News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California bill would ban sales of Skittles, other ‘toxic... by exabrial on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:40PM (#35278423)
> the less processed foods that we eat

This is literally none of the government's business

Re:California bill would ban sales of Skittles, other ‘toxic... by dragontamer on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:42PM (#35278468)
I dunno. The US Government thinking about what we eat has been around since at least iodized salt, probably earlier. There's a famous 1800s court case about whether or not Tomatoes are fruits or Vegetables.

The bulk of these regulations came after Sinclair's "The Jungle", pointing out all of the problems at food processing plants (albeit in fictional form, but there was truth in fiction)

--------

Whether or not the US Government "should" care is kind of a settled case for over a century in my eyes.

Now that being said, "processed food" is such an incredibly vague category filled with obvious snake-oil salesmen and fake news that I loathe to give any of that much of my attention. But the government thinking about what foods are safe (or not) to eat? That's literally their job and has been for a long, long time.

-------

Now we can talk about where the regulations have failed, such as the Peking Duck exemption. (Peking Duck is delicious, and clearly safe. But by 1970s law / understanding of regulations, it was quite illegal). And its important to remember these cases and that regulation is far from perfect. But the overall concept of caring about what foods are safe and not safe is the point of FDA, USDA, and a whole slew of other agencies.

Re:California bill would ban sales of Skittles, other ‘toxic... by haliskerbas on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:44PM (#35278502)
I would love it to be the government's business. I spend most of my time doing W2 work which the government automatically takes a cut from. I don't want to become a nutritionist, and I don't want candy to kill me faster than it would in Europe.
Re:California bill would ban sales of Skittles, other ‘toxic... by exabrial on Thursday March 23, 2023 @02:46PM (#35279463)
Who is forcing you to eat candy?
Re:California bill would ban sales of Skittles, other ‘toxic... by haliskerbas on Thursday March 23, 2023 @03:50PM (#35280364)
No one, just like no one forces me to walk outside, but I love being able to breathe air that is not as poisonous (aka EPA).
Re:California bill would ban sales of Skittles, other ‘toxic... by exabrial on Thursday March 23, 2023 @05:36PM (#35281633)
The difference is, air you don't have a choice, it's a shared resource, and it's required for life.

So who is making your eat skittles?

Re:California bill would ban sales of Skittles, other ‘toxic... by p0pcult on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:45PM (#35278516)
That's certainly one take. They probably shouldn't be able to regulate seatbelt use, or forbid pollutants.

The free market will take care of it, right?

Re:California bill would ban sales of Skittles, other ‘toxic... by xcdzvyn on Thursday March 23, 2023 @02:17PM (#35279028)
Seatbelts were a product of the free market
Re:California bill would ban sales of Skittles, other ‘toxic... by p0pcult on Thursday March 23, 2023 @02:40PM (#35279380)
The requirements to use them, where they exist, are not.
Re:California bill would ban sales of Skittles, other ‘toxic... by dsfyu404ed on Thursday March 23, 2023 @03:06PM (#35279752)
Seatbelts were gaining adoption pretty damn fast before they got mandated. Ditto for safety glass, brake lights and airbags. I think if we didn't mandate them the only cars without them these days would be those ultra basic trims that they only make five of so they can advertise a low "starting at" number.

ABS and traction control are the questionable ones that saw their adoption plateau and probably wouldn't have the adoption they do without government. Modern collision avoidance stuff appears to be making its way through the market lightening quick without mandate.

Re:California bill would ban sales of Skittles, other ‘toxic... by RubberSoul on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:55PM (#35278670)
This is, of course, a major philosophical debate. I will just say that there could be reasons this is the government's business.

One issue with modern food production for consumers is that it can be difficult to determine whether a particular ingredient is safe or healthy. Information has public good qualities, and having each consumer make an individual determination about whether each ingredient is safe/healthy is costly. The obvious way to justify government intervention here is that it's more efficient for us to pool resources and empower a third-party to produce the information we need and ban/label products that are likely unsafe. The decisions won't always be right, but the approach might be much preferred to the alternatives.

Plus, conditional on socializing a lot of medical costs, it might make sense to put restrictions on behaviors that affect individual health.

Re:California bill would ban sales of Skittles, other ‘toxic... by exabrial on Thursday March 23, 2023 @02:45PM (#35279456)
So to summarize:

* Your body, not your choice

* If a person puts a substance into their their body that the governement doesn't like? Incarcerate them? Fine them to take away their means of buying more food?