News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by bb88 on Thursday March 30, 2023 @08:41PM (#35380853)
That's the thing, tubes used to be a dime a dozen. Just not anymore once transistors took over.

I'm not saying it's not nostalgia, it could very well be....

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by teddyh on Thursday March 30, 2023 @08:47PM (#35380891)
Exactly my point. If tubes still were, and always had been, a dime a dozen, then nobody would care about building (or buying) fancy expensive equipment with tubes! Tubes would be seen as obsolete junk.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by progrus on Thursday March 30, 2023 @09:26PM (#35381190)
Except for guitar amps - I think you underestimate how tribal and idiosyncratic the tone hounds can get.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by bb88 on Thursday March 30, 2023 @10:58PM (#35381939)
I'm don't underestimate it at all. There's a certain warm tone that tubes produce. It's gentle in a sense. A DAC can be harsh.

A naive view point is that the analog output of an analog device is going to be smooth.

The digital output will add noise on the stair step transitions.

I'm not saying this is the case in reality. I'm just saying, it's useful to think about when dealing with analog vs digital signals.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by progrus on Friday March 31, 2023 @12:08AM (#35382440)
“Warm tone” is just another name for gentler distortion, where non-linearities happen before the hard clip limit. It can be modeled pretty well digitally as long as the digital signal itself doesn’t clip, but I agree the real thing is best.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by kazinator on Friday March 31, 2023 @01:32AM (#35383014)
> There's a certain warm tone that tubes produce.

LOL, what? Tubes produce the distortion you hear in most branches of heavy metal, and iconic sounds throughout the whole spectrum of guitar rock.

In its raw form, it sounds awful; it has to be carefully shaped by filters, to remove high frequency "fizz" as well as annoying midrange frequencies to which the ear is sensitive. Even then, that filtered tone isn't something you could listen to via hi-fi equipment or record directly; it is amplified into certain kinds of cabinets with certain kinds of speakers. After all that, some people still hate it. :)

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by bb88 on Friday March 31, 2023 @02:05PM (#35390814)
You've clearly never listened to Fleetwood Mac on a tube stereo. It's not harsh. It's not perfect, but it is warm.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by progrus on Friday March 31, 2023 @05:19PM (#35393811)
I love my tube stereo. It would take an expensive solid-state amp to get close to its character, and it glows like a little fireplace :)

Side note - I have a hunch that the term “warm” was coined unconsciously. It’s not the actual sound; it’s the sound characteristic of warm glowing tubes, the sound of electricity fizzing through hot metal.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by kazinator on Friday March 31, 2023 @08:58PM (#35395875)
For a few hundred bucks, second hand, I can get a distortion-free sound-reinforcement amplifier, that can pump something like 600W per channel into a 4 Ohm load.

The equivalent all tube amp would require a line of credit from the bank, and would need to be on wheels.

To inject pleasing tube distortion into it, which I could turn on and off easily, I could put two inexpensive tube pedals in front of its inputs, like these:

https://www.amazon.com/TC-Electronic-Tube-Overdrive-Pilot/dp...

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by progrus on Saturday April 01, 2023 @12:13AM (#35397050)
My stereo is 15 watts (through the tubes, but still) - RIP your ears. Agreed that circuits in the preamp stage make the vast majority of the difference.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by Maursault on Saturday April 01, 2023 @11:17AM (#35400944)
> In its raw form, it sounds awful

Not really, and it isn't just warmth. The distortion is a unique pattern of simple and monotonically decaying series of harmonics, dominated by moderate levels of second harmonic. This is probably why most find it pleasing.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by kazinator on Saturday April 01, 2023 @01:39PM (#35402215)
* * *
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by ilyt on Thursday March 30, 2023 @11:08PM (#35382007)
Well, my amp is not in any of emulators so I have my excuse. But I kinda like single purpose of dedicated amplifier
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by progrus on Friday March 31, 2023 @12:13AM (#35382466)
I like analog hardware mostly because of the knobs, but there is also a nice spiritual connection to the sound energy.

Note that a solid-state amp can still be analog, transistors vs. tubes is distinct from analog vs. digital. Analog solid-state amps can make fantastic sounds, but transistors are much better at staying linear until they clip, so the transitions to nonlinearity/distortion are abrupt and the crunchy tone is less “warm”.