News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:$39 Cooler Master case turns your old Framework Laptop pa... by senttoschool on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @12:24AM (#35352537)
>Upgrading is cheaper than a whole new system. This saves consumers money. Modern laptops increasingly solder parts down, making upgrades nigh-impossible (I've tried multiple times).

A MacBook Air can easily last 5 years+. I've had mine for 10 years. Will the average Framework laptop last as long as the average MacBook?

>Countering planned obsolence and expensive repair costs associated with modern products.

Macbooks receive updates for 5+ years usually. Even after that, it's perfectly usable. I highly doubt that the hardware inside Framework will be supported for as long as Macbooks.

>Enabling upcycling, repurposing, and reducing ewaste. There are a fair number of environmentally conscious people in tech and tech-adjacent industries.

Upgrading parts cause e-waste, especially if the chips aren't generally as good as Apple Silicon so you have to upgrade more often. If you trade in or recycle your laptop with Apple, they should be able to do a better job of recycling than your average Framework user.

To me, the main selling point of Framework is that geeks can upgrade the CPU/GPU every year or once a year because they always want the fastest. The fact that Framework markets this as "environmentally friendly" is just a way to make them feel better about constantly upgrading. You can't convince me that the average Framework laptop is more environmentally friendly than a Macbook Air over its lifetime.

Re:$39 Cooler Master case turns your old Framework Laptop pa... by kstenerud on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @12:35AM (#35352639)
> A MacBook Air can easily last 5 years+. I've had mine for 10 years. Will the average Framework laptop last as long as the average MacBook?

I don't see why not. My old thinkpad is still perfectly usable 8 years after I bought it (used, already 5 years old). All I had to do was put more RAM in it and replace the hard drive with an SSD. The display is starting to go, although I could get a replacement for $40. I also replaced the battery awhile back for less than $100. This thing will easily last another 5 years, probably more (after which I'll probably repurpose it as a pi-hole or print server or something).

> Macbooks receive updates for 5+ years usually. Even after that, it's perfectly usable. I highly doubt that the hardware inside Framework will be supported for as long as Macbooks.

It's running Linux, so, yeah it absolutely will. I can still get the latest and greatest Linux updates for my 13 year old laptop. Windows support for it is also still strong. Meanwhile my 2011 MBP is long since no longer updatable.

> Upgrading parts cause e-waste, especially if the chips aren't generally as good as Apple Silicon so you have to upgrade more often. If you trade in or recycle your laptop with Apple, they should be able to do a better job of recycling than your average Framework user.

Now this is just getting downright silly.

> To me, the main selling point of Framework is that geeks can upgrade the CPU/GPU every year or once a year because they always want the fastest. The fact that Framework markets this as "environmentally friendly" is just a way to make them feel better about constantly upgrading. You can't convince me that the average Framework laptop is more environmentally friendly than a Macbook Air over its lifetime.

And, of course, finishing off with a final strawman flourish.

Re:$39 Cooler Master case turns your old Framework Laptop pa... by schoen on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @12:48AM (#35352747)
> It's running Linux, so, yeah it absolutely will. I can still get the latest and greatest Linux updates for my 13 year old laptop.

For example, Linux explicitly supported 386 CPUs until 2012 (its successor CPU came out in 1989) and is only discontinuing support for the 486 CPU now (its successor CPU came out in 1993).

https://www.tomshardware.com/news/linux-removes-486-cpu-supp...

I'm running some 20-year-old Dell desktops with Linux, and they still run a mainstream present-day distribution and get software updates.

Re:$39 Cooler Master case turns your old Framework Laptop pa... by kstenerud on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @12:59AM (#35352820)
This really is the kicker. CPUs over the past 20 years have gone from 2.4GHz to 5.6GHz clock speeds + bigger cache size and more cores. For most common tasks you're not going to see much difference between a 2-core and an 8-core CPU.

There just isn't much need for CPU advancements in today's average workloads (browsing, word processing, spreadsheets). Any further advancements (such as AI) will happen in the GPU (or whatever they're going to call the accelerator cards now that they're multi-purpose), while the CPU fight switches over to energy efficiency.

Re:$39 Cooler Master case turns your old Framework Laptop pa... by sonzohan on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @01:23AM (#35352993)
> You can't convince me that the average Framework laptop is more environmentally friendly than a Macbook Air over its lifetime.

How do I put more RAM in my 8GB Macbook Air?

Re:$39 Cooler Master case turns your old Framework Laptop pa... by rhn_mk1 on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @03:09AM (#35353695)
*without replacing the entire thing
Re:$39 Cooler Master case turns your old Framework Laptop pa... by lostlogin on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:25AM (#35354190)
If you’re planning on keeping it a long time, surely you’d get more RAM at purchase time?

Minimum ram is never going to be good in 5-10 years.

Re:$39 Cooler Master case turns your old Framework Laptop pa... by SXX on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:50AM (#35354370)
It's exactly what I usually doing.

ThinkPad X220i with 16GB RAM in 2011.

Macbook Air M1 with 16GB RAM in 2020.

In both cases it was the most RAM I could get.

Re:$39 Cooler Master case turns your old Framework Laptop pa... by rhn_mk1 on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @05:31AM (#35354687)
If you have enough money up front, or foresight, then yes. Even if that's the case in the minority of cases, that's enough to make it less environmetally friendly that being able to upgrade.
Re:$39 Cooler Master case turns your old Framework Laptop pa... by chpatrick on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @06:32AM (#35355151)
Some people can't afford that, and Apple sells storage and RAM at extortionate prices.

Maybe you start out thinking you just need to do your taxes but then get a job in video editing. People want to upgrade all the time and it's really bad that you have to toss out the whole computer to do it.

Re:$39 Cooler Master case turns your old Framework Laptop pa... by sonzohan on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @07:32AM (#35355633)
You usually have to customize the order on Apple's website to do this, which means your laptop could take a few weeks to arrive.

There's also other circumstances where this isn't an option. When I worked at a public university (UC system) that had an agreement with Apple, we could only purchase hardware that was in the University bookstore.

The University bookstore only stocked base models. Even the top-of-the-line 15" Macbook Pros didn't have a 16GB option once the RAM started being soldered down.

Re:$39 Cooler Master case turns your old Framework Laptop pa... by windowsrookie on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @08:04AM (#35355923)
My friend was using his 8 year old MacBook Air with 4GB RAM until just last year when it stopped turning on. Browsing the web, watching YouTube, checking emails all worked just fine with 4GB of RAM.

Microsoft sells the surface laptop 2 with 4GB of non-upgradeable RAM today in 2023.

The 8GB of base RAM in the MacBook Airs will absolutely be fine for most people for the next 5-10 years. If you are tech savvy enough to even know what RAM is, then yes, I would recommend upgrading to at least 16GB because you are likely doing more than just browsing the web.

Re:$39 Cooler Master case turns your old Framework Laptop pa... by guywithahat on Friday March 31, 2023 @08:49AM (#35386316)
You're being down voted but I think you're 100% right. Most processing intense tasks are done on the GPU nowadays anyways, so even if someone truly needed the fastest machine to train their neural networks (which frankly still wouldn't justify a new motherboard every year) they couldn't use a framework laptop anyways because it only has a CPU