News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by wilg on Saturday April 01, 2023 @09:04PM (#35405976)
Based on the comments in here (and on related stories) I think the US transportation conversation needs to change in some way.

Mostly, it's a lot of people complaining about cars. Which is fine, I mostly agree. But the anti-car stuff is becoming extremely toxic and parroting half-remembered tweets about induced demand, finding slightly different ways to describe cars as death machines, and good old-fashioned liberal American self-flagellation.

We're past the point where it's transgressive to point out the problems with cars, we need to actually have some kind of a sensible discussion that involves practical considerations. In particular, anti-car people need to have a good handle on why people actually like cars. Otherwise, it'll just be more of trying to punish people, like the guy in this thread who says "the key to this morass to make car owners suffer". We've got to do better than that!

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by actionablefiber on Saturday April 01, 2023 @09:23PM (#35406113)
One major issue is that if you as an individual attempt to go car-free, the resulting lifestyle makes cars into such an incredible intrusion into your daily life that it is hard not to become more radicalized.

That has been my story at least. My bus is late and slow, because it's stuck in bumper-to-bumper traffic from all these people driving motor vehicles with a single occupant. I need ear protection on my commute because the 14th Street Bridge into DC pairs pedestrians and cyclists side-by-side with 60mph motor traffic with no noise protections. I lost a day at work because I got hit on my bike by a truck driver who was on his phone, and had to go to the ER. I am shaken and my heart rate is pounding and I am pondering my own mortality because someone gunned their engine through a left turn while I was walking across the street with a pedestrian signal - they accelerated instead of stopping to yield and I had to jump out of the way to save my own life while they sped off.

If you recognize how awful cars are for the environment and how they make city life inconvenient, unpleasant and expensive, and so you make the personal decision to forgo them to be part of the solution rather than the problem, you are taking a step into a life that will nudge you more and more to truly despise motor vehicles because your daily life will be filled with only negative interactions with them.

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by wilg on Saturday April 01, 2023 @09:50PM (#35406283)
Do you feel you're gaining a lot by subjecting yourself to this situation?
Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by actionablefiber on Saturday April 01, 2023 @10:04PM (#35406379)
Quite a lot. I save a lot of money - my monthly transportation cost is some two-digit number even after including the occasional weekend trip to other cities - most of which I squirrel away and some of which I spend on other things; I am always in excellent physical shape; I have a deep knowledge of the metro, bus, bikeshare, trail and bike lane systems around the DC metro area and spend a lot of time using low-stress separated infrastructure; I go anywhere in the city anytime I want without ever having to think about parking, tolls, gas or congestion.

The drawback, if you can call it that, is that I am radically anti-car, as a direct result of the lived experiences that that life gives me.

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by wilg on Saturday April 01, 2023 @10:10PM (#35406414)
Cool, that's a good pitch for not owning a car, and sounds great!

My issue is not with people who are anti-car, but with people who cannot understand why other people have different priorities and who make different trade-offs. That's key to building a better world.

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by actionablefiber on Saturday April 01, 2023 @11:06PM (#35406751)
> My issue is not with people who are anti-car, but with people who cannot understand why other people have different priorities and who make different trade-offs.

A lot to say here for why I think the number of people who can legitimately claim it is a morally neutral matter of priorities and trade-offs for them is small.

For one, there are stigmas around transit and biking. Funnily enough they are contradictory: that only the poor get around with transit and biking, and that only upper class elitists get around with transit and biking. It is extremely common for people to oppose new infrastructure or denser housing on the grounds that it will either A) cause "undesirables" to come to the neighborhood and destroy property values, or B) induce gentrification.

For two, for a lot of people, living car-centrically is an automatic habit because it was a deeply ingrained assumption all throughout their upbringing that you just need a car and that owning a car is an important rite of passage and social signifier in adulthood.

For three, lots of people who were steeped in driving growing up are intimidated by the thought of learning to navigate a transit system or learning to ride a bike.

The last and to me most important thing is that the politics of car dependency are destructive to everyone. It is a negative-sum game to widen all the highways, and increase all the parking minimums, and zone for low density, and block bike lanes. It is extremely wasteful in terms of public resources and environmental destruction and it harms everyone's quality of life.

A lot of people don't really grasp the danger and unpleasantness that their car imposes on others. Seeing, smelling, hearing, tiptoeing around motor vehicle traffic are all deeply unpleasant and you have to place an enormous amount of trust in motor vehicle operators not to kill you where you stand. This is one thing that makes me not sympathetic to the "different priorities and trade-offs" argument. The internal logic is about pros and cons to one's own self, not about the pros and cons to everyone else, and motor vehicles have many properties that put this in stark relief: they are getting bigger and heavier making them safer to the driver and more deadly to whoever they hit; their horns are loud enough to cause ear damage and cause a giant fright to bystanders but are muffled inside the cabin; and of course huge, huge tracts of even walkable cities like NY are dedicated to motor vehicle traffic with many lanes while people walking, biking, scootering, dining outdoors and so on are forced to fight for scraps of space at the margin.

For me living without a car is not just about the benefits it offers to me personally but also the full understanding of the harms to others I am refusing to inflict, or even run the risk of inflicting, by opting out.

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by wilg on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:55AM (#35407309)
Not only do I think this is a completely legitimate point of view, I fully agree with you in terms of your policy goals: walkable neighborhoods, high density, no parking minimums, pedestrian-and-bike-focused city design. I don't want to see cars parked on the sides of the streets. No question in my mind that's the better environment to be in.

Some pushback on your facts:

Firstly, cars are getting significantly better as they go electric. Smell is eliminated, while noise and environmental impact will be significantly reduced - without any changes to our road infrastructure. Anti-car people tend to push back on the idea that electric cars are significantly more environmentally friendly, but they're flat-out wrong. A Tesla Model 3 is 5x more efficient than the average new gas car. Four people driving in that same Tesla emit less greenhouse gas than if they were traveling on UK rail. Cars are also are pushing forward electrification technology in other domains. Impact from mining for battery materials is improving. That mining is necessary anyway for grid storage if we're to switch to renewable energy, not to mention that EV batteries are 99%+ recyclable, so we don't have to mine this material forever, either.

It's also not the case that cars are only getting safer for the passengers. Technologies like automatic emergency braking that always watch out for pedestrians and bikers is now standard, and will continue to improve as cars become more autonomous.

In the US, average weight of cars is basically the same as it was in 1975, and per-capita pedestrian deaths have halved over the same period.

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by sagarm on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:55AM (#35407613)
Car dependent suburbanites are also anti car: their neighborhoods are designed to make driving through them inconvenient, to minimize the the cost of their car dependent lifestyle on THEM. I just want exactly the same car-hostile design, with 15 mph speed limits and copious dead ends, in my neighborhood so my neighborhood streets are also safe enough for kids to play in. How can suburbanites object?

The status quo is that the external costs of car dependent lifestyles are almost entirely pushed onto other people via highways slicing through the middle of cities, roads being paid for mostly via the general fund, larger vehicles protecting occupants at the cost of everyone else, sound isolated cabins protecting drivers from the noise they create and requiring louder emergency sirens...it just goes on and on.

EVs are better for the environment than ICE vehicles, but the noise, air pollution via tire dust, and physical danger they present is the same. The real EV is an e-bike, but most people don't want to bike because sharing roads with cars feels too dangerous. As a result, cars on the only choice.

I want 90% of my city streets to block through traffic with physical barriers, just like the suburbs. Many intersections should allow ONLY pedestrians, cyclists, transit, and service vehicles through, so the fastest and most pleasant ways from point A to point B are walking, cycling, or transit.

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by nayuki on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:15AM (#35407714)
That's right. Suburbanites want the freedom to drive everywhere but also limit through-traffic and noise on the street their house exists on. That's why twisty roads and culs de sac exist. "Oh The Urbanity!" argues this point elegantly in: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dqQw05Mr63E "The Suburban Traffic Contradiction"
Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by slifin on Sunday April 02, 2023 @05:22AM (#35408683)
electric cars do have some benefits that you outline but also some new dangers I've been nearly hit by a driver who accelerated as I attempted to cross

At the time he was a long way off but by the time I crossed he had accelerated to the point he could have hit me

Electric cars will still cut up my local town into little isolated islands the same way normal cars do

Car alternatives need so much more support than they get right now it's unreal

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by actionablefiber on Monday April 03, 2023 @11:29AM (#35425418)
> Firstly, cars are getting significantly better as they go electric. Smell is eliminated, while noise and environmental impact will be significantly reduced - without any changes to our road infrastructure.

The issue with the road infrastructure is also that it necessitates cars to begin with. With wide, sprawling networks of roads where motor traffic is too fast for people to comfortably walk and cycle, you end up with huge amounts of suburban sprawl. Things are located far apart; tons tons tons more infrastructure needs to be built to provide roads, water, electricity, gas, Internet, police, fire response, schooling and wastewater treatment to those people living in sprawling exurban developments. All the parking lots and strip malls and highways mean that it is simply impossible to make a trip by any way other than car, which triggers orders of magnitude more motor vehicle trips of orders of magnitude longer distance than in a mixed-use walkable neighborhood, so it's not even really useful to draw a comparison between the marginal emissions of four people in a Tesla vs. the amortized emissions of four people on a train.

> Technologies like automatic emergency braking that always watch out for pedestrians and bikers is now standard, and will continue to improve as cars become more autonomous.

I hope this will save lives, but it will never be enough to break the environment of fear and the lurking danger of death that comes with navigating cities with motor traffic, especially since you can never assume that a car is equipped with it (and that it will function correctly). You need to have an incredibly high level of trust, one that just doesn't exist when you are interacting with someone using a different means of spatial displacement. Bikes and scooters are light, slow, small, maneuverable, and offer such good visibility, both to and of the cyclist, that every single risk factor is extremely low.

Or to put another way: in the aggregate it will save lives, but will you always be able to count on it to save yours?

There are other considerations too: a person in any vehicle can, and (in my experience) many do, park or drive in bike lanes or fail to yield to bike lane traffic when making turns. Here you have not the physical threat of the car itself but the fact that by doing this the motorist can force other people to execute dangerous maneuvers, like merging into high-speed motor traffic, splitting the lane or hopping onto the sidewalk to avoid the car.

And as for noise - firstly the tire noise is still there and actually worse due to vehicle weight. The honk is still there, it is still loud enough to trigger a bystander's fight or flight response, and hoo boy is there a lot of it! The people driving in DC and NY seem endlessly upset about the fact that they are doing so.

> In the US, average weight of cars is basically the same as it was in 1975, and per-capita pedestrian deaths have halved over the same period.

There is a lot going on with these numbers. For one, the main cause of this trend was the mass adoption of cars: people are simply walking a lot less than they did half a century ago. For two, the downward trend has sharply reversed since 2009: pedestrians deaths are rising very quickly, rising 50% between 2009 and 2020[1], coinciding modestly with the rise in popularity of mass market pickup trucks and SUVs.

[1]https://www.statista.com/chart/17194/pedestrian-fatalities-i...

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by vGPU on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:55PM (#35427249)
What about the medical costs from getting hit, or if you get hit again and are injured to the point where you are disabled for some time?

I have a motorcycle and I don’t feel comfortable driving to/through the city because of the number of times I’ve been run off the road, almost hit, or getting rammed while stopped at a traffic light in an SUV.

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by actionablefiber on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:35PM (#35427979)
> What about the medical costs from getting hit, or if you get hit again and are injured to the point where you are disabled for some time?

The motorist's insurance paid for that. For incidents where that doesn't happen, this is stuff I have my own insurance (including critical accident insurance) for. Also as I keep riding, my judgment gets better, my knowledge of the area gets better, and I can anticipate/avoid danger more easily. I can't really speak to motorcycles because, due to their higher weight and beefier motors (compared to, say, a scooter or e-bike), they are subject to significantly different rules and cannot use separated infrastructure like multi-use paths, cycletracks, protected bike lanes and sidewalks. My commute from Arlington to DC is about 90% covered by separated infrastructure. I have to deal with cars when running errands inside the city but typically speeds are much lower and there are usually low-stress routes available.

I mean ultimately there is a nonzero risk, both financial and bodily, much as there is when you are in a motor vehicle. I've had plenty of friends facing surprise three- or four-digit bills due to mechanical issues or damage with their car. In the DC area, motorists frequently crash into other cars while on highways or stroads, sometimes killing themselves or others. Vehicle manufacturers have superbly played the public by using the fatalities of their own vehicles as a marketing point to sell even larger and heavier vehicles under the guise of "safety" that cause even more fatalities in a collision scenario. It's an arms race and I have absolutely no desire to play a role in it.

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by GaryNumanVevo on Saturday April 01, 2023 @09:38PM (#35406194)
Put another way: "sensible discussion" is the reason why the US is stuck with car-dependent sprawl. The practical considerations were decided decades ago, and have been cargo culted into every facet of US urban and suburban design.

Cars are the designated post-hoc rationalization for an environment that is almost exclusively built for them.

If the "transgressive" tone of the conversation is the only takeaway you have, then perhaps you are not listening closely enough.

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by wilg on Saturday April 01, 2023 @09:46PM (#35406263)
This is exactly the type of pseudo-intellectual crap that I'm trying to wade through.

You're trying to present the argument in exactly the same way I'm objecting to, like you're opening my eyes that I'm in the Matrix. That it's surprising or interesting to learn that the US is built around cars in many ways, and that's affecting my thinking such that I could not consider that cars are bad. Maybe I need to "listen" more closely, like I can't understand the secrets of the world that you are privy to.

This is all intellectually dishonest masturbatory fluff.

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by GaryNumanVevo on Saturday April 01, 2023 @10:02PM (#35406372)
> This is word salad

Is there anything you'd like me to clarify further for you?

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by wilg on Saturday April 01, 2023 @10:04PM (#35406380)
I edited my post.
Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by pxmpxm on Sunday April 02, 2023 @08:04AM (#35409681)
It's not the ability comprehend what you wrote, but rather the content - the point you're making is the same cliche white-kid-from-the-suburbs-moves-to-a-city infallible argument ("you only need cars because the system makes you want cars").

There's decades of revealed preference for larger, more private housing, rather than density and mass transit, and that dynamic strongly correlates to income.

Median household income in the states is nearly double of said demographic's mecca, the Netherlands, and I would bet my lunch money that car ownership and utilisation there goes up with income as well. So relatively dense places with relatively poor-er population will optimize towards mass transit and biking and what not, because people can't afford cars and larger houses to begin with.

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by kohidavez on Saturday April 01, 2023 @09:17PM (#35406074)
Yea! Won’t someone finally think about the cars?
Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by wilg on Saturday April 01, 2023 @09:45PM (#35406256)
This is an example of the toxic bullshit I'm unhappy with.
Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by nayuki on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:08AM (#35407683)
I don't think so; the emergent urbanism conversation is a step in the right direction.

The anti-car stuff is extremely toxic because a large segment of society refuses to listen. Induced demand is how every lane-widening project is a huge money sink while failing to deliver on the promise of reduced congestion. You think complaining about death machines is comparable to the thousands of people inside and outside of cars who have near-death experiences every day due to cars? Or people losing autonomy and dignity by losing the ability to drive is not toxic? These topics have been politely brushed under the rug for too long.

Is it wrong for disenfranchised people to express their frustration? Are they required to empathize and understand their abusers?

Sensible solutions? They've been put forth ad nauseum already. Ending single-family exclusive zoning. Enabling mixed residential-commercial areas. Reducing commute distances. Funding public mass transit. Ending parking minimums. Tolling roads and mileage. Recognizing that roads are overbuilt and there is not enough tax base to maintain them.

Anti-car people know very well why people like cars. The dominant culture is kind of hard to ignore. The most common reasons are a sense of autonomy, the fact that working and doing errands without a car will increase travel time by several multiples, and the fact that it's a comfortable norm that almost everybody has accepted (can't go wrong with the herd right?).

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by joenot443 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @09:18AM (#35410205)
> You think complaining about death machines is comparable to the thousands of people inside and outside of cars who have near-death experiences every day due to cars?

This is a wildly uncharitable and disingenuous reading of their comment. I stopped reading yours at that point, I'm sure you can do better.

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by nayuki on Sunday April 02, 2023 @11:35AM (#35411631)
How am I being wildly uncharitable and disingenuous? The post I was replying to said:

> the anti-car stuff is becoming extremely toxic and [...] finding slightly different ways to describe cars as death machines

I'm refuting the complaint about the anti-car conversation being extremely toxic because the reality of car-dominant culture is toxic.

If you stopped reading my comment, aren't you choosing polarization over reconciliation?

Want to see toxic? Here are a couple of posts plucked from the r/FuckCars front page:

https://www.reddit.com/r/fuckcars/comments/128yjd9/i_just_wa... - The norm of cars parked on and blocking the sidewalk. Do pedestrians and wheelchair users not have rights?

https://www.reddit.com/r/fuckcars/comments/1291pfo/my_foot_g... - Car-ped collision, driver brushes it off as "oops wrong pedal".

https://www.reddit.com/r/fuckcars/comments/128qx21/cue_the_p... - Employee gets hassled for storing bike at workplace, no such treatment for storing a car.

Car culture is the dominant default. It's too easy to brush off non-drivers' problems as trivial and not worth solving.

Re:Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities by slifin on Sunday April 02, 2023 @05:15AM (#35408645)
As someone who dislikes cars or let's say dislikes the fact there's no other choice

I know exactly why people like cars, because I was one, I grew up playing with toy cars, micro machines, garages, play mat with roads, Sim city for car planning, building cars in Lego, playing need for speed, gran turismo, midnight club run, mad max, grand theft auto, truck simulator, watching Tokyo drift

Cars are everywhere in our culture, huge bits of car infrastructure like traffic lights and roads that run for miles that just connect to a shed are completely normal

The bigger problem for us "anti car" people is that it's so ingrained that people no longer see or care about the determental aspect of car dominance

People look at horrific crashes like a car wedged on a side of a building and they dismiss it as a driver problem

They look at traffic jams and they look at it as an other person problem

They look in their neighbourhood and don't notice that their kids can't safely play in their neighbourhood and then wonder why they're glued to phones

The problem we have is recognition first and foremost then it's education, YouTubers not just bikes and strong towns do an amazing job of that