Re:“Can we ban iPhone in retaliation?” Chinese internet reac...
by schuke on Saturday March 25, 2023 @08:00AM
(#35301790)
Hasn't China been preemptively retaliating since 2000? Among FAANG only Apple still works. And FANG is actually the surname of the father of the Great Firewall. (Fang Binxing)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:“Can we ban iPhone in retaliation?” Chinese internet reac...
by RobotToaster on Saturday March 25, 2023 @08:14AM
(#35301898)
Not really, they either pulled out or got banned because they wouldn't remove content that broke Chinese law, any Chinese company who did the same would also be banned.
Tiktok hasn't broken any American laws that result in more than fine.
Re:“Can we ban iPhone in retaliation?” Chinese internet reac...
by schuke on Saturday March 25, 2023 @09:26AM
(#35302415)
No. 1. China's constitution protects free speech. Rendering many 'laws' unconstitutional. This may be too philosophical, so there is 2. Many 'laws' are intentionally vague so their application can be as arbitrary as possible: anything can 'disturb public order' or 'violate social morale'. Who's to decide? Of course it's the Party, not the law. 3. If you look carefully, even those catch-all regulations aren't there in many cases. Chen Yun, one of the Deng Xiaoping-era elders famously argued against making a News Law, saying "When the KMT was in power, we [the Communists] studied their news laws very carefully and exploited loopholes. Now that we're in power, it's better there is no law at all." In China, laws are "made strictly, violated widely, and enforced selectively." This is the real world Constitution.
Re:“Can we ban iPhone in retaliation?” Chinese internet reac...
by RobotToaster on Saturday March 25, 2023 @10:27AM
(#35302958)
>China's constitution protects free speech. Rendering many 'laws' unconstitutional.
China's constitution is interesting, as it grants both rights and obligations on citizens, such as the obligation to observe public order and respect social morality.
http://www.npc.gov.cn/englishnpc/constitution2019/201911/1f6...
Re:“Can we ban iPhone in retaliation?” Chinese internet reac...
by EE84M3i on Saturday March 25, 2023 @10:11AM
(#35302790)
> Among FAANG only Apple still works.
Hmm, is this true?
Amazon has amazon.cn still running as far as I know, and supports china regions in the aws-cn partition via separate companies that "operate" the regions for them.
As far as I know, meta and Google don't operate their normal services in china, but I thought they still had offices there, which presumably do something.
Re:“Can we ban iPhone in retaliation?” Chinese internet reac...
by schuke on Saturday March 25, 2023 @12:09PM
(#35304049)
The business that Amazon, Facebook, Google have in China is tiny relative to their size. Amazon has a few machine-translated pages that relay their US, UK, DE, JP sites' goods to China. Kindle's shut down. FB & Google sell some ads to local exporters.
Re:“Can we ban iPhone in retaliation?” Chinese internet reac...
by jones6ofMont on Saturday March 25, 2023 @01:19PM
(#35304825)
You forgot HK. There are literally billions of American companies depended on Chinese labor inside China as well. Walmart would collapse literally overnite if Xi just restrict Walmart buying anything from China. Heck Xi can revive Kmart just by allowing Kmart to do so instead. I dont see American able to get away with TikTok ban. China could easily retaliate by supporting demise of Ukraine and blowing up Norway pipes. Eu especially Germany if dare to retaliate will face severe recession...in the range of 30+% unemployment. Americans 2 carrier fleets could go down with 40K American casualties with hypersonic missiles (remember Talebans defeated Americans, China would be like Talebans Star Trek). That kind of blow would be similar to Spanish Armada defeat outcome. And we not even talking about GoT styles of assassinations. Look up Chinese 5000 years history of assassinations (NK used one to get rid of the brother). Americans are not used to assassinations of whole families. They only thought of immediate killings of the main persons within a specific time frame. In Chinese cultures, assasinations play out longer term like decades and total anhinilation...they even have life motto based on that call exterminating grass by pulling out all the roots. Do you think there are enough Secret service to protect Fortune500 execs and their families? They dont even have enough to protect their congress members. You think Putin pollonization was horrible, then realized entire GoT was based on actual Chinese history set in Jin Dynasty.