News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ralfn on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @02:24PM (#35361186)
While OpenAI is making an aggressive play on being the platform that eats all other platforms and is positioned to be a neutral party directly on the transaction with self service plugins (apps), Microsoft is squandering the opportunity the way they squander every opportunity.

Not realizing the game changed and playing yesterday's game in today's world.

The reason why people prefer these chats over clicking search results and finding the relevant information is that the search results themselves as well as the first page of links forces your brain to filter 99% commercial information that you don't care about. You don't want to subscribe to newsletters. You don't want notifications. You wish the site would just die rather that pollute the search results and push more to-the-point non profit sources further down.

And bringing ads in the game makes it impossible to make the platform play due to conflict of interests. You are either serving the user or the advertiser. Ads is the wrong business model for this, and OpenAI is positioned to be the winner here (against both Google and Bing) in a market larger than search and advertising.

I will definately keep paying for the answers to be in my interest and look forward to spending money directly through ChatGPT, much like I spent money on iOS, Android and Steams's platform today.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by sebzim4500 on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @02:27PM (#35361231)
>Microsoft is squandering the opportunity the way they squander every opportunity.

While I find ads as annoying as you do, I don't think they are squandering anything. The vast majority of internet users are fine looking at ads, or else they would use an adblocker.

The earlier they start playing with ads the earlier they can get an idea for how much revenue is on the table. Without this data how can they know what inference cost can be justified long term?

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ralfn on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @02:35PM (#35361329)
I think I'm failing to communicate my point here.

It's the wrong bussiness model. The power of these chats is integration. To have the chat suggest a travel plan -and- book all the underlying steps. To integrate 3rd party services on the fly based on your specific requirements while rolling it up in a single transaction.

That only works if the chat is representing my interests. Not just from a user perspective, but also from a regulatory and anti-trust perspective.

ChatGPT is positioned to be a platform of apps that are integrated. Bing is positioned to be a search engine, making money on ads.

The whole point is to never leave the chat. To have it all come to you on your terms.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by travisjungroth on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:13PM (#35361848)
But are you willing to pay a 5-30% premium? I think I am, but not everyone is.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ralfn on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:17PM (#35361919)
You are always paying that! Ads aren't free either. Neither is the marketing, the website, the app, etc. Getting your customers is expensive, serving them is as well.

But you wouldn't need any of those to compete in this market, any more than an Uber driver would need that.

All you need is to tell a chat about your API and focus on your actual product. It is a much more submissive relationship with the customer, but not a less profitable one.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by travisjungroth on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:50PM (#35362390)
It’s not the same. The mechanism has a serious effect on behavior. You’re saying you would give the chat a cut but it’s not yours to give. You pay $100 for something and you tell the vendor “I found this through chat. You get $70 and they get $30.” I don’t really see that working. If the vendor opts-in to this relationship and chat only shows people who pay then it’s called advertising or reselling. If they show everyone, then there’s little incentive to pay.

I’m not saying it’s unsolvable, but this getting a cut idea is not a solution.

I do see abandoning normal advertising and optimizing for chat being possible. It’s like SEO. Not sure it’s a sufficient model for the chat services.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ralfn on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:06PM (#35362681)
Let me phrase it differently.

When people give Apple Music a cut of their song sales, or when people give Apple a cut of their iOS in game spending, it is not called advertisement.

When you pay to tell someone who doesn't want to hear it about your product, thats advertisement.

The smart play here is the platform play. Clicking on a link and leaving the chat is the opposite of the intent and purpose of the chat. It makes sense for search because going to another website is the point. For search it is the correct business model, but for chat it is not. The chat is the platform. Leaving it breaks all the advantages.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ezst on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @05:22PM (#35363908)
> When people give Apple Music a cut of their song sales, or when people give Apple a cut of their iOS in game spending, it is not called advertisement.

That's assuming the song or app you purchase isn't the result of heavy promotion in the first place (in all ways possible, direct or indirect)…

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by travisjungroth on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @06:05PM (#35364477)
Apple Music is a reseller, distributor, whatever you want to call it. Their interests are generally more aligned with yours but not entirely.

This commission based system is not a silver bullet. It won’t be the optimal business model, the smart move, and be totally aligned with your interests. You can’t do that with commissions.

No one is going to trust it to help them decide between going on a vacation versus taking time off at home when it’s getting a cut of the plane tickets.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by sebzim4500 on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @06:59PM (#35365083)
A huge number of people are. You can very often get cheaper prices than Uber/Deliveroo if you order from the restaurant directly but that's less convenient so it doesn't happen (as much).
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by travisjungroth on Thursday March 30, 2023 @09:15AM (#35372181)
Good example!
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by bruce511 on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:36PM (#35362182)
I feel like you're almost advocating for a "Google where -only- ads are displayed.

>> At no point would I accept the product choices to be decided by who pays Microsoft more

But in all your examples you're absolutely going to get products which pay MS more. Pizza from the "highest rated place". Rated by whom? Against what criteria? Neutral professional Chriatmas Gift; I mean, paid product placement here we come.

>> But I'm perfectly fine with a neutral chat taking 5-30% cut on the transaction.

So, I sign up to "supply" (but not "advertise") my product for a 30% cut of the proceeds, but you don't expect the engine to push the higher-value ,higher-cut options? The engine should be neutral - regardless if the product is signed up or not? Regardless of the commission?

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ralfn on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:52PM (#35362420)
The engine wouldn't allow you to order something from a vendor that hasn't signed up.

Just like you can't pay for iOS app outside of their appstore.

Just like how Uber, DoorDash, Booking.com are neutral vendors. They don't care from which restaurant you order or which hotel you book. You can filter by customer rating. They make the same either way. Same for iOS or Android apps or Apple Music or Steam.

It is in their interest to keep it fair and have the users decide which of their suppliers wins.

I don't see a difference.

They especially don't care if I'm doing all my transactions though them anyway. The only thing that decides how much I spend, and therefore they make, would be my income.

Keep in mind OpenAI wouldn't be the only game in town, just the first, so if the same query gets a better or cheaper deal somewhere else they would lose me as a customer.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ipaddr on Thursday March 30, 2023 @12:38AM (#35368044)
You don't have to signup for Uber or Doordash they send orders your way regardless.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by lancesells on Thursday March 30, 2023 @07:58AM (#35371272)
DoorDash and Booking.com have paid placements. They are not neutral.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by manuelmoreale on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:29PM (#35363037)
> I don't want a link. I don't want to engage.

Isn’t this just another way to say that you don’t want the burden of choice, you just want someone else to chose for you? And in that case, capitalism will chose for you and you’ll definitely not get what you want or what is best for you but rather what has paid more to be promoted and sold to you.

It’s not better than clicking and buying the first result on Amazon.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by Kye on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @06:30PM (#35364786)
There isn't a place in modern commerce where it's like this. All the items at the grocery store, the product displays in the window, and so on are placed by who pays more or what gets the most profit. That's why they put candy and tabloids by the register. I would like if this ended up different, but what would make it so? Pay-to-play is the order of the day.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by nwienert on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @02:50PM (#35361539)
I’ve yet to see an example of *GPT be better at search than Google.

I’ve seen a few examples that breathlessly proclaimed that they literally saved lives or saved hours of time, but when I typed the 3 most obvious keywords from their input into Google, the first result always has the answer right there.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ralfn on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:06PM (#35361746)
I never have a search problem.

I need either information, a service or a product. Or information about a service or a product.

I never need a search, a website or an app. That's never the problem I'm trying to solve.

Search, websites and apps are the tools I have to use (currently) to solve my problems. In the process I have to:

- deal with the fact that the interest of the makers of the app or website do not align with mine

- deal with privacy invasions/ads/notifications

- deal with things being phrased disingenuously

- deal with apps needing to update, website being broken/bandwidth wasted

And most importantly, unless two vendors implemented an integration together, I have to integrate their services myself!

I never want to leave the chat. I want to do all my transactions from the chat. All of them. On my terms. With my prompts.

Whoever facilitates that can take a 5-30% cut on all my online transactions.

Examples:

- book me a highly rated hotel in Berlin around 100 euro p/n most suitable for a staycation for next week Monday to Friday. Make a reservation near that hotel for the highest rated traditional German cuisine restaurant with a price per plate of 20-30 euro

- send every contact ive emailed with from my work email in the last year a Christmas card with a funny but professional pun about the invention of the steam engine. Send it to their work address.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by rchaud on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:37PM (#35362195)
> - book me a highly rated hotel in Berlin around 100 euro p/n most suitable for a staycation for next week Monday to Friday. Make a reservation near that hotel for the highest rated traditional German cuisine restaurant with a price per plate of 20-30 euro

I imagine this will go about as well as if you chose to purchase an apartment purely on the basis of the real estate agency's description.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ralfn on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:46PM (#35362333)
This is what I do now on booking.com. If you have a smarter strategy let me know. But whatever the strategy is: it can be automated.

I also spent a lot more time on the choice where I live than the hotel in going to stay at for a week. Weird.

And although ChatGPT currently doesn't have up to date information about hotels or the ability to book it (a simple booking.com plugin would enable that though), it is smart enough to either pick a hotel with remote working facilities or consider one with coworking spaces nearby.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by rchaud on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:54PM (#35362466)
I don't know if it's a smarter strategy, but you can send a travel agency your list of requirements and they'll send you back a quote. My parents' generation are probably the only people that still use agencies, but it works for them.

It takes longer than a search query, but they don't want the hassle of coordinating logistics, and have some peace of mind that they're getting what they asked for.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ralfn on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:09PM (#35362723)
So what's the bussiness model of the travel agency?

- they take a cut

- they are neutral because they want repeat bussiness

- they are personalised around your requirements

- they take care of the little details

It's exactly what I'm describing here, except automated. Because at heart their work is analyst work and thats exactly what you can automate with a LLM

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ezst on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @05:04PM (#35363610)
What makes you think those results would be neural, and not sponsored/SEOed the same way everything is these days? What makes you think the machine works for you and not the advertisers? Also, to this day, LLMs/ANNs are not capable of explaining their outcome, and you won't argue/reason with them. That's a pretty big difference if you ask me.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ralfn on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @05:46PM (#35364220)
>What makes you think those results would be neural, and not sponsored/SEOed the same way everything is these days?

Because it would be the less profitable bussiness.

>Also, to this day, LLMs/ANNs are not capable of explaining their outcome, and you won't argue/reason with them

How would I be able to tell that your response is human and not a LLM?

I definately can argue within a chat thread. They can also provide a plausible sounding explanation.

We know due to the nature of the technology that that explanation (sounding rational, deductive) isn't the truth.

We are just not all ready to accept all the same shortcomings also apply to humans.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by nico on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @06:33PM (#35364821)
Very well said. Thank you for the great thread.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by nwienert on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @11:42PM (#35367642)
> Because it would be the less profitable bussiness.

How is this different from Google?

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ezst on Thursday March 30, 2023 @04:56PM (#35378730)
>> What makes you think those results would be neural, and not sponsored/SEOed the same way everything is these days?

> Because it would be the less profitable bussiness.

How so? Considering that almost everything on the web right now runs on ad revenue, why would they pass on the opportunity to cash on that if they do no worse than the rest? Especially considering how lucrative those referrals might be, with our lack of preparedness countering those with traditional ad blocking techniques and being more susceptible due to inexperience.

> We are just not all ready to accept all the same shortcomings also apply to humans.

Because they do not. If you hire a human to do a job for you, you are bound by a contract (and protections, and recourses and enforcement). In the end you will be able to know whether you got robbed into a referral scheme and that's bad for business. With this kind of AI, the result is all you get (technically there is no way to explain it), which gives unfair deniability. Regulators might end up ruling whole classes of algorithms as unfit for purpose/deceptive, and I would personally applaud that. We are just at the beginning of all that and we should focus on developing the technology so it keeps working for us reliably, and not against us or under undetermined circumstances.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by rchaud on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @05:07PM (#35363672)
> except automated.

The devil is always in the details. A travel agency builds contacts with airlines, hotels, tour groups etc, so they can have a backup option available if your first preference is not. That requires humans.

An AI system that is simply browsing through the same websites a human would is going to come up with a lot of "no" responses for specific booking requests, or will simply quote higher prices once the booking websites figure out how to detect them.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ralfn on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @05:52PM (#35364289)
I'm not suggesting OpenAI is maintaining those contacts. I'm suggesting booking.com will upload an API integration into the ChatGPT platform. Just like they uploaded an app into the AppStore.

Perhaps they will try to up the price on this platform compared to others. But only until AirBnB comes to compete on this platform too (and uploads their API integration)

It's a platform game.

There was a time when Google tried to index everything and afterwards came a time when everything tried to be indexed by Google. Once you are the default, they have to be there and they will have to compete with others there.

And as long as the chat protects users from losing control over their intent, that's where the users will be and that's where you will need to be offering your products to be viable. Obviously at that point the regulators come knocking..

Assuming there would only be one player. There won't be, but for now only OpenAI is actually aware of the opportunity and Microsoft doesn't even seem to understand it's a platform game now and not an ad game.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by electrondood on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:07PM (#35362693)
I would add: "Open an incognito window because I don't feel like seeing targeted ads for the random crap I'm curious about."
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by mejutoco on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:00PM (#35361653)
The other day I asked chatgpt about a Polish supermarket with a logo in a certain color and an animal in it. I could not remember the name. We continued our conversation until it was clear I was misremembering some things (I thought the name started with x letter, and that was false). Eventually chatgpt suggested the correct one.

The search was something like: "Polish supermarket with red and white logo and a bird in the logo, that begins with the letter K".

The first google result to wikipedia has it, to be fair, but without this back and forth idk if I would have found it.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by tapland on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:28PM (#35362068)
It’s extremely wild to see this obfuscated with the wrong colors, animal and name, when it’s just a common grocery store chain in Poland.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by rchaud on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:39PM (#35362233)
Ah, but ChatGPT is trained mostly on English materials.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by mejutoco on Thursday March 30, 2023 @09:33AM (#35372447)
That is literally what I remembered about the supermarket, so that is what I searched. It is a supermarket in Poland, not a Polish one I believe.

P.S. It was not Biedronka! it was Auchan, and I thought Auchan started with K, because of the bird.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by roberttod on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:27PM (#35362057)
I think you need to try it out, with GPT4, because it is so obviously much better than Google. Simple queries are fine with Google, not much difference, but especially for things like coding problems (where you can e.g. specify the environment you are running in) it has always responded with the correct answer the first time. It's already saving me over an hour a day, and as far as I understand there is much more things it can do I am not using.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by nwienert on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:14PM (#35362792)
I'm genuinely asking for a good example here. I've tried a bunch and every time I find Google about 100x faster. I think GPT is good for some things, but search and recommendations it's like going back in time.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ralfn on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:40PM (#35363250)
Here are some of my questions of today:

> We need to travel by train from Rome to Montpellier, but it is too many stops to do at once. So we would like to stay somewhere for a day in between Rome and Montpellier. What are our options? It needs to be safe, not adding a lot of extra travel time and suitable for a workathon

It returns with four options, approximate travel times and advantages and disadvantages. It understood coworking cafes or bussiness hotels would be a requirement.

> What are all the places an SSL certificate could be cached when calling an API from a Jupiter notebook?

It mentioned some obvious things such OS/browser/network-device, but also that a particular python package exists that is doing this at the application level as well, but only in memory and that a restart of the Jupiter kernel would resolve that.

Now, I'm curious with what kind of keywords I could get meaningful output from Google for these two examples.

What i suspect is happening is that you are micro managing your chat as if it's search. Picking keywords rather than just telling it the problem you are actually trying to solve. Splitting up your problem in sub problems and then trying to find each peace of information manually and combining it yourself to form a conclusion.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by rstuart4133 on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @10:48PM (#35367255)
> It returns with four options, approximate travel times and advantages and disadvantages.

This trust in it's response reminds me early days of the internet. That would be the time when the people who created it were just exploring what the technology could do. It was a wonderful time. People posted amazing HOWTO's to Usenet that were chock full of useful information, you only received email from like minded friends, and almost nothing was censored and most of it was useful. It looked like the future was bright.

But then it grew so big you could not recognise most of the sources, and into that void stepped content aggregators like MySpace and Facebook I refuse to go near, and Alta Vista started ranking stuff by how much they were paid. Usenet was overrun by lies from spammers as was my inbox. And now if I don't run an ad-blocker, I find it difficult to differentiate Google's search results from the ads at the top, and near bloody impossible on sites like Amazon, and GMail / Hotmail mines my personal correspondence for ways to manipulate me.

And so it will be with those concise AI responses. Except you have absolutely no way to cross verify - you only get what a machine that will likely be far smarted than any of us wants you to know, in order to maximise it's profit.

Thank you, but I'll pass.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by iudqnolq on Thursday March 30, 2023 @02:53AM (#35369019)
Every time I take a careful look at someone's handpicked example of GPT getting it right there's at least one serious mistake.

> Florence, Italy: Florence is a beautiful city with a rich history and culture. It is only a 90-minute train ride from Rome, making it a convenient stopover point. Florence also has plenty of cafes, co-working spaces, and other amenities that are conducive to a workathon.

Mistake: The purpose is to split up a long journey. Florence would split it into a 1.5h day and a 10.5h day.

> Marseille, France: Marseille is a bustling port city on the Mediterranean coast of France. It is about a 3.5-hour train ride from Rome and has a vibrant cultural scene and a variety of co-working spaces and cafes. You could spend the day exploring the city's many museums, parks, and markets.

Mistake: Factually wrong about the travel time, per Google maps GPT is off by a factor of 3.

Mistake: The purpose is to split up a long journey. Marseille would split it into a 10.5h day and a 2h day.

Mistake: Forgot about the workathon requirement

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by vidarh on Thursday March 30, 2023 @04:17AM (#35369600)
W/GPT4 for me it suggests Rome->Genoa, stay, then Genoa-> either Nice or Marseille, and then on to Montpellier.

GPT3.5 suggested a list of Florence, Nice, Genoa and Marseille. When I asked it for a breakdown of the travel times, it got them pretty close ("Can you give me rough travel times for each of these options?") given the large variations in travel time depending on specific timing and transfers for several of these.

When I then asked it for somewhere closer to the midway point, it didn't come through (it suggested Pisa, which is about as bad as Florence), Turin, which is an alternative to Genoa, but doesn't fix the imbalance, or Lyon which is about as bad as the Pisa option but in the opposite direction (fast train to Montpellier), but the options also aren't in aggregate much worse.

The problem here is that there aren't as far as I can tell any very balanced options. You can try to do e.g. Ventimiglia or Sanremo (which GPT4 gave when I pressed it on splitting it more evenly), which will give you a more evenly distributed travel time, but because the overall travel time will be longer they're not at all obvious options.

You also seems to focus on catching it out rather than getting a result. If you want precision from the first query, then you need to give far more precise questions.

You need to treat it as a conversation, not a brief to be answered with a report. If you insist on treating it as a brief you will not get good results out of it. Your loss, in that case.

For cases where a simple lookup will work, it's a waste. Just use Google. For cases where there is in fact not a single perfect option, and where you need to weigh pro and con, it works well with the caveat that you do indeed need to be careful and check specifics. The same way I'd check specifics if I had a conversation about this with a friend.

With plugins, so it can verify precise details we can expect a significant leap in capability here.

But even for now, the answers I got to this were ones I was happy with, and another reason for me to use it more.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by iudqnolq on Thursday March 30, 2023 @05:57AM (#35370297)
I plugged that into whatever chat.openai.com is.

> You also seems to focus on catching it out rather than getting a result.

Nope. I have nothing against GPT. I find Copilot useful enough to pay for. I'm just sick and tired of people promoting it with obviously wrong examples.

The story of Clever Hans shows that humans are very good at convincing themselves something is smart when really they're subconsciously feeding it answers. So I do think validating GPT requires thinking a little adversarially rather than aiming to help it.

> The problem here is that there aren't as far as I can tell any very balanced options

Then that's exactly what GPT should have said here.

> For cases where there is in fact not a single perfect option, and where you need to weigh pro and con, it works well with the caveat that you do indeed need to be careful and check specifics. The same way I'd check specifics if I had a conversation about this with a friend.

If someone had a track record of doing rote work decently but messing up anything requiring critical thinking then I'd entrust them only with work appropriate to their skillset until they proved otherwise. That's exactly what I'm doing with GPT: I use it to do my busywork, but I'm not asking it for anything like travel advice until it gets quite a bit better.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by vidarh on Thursday March 30, 2023 @09:33AM (#35372446)
I didn't suggest you have anything against GPT, but that the way you're interacting with it is counterproductive if you want it to be useful to you like the person you first replied to rather than finding flaws in it. It's easy to find flaws in it. E.g. I just had a lengthy "argument" with it about the right directions between two places in Nice out of morbid curiosity of why it got the first question so wildly wrong (conclusion: It knows of lots of roads. It does not yet know how most of them are connected, which neighbourhoods they are in, which direction they go, or how to route; this should be unsurprising as it's unlikely to be in its training data; and that's fine, just don't use it for that).

In the example you picked apart, it got it close enough to be useful even though the answers have plenty of issues.

> The story of Clever Hans shows that humans are very good at convincing themselves something is smart when really they're subconsciously feeding it answers. So I do think validating GPT requires thinking a little adversarially rather than aiming to help it.

If the goal was to validate GPT, sure. But the goal above was not to validate GPT. The discussion was over whether it could be useful. That doesn't require "validating it". It just needs a rough understanding that is more right than wrong with respect to which types of queries are productive in producing results that saves us time without doing harm.

Yes, that means there are lots of applications where it's not suitable. That's fine.

> Then that's exactly what GPT should have said here.

I disagree. The question explicitly did not ask for that. It said it was too far to travel in one go, without explaining what the longest number of hours acceptable to travel in one day was. That a human might implicitly interpret it that way based on personal preferences might well be the case. But responding that there were no evenly split options would indicate a failure to carefully read the question. Explaining why the options did not split it evenly would be good (but GPT really would not be up to the job in this case).

Note that GPT still gets this plenty wrong, so I'm not suggesting it's up to scratch in this area.

Adding a constraint of no more than 8 hours per day, GPT3.5turbo (free ChatGPT) messes up (still suggests Florence, and gives the nonsensical suggestion of Avignon). GPT4 (paid ChatGPT only) suggests Genoa and Nice.

Lowering the threshold to 6 hours (which AFAIK is not possible), GPT3.5turbo gives the same broken set of options. GPT4 still suggests Genoa and Nice, wrongly claiming no more than 6 hours per day, so that is definitely a problem. In this case it should have said there's no way of doing that.

Trying to be more explicit about this (" We want to travel no more than 6 hours from Rome to the stopover, and no more than 6 hours from the stopover to Montpellier") does not help, so this is indeed a strong indicator that it struggles with this particular type of constraint and you shouldn't trust it on this subject other than to give ideas.

When thinking of what would make it get this right, it's not surprising: There likely aren't that many travel descriptions containing distances and travel times in its training data, and it can't read maps yet.

> If someone had a track record of doing rote work decently but messing up anything requiring critical thinking then I'd entrust them only with work appropriate to their skillset until they proved otherwise. That's exactly what I'm doing with GPT: I use it to do my busywork, but I'm not asking it for anything like travel advice until it gets quite a bit better.

That's exactly what I'm suggesting. Maybe with the extension that asking it "tell me how to do X" questions often works well, and that sometimes even questions where you know it'll mess up the details will give you enough ideas to go on. E.g. in this case, at least GPT4 gives reasonable options even though the travel times are messed up (when the plugins are opened up, hopefully this will improve significantly). That might not matter for a region you know, but for a region you don't, getting a list of cities to plug into route planners might still be worthwhile as long as they're more right than wrong.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by iudqnolq on Thursday March 30, 2023 @10:04AM (#35372879)
> but that the way you're interacting with it is counterproductive if you want it to be useful to you like the person you first replied to rather than finding flaws in it

I can't speak to the answer the person I replied to got, because they didn't post it. If they got the answer I got asking the same question the answer they got wouldn't have been useful to them.

It's only counterproductive if I'm wrong. If I'm right that it's not yet useful for this sort of thing I'd only waste my time giving it more chances.

> in this case, at least GPT4 gives reasonable options even though the travel times are messed up

The reasonability of the options fundamentally depended on specific facts in this case. Mixing up a 3 hour train ride and a 12 hour train ride ruined the answer. So the answer I got from ChatGPT was fundamentally broken.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by stravant on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:37PM (#35362200)
Recipes.

Oh my god, have you tried to search for a recipe before? Pages and pages and pages of bloated garbage. I just want ingredients and steps goddamnit.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by rchaud on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:00PM (#35362566)
Recipe websites got the point, back when Google AdSense used to pay out properly. Google slashed those payouts to the bone, which led to recipe sites lengthening their web pages with paragraphs, so they could fit in more ads to compensate for the reduction in payouts.

Something similar will happen here. Today, recipes on Chatgpt are to the point. Tomorrow, they might start adding affiliate links to the ingredients. A year from now, the experience won't be any better than what you currently have on Google.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by bleep_bloop on Thursday March 30, 2023 @05:08AM (#35369961)
>Something similar will happen here. Today, recipes on Chatgpt are to the point. Tomorrow, they might start adding affiliate links to the ingredients. A year from now, the experience won't be any better than what you currently have on Google.

Correct me if I've misinterpreted your comment but it appears you're suggesting that rather than use something that is a superior product in more than one factor, you're advocating for using a product that is terrible in many factors just because... The superior product might get worse... Eventually...

Blind loyalty to a corporation no matter how terrible they make my experience and abuse my trust isn't really something I'm desperate to cling on to. There is a thirst for ChatGPT for a reason. Nothing is stopping OpenAI from pulling all the same anti-consumer behaviour that Google pulls today, but then the field is wide open for someone to come along and pull a ChatGPT on them, and the cycle continues.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by rchaud on Thursday March 30, 2023 @09:58AM (#35372808)
I'm not advocating for Google at all, they have written the book on how to ruin a good thing with greed. OpenAI will use the same playbook, and possibly more rapidly than Google did.

If anything, I'm advocating for a perspective on technology that goes beyond dunking on incumbents because the newer, sleeker thing has arrived. Look at the economics of this industry and the motives of the market entrants; the new thing is only a donut or two or away from turning into the same bloated mess as those it sought to replace.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by vidarh on Thursday March 30, 2023 @06:22AM (#35370485)
So we'll run our own models to filter the interactions with the corporate models.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by dougfelt on Thursday March 30, 2023 @12:16AM (#35367903)
Oh man so much this.

We have a brief window where ChatGPT will be clean and useful, before it gets loaded down with ads and bloat. Might as well use it while we can.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by NoZebra120vClip on Thursday March 30, 2023 @05:23AM (#35370070)
I have enjoyed WikiHow, which is ad-supported, but eschews all the starry-eyed tales of when I was a wee lass in rural Croatia, and lets you learn how to cook lamb steaks with no-nonsense ingredients, steps, and expert tips. (Read all the way to the end).

https://www.wikihow.com/Cook-Lamb-Steaks

They've got the basics, so I'd say it's best for novice chefs who want to fix a basic meal. There aren't a lot of gourmet variations or brand-name shills there.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by vidarh on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:09PM (#35361794)
Ask for something more specific and bespoke.

I've e.g. had it produce the HTML, CSS and basic web app for a site I was putting together. Custom, with my content and the layout and design I wanted. None of it was stuff I couldn't do myself from scratch without even a Google search, but it wrote out an hour or two's worth of boilerplate in a few minutes of prompting.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by kernal on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:38PM (#35362222)
>I’ve yet to see an example of *GPT be better at search than Google.

Until ChatGPT has the ability to index at the scale of Google it never will be.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by lemoncookiechip on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @05:17PM (#35363817)
I've had the complete opposite experience. Hallucinations aside (more common with bad prompts or niche/specific topics), ChatGPT 3.5 has been perfect for searching anything that isn't past the model's cut-off date, as well as summurizing long articles I don't have the time or patience to read.

Google on the other hand, is at a point where even Yandex of all search engines is starting to give better results, especially when it comes to image searching and content Google doesn't like as much like piracy. Google used to be amazing back in the day, nowadays I find myself having to specify REDDIT (or a specific forum) on my searches because the top results without it are hardly ever good.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by andrewljohnson on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @05:40PM (#35364137)
It’s faster for coding.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by shakow on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @07:22PM (#35365352)
I can give you my trivial experience from a couple of days ago:

Google:

> latex macro behaves differently math mode normal mode

ChatGPT:

> How can I make a LaTeX macro behaves differently in math mode and normal mode?

Google failed, ChatGPT succeeded instantly.

Now that's but a single data point, but I found it cute.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by d136o on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @02:54PM (#35361569)
I’m far from an expert (just an engineer who likes to download and try out demos) but one dark view of the alignment chatter is that it’s really about whether can you can get this new big artificial brain to push any user in the direction of BigCorp goal, while letting the users think that it’s answering their questions etc.

I’d love to think that we can have AI agents working locally (with privacy) in alignment with our personal goals, but that seems like one of those things that won’t happen. (Will apple come through in terms of enabling local+decentralized inference/training?)

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ralfn on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:16PM (#35361898)
It's in the interest of the semi conductor industry for LLM to become a commodity, so it will.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by seydor on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:05PM (#35361738)
That's how google started as well. Ads is a tried and true model and is not going anyway anytime. People won't pay for bing chat search
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ralfn on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:46PM (#35363335)
The point is not to leave the chat.

If you could buy the car from the chat, thats the correct bussiness model.

Ads were the correct business model for search, where the goal is to find and click on a relevant link.. but that's the exact opposite of a chat. Clicking a link means the chat failed its purpose.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by blibble on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:06PM (#35362671)
I think this sums up modern microsoft perfectly actually

no matter the potential future value of the product, they can't resist putting shitty ads into it to make a quick buck today

imagine what windows is going to look like in a few years time

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by goldfeld on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:19PM (#35362863)
A floundering corporation has the extractivist mentality. Windows is on its way out so the suits pump it full of cheap bait to catch all the dollars they can, then they move on to other products naturally. It has been a rotten thing for a while, since the executives and investors don't really care about that brand, only about their own portfolios.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by robertlagrant on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:23PM (#35362930)
Flaundering? I think Microsoft is a perfectly cromulent company.

(Bah! Keeping it.)

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by goldfeld on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:28PM (#35363017)
Haha, I fire first but always double-check later the things that on second thought look strange. TIL English is still hard for me after over 25 years, and I used to think I was a more careful speller than native speakers who often type by the memory of words' sounds, and I do not. It can always publicly bite you in the tushy.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by robertlagrant on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @06:28PM (#35364751)
I think it's a great word! Wonderful to be there for its genesis.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by goldfeld on Thursday March 30, 2023 @11:07AM (#35373795)
Sorry about the late reply I was up to my neck in money flaundering activities.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by lotsofpulp on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:28PM (#35363024)
I wish my business was floundering like Microsoft.

https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/MSFT/microsoft/net...

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by goldfeld on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:34PM (#35363135)
A tech company can be on unstable ground morally (well I guess all are on principle), or more modernly, in terms of mindshare. Financials are not always the root of all that matters.
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by MuffinFlavored on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:59PM (#35363520)
> Microsoft is squandering the opportunity the way they squander every opportunity.

https://www.google.com/search?q=microsfot+market+cap

$2.09t

"squander opportunity"

I agree with you though. I do not have a single Microsoft product in my house. No Windows, no Xbox, etc.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by scrollaway on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @07:11PM (#35365242)
You don’t get GP’s point and you’re talking about something completely different.

The game has changed. It doesn’t mean their existing customer base has suddenly vanished and threw their Xboxes away.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by hankchinaski on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @05:53PM (#35364308)
Either the monetization is done with ads or with paid subscriptions. They chose to be in the former category. And I personally don’t mind clicking ads for the sake of not paying a premium. The two models can coexist
Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by ralfn on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @06:40PM (#35364889)
The third model is the platform model and thats the only one that makes sense here.

An ad would send you to another site. The point of the chat is so you don't have to go to all the shitty sites and deal with all the marketing speak.

So the options are either:

- subscription, as they do now (ala Netflix, Officd365)

- free, with ads having the profit maximalisation be the exact opposite of the main selling point (ala Google, Bing, Facebook)

- platform, free for the user, but taking a cut from vendors that would integrate (ala iOS, Android, Steam, Amazon, Salesforce)

In other words, rather than being an ad, it could offer to buy the car directly from the chat.

The later is the most profitable solution and also ensure the interests of the user and the platform align. Platforms don't care which product you buy through them, they take the same cut, and would rather make you as happy as possible so you don't go to the competitor.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by majormajor on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @06:13PM (#35364582)
It's not clear to me that ChatGPT will realistically be able to avoid some variant of either SEO or pay-to-play just like search.

If you've got a dozen plugins for getting food delivered, how does one get picked?

If it's the user picking, they're at risk of the user cutting out the middleman, especially if the novelty of "tell the robot to pick an item" wears off and people want to actually look at menus.

If it's something behind the scenes (either the model or some other software OpenAI writes) then that's a big big big temptation for pay-to-play a la app stores including direct advertising "promotional placement" like you see in mobile app stores. And even if it's not pay-to-play, once people start figuring out what makes plugins more or less likely to be triggered, it's SEO season.

Nobody else has managed the art of "make it purely in the user's interest" with their marketplaces; it ends with one or both of either temptation to play both sides OR gamification/optimization/deception from the vendors behind the scenes.

Re:Bing Chat now has Ads by acchow on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @06:30PM (#35364780)
What happens when the SEO-equivalent cottage industry for LLMs appears? Will trainings models be so easy?