Space itself is expanding.
where does red shift come from if things aren't moving apart?
Thus, our vantage point is fixed.
I'd imagine one of the techniques used is to look for time-varying influences in the data, which implies there are bodies orbiting each other. If there aren't any, then you can look at the spectroscopic signature of the light and see if it makes sense for a black hole. I'd imagine black holes do nothing to refracted light, but dark bodies would result in slightly blueshifted light as 'newer' light reflects off its surface. This might be what PyAutoLens does (as well as fitting the shape of distortions and such)
This finding seems to have a highly complex relationship to the data, and to not have been replicated anywhere yet. This is the perfect place to add a "something that looks like" before the "galaxy sized black hole".
But well, this is a criticism of journalism anyway, not of astronomy.
the confusion here is because if this formed in 13 billion years, our understanding of the formation of the universe is very flawed, and generally, scientists both do and do not like it when stuff like this is proven wrong with new evidence.
they like it because discovery and increased understanding is the whole reason they became scientists in a lot of cases.
they don't like it because if this is wrong, what else is wrong, and what does that mean for everything else we think we know? what gets upended because of this?
This kind of alignment happens all the time. Stars that line up perfectly but are separated by light years, galaxies that line up perfectly etc.
techwiz137 pointed out[3] an existing known black hole, TON618, is 66 billion solar masses[4]. So the new find is large but not the largest ever found.
[1]https://www.durham.ac.uk/news-events/latest-news/2023/03/lig... [2] https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15514 [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35360780 [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TON_618
For example, if we are measuring how light bends - how do we know there aren't many hidden (i.e. not large or bright enough to be noticed from earth) objects causing additional distortion and therefore throwing off our measurements? Do we also observe it over time to get more confidence, or have some other cross-checks that give us more certainty?
Either way, every once in a while I find it wild just how much we can deduce about the universe from our tiny fixed vantage point.