News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by glenstein on Monday April 03, 2023 @06:55AM (#35421418)
I find this concept to be helpful in countering the epidemic of false equivalences, or the pennywise pound foolish contrarianism that you see so frequently in internet comment sections.

My favorite example is probably whenever there's articles about sitting being bad for your health. You tend to get a couple of contrarians replying, "Well standing more may sound like good advice but standing can cause lower back pain, so it's not so simple!" However, that reply completely loses grasp of the relative scale of the two things, inviting you to consider the inconveniences of lower back pain as being on the same level as heart disease.

I think the more serious examples of Wronger Than Wrong relate to authoritarian states. A year ago when the Russian invasion started, some people suggested the Russian crackdown on dissent was unremarkable, and compared it to the United States during the Iraq war. And it's not wrong, in that they might fit into a similar category, but it represents a complete failure to assess the relative scale of those two things.

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by baxtr on Monday April 03, 2023 @07:48AM (#35421893)
I’m not sure if the example fits to the concept.

Your example describe a poor trade-off discussion.

The wiki article describes a “spectrum of wrongness”, on which you can sort wrong things.

My 5c at least. But maybe I’m wronger!

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by glenstein on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:06PM (#35426210)
You are right.

With the sitting example, the ideal case is perfect health. The trade-offs have different distances from the ideal case. You are correct that those distances are not strictly distances of wrongness, but they are nevertheless something you can be "Wronger Than Wrong" about if you treat them the same.

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by xg15 on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:12AM (#35422166)
I noticed something similar in popsci articles and a lot of (soft) sci-fi: They are often enamoured by a particular set of subfields in physics, namely particle physics, relativity and quantum theory. But they rarely make an attempt to make those fields accessible to a casual reader or clear up apparent contradictions - on the contrary, they usually highlight the counterintuitive or paradox aspects and maintain an air of arcane knowledge and mysticism: Only Einstein could understand relativity because he was imbued with the spirit of genius, us normal mortals can only marvel at the beauty of knowledge made for minds greater than us!

This always seems to me more like "anti-science journalism" because while it superficially celebrates "science", it also strongly discourages the reader from trying to make sense of it.

My pet conspiracy theory is that some groups (i.e. religious groups and panpsychism folks) are very invested in the idea that human consciousness exists separate from the physical universe - or at the very least is a fundamental force that cannot be explained by any other physical phenomenon.

Connected with this is the religious notion that humans are sort of the "main characters" of the universe and the rest of it is made specifically for them.

Quantum theory introduced some technical terms which were very unfortunately named and gave the impression that the theory would support that view - when in reality it was just a misunderstanding. Those groups took this apparent backing of "science" and ran with it - and have little interest in the general public understanding enough of physics to realise the mistake.

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by jiggawatts on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:23AM (#35422317)
The Many World Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics was rejected out of hand by scientists that were also religious. They could not accept a theory that doesn't make "this" Earth (where Jesus preached) special and unique in the eyes of God.

Similarly, Block Universe ideas are rejected by many people on the grounds of "but what about free will?".

Here's an idea: Go ask ChatGPT to decide something, to use its free will, and then weep that it can do it despite being an entirely static array of numbers.

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by danielvf on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:16AM (#35422977)
An LLM like ChatGPT ends up with a bunch of probabilities for the next word-ish. A random number generator then picks from them, weighted by probability, and then the process loops. So while the weights are static, the actual execution is very much non-deterministic.
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by gpderetta on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:41AM (#35423390)
Do they use an actual physical source of randomness for every random number? Or is it a prng? Because in that case it is fully deterministic.

And consider the case that in fact they could use actual random numbers. Would it make a difference?

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by amalcon on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:37AM (#35423335)
While I can't say whether ChatGPT or others are actually doing this, it's entirely possible to use a PRNG in that spot with no loss of effectiveness. PRNGs are specifically designed to create the appearance of randomness out of a process that is in fact wholly deterministic.
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by plg94 on Monday April 03, 2023 @10:25AM (#35424100)
Just because we cannot determine something doesn't mean it's non-deterministic. The question of the existence of free will is very similar – if not equivalent – to the existence of real randomness. I.e. a dice roll may be deterministic if you just know the right set of complicated equations for gravity, air resistance, turbulence etc.
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by v64 on Monday April 03, 2023 @11:42AM (#35425680)
> the actual execution is very much non-deterministic.

Only as a default. Temperature can be turned to 0 and other token selection settings changed from the defaults to create deterministic output from a given prompt.

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by klodolph on Monday April 03, 2023 @10:39AM (#35424371)
Is the many worlds interpretation a theory? Depending on your formulation of many worlds, it is untestable, even in theory. From what I can tell, many worlds is more of a philosophical framework for talking about quantum mechanics, rather than a theory about how the universe works. If it’s a philosophical framework, then it’s enough that you have philosophical grounds for opposing it, you do not need to wait for evidence.
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by jonnat on Monday April 03, 2023 @10:40AM (#35424386)
> The Many World Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics was rejected out of hand by scientists that were also religious

Do you have a reference for that? The Many Worlds interpretation was initially rejected by John Wheeler, Everett's Ph.D. advisor, under the influence of Neils Bohr, but I've never read anywhere that the motivation of the two was in any way religious.

The book What is Real? by Adam Becker has a good account of this history.

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by xg15 on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @02:09PM (#35443716)
> Similarly, Block Universe ideas are rejected by many people on the grounds of "but what about free will?".

Didn't know about block universes so far, but as for the general idea of a deterministic universe, I never quite got why people see it so much as a contradiction to free will.

When we experience free will in our lives, I think what that mostly entails is that we have thoughts and make decisions based on our experience of the world - plus our own knowledge, memories, attitudes, feelings etc. Our thoughts and actions are influenced by a great deal of what happened in the past, but we don't access the past directly: All we have is our memory of past events. And memories, knowledge, attitudes etc are all part of the brain - and therefore part of the current world state.

So as long as the entirety of your thinking and decision-making is only based on your memories, this seems perfectly compatible with a deterministic universe to me. It also doesn't restrict free will in any practically meaningful way: All it says is that if given the exact same "brain state", you'd decide in the same way - but it's practically impossible to have the same brain state twice. If you can remember having made a choice in the past, then your brain is already in a different state than it was back then, so it's perfectly possible to choose differently the second time without violating determinism.

On the other hand, if you could somehow reset your brain exactly back to a previous state, this would imply forgetting everything that had happened since that time - and then it's not a big surprise that you'd choose the same way as you did the first time.

(And I think if you use that definition of "free will" then in principle even LLMs could have it: They have their own "brain state" with "memories" encoded as the model weights, the prompt and all the tokens emitted previously in the conversation.)

There is a second, orthogonal discussion about free will, which asks how much influence biological and subconscious factors have on thinking. I think the famous "your neurons triggered long before you 'decided' to push the button" experiment belongs to that category. I found that discussion always much more reasonable, but also a lot less clear-cut: There is a much larger spectrum of possible outcomes than the binary "full free will/no free will" of the "deterministic universe" discussion.

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by tokai on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:16AM (#35422228)
>My pet conspiracy theory is that some groups (i.e. religious groups and panpsychism folks) are very invested in the idea that human consciousness exists separate from the physical universe

That's what the Templeton Foundation is doing.

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by ted_bunny on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:18AM (#35422248)
If I have to define "observer" for these types one more damn time...
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by agentgumshoe on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:15AM (#35422205)
Or they're just nerds that like writing stories about it because they think it's cool...
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by xg15 on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:20AM (#35422273)
Nothing against sci-fi writers, true. But I'm annoyed at science journalism which has the ambition to make actual science accessible to the public and still falls into the same traps.
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by agentgumshoe on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:44AM (#35422547)
Yeah definitely. I have a feeling it's just because most of them don't actually have the experience/knowledge to do it properly, mustn't pay enough :(
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by waiquoo on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:11AM (#35422920)
I'm going to drop a link to this blog: https://profmattstrassler.com/about/about-this-site-and-how-...

I am not a particle physicist, but the explanations of quantum mechanics and particle physics here have been sufficiently detailed to let me get past the hand-wavy, paradox laden pop-sci descriptions you see elsewhere.

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by HardlyCurious on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:51AM (#35423542)
So are there no secular pop sci authors to clear things up or is your pet theory just you trying to blame an issue on your out group?
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by boxed on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:16AM (#35422991)
Afaik the studies don't bear out that it's sitting that's the problem. It's the lack of running.

https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/03/modern-hunter-gather...

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by bbarnett on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:23AM (#35423108)
The word 'run' or 'running' does not appear once, in the article you linked. It does discusses general activity, walking, and even how they sit.

Running != walking.

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by boxed on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:38AM (#35450644)
Yes, the word "run" does not appear. But you've just cherry picked a fact and claim it has anything to do with what I wrote. Which it doesn't.
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by awkward on Monday April 03, 2023 @10:39AM (#35424375)
Alternately, it may be a bit of an infohazard for non experts to throw around accusations of wronger than wrong.

If opinion A is wrong, and opinion B is wronger, and elevating B over A is most wrong, the correct action aligns with the (wrong) stance of "protect A at all costs."

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by digging on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:30PM (#35427888)
I don't see how that follows. The obvious correct action to me is "seek C". Opinion A would simply be a safer fallback until C is found.
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by awkward on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:05PM (#35429562)
Most people, for most things, don't have the luxury of seeking C. They simply need to know enough that they can go about their lives and be effective.

For a programming example - I've been in jobs that enforced the "single return value" rule over functions. For older versions of C or other languages, this makes sense. The shop mostly used C#, which uses exceptions, which means that the benefit of the single return wasn't there, because any line potentially exits the function. The rule then prevents exit early and similar, more effective techniques.

The people setting the rule had learned that Djikstra style structured programming was better for writing business software than the older, goto using, more imperative style. The rule to make sure you were doing A and not B had lasted well into the discovery of C.

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by pseg134 on Monday April 03, 2023 @11:06AM (#35424915)
I take issue with your Iraq war example. The United States has different control mechanisms than Russian when it comes to dissent in their populations. The United States manufactures consent. Russia crushes dissent. Both countries definitely wield their control at similar levels and to the same effect. That you seem to prefer the US style is simply a personal preference not an expression of some truth.
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by ouid on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:11PM (#35426327)
I think you might actually be underestimating the role of lower back pain in your future happiness.
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by BeetleB on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:23PM (#35426582)
I think sitting is a lot more likely to give you lower back pain, though.
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by glenstein on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:13PM (#35427575)
My dad had devastating lower back pain that he described as being stabbed by a knife, and no history of heart disease. I understand that I need to make choices to minimize the possibility of this happening to me, and I nevertheless believe that heart disease is the more significant health threat.
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by Firmwarrior on Monday April 03, 2023 @02:12PM (#35428695)
My dad had the same thing, eventually turned out he had a gigantic blood clot in his back that'd been getting bigger every year

Might be worth checking into!

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by glenstein on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:22PM (#35433346)
Is the upshot of this supposed to be that lower back pain is approximately equivalent to heart disease as a significant health risk?
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by Firmwarrior on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @09:53AM (#35439634)
I dunno about that.. I'd just say that if you're in good physical shape, have good insurance, and have persistent back pain, that might be something to check into
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by ouid on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:15PM (#35429704)
Run me through your back of the envelope calculation here. It seems to me like you have plugged in -infinity for the utility of heart disease which is an example of the scale insensitive reason you are currently accusing people of.
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by glenstein on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:19PM (#35433334)
I find this a deeply confusing comment. You're strawmanning rather than steelmanning (also helpful concepts), because I think a much more reasonable interpretation of what I'm saying is just that I'm reading the two differently enough that I can differentiate them.
Re:Wronger Than Wrong by ouid on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:01PM (#35433615)
I asked you to run me through your calculation, followed by my best estimation of your argument. If you can't provide your reasoning, then I can't do any better than my guess.

You're the one who has taken the stance that people who say "standing is bad for your back" are universally failing to account for the relative scale of the two considerations. I think it's likely that you're making a number of errors yourself when coming to that conclusion, and I would appreciate it if you would share them.

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by tzs on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:24PM (#35426605)
> My favorite example is probably whenever there's articles about sitting being bad for your health. You tend to get a couple of contrarians replying, "Well standing more may sound like good advice but standing can cause lower back pain, so it's not so simple!" However, that reply completely loses grasp of the relative scale of the two things, inviting you to consider the inconveniences of lower back pain as being on the same level as heart disease.

Some of that is because the sitting articles often misunderstand the research, and even if the article doesn't a lot of readers here misunderstand the article taking it to mean that as soon as your butt hits the chair you start taking serious damage.

It is prolonged sitting that is bad. Stand up and move around occasionally and sitting is fine.

As far as standing goes, standing too long has more risks than just lower back pain. For people who already have some ischemic heart disease it increases the progression of carotid atherosclerosis, and in increase the risk of varicose veins.

Here's a nice summary from ergonomics researchers of the risks of sitting too long and standing too long [1]. Here's what they recommend:

> Sit to do computer work. Sit using a height-adjustable, downward titling keyboard tray for the best work posture, then every 20 minutes stand for 8 minutes AND MOVE for 2 minutes. The absolute time isn’t critical but about every 20-30 minutes take a posture break and stand and move for a couple of minutes. Simply standing is insufficient. Movement is important to get blood circulation through the muscles. And movement is FREE! Research shows that you don’t need to do vigorous exercise (e.g. jumping jacks) to get the benefits, just walking around is sufficient. So build in a pattern of creating greater movement variety in the workplace (e.g. walk to a printer, water fountain, stand for a meeting, take the stairs, walk around the floor, park a bit further away from the building each day).

[1] https://ergo.human.cornell.edu/CUESitStand.html

Re:Wronger Than Wrong by antisthenes on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:35PM (#35430018)
The equivalency of opinions (e.g. giving opinions equal weight at all times) is the bane of modern discourse.

Sometimes it feels like 90% of the general populace doesn't understand the difference and it's easier just to throw your hands in the air and cut contact off with the person than to try to explain to them this concept.

Luckily, once you make friends with the 10% club, your life starts to feel great.