Even with the addition of backup cameras I still look all around and check blind spots as if I didn't have a camera. No backup camera I've used shows enough information to be confident enough otherwise.
Unless ya'll have some truly high end cars I don't see how anyone can confidently back up with just a camera and not fear hitting objects/children etc.
I never even thought about my habit until a friend who is very terrified of riding in cars told me they were made comfortable by how much I look around me while driving. Which just convinces me further that most people shouldn't be on the road.
If I look backward I wouldn't see a small child right behind my vehicle. The parking sensors and backup camera would, though. That's why I feel like it's weird to look backward instead of looking at the video feed from the wide-angle camera.
E.g. Mazda 3 has that - if it detects a vehicle or even a pedestrian approaching from the side while reversing, it starts beeping and showing orange chevrons on the camera screen to alert me.
Obviously, this doesn't remove the need to look around and not rely only the sensors and cameras. The tech may fail and the ultimate responsibility is with the driver.
I check blind spots I know my camera has but then use the camera to actually back up because it's got a far better view from the back of my car than I do from the front seat.
Might be a side effect of how we're taught in the UK, but we were always told we should keep glancing in our mirrors whilst driving so it seems natural to me at least.
tl;dr, look around in real life, too. I'm not sure why the parking sensors didn't notice the tree or the curb, to be honest.
I have a car with both (birds eye view and parking sensors), and they are absolutely complimentary to each other, and I use them for different reasons. E.g. for squeezing through my garage door (I only have about 1.5 inch of clearance on each side) I like the birds eye view, but then when I pull up to the front of the garage I use the sensor because I know exactly how many inches from the front my car should be so that I can both walk around the front and the back if I need to unload stuff from the trunk.
edit : English subtitles : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q4jeN2QO1Gs
Meh. I have the sonar equipment in my car and it works nicely, and I'd view its removal as a mild loss. But it wouldn't have changed the purchase decision. It's a technical mistake, and at the margins will probably hurt them in sales.
But there's nothing here to justify the size of the thread we're spending on it. It's a parking sensor.
AFAIK, pretty much none of the driverless systems are using parallax. The reason why not is that parallax only gives good depth information at most up to about 10 feet. Disparity mapping is pretty limited in real life.
Instead they get depth from video.
I'd imagine in almost every situation the car would cast a shadow to that featureless wall. Although Tesla might not have a camera placed to a right spot to actually see that shadow...
Do you have a source for that? DfM is pretty much always a worse option than multi-camera reconstruction AFAIK.
> almost every situation the car would cast a shadow to that featureless wall.
I think "almost every situation" a pretty low bar for automotive safety.
I don't know too much about what people do in the automotive world, but in robotics it's pretty common to have an IR pattern projector if you really need depth on featureless surfaces.
I think this can only ever be reliable with a projection. A pulsed line laser or something that is synced with the camera. Then again, a simple ultrasound sensor might do a better job.
Otherwise the system might work, but is much more unstable in non-optimal conditions. Robustness is a pretty important feature for driverless systems. That said, stereoscopy would at least be better than only one camera.
That's a pretty ridiculous penny pinching.
Modern cars, like all tech, are losing customizability and repairability in favor of slick designs and vendor control. I just hope the car-equivalent of tower PCs never fully go away.
I guess it helps explain why Tesla's margins per car are so huge.
From sales alone, ie. 420k a quarter or 1.6 million a year[1], they save $180M in a year and Munro estimates $100k/yr savings in removing them from their inventory.
0: https://youtu.be/LS3Vk0NPFDE?t=276
1: https://ir.tesla.com/press-release/tesla-vehicle-production-...
Ford is eliminating AM radio from its entire line (except where contractually required), saving, I suppose, less than $10/vehicle. They’d rather deal with the bad press to save a few bucks from their BOM.
[0]: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/10/business/media/am-radio-c...
Look at TVs and computer monitors for example. I've got a Samsung SyncMaster T240 monitor that blasts out annoying noise all across the 2m ham band (and nearby police and fire bands). I've got to turn it off if I want to usefully scan those bands with a radio that is within a meter of the monitor.
Yet it passed FCC certification. Yes, it is noisy, but even if I were in a small apartment it would not be noisy enough to interfere with someone in another apartment. It just is a problem near the monitor.
Not all TVs and monitors are noisy. When playing with an RTL-SDR on my 2017 iMac I've never found any significant noise coming from the iMac for example.
Unfortunately this is something that reviewers don't seem to ever test.
You may have been remembering the GM ignition crisis which was exactly that — engineering team shipped inadequate springs at a potential cost savings of pennies per vehicle that allows the cars to turn off while moving.
Is OP saying that the proximity beeping would be done by the cameras (some sort of computational videography like an iPhone?) rather than the old sensor type or that the only answer would be visual? If the latter, that’s crazy - my truck has amazing cameras but if I am trying to back up with the sun low in the sky behind me, or the camera covered in dirt or snow, it is useless.
Sorry but that's a large logical chasm you just casually leapt. How does bird's eye view magically determine the distance to a textureless wall when parallax fails to detect it?
Why do cars with birds eye view still come equipped with parking sensors if they are obviated?