudin, the previous District Attorney) they've moved towards "soft on crime" policies that may have contributed to what friends who live there are referring to as 'lawlessness'

Some policies that likely have contributed include:

Bail Reform: They've prohibited cash bail, meaning most offenders who are arrested have no incentive to stand trial or prevent fleeing. No idea what the effect has been here, and as I understand it, offenders deemed violent are asked to forego bail. Again, no information on whether that's a voluntary ask or an imposed demand, but the impression is that people are arrested and back on the streets the same day to potentially reoffend.

Decriminalized theft up to $950: It is now quasi-legal to walk into a store in San Francisco, steal up to $949 in merchandise, and walk right back out. Allegedly, police won't respond to such incidents, and there's no deterrent from doing so. This has led to gangs who take turns, each walking in and snagging almost a thousand dollars worth of merchandise, then pooling the goods and reselling them. Pharmacies seem to have been particularly affected.

This was walked back somewhat, as shoplifting is now considered a felony again, especially if done as part of a ring, but police are apparently still extremely unlikely to respond.

Reduced sentences: Due to budgetary concerns, California as a whole is now imprisoning offenders for less time, issuing shorter sentences and early release as much as possible so that they do not have to bear the cost of imprisonment.

They defunded the police: Or, at least they pretended to? They promised to redirect $120 million of police funding away from law enforcement to support other social initiatives, and I remember a remark at the time that this was to fund reparation initiatives that they seem to be aiming to implement, but I have no idea as to the sincerity of that. That said, in the years since this promise, police budgets are up from where they were, so they seem to have either reversed course or possibly never gave it more than lip service. I'm not sure.

All together, if those are to be believed as causes (rather than say, wealth inequality, general social unrest, etc.) then it's worth looking into. Crime is up 110% in San Francisco relative to the American average, and is up 91% relative to the average in California.

Two additional notes: I'm just relaying what I think might have been OP's causes for attributing this to government action. I have no idea. I don't live there. Also, it seems that residents aren't particularly happy with it, as there was a (failed) attempt to recall Gavin Newsom, and a (successful) attempt to recall Chesa Boudin, and there are efforts underway to recall Mayor London Breed as well. No idea how that will fare.

Edit: It's probably worth remembering that someone can be stabbed anywhere, and if the fact that this happened in San Francisco confirms a bias you had, it's probably worth reframing it as somewhere else. Confirmation bias is our common enemy, and one that we don't have to succumb to just because our brains insist on it. Ask yourself if your tirade applies if you replace "San Francisco" with Zurich, Tokyo, Toronto, or Frisco Texas.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by agrippanux on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:40AM (#35453982)
The recall attempt on Newsom originated in the very conservative East County of San Diego (home to the convicted and Trump-pardoned former Rep Duncan Hunter, and current ultra-MAGA Rep Darrel Issa). Newsom hardly campaigned in the recall - only put some effort in the final month - and won by almost exactly the same margin he took office with originally.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by muglug on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:16AM (#35453624)
Worth pointing out that no European country has a cash bail system, yet many of them manage to have cities with much lower crime rates than SF.

Cash bail isn't "tough on crime" policy — it's a "keep penniless people in jail" policy, since non-violent crimes like petty larceny are more likely to be committed by poor people.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by jeffbee on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:24AM (#35453742)
No European country has decades-long prison sentences, either.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by muglug on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:52AM (#35454200)
That's not true — every European country except for Portugal has life imprisonment.

But they generally do have shorter sentences for the same crimes than the US.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by jeffbee on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @10:34AM (#35454949)
"Life imprisonment" in e.g. Germany is an indefinite sentence with parole eligibility at 15 years, 18 years in France, 15 years in Belgium, etc. According to Wikipedia there are currently 550 inmates serving indefinite sentences in France, and 33000 inmates serving life sentences in California.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by bmelton on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @11:20AM (#35455706)
I think that's generally true in America as well. A "one-life" sentence in America generally amounts to 15-25 before parole eligibility.

I don't know the prevalence of back-to-back life sentences in Germany (or in America, really) but we have some oddities like the Green River Killer, who got a life sentence for every murder he pled guilty to committing, so he's serving 48 life sentences consecutively.

I am as impressed with France's low percentage of life (indefinite) sentences as I am shocked that California's 160+% life detention rate despite having almost half the population.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by chmod775 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:59AM (#35454339)
Worth pointing that there's no such thing as "police not responding" in many European countries either. Just a heated argument with your neighbor and someone calls the police? They're going to show up even if no crime is being committed, try to mediate and diffuse the situation - because their multi-year training covered that as well, not just the application of government-sanctioned violence.

I don't think long sentences work as a deterrent if there's just a low expectation of the chaps in uniforms even putting in any work.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by nemothekid on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:13AM (#35453589)
Chesa Boudin was a scapegoat for the cities problems and his recall almost a year ago now hasn't changed things significantly. It sounds like the talking points are to ask for recalls further up the chain of command; maybe we will eventually get a chance to recall Joe Biden. However, god forbid you say anything bad about the poor police department, who are somehow still unable to do their jobs because of Chesa.

I'm not sure what can be done to fix the more systemic issues in SF; I'm assuming this will continue until we magically get a republican mayor and once that mayor fails to realize they can't ship the homeless westward, nor melt them into biofuel we can start to take a look at some of the policies that has absolutely gutted the ability for anyone to afford to live in SF and a couple well off people living in houses and the mentally incapacitated living in the street.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by jeffbee on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:55AM (#35453335)
This is just cut and pasted from some right wing talking points. Cash bail reform has not caused a decline in the number of people who flee. It also is not associated with re-arrest. It is associated with reduced harm for arrestees, which is important because many innocent people are arrested.

$950 is a completely reasonable threshold for felony theft. Before this state-wide, not city-specific, reform was introduced California had the lowest threshold in the nation. It is still fairly low. In Texas, the threshold for what you inaccurately call "quasi-legal" is $2500.

Shorter sentences is a solid reform because longer sentences are not associated with better outcomes and it costs $100k/yr to keep someone in prison, and that's money that could be spent on community policing instead.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by ndiddy on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:15AM (#35453614)
> $950 is a completely reasonable threshold for felony theft. Before this state-wide, not city-specific, reform was introduced California had the lowest threshold in the nation. It is still fairly low. In Texas, the threshold for what you inaccurately call "quasi-legal" is $2500.

I believe the difference is that district attorneys in Texas will actually prosecute misdemeanor theft, while this isn't true in the Bay Area.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by jeffbee on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:22AM (#35453721)
You believe it based on what? Hoover Institution press releases or some data you can actually share with us?
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by throwanma on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @02:28PM (#35458482)
No data needed, the proof is in the pudding.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by its_ethan on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:25PM (#35459898)
Not that you seem like you're likely to have your mind changed, but you can look at prosecuted misdemeanors on this website broken out by type. Misdemeanors prosecuted for burglary have been declining pretty quickly sine 2018. For theft, they only prosecuted 48 cases since 2011, I'm guessing there's been way more instances of theft beyond those 48 cases over 10+ years lol. Petty theft also has been on decline since 2018 for what it's worth.

https://www.sfdistrictattorney.org/policy/data-dashboards/

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by jeffbee on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:37PM (#35461406)
I don't think I am being unclear about my request. Your dashboard in no way shows or implies that a district attorney in Texas is more likely to prosecute a misdemeanor theft than the SF district attorney.

All your dashboard says to me is that the DA presses charges in the majority of misdemeanor petty theft arrests, and the trend in the absolute decline of such cases is driven by the lack of arrests, which declined more than half from 2011 to 2022, which is consistent with my point that it doesn't have anything to do with the DA, it is caused by poor police productivity.

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by its_ethan on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:33PM (#35483584)
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by bmelton on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:33AM (#35453877)
> This is just cut and pasted from some right wing talking points

Not that it matters, but these were the collected thoughts of my resident friends and colleagues who live there, none of which you could remotely consider anywhere close to "right wing."

Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by jeffbee on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:52AM (#35454197)
The fact that these are memes promulgated by reactionary media outlets, and the fact that you heard them second-hand from people in San Francisco, are not really contrary.
Re:Former Square CTO Bob Lee Stabbed to Death in Downtown Sa... by bmelton on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @11:30AM (#35455849)
The claim you made and that I was responding to was that "I cut and pasted these from right wing sources."

Zero percent of that allegation is true.