News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by mertd on Monday April 03, 2023 @02:38PM (#35429122)
> With birds eye view, parking sensors aren't really needed anymore, so they didn't place an order for new sensors.

Sorry but that's a large logical chasm you just casually leapt. How does bird's eye view magically determine the distance to a textureless wall when parallax fails to detect it?

Why do cars with birds eye view still come equipped with parking sensors if they are obviated?

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by gnicholas on Monday April 03, 2023 @02:43PM (#35429209)
Parking sensors are handy if you're looking to the side or back when reversing, since you can hear them without looking at the screen in front. I honestly don't know where I'm supposed to look when backing up sometimes — it feels irresponsible to just look forward at a camera display, but in most cases that shows more than looking all around would. Parking sensors are nice because you can hear them chirp no matter where you look.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by officeplant on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:20PM (#35429790)
>honestly don't know where I'm supposed to look when backing up sometimes

Even with the addition of backup cameras I still look all around and check blind spots as if I didn't have a camera. No backup camera I've used shows enough information to be confident enough otherwise.

Unless ya'll have some truly high end cars I don't see how anyone can confidently back up with just a camera and not fear hitting objects/children etc.

I never even thought about my habit until a friend who is very terrified of riding in cars told me they were made comfortable by how much I look around me while driving. Which just convinces me further that most people shouldn't be on the road.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by gnicholas on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:26PM (#35429870)
> Unless ya'll have some truly high end cars I don't see how anyone can confidently back up with just a camera and not fear hitting objects/children etc.

If I look backward I wouldn't see a small child right behind my vehicle. The parking sensors and backup camera would, though. That's why I feel like it's weird to look backward instead of looking at the video feed from the wide-angle camera.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by officeplant on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:34PM (#35429999)
I don't mean that I look backwards the whole time. I mainly look at the camera, but at the same time I'm glancing around checking mirrors and looking out of the windows for hazards. I've watched some people just stare down into a camera and then be surprised when they nearly hit a truck that was coming down the parking lot not yet visible in the camera.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by janoc on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:45PM (#35430154)
That's why many cars include also a radar that detects and alerts you of approaching traffic from the sides before it comes into view - both camera and the driver (the blind spots when reversing are large).

E.g. Mazda 3 has that - if it detects a vehicle or even a pedestrian approaching from the side while reversing, it starts beeping and showing orange chevrons on the camera screen to alert me.

Obviously, this doesn't remove the need to look around and not rely only the sensors and cameras. The tech may fail and the ultimate responsibility is with the driver.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by misnome on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:41PM (#35430084)
No, but you might see a child walking or running in from the side
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by gnicholas on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:15PM (#35430610)
My camera has a very wide angle, and is 10 feet behind where I am (and can see around bushes/cars that I can't). There are definitely times that I can see things the camera can't see, but I feel like the balance is that the camera can see more.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by giantrobot on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:40PM (#35430076)
Which is where the utility of backup cameras comes from. It's nearly impossible, at least impractical, to design a car that holds human beings with a rear view that could provide the same field of view as a camera. Even if the back of the car was a giant pane of glass just having a trunk or back seat will occult the driver's rear view such they could miss a curb, pet, or small child. Even a shitty camera will give a better view than most cars' actual rear view from the driver's seat. They're even more useful when you consider they better enable shorter or taller drivers that don't have the ideal view out the back of the car.

I check blind spots I know my camera has but then use the camera to actually back up because it's got a far better view from the back of my car than I do from the front seat.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by Accacin on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:46PM (#35430166)
I mean, do both? Surely as a driver we should be using all the information we can get to drive safely. When I'm reversing I'll look around, get in position to reverse, and alternate between side mirrors, looking around, and the reversing cam.

Might be a side effect of how we're taught in the UK, but we were always told we should keep glancing in our mirrors whilst driving so it seems natural to me at least.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by gnicholas on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:17PM (#35430653)
Turning my head quickly to pivot between the video screen and the back (and the back left) makes me feel like I'm being less safe than if I just looked straight at the video or possibly straight backward.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by msrenee on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @07:36AM (#35438009)
In most cases, I do an initial sweep, then use my camera. If I'm backing from between two vehicles, I check the camera, then turn around and keep an eye for anyone coming from either side. The fisheye on the backup camera helps a lot, but it's not going to show the idiot going 20 mph through the parking lot until it's too late.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by jwestbury on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @04:22AM (#35436651)
I nearly backed into a tree that managed to slip into the blind spot between stitched-together camera feeds on a rented BMW with 360-degree camera. I was only saved by the curb stopping me inches before impact with the tree.

tl;dr, look around in real life, too. I'm not sure why the parking sensors didn't notice the tree or the curb, to be honest.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by pohatoo on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @12:06PM (#35441822)
A friend of mine was backing in to an unfamiliar parking garage and was watching the screen and all of a sudden we hear a scrape. There was an air duct over hanging the car and we hit it. The camera didn't think to show the roof. Luckily for us we hit the duct before hitting the sprinkler. That would have been a disaster.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by hn_throwaway_99 on Monday April 03, 2023 @02:46PM (#35429247)
Was just about to post this, glad someone else did.

I have a car with both (birds eye view and parking sensors), and they are absolutely complimentary to each other, and I use them for different reasons. E.g. for squeezing through my garage door (I only have about 1.5 inch of clearance on each side) I like the birds eye view, but then when I pull up to the front of the garage I use the sensor because I know exactly how many inches from the front my car should be so that I can both walk around the front and the back if I need to unload stuff from the trunk.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by xenospn on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:46PM (#35430168)
How do you open the car door inside the garage?!
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by pieter_mj on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:21PM (#35430712)
By opening the door to the living room, opening the car door in the free space that has been cleared by opening the living room door. easy peasy : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3-MaC9fFtz0

edit : English subtitles : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q4jeN2QO1Gs

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by MaxikCZ on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @03:36AM (#35436323)
I love how at the end he puts two chairs in front of the door, as if otherwise it would be too easy
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by sharno on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:57PM (#35460274)
lol, never saw that before, the last step of pushing the car to close its door is just a beauty
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by tom_ on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:47PM (#35430184)
At a guess, the garage is wider than its door.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by hn_throwaway_99 on Monday April 03, 2023 @06:43PM (#35432382)
Correct.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by doublesocket on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:03PM (#35430438)
They exit via the sunroof.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by ajross on Monday April 03, 2023 @02:52PM (#35429342)
It's a parking sensor. How many parking garages are textureless walls? Borrowing phrasing from the grandparent: "promise the impossible" may indeed be bad marketing, but "demand the needless and infeasible" is at least as much a problem here. Everything, everything about Tesla has to be some kind of existential argument about how This One Thing Proves Everything I Hate. And.. it's still just a parking sensor.

Meh. I have the sonar equipment in my car and it works nicely, and I'd view its removal as a mild loss. But it wouldn't have changed the purchase decision. It's a technical mistake, and at the margins will probably hurt them in sales.

But there's nothing here to justify the size of the thread we're spending on it. It's a parking sensor.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by vardump on Monday April 03, 2023 @02:52PM (#35429346)
"parallax fails to detect it"

AFAIK, pretty much none of the driverless systems are using parallax. The reason why not is that parallax only gives good depth information at most up to about 10 feet. Disparity mapping is pretty limited in real life.

Instead they get depth from video.

I'd imagine in almost every situation the car would cast a shadow to that featureless wall. Although Tesla might not have a camera placed to a right spot to actually see that shadow...

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by rcv on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:05PM (#35429561)
> Instead they get depth from video.

Do you have a source for that? DfM is pretty much always a worse option than multi-camera reconstruction AFAIK.

> almost every situation the car would cast a shadow to that featureless wall.

I think "almost every situation" a pretty low bar for automotive safety.

I don't know too much about what people do in the automotive world, but in robotics it's pretty common to have an IR pattern projector if you really need depth on featureless surfaces.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by raxxorraxor on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @08:28AM (#35438515)
While it does work for human eyes somehow, it is quite difficult in computer vision. It could give you precise information but you need to match two almost identical pictures via stereoscopy and that with a significant framerate and resolution. The advantage might be that you can have better conditions that a human skull provides, but the needed calculation power is quite significant.

I think this can only ever be reliable with a projection. A pulsed line laser or something that is synced with the camera. Then again, a simple ultrasound sensor might do a better job.

Otherwise the system might work, but is much more unstable in non-optimal conditions. Robustness is a pretty important feature for driverless systems. That said, stereoscopy would at least be better than only one camera.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by mostdataisnice on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:04PM (#35429552)
What it comes down to is a strong, dogmatic belief at Tesla that vision will solve all problems. It's not aligned with reality unfortunately
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by giantrobot on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:30PM (#35429943)
A strong dogmatic vision that seems to come entirely from a desire for cost reduction rather than a concern for safety or functionality.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by janoc on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:41PM (#35430096)
The set of parking sensors costs what? 100 USD? On a car that sells for upwards of $30-40k?

That's a pretty ridiculous penny pinching.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by xenospn on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:47PM (#35430191)
Almost every component of your car is the result of absolutely insane cost cutting and overworked suppliers. Car companies are notorious for putting enormous pressure on subcontractors to reduce prices at all costs.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by aylmao on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:51PM (#35430254)
Worth noting there's other savings associated with reducing complexity; operational, supply, QA, etc. But yeah a car that's worth that much I think should certainly have them.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by FredPret on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:21PM (#35430709)
I’d pay extra if they remove FM too. My previous car always blasted the radio when started. The radio is either white noise or people talking or music that isn’t mine… not sure which is worse.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by aylmao on Monday April 03, 2023 @06:59PM (#35432535)
Throwback to a past where you cloud remove the audio player and replace it with one you bought, all for not that expensive.

Modern cars, like all tech, are losing customizability and repairability in favor of slick designs and vendor control. I just hope the car-equivalent of tower PCs never fully go away.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by WeylandYutani on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @06:37AM (#35437534)
Yes in those days car stereos were frequently stolen. The entertainment system is so integrated these days you'd have to steal the entire car.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by MengerSponge on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:54PM (#35430315)
$100 here, $100 there, after a while you're talking about real money!

I guess it helps explain why Tesla's margins per car are so huge.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by judge2020 on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:01PM (#35430408)
Munro & Associates estimates the cost of the sensor plus installation to be $8 so $96 across the car, and the rest of the cost for the wiring totals to $114[0] all including cost to install them.

From sales alone, ie. 420k a quarter or 1.6 million a year[1], they save $180M in a year and Munro estimates $100k/yr savings in removing them from their inventory.

0: https://youtu.be/LS3Vk0NPFDE?t=276

1: https://ir.tesla.com/press-release/tesla-vehicle-production-...

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by gumby on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:56PM (#35430334)
> That's a pretty ridiculous penny pinching.

Ford is eliminating AM radio from its entire line (except where contractually required), saving, I suppose, less than $10/vehicle. They’d rather deal with the bad press to save a few bucks from their BOM.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by tehnub on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:29PM (#35430806)
This may be marketing lies, but I thought that was due to AM radio not working well on electric vehicles [0].

[0]: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/10/business/media/am-radio-c...

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by gumby on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:42PM (#35430977)
If you can’t use an AM radio in an electric vehicle your vehicle is violating FCC regulations.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by tzs on Monday April 03, 2023 @07:25PM (#35432832)
I don't think the FCC cares about interference unless it affects other people.

Look at TVs and computer monitors for example. I've got a Samsung SyncMaster T240 monitor that blasts out annoying noise all across the 2m ham band (and nearby police and fire bands). I've got to turn it off if I want to usefully scan those bands with a radio that is within a meter of the monitor.

Yet it passed FCC certification. Yes, it is noisy, but even if I were in a small apartment it would not be noisy enough to interfere with someone in another apartment. It just is a problem near the monitor.

Not all TVs and monitors are noisy. When playing with an RTL-SDR on my 2017 iMac I've never found any significant noise coming from the iMac for example.

Unfortunately this is something that reviewers don't seem to ever test.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by rnk on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @12:59AM (#35435276)
Almost every EV now comes without an AM radio because of the interference. The original tesla model S had an am radio, but now they dropped them. It's apparently not a requirement any more. They must have some some special work to somehow eliminate the interference of the electric drivetrain.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by WeylandYutani on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:53PM (#35431120)
Mercedes and BMW couldn't get away with it because they sell on premium and German engineering.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by cycomanic on Monday April 03, 2023 @05:11PM (#35431351)
Well the whole VW cheating disaster was prompted by trying to save a few $ in parts IIRC
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by mikeyouse on Monday April 03, 2023 @06:38PM (#35432322)
Nah, that was much more defensible from a penny pinching standpoint since they would’ve had to reengineer their vehicles for larger DEF tanks, would’ve had to represent lower fleet mileage, etc.

You may have been remembering the GM ignition crisis which was exactly that — engineering team shipped inadequate springs at a potential cost savings of pennies per vehicle that allows the cars to turn off while moving.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by jimmydddd on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @12:46AM (#35435195)
On a podcast (Lex Fidman I think), the former head of the AI group seemed to say that Tesla would rather focus all of its resources on vision instead of using some resources on researching, specifying, ordering and calibrating sensors.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by gary_0 on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:51PM (#35431104)
Humans have top-notch visual/spatial reasoning systems and we still bang our shins and elbows on stuff. We shouldn't be removing proximity sensors from cars, we should be installing them on people!
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by Fr0styMatt88 on Monday April 03, 2023 @05:04PM (#35431274)
To that point, humans have a whole proprioception system (as well as the direct sense of touch) and auditory system to help feed that spatial reasoning system.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by voisin on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:12PM (#35429649)
> With birds eye view, parking sensors aren't really needed anymore, so they didn't place an order for new sensors.

Is OP saying that the proximity beeping would be done by the cameras (some sort of computational videography like an iPhone?) rather than the old sensor type or that the only answer would be visual? If the latter, that’s crazy - my truck has amazing cameras but if I am trying to back up with the sun low in the sky behind me, or the camera covered in dirt or snow, it is useless.

Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by bdcravens on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:14PM (#35430596)
Yes, my EV6 has both, and they are just 2 different useful features.
Re:Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictabl... by raxxorraxor on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @08:12AM (#35438340)
Theoretically they would not be needed, but I agree that the mechanism of some ultrasound sensors is much more reliable. Given that they are as cheap as they are, I don't know why a car would leave them out in the first place given the margins of modern cars.