The opinion that it should be addressed or not? Because there's no feasible route to addressing it that doesn't involve reducing fossil emissions.
You can fly an airplane on non-fossil fuels.
As the original commenter also said: He'd rather focus on earning money than saving a bit. Maybe that opinion translates to the climate debate?
Maybe he wants to produce large amounts of energy with limited externalities instead of saving a bit.
The climate morality debate is complicated because it's all statistical. "Drown Bangladesh and Florida" is obviously a wrong outcome, but there's no one individual wrong action that leads there. You could come up with an approximation like "each gallon of jet fuel consumed raises the sea level by one femtometre"; each action is individually trivial, but combined they are not trivial.
I think nobody disagrees. Your entire comment is rhetoric handcuffing. Nobody proposed to let "Bangladesh and Florida drown".
We are discussing ways to avoid current path of climate change which can involve other means than reducing mobility.
Unfortunately a lot of people are set on an extremely narrow path, which is a moral issue. How are you going to explain to third world countries that you do not think they have the right to prosper like the US did?
In the end, it is morally wrong to be single minded on the solution to the issues. We need to consider other means. Let the means compete and pick the best way.
No, the hard part is that we just can't do the obvious, because there is no one global government that could mandate it. Instead, everyone at every level - individual, corporate, governmental - is better off short-term by not doing any climate mitigation, because those who do will lose business to those who don't.
Not at the scale of commercial airlines though and certainly not (yet) as cheaply.
Also, it is interesting to see, that you think it is more practical to eliminate air travel, than to employ new techniques to allow air travel while being climate neutral.
Or am I missing something?
The discourse on qualifying different forms of fuels is way more confusing.
It is also dangerous. If we allow marketing of "net-zero" fuels, fossil fuel companies will offset their fuel with CO2 certificates.
The only thing that matters is preventing extraction of fossil fuels in the first place.
That's why the fossil fuel industry promoted the idea of "carbon footprints", and why Adtech make their datacenters renewable - greenwashing their business that makes money selling the whole economy of fossil-fuel derived stuff, including flights and the fossil fuel industry's actual propaganda[1][2].
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox
[1] https://www.clientearth.org/projects/the-greenwashing-files/
There really isn't any other way to address climate change than by reducing emissions.
Yes, and they reduce CO2 emissions.
A kg of fuel should have roughly the same CO2 emission regardless of how it is produced?
The thing it that synthetic fuels are cyclic. We collect the emitted CO2 again.
Like this:
> The thing it that synthetic fuels are cyclic. We collect the emitted CO2 again.
This is a bad argument, as you can employ the same argument with fossil fuels.
Fuels emit CO2. we can produce fuels by sequestration.
No you can't. "Let's burn oil/gas/coal and then re-capture all the CO2 back" is not something that you can do feasibly, economically, and at scale.
I definitely understand your sentiment. It is hard to restrain oneself of a good for some cause to see other people using it.
In this case it might be productive to adapt a new view that better suits reality and increases congruence between ideas about the world and imperics.