Facebook is filled with smart people. They understand the trends better than we do. As you'll note, 4 of their top 5 Risk Factors relate to the web-to-mobile shift and the problems inherent with that.
From the filing:
#2 - "We generate a substantial majority of our revenue from advertising. The loss of advertisers, or reduction in spending by advertisers with Facebook, could seriously harm our business;"
#3 - "Growth in use of Facebook through our mobile products, where we do not currently display ads, as a substitute for use on personal computers may negatively affect our revenue and financial results;"
#4 - "Facebook user growth and engagement on mobile devices depend upon effective operation with mobile operating systems, networks, and standards that we do not control;"
#5 - "We may not be successful in our efforts to grow and further monetize the Facebook Platform;"
I think this is correct, and it explains why the IPO exit is happening now. Most of the insane growth (in profit as well as valuation) has already been squeezed out.
I would amend that to say: most of the easy growth has been squeezed out. But there's still a huge opportunity for Facebook to grow revenue/profit if they switch to using personal data to make well-directed ads they can push to sites using Facebook Connect and/or if they can roll out a solid first-party Facebook-phone. [1]
Those are both far trickier than "grow Facebook", so it does make sense to capture some returns now. But I think it would be short sighted to write their future prospects off entirely.
[1] They could quite possibly fork Android and do to Google in the phone market what Amazon is doing to the tablet market. And they'd be crazy not to try.
Facebook has (wisely) focused almost entirely on user growth and retention over the last few years. That it stumbled into being an attractive display-advertising platform was almost inevitable, and required little effort. The real money lies on the distributed mobile and web ecosystem, into which Facebook has been diligently inserting itself as a de facto credential and backend. (Think of Facebook as the "Intel Inside" of the entire content web and mobile content web, and you get the idea).
Facebook has established an impressive beachead with FB Connect, and from there, it's only a matter of time before it can monetize its FB Connect partners through contextual and interest-based advertising services. Google should be very concerned -- and, to that end, it would not surprise me in the least if the threat of FB Connect to AdSense (and, to some extent, AdWords) was a significant factor in the race to develop Google+.
No, hitting the investor limit means only that you have filing obligations with the SEC. There is no obligation to trade your stock publicly.
Interesting. While the other points are gloomy-doomy and a bit vague, this one lends itself to a concrete solution, doesn't it?
Edit: Ooh i get it.
So actually I don't worry about either company's continued success. Both Google and Facebook are here to stay and grow even bigger.
Let's not get carried away, this is not true at all. Even outside of tech circles, there are plenty of people that have no interest in what Facebook offers.
Phone numbers are definitely obsolete.
Phone numbers are abstracted, but they are definitely not obsolete.
Semantically, choosing "obsolete" might have been incorrect, but I think the point stands. IP address and phone numbers don't matter anymore to the end users.
Since a lot of mobile apps have some type of Facebook integration (ie: a Facebook app id), Facebook has a good idea of who has what apps installed and they can serve up apps that are relevant to the user both on the interest graph and the data of what other mobile apps they have installed.
Wouldn't be surprised to see them move into mobile advertising hard in 2012/2013.
* Disclaimer: This is all speculation, no insider information was divulged
They talk much about Pictures, but most of the people i know don't post any. The big success of Facebook is the E-Mail IM replacement for young people, but it is very difficult to advertise on that. Who made ever money on IM and Mail? ICQ and AIM had impressive numbers, but were never a big success financially.
I know also people who share them, but max every week and probably just 5 friend really look at them. When you look at pictures, how can you concentrate on ads? They are not even in the middle like Youtube's. Pictures on mobile reduces the space for ads even further and you will always be uglier than every competitor.
I'm not really sure that applies universally. The majority of my stream post pics from mobile (either directly, thru instagram, etc.).
>The big success of Facebook is the E-Mail IM replacement for young people...
In mobile? I don't see that happening either, as most too used to texting/iMessage/BBM
Where I do see a lot of usage is in-stream. If they can figure out how to serve up ads within the timeline without being too intrusive then that would be the way to do it in mobile. Tho that new timeline crashes more often than it works in mobile (at least in the iOS version)
What is the benefit of looking at someones timeline and how often will you do it? Facebook needs incredible engagement (what it has right now on the desktop) and space do display ads. Youtube has the content, but what brings people back to FB? Don't forget all these social Startups will hurt Facebook on engagement.
Also, I believe stats will show that engagement is rising rapidly on mobile, and that's what keep people logged on FB.
The four things people do on phones (call, email, text, and nowadays photo-share) are all inherently social things. Crucially, your iPhone contacts list likely has only the first/last name and phone number for each person, whereas the Facebook app is far richer in its implementation of the very same contacts list -- because the person on the other side has gone to the trouble of keeping their address, phone, picture, and the like all fresh and up to date[1].
So the FB Phone would be an enormous improvement in contacts management over what we currently have, and an FB Phone Directory would probably not be long in following[2].
Once people are using the FB Phone, you'd want to heavily push FB Credits as the payment solution for everything. I am sure that from a fraud protection standpoint, the identity signals that an FB account provides are highly desirable to Visa and Mastercard. FB could also just cut out the middleman and do payments directly with an FB Card, instantly accepted by 800+ million people worldwide and countless businesses. Sign up for FB.com and accept/receive payments. Use the social graph for authentication, where each node has an authenticity rank (based on its date of first signup, number of non-commercial posts, number of authentic friends, and the like). It's easy to set up a fake email address, but much harder to fake a realistic profile for years and get "real people" to friend you and interact with you.
Thus, a Facebook purchase or clone of something like WePay or Square would seem like a logical move. Embrace the shift towards mobile and own mobile payments by owning identity. Owning identity means a lower risk profile and higher profit margin than any competitor in payments.
[1] Not incidentally, the use of the FB Phone would ensure that people have even more of an incentive to keep their contact information up to date and searchable.
[2] This directory would be a huge product in its own right and the core of a real social search product, something more along the lines of findpeopleonplus.com than anything that's called itself "social search" to this point. The purpose of social search is to find a person, not a web page.
However, it knows so much about users and keeps them logged in, so it definitely has potential to serve highly targeted or viral campaigns everywhere else on the web and mobile apps, a much better version of adsense.
Secondly, it is involving itself deeply in to user's habits and eventually may make a big play in to e-commerce, getting a cut out of every transaction made by the user (while frictionlessly sharing the information, of course). Credits is just in its infancy.
Finally, its learning so much about user's habits on the web that it can do a better job than Google at search, and make a killing on search ads.
If all this happens, $100B is a bargain.
This is the real reason Google is getting desperate about Google+, they are worried about FB launching its own hyper targeted ad network. Google has context and tons of advertisers, FB has context and deep demographics and quite a lot of advertisers.
For instance, in my business Facebook ads are worthless. We depend on user intent "I'm looking for THIS" (in our case local service professionals). In search that intent is very clear, in Facebook way less so.
If I was selling lifestyle merchandise or advertising a consumer site, Facebook would be really attractive I'd think.
Both sides want a big piece of what the other has.
Serving up ads on other websites is where the magic happens.
Today, the most effective FB ads are the ones that show up in the News Feed after your friends "Like" or take action on an ad or brand page. The ROI on these ads crushes that of traditional display ads (including those on the FB right-side margin) AND the targeting is still in its nascency.
The best part is that these ads transfer seamlessly to mobile or any future platform.
1) They have users logged in all the time ... they can serve targeted ads (e.g. gender based ads) 2) AdSense is monopolizing the market now
Google brings us a few hundred a day, consisten conversion.
Apparel retail. FWIW.
As far as I'm concerned FB traffic is junk. Comes handy for load-testing though.
Search is the optimal context for presenting an ad -- you have the chance to make an impression to a person who is looking for information about something right at that moment. If you can get the right ads correlated to the search terms, you're handing the user a URL to information they're already looking for.
In most other situations, ads are noise -- they're a distraction from what the user really came there to pay attention to.
In the case of Facebook, it's the user's friends and interests. Which means your real goal with a FB campaign is to get people liking/following you. Buying comes later.
Were you doing multi-channel tracking ? - it's much more important when you're going after passive traffic sources in general.
Still, by far the best conversion comes from direct interaction with my community of potential users.
Our suppliers/vendors have exclussive right to brand management.
FB traffic is not very good if you don't optimize and tweak your campaigns to find what works best, but 200k uniques and no conversions is insane and I'm sure you could make that work much, much better; and I have data to prove it
disclaimer: I work for one of the first fb ads API tool vendors, but I'm an engineer, not a salesperson :)
Don't let the marketing talk of the homepage fool you into thinking we are all social-mediay-businesslike, we run on smart code and awesome client servicing.
IMO, Facebook's future depends on two things:
1) Figuring out how to serve up contextually relevant ads on mobile platforms in a nonintrusive and, ideally, useful way.
2) Figuring out how to serve up contextually relevant ads outside of Facebook, to Facebook Connect-backended partner sites and apps. (Sort of like an AdSense/AdWords hybrid, but based on very intelligent user-interest and browsing data).
I'm betting on #2's being the runaway breadwinner for Facebook in the long run. The longterm strategy seems to be to reduce reliance/dependence on Facebook.com in favor of Facebook Connect.