News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by teddyh on Thursday March 30, 2023 @08:15PM (#35380659)
If people only liked the sound, I would assume that it could be emulated on the digital sound processing platform they already use. People buying tubes must be something else.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by retrac on Thursday March 30, 2023 @08:33PM (#35380792)
Modern digital sound processing allows the flawless recreation of a piano, and even to create an instrument with qualities no piano built in the old style could have. Everything, and more. Cheaper, probably portable, and it doesn't require tuning. In fact, most people who play the piano now play on such instruments, most of the time.

Yet some people still buy actual pianos. Because there's an art and craft and history to pianos, and they're majestic, slightly intimidating machines; and they're expensive status symbols. A tube amp for a guitar is much the same.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by teddyh on Thursday March 30, 2023 @08:42PM (#35380856)
Yes, because pianos are still viewed as special, which is in turn because they are expensive to buy, hard to transport, take up a lot of space, and requires regular service (tuning). But tubes lack (or could potentially be made to lack) all of these qualities, which is why it would be risky to try to make tubes more cheaply available.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by retrac on Thursday March 30, 2023 @08:52PM (#35380927)
A tube amplifier made in the style of mid-20th century ones is expensive, hard to transport, bulky, and requires regular tuning/maintenance (when compared to a solid-state device). Like you say, that's why people still buy and make them.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by kazinator on Thursday March 30, 2023 @09:44PM (#35381337)
> Modern digital sound processing allows ...

... what the power amplifier and speakers that you can afford then forbid.

You will simply not re-create the sound that a real piano creates in a room with a digital signal, going into some amp and pair of ordinary speakers.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by Blackthorn on Thursday March 30, 2023 @10:17PM (#35381612)
How fortunate, then, that 99.9% of all piano music heard is going through an amp and a pair of ordinary speakers!

I've made it a point to attend classical music concerts, and even I think that 0.1% might be pushing it when it comes to the piano sounds I've heard in a room.

I've got nice flat-response studio monitors so I could get a close enough room sound if I wanted (not that I could play a piano worth a damn in order to do that LOL). Honestly they weren't particularly expensive. Certainly less expensive than a single piano tuning!

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by kazinator on Thursday March 30, 2023 @11:20PM (#35382091)
A piano is a 3D object; it has long, vibrating string courses, and a large sound board. When you're playing a piano, sound is coming at your head from various angles. It changes depending on how you turn/move your head.

All of that is condensed into a single voltage signal and sent to a speaker.

A speaker is also a 3D object; it has various modes of vibration. With multiple speakers in a cabinet (even with just a mono signal, not talking about stereo), and reflections from walls and so on, you can hear different things in the 3D space.

These are not related; the speaker cabinet just won't reproduce the experience of playing a piano, or being right next to one. It reproduces its own sonic 3D signature.

Now if you're listening to a piano from a distance in a big hall, some of this matters less. Your head movements don't make much of a difference; it's almost just coming from a single point that could be represented by a single point source (one mic capture), panned into a stereo sound stage.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by Blackthorn on Friday March 31, 2023 @12:31AM (#35382588)
I'm aware of all of that.

However: 99.9% of all piano music heard is not heard through a live piano directly. Make that several more nines if you're talking about someone who doesn't even play piano and occasionally hears something in a huge audience hall. It's heard recorded, and then played through a speaker.

Then let's say I want to play. If I'm trying to match something I've heard, it doesn't even make sense to take that physical piano into account. What I heard was a recording. I lose nothing by playing it out of a speaker.

If I want to play just for the joy of playing a physical object or something, that's a different story. But if I'm playing for a purpose other than that, the speaker loses nothing. And best of all? It's light and cheap!

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by kazinator on Friday March 31, 2023 @01:54AM (#35383141)
> However: 99.9% of all piano music heard is not heard through a live piano directly.

That's obviously false for the individual who is a life-long, dedicated pianist, who listens to the piano in front of him or her for hours, daily, more than any other piano.

They would be short-changed by some piano synthesizer patch coming out of a pair of speakers.

> But if I'm playing for a purpose other than that,

In particular: the purpose of creating a quality recorded sound without the hassle of an acoustic space, with excellent microphones, placed expertly, going into quality preamps, and all that.

Synthesized and modeled sound makes it easier to produce (or fake, depending on your viewpoint) quality recorded music.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by H1Supreme on Friday March 31, 2023 @10:21AM (#35387562)
OP is clearly referencing the sum of all people who listen to a piano in a song. Not the "life-long, dedicated pianist"'s of the world. And to further that point, lots and lots of folks who play in touring bands do not haul a piano with them. They're usually using something like a Nord Stage.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by munificent on Thursday March 30, 2023 @08:23PM (#35380712)
There are many many digital tube amp emulations and they are widely used.

But when it comes to music and audio, there's a lot of subjectivity and magical thinking and some people believe that the real thing is better than a digital emulation. Whether they're objectively right is an open question, but they believe it enough for it to be worth spending money on.

There's another aspect to this which is the creative spark itself. If you've ever tried to do something creative, you know it can be really hard to summon the right headspace to get your emotions out into some tangible form. It takes a weird, tenuous mix of confidence and vulnerability to make it happen. It's really easy for that delicate psychological balance to collapse.

I think for a lot of musicians, certain gear has a talismanic ability to help them preserve the mental state they need to create. Now, you could argue that this is all just placebo affect. But in this case, the entire goal is to create a certain mental self-confidence, so the placebo effect is reality. When belief is the point, if you believe it works, it actually does work.

Tube amps are one of those things that helps some people connect with their muse.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by teddyh on Thursday March 30, 2023 @08:34PM (#35380797)
That magical thinking only works, though, if the object in question is special in some way. If it can be had for a dime a dozen at any time from any local corner store, the object loses its magic.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by bb88 on Thursday March 30, 2023 @08:41PM (#35380853)
That's the thing, tubes used to be a dime a dozen. Just not anymore once transistors took over.

I'm not saying it's not nostalgia, it could very well be....

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by teddyh on Thursday March 30, 2023 @08:47PM (#35380891)
Exactly my point. If tubes still were, and always had been, a dime a dozen, then nobody would care about building (or buying) fancy expensive equipment with tubes! Tubes would be seen as obsolete junk.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by progrus on Thursday March 30, 2023 @09:26PM (#35381190)
Except for guitar amps - I think you underestimate how tribal and idiosyncratic the tone hounds can get.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by bb88 on Thursday March 30, 2023 @10:58PM (#35381939)
I'm don't underestimate it at all. There's a certain warm tone that tubes produce. It's gentle in a sense. A DAC can be harsh.

A naive view point is that the analog output of an analog device is going to be smooth.

The digital output will add noise on the stair step transitions.

I'm not saying this is the case in reality. I'm just saying, it's useful to think about when dealing with analog vs digital signals.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by progrus on Friday March 31, 2023 @12:08AM (#35382440)
“Warm tone” is just another name for gentler distortion, where non-linearities happen before the hard clip limit. It can be modeled pretty well digitally as long as the digital signal itself doesn’t clip, but I agree the real thing is best.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by kazinator on Friday March 31, 2023 @01:32AM (#35383014)
> There's a certain warm tone that tubes produce.

LOL, what? Tubes produce the distortion you hear in most branches of heavy metal, and iconic sounds throughout the whole spectrum of guitar rock.

In its raw form, it sounds awful; it has to be carefully shaped by filters, to remove high frequency "fizz" as well as annoying midrange frequencies to which the ear is sensitive. Even then, that filtered tone isn't something you could listen to via hi-fi equipment or record directly; it is amplified into certain kinds of cabinets with certain kinds of speakers. After all that, some people still hate it. :)

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by bb88 on Friday March 31, 2023 @02:05PM (#35390814)
You've clearly never listened to Fleetwood Mac on a tube stereo. It's not harsh. It's not perfect, but it is warm.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by progrus on Friday March 31, 2023 @05:19PM (#35393811)
I love my tube stereo. It would take an expensive solid-state amp to get close to its character, and it glows like a little fireplace :)

Side note - I have a hunch that the term “warm” was coined unconsciously. It’s not the actual sound; it’s the sound characteristic of warm glowing tubes, the sound of electricity fizzing through hot metal.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by kazinator on Friday March 31, 2023 @08:58PM (#35395875)
For a few hundred bucks, second hand, I can get a distortion-free sound-reinforcement amplifier, that can pump something like 600W per channel into a 4 Ohm load.

The equivalent all tube amp would require a line of credit from the bank, and would need to be on wheels.

To inject pleasing tube distortion into it, which I could turn on and off easily, I could put two inexpensive tube pedals in front of its inputs, like these:

https://www.amazon.com/TC-Electronic-Tube-Overdrive-Pilot/dp...

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by progrus on Saturday April 01, 2023 @12:13AM (#35397050)
My stereo is 15 watts (through the tubes, but still) - RIP your ears. Agreed that circuits in the preamp stage make the vast majority of the difference.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by Maursault on Saturday April 01, 2023 @11:17AM (#35400944)
> In its raw form, it sounds awful

Not really, and it isn't just warmth. The distortion is a unique pattern of simple and monotonically decaying series of harmonics, dominated by moderate levels of second harmonic. This is probably why most find it pleasing.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by kazinator on Saturday April 01, 2023 @01:39PM (#35402215)
* * *
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by ilyt on Thursday March 30, 2023 @11:08PM (#35382007)
Well, my amp is not in any of emulators so I have my excuse. But I kinda like single purpose of dedicated amplifier
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by progrus on Friday March 31, 2023 @12:13AM (#35382466)
I like analog hardware mostly because of the knobs, but there is also a nice spiritual connection to the sound energy.

Note that a solid-state amp can still be analog, transistors vs. tubes is distinct from analog vs. digital. Analog solid-state amps can make fantastic sounds, but transistors are much better at staying linear until they clip, so the transitions to nonlinearity/distortion are abrupt and the crunchy tone is less “warm”.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by munificent on Friday March 31, 2023 @12:39PM (#35389634)
Rarity is one aspect that can summon that talismanic belief, but not the only one. There are lots of guitarists who have an abiding love of Stratocasters despite them being the Wonder Bread of guitars. What they have instead is a connection to history and other shamanic players: many famous guitarists have played strats, so even though your strat isn't the one Stevie Ray Vaughan played, it is sort of the same species in the underlying animistic magical thinking.

With tubes, I think would hold even if the tubes themselves became cheap as chips.

Time is another one: simply using the same piece of gear for years can imbue it with the power of ritual. Many writers use the same kind of paper and pen, and sit at the same sea, and the repetition alone is enough to summon the write mental state.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by criddell on Thursday March 30, 2023 @09:02PM (#35380982)
Your comment made me think of Jim Lill, a professional guitar player out of Nashville. He has a whole YouTube series where he tries to figure out where guitar tone comes from.

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCvAovXWLq8Q6VITKAB_Rjww

I found it pretty fascinating and watched them all in one night.

Wired wrote about him back in January.

https://www.wired.com/story/jim-lill-interview-youtube/

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by mikewarot on Friday March 31, 2023 @10:09AM (#35387394)
I figured his youtube series would show up here. Take my Upvote.

I'm now of the strong opinion that there is NO need for tubes any more, unless you've got old gear you want to keep working, and are willing to fork over the money for the tubes, and the power they waste as heat.

It makes me sad, I've been learning how to repair old tube ham gear (Collins, et al) from a friend who's been doing it since he was a kid in the 1950s. I've learned to have strong contempt for silver mica capacitors, and a reverence for the silence of modern non-dynamotor power supplies.

The strangest case was the RF amplifier that didn't work... because the ground lug the grid was connected to, wasn't a good ground.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by bb88 on Thursday March 30, 2023 @08:31PM (#35380773)
It's possible it's just pure nostalgia on my part I guess, but my experience is that 1950's to 70's music sounds better on a tube amp. I'm speculating that the music was mixed for tubes -- and they wanted the warm sound of the tube to come through. So the sound was mastered for the imprecise tube amps of the time.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by elseweather on Thursday March 30, 2023 @08:21PM (#35380698)
I dunno, man. At least with guitar amps the solid state ones _try_, but even expensive ones kinda suck compared to a tube amp
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by charrondev on Thursday March 30, 2023 @09:27PM (#35381199)
I haven’t been able to tell the difference for a while. I switched from a Marshal JTM45 to an Axe FX III w/ a big FR/FR cab and it sounds damn good and is a lot more flexible.

The other benefit to the new modellers (which for the past 5 or so years have been really high quality) is they are far more versatile and weigh a lot less.

Now the key is to invest in a good speaker cabinet, just like with a tube amp. Unfortunately there aren’t a ton of places where you can test drive them at least where I live. There’s another company that makes high quality modellers (Kemper) and they make a matching cab, but I’ve never seen one in person.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by kazinator on Thursday March 30, 2023 @09:57PM (#35381426)
Many solid state guitar amps are made by the tube amp companies, who have a vested interest in treating those models as entry-level stuff from which the real pro is supposed to upgrade to the inconvenient tube stuff.

The mistake with most solid state guitar amps is that they have similar wattages to tube amps. At stage volumes, it's easy for a measly 50 or 100W thing to go into clipping.

If you want solid-state guitar amplification, skip guitar amps and use a high wattage power amp used for sound reinforcement. E.g. something that puts out like 800W or more into a 4 Ohm load. This will have the headroom not to crap out when competing with the other guitarist's 100W head.

Not only that, but it will cost you less $$$ (particularly in the second hand market), and likely weigh less than your friend's 100W tube head.

Solid state guitar amps from guitar amp companies are snake oil, basically. They are not representative of what you can do with solid state.

Did you know Eddie Van Halen used solid state amps? One thing he did was to use a Marhsall tube amp head as a giant guitar pre-amp: capture the speaker output, reduced to line level, and re-amplify with a power amp, like a H&H V800.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by JKCalhoun on Thursday March 30, 2023 @11:06PM (#35381993)
Yeah, hard for me to wrap my head around why you would throw high speed digital circuitry, DSPs, and complex algorithms into a box to try and emulate the sound that a simple heated cathode in an evacuated glass tube can produce. $24 can still get you a decent 12AX7, I believe.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by JohnBooty on Thursday March 30, 2023 @08:50PM (#35380916)
Digital emulation also usually involves some milliseconds of lag, which may or may not matter for a specific use case.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by kazinator on Thursday March 30, 2023 @10:01PM (#35381462)
Every foot of air between your ear and a musical instrument (or its speaker cabinet, if applicable) adds about a 0.9 ms delay.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by Clamchop on Thursday March 30, 2023 @10:50PM (#35381868)
But we'd be talking about differential lag between various signals, which is worse.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by tiberious726 on Saturday April 01, 2023 @10:04AM (#35400401)
Even professional musicians can't detect less than 20ms of latency. You have plenty of budget
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by progrus on Thursday March 30, 2023 @09:11PM (#35381065)
You’d think, but you still need a megahertz-resolution DSP to emulate some signal chains closely, due to phasing and reflected harmonics:

https://youtu.be/GjtEIYXrqa8

Although to be fair, most of the time “liking the sound” is indeed just due to quirks of the analog implementations, like eq cramping. Those differences were emulated long ago, and producers often do reach for a “colored” emulation instead of the “ideal” digital filter.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by systems_glitch on Thursday March 30, 2023 @09:34PM (#35381256)
This. It's so simple to just use tubes if you want it to sound like tubes and don't need to carry it in your pocket.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by ilyt on Thursday March 30, 2023 @10:59PM (#35381941)
Funnily enough, same problem with trying to emulate CRT on LCDs
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by kazinator on Friday March 31, 2023 @12:17AM (#35382485)
In terms of audio, you only have to emulate what can actually be heard. Ears don't hear phase effects that require megahertz resolution.

(Ears hear only binaural phase effects. If the phase doesn't change when you turn your head, it is not relevant.)

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by progrus on Friday March 31, 2023 @12:38AM (#35382643)
Check out the video. Harmonics above Nyquist can still reflect back into the audible range.