News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by SQueeeeeL on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:00PM (#35249937)
Was Google really a beloved employer? I feel like that was vapor marketing hype most real people saw through as bs, you'd pretty much see constant stories of overwork and toxic teams run by incompetent "project managers" just like every other overvalued Silicon Valley FAANG shop
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by aix1 on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:11PM (#35250117)
Overwork? Toxic teams? Project managers running teams?

I've been at Google for a very long time, in quite a few orgs, and none of those things ring any bells. (Some probably exist in some pockets, though the last one sounds particularly implausible. It's just not how Google job ladders and the management structure work.)

Now, I have to admit to having not read the article, but the headline does resonate. I've spoken to a lot of current Googlers about this, and their attitude towards the company has definitely changed rather dramatically, almost overnight. People in non-US jurisdictions are feeling this particularly acutely, due to how the layoffs have been playing out for them.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by Shish2k on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:03PM (#35250916)
I’ve been at Meta for a few years and would say similar - I’m pretty sure that at any company with tens or hundreds of thousands of employees, you are going to get some horror stories - but in general it used to be an amazing place to work (ranked #1 on glassdoor for several years for good reason), but now… ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by sawyna on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:19PM (#35251163)
I currently work at Google and my take is that it really depends on the team. If an IC is toxic, the effect of it isn't terrible. If a manager is, the effect spreads and if a manager of managers is toxic, that's a recipe for disaster and so on.

I personally am in a situation where nasty politics are being played out just for the sake of getting promoted. It's fine to focus on your promo, but not at the cost of your colleagues or the environment.

That being said, the broader google ecosystem and culture holds on a macro level. It really is the people that work there who define and uphold it. A couple of rogue high level folks are enough to destroy it.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by super256 on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:09PM (#35251003)
> Overwork?

I don't know anyone working at Google, nor anyone who worked at Google in the past (except a single intern). Hell, I don't even live anywhere near a Google campus!

But I always assumed that Google wants you to spend your whole day there, from morning until evening. Because big tech is usually implicitly aiming at that.

- Serve three major meals a day, + you can bring your dog to your office, which eliminates any reason to go home (especially for those who don't have a house or spouse to take care of).

- Shuttle bus, where many employees have like, idk, 40min of free time? Why not just start working on the laptop already?

- Food servings are stretched out. Breakfast is till 10AM; dinner is served at 6:30PM, so if you started at 8:30AM, you need to stay another 1.5h to make use of dinner. Why not work in the meantime?

And some classical fear stuff which makes you want to work hard and long hours:

- Aggressive deadlines

- Get the promotion in 2 years or get fired

I dunno, I probably wouldn't mind working under these conditions, but I think there are reasons why the average tenure of a Googler is 1.5 years.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by jchw on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:23PM (#35251221)
I worked at Google for three years. It was a great experience and I mainly left because I had grown accustomed to remote work and was planning on moving back to live closer to family after having a falling out with the bay area.

I do get the impression that people have had vastly differing experiences at Google, but the culture was very laid back. Deadline pressure existed, but ultimately it never felt that bad: if we weren't going to hit it, we weren't going to hit it. It happened.

>Get the promotion in 2 years or get fired

I don't think this is true. I'm pretty sure once you're L4 or so you can pretty much coast. I heard a similar thing when I was at Google, but knew of many counter examples within my circle of coworkers.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by super256 on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:47PM (#35251547)
First: Thank you for sharing your experience! But I have one question, I'd be glad to get some clarification.

> I'm pretty sure once you're L4 or so you can pretty much coast. I heard a similar thing when I was at Google, but knew of many counter examples within my circle of coworkers.

Do you mean that there are employees who were below L4 and have not been promoted in the past two years?

Or do you mean that you know employees, who are L4, but haven't promoted to L5 in the past two years?

In general, it seems (judging from HN comments) like L4 is the minimum growth expectation.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by jchw on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @04:38PM (#35252179)
I am not sure if it is ladder-dependent but yes, you can stay at L3 for longer without getting fired. Not sure if there's actually a set limit anywhere, and I suspect it's more of a rule of thumb.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by mathattack on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:42PM (#35251467)
Part of the reason the average tenure is so short is companies usually quote Median, and that’s low by definition in high growth companies. If you double your headcount in 2 years, your median will be less than 2 years even if nobody quits.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by munificent on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:55PM (#35251640)
> I always assumed that Google wants you to spend your whole day there, from morning until evening.

People always cynically assume that's why Google has the perks but in all the Google offices I've worked from or visited, the building is a ghost town after 6:00pm.

The real reason is that Google is competing with other tech companies and perks are an effective incentive to get people to pick your company over another one.

> Because big tech is usually implicitly aiming at that.

Tech companies are aiming for maximum long term productivity of intellectually challenging complex work. I'm not aware of any data that shows the way to get that is by grinding your employees into the dust with overtime.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by Firmwarrior on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @06:10PM (#35253356)
yeah, I've heard a crazy amount of bellyaching at other FAANG companies about not having the same perks as Google

I'm sitting here thinking "News flash: you can just buy lunch for yourself at a restaurant using the $400,000 they pay you per year"

Those perks are the real deal. They do pull people in

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by munificent on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @06:31PM (#35253619)
> "News flash: you can just buy lunch for yourself at a restaurant using the $400,000 they pay you per year"

The magic of free food as a perk is that it's a non-zero value proposition for both employees and the company.

Before I worked at Google, I worked at a software job without free food. We could afford to eat out for lunch every day and we did.

But it meant at least twenty minutes of driving every day. The food was more expensive because it didn't have the same economies of scale as cafeteria style service. It was less healthy because restaurant food tends to go over the top with salt and fat to amp up the flavor and entice people in. There were never any serendipitous conversations with new coworkers because I always went with the same team every time.

Conversely, when I eat at Google now, it's a five minute pleasant walk. There's no wasted time sitting waiting to get served. There are fewer options so I don't get stupid analysis paralysis deciding where to go to lunch or what I want to eat. I eat more salads and smaller meals because I don't feel compelled to get my money's worth. When I travel to other offices, I know I can easily get breakfast and lunch there without having to navigate an unfamiliar city if I don't feel like it.

Meanwhile, the cost of driving to restaurants and eating out each day is quite a bit higher than the total cost of feeding employees in a cafe. So for companies that don't offer this perk, they have to compensate employees enough for them to feed themselves and I suspect that the total comp for that is more expensive than just feedling them.

Free food is my absolute favorite perk at Google, and I treasure it deeply.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by Firmwarrior on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @07:05PM (#35254027)
Yeah, all that stuff is true.. although most of it's true about the subsidized cafeterias at Amazon, Apple, and Microsoft too
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by munificent on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @07:01PM (#35268254)
I'm not making a relative comparison to other companies that also offer free food.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by scarmig on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @04:37PM (#35252168)
> I don't know anyone working at Google, nor anyone who worked at Google in the past (except a single intern). Hell, I don't even live anywhere near a Google campus!

I did a couple year stint at Google, and I also didn't know anyone who worked there at all.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by super256 on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @06:01AM (#35258889)
I just wanted to underline that my "knowledge" comes from reading HN comments. And it looks like I got a lot of stuff wrong too!
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by tdeck on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @11:38PM (#35256512)
Did you hear about "megablocks"? They ran the shuttles and cafes on the weekends and "encouraged" engineers to work through the weekend until that project was done. I wasn't in that org and joined Google a bit after the project concluded, but it had an infamous reputation that stuck around.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by aix1 on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @12:35AM (#35256881)
No, never heard of "megablocks".
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by tdeck on Thursday March 30, 2023 @04:26AM (#35369659)
It might actually have been spelled "megablox"; it's been too long.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by mingus88 on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:10PM (#35250097)
Before the doubleclick merger, Google was absolutely the ideal place to work as an engineer.

I feel that perhaps after 2007 a lot of Google's reputation was still held up by what the culture was like in the years surrounding their IPO.

But of course, this is ancient tech history. I haven't entertained a Google recruiter in probably a decade now.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by cmrdporcupine on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:25PM (#35251235)
I wasn't there in 2007, didn't get there til 2011, but looking at the facts think 2007/2008 era it seems like a juncture from one Google to the next, for sure.

The other, really major, shift -- which happened while I was there -- was Patrick Pichette leaving as CFO and Ruth Porat coming on. And then the subsequent "Alphabetization" which... it was so bungled and mismanaged... and it was clear at that point L&S were clueless about what was actually going on inside the company... that to me was when the company had seriously dramatically shifted in tone and structure. I think that was .. what... 2015?

Sundar taking over was just the formalization of that degradation.

For me, personally I wish I'd only stayed there for 4-5 years, and left around then. But before remote work there weren't any competitive options in my region, so I got stuck there for 10 years.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by nostrademons on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @04:01PM (#35251724)
(I was there 2009-2014 and again 2020-present. Worked with several single/double-digit employee number Googlers.)

IMHO the "eras" of Google were:

1.) 1998-2001. Origins. Larry was CEO, company was still basically in the garage or the PayPal offices in Palo Alto, everything was an ad-hoc scrappy startup.

2.) 2001-2004. Growth. Eric was CEO. They moved into the Googleplex. Exploring new lines of business (Groups, AdSense, GMail, Maps/Earth), but they were all just explorations, and most of the company remained focused on Search. Key infrastructure like GFS, MapReduce, BigTable, Stubby, Sawzall were invented.

3.) 2004-2008. Conglomeration. Eric was CEO. IPO. Big college-hiring push started in this era (remember the Google Labs Aptitude Test?), as did a push to hire outside managers from other companies. GMail, Maps, Labs, Scholar, Toolbar, Chrome, Android all launched, and Docs/Sheets/Slides/YouTube were acquired. This is when the modern Google product portfolio was built, and much of its current culture and processes solidified.

4.) 2009-2010. Interregnum. Eric was CEO. Financial crisis happened here, which basically shut down growth, and it also faced serious competitive threats from Bing, iPhones, etc. As a result the culture during the interregnum almost harkened back to the 2001-2004 era: there was a refocusing on core search/ads/infrastructure and a generally scrappier mentality.

5.) 2011-2015. Google+ & X. Larry was CEO again, company shifted to make everything about G+. There was an overall futile attempt to address a major competitive threat that turned out not to matter anyway.

6.) 2015-2020. Alphabetization. Sundar was CEO, but Ruth came in as CFO and realistically runs the company. Finance plays a much bigger role - I don't think Google's produced a single successful new product post-2015 (come to think of it, there weren't many new successes post-2009), but revenue has grown through continued optimization and profits have grown through cost-cutting.

7.) 2020+. Post-COVID. Culture was hurt significantly by remote work, it's very hard to realign the company to adapt to outside changes.

The irony is that what many Googlers nostalgically think of "Google culture" actually came from the 2004-2008 era, when Eric was CEO and many of the new hires either came from college or outside companies. If you listen to pre-IPO hires, they'll say that very early Google culture was a lot scrappier, a lot less entitled, a lot more opinionated, a lot more willing to take top-down direction from Larry specifically, and a lot more focused on the work itself and how to deliver excellent technical solutions quickly.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by cmrdporcupine on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @04:55PM (#35252415)
"7.) 2020+. Post-COVID. Culture was hurt significantly by remote work, it's very hard to realign the company to adapt to outside changes."

Agreed. I left end of 2021 after a year and a half of struggling with bad execution on WFH. Some teams did better than others but company as a whole I think lost out on that.

WFH can work. But it didn't work at Google, really.

And when the office was open during those times I went in, and the whole situation was just... crap. Floating reserved desks. Take away meh, food. Nobody else in the office. Ghost town but somehow the parking situation still sucked.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by nigelk on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @05:26PM (#35252806)
As someone who was there start of 2007 to end of 2010, this resonated. My first two years were very different to the last two.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by holografix on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @04:40PM (#35252199)
From the lofty heights of your high horse I doubt anyone on earth would even hear you and run risk of being “entertained” by you.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by mingus88 on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @10:27PM (#35256000)
Whatever dude. I'm the one getting frequent inMails from Google recruiters. I have never once applied for a role there.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by pwinnski on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:13PM (#35250143)
At Google, developers were the product, not overhead. As such, they were supported lavishly, with meals and massages, at a level not previously seen, at least not in career available to people who weren't fifth-generation Ivy grads. And the pay, total comp is still trumpeted here at HN as among the highest around.

Sure, a lot of people saw those perks as being aimed a particular demographic: young people without attachments who were willing to spend nearly 168 hours each week on site. And a lot of us saw the selection of perks as those most likely to attract that demographic.

But people who joined Google didn't often leave for reasons related to Google, and I'm not sure there's a better way to describe that than "beloved." Low turnover tells the story.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by cromwellian on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:31PM (#35250417)
Yup. I was at Google for over a decade, I should have left years ago for a startup, I had offers, but I loved what I did, I loved my fellow coworkers, and I was well compensated. There was little reason to leave, and a lot of reasons to stay.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by solarkraft on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:44PM (#35250614)
Have you left?
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by cromwellian on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:50PM (#35250718)
Laid off, and from the one division I thought would be less subject to layoffs: AI. (I thought Ads would be well insulated too, but I know a lot of Ads folks who were let go). But I'm not that broken up about it, because I feel like tech is getting exciting again, almost like the 90s, when everyday, some new amazing thing comes out. Last week in AI for example, super exciting.

There's a lot of opportunity now to build cool stuff in this emerging ecosystem, it's totally unknown space, and what's going to exist 5 yrs from now is going to be as crazy as all of the companies that now exist because of smartphones, or the invention of the browser.

I think Google (and OpenAI) might be the best places for AI research, but I'm not sure Google is the best place for applied-research at the application level. I think the startup ecosystem is going to explore that space way more rapidly, and it'll be fun to play in that space.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by tenpies on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:48PM (#35250680)
> As such, they were supported lavishly, with meals and massages, at a level not previously seen, at least not in career available to people who weren't fifth-generation Ivy grads.

I think if you push further back, we did see it. Go find the oldest retired IBMer you can and ask them what it was like in the good days. You'll find it was very similar.

Sure, they didn't do the whole come-be-an-activist-while-ignoring-your-actual-job thing, and there were no nap pods, but the perks were up there. From free food to the parties (and yes, your kids are coming to many of them and they and your wife/husband are going to get free gifts from IBM at every chance). There was a time when landing a job at IBM was like getting a job at Google was a while ago - except that they still did the employee-for-life thing and even if you were laid off, it was with your consent (and an obscene benefits package).

But you also did have to do actual work, not just attend one meeting per week with no deliverable.

Edit: Actually I think it may have been even better back then. There was no company shuttle to the office. You had a company car. There was no roommate while giving 60% of your income to a landlord, housing was still affordable and your spouse didn't really have to work unless they wanted to.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by VirusNewbie on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:40PM (#35251432)
> Go find the oldest retired IBMer you can and ask them what it was like in the good days. You'll find it was very similar.

I don't think this was true. Before Google really started poaching everyone, big tech engineering jobs were almost always lower paid than almost any managerial job, and compensation was never in line with lawyers or medical doctors.

Plenty of people who put in 10+ years at FAANG companies have enough to retire, did you really see IBM engineers retiring in their 40s (or, the ability to if they wanted?).

I've been in the industry for over 20 years, and when I started, regardless of how good of an engineer you were, unless you hit it big with an IPO riches were not to be had. That has changed drastically in the last fifteen years.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by jldugger on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:02PM (#35250901)
> As such, they were supported lavishly, with meals and massages, at a level not previously seen

This is simultaneously true and the CEO wrote a book about how he did an across the board 10 percent raise[1] because Google was underpaying relative to the competition, _for some reason_.

[1]: https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748703523604575605...

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_L...

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by 908B64B197 on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @04:25PM (#35252004)
> Sure, a lot of people saw those perks as being aimed a particular demographic: young people without attachments who were willing to spend nearly 168 hours each week on site. And a lot of us saw the selection of perks as those most likely to attract that demographic.

It reflects the demographics of the early employees and founders.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by drewg123 on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:30PM (#35250400)
I was there 2013->2015. It was not viewed as "beloved" in my eyes; more like a benevolent, paternalistic overlord. There were certainly negatives. It was nearly impossible to concentrate at work, due to being in a large open space with many teams, and they would not let me be full-time remote (even as an L6 "staff" SWE), crowded bathrooms, crowded cafes, etc.

However, they put a lot of effort into the endless perks, and the feeling of job security. It really felt like they cared about you, and your career development.

I was shocked by the layoffs. My old group's PM, who was fantastic (and well connected) was let go in the purge.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by cromwellian on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:36PM (#35250498)
If you remember, there was the great "de-frag" at one point, where they wanted to reduce # of satellite offices, and tried to move everyone into a few big HQ, this resulted in overcrowding, and one aspect of that was "no remote work". (post-pandemic, this sounds bizarre now).

The closing of some of the satellite offices resulted in some of the first shocking "layoffs", for example, the Google Atlanta office was shuttered, most of the former couldn't move, and so left for other companies. (technically not a layoff, but if you can't relocate, it's basically the same) :(

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by drewg123 on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:44PM (#35250613)
The defrag was a year or two before I joined, as I recall.

The remote work policy seemed to go by org. I worked in platforms, and our VP was old-school, adamantly opposed to remote work. He'd proudly walk around the office, surveying his domain. He was rather like a proctor in an exam. Meanwhile, I worked closely with several folks in the kernel team who were allowed to work remotely. One of them was very interested in what we were doing, was a luminary in his field, and wanted to transfer to our group, but worked remotely, and didn't want to give that up. Similarly, I left for Netflix because they allowed remote work in the Open Connect kernel group.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by cromwellian on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:29PM (#35250392)
As someone who worked at Google for 15 yrs, who also worked at Oracle and IBM, I can confidently say that Google was the least toxic, least overworked place I've ever been. That's not to say there aren't management problems, especially around the erratic way they launch new projects and kill others with no real rhyme or reason, but working environment was never one of the complaints.

At IBM and Oracle, I'd regularly be in meetings with shouting matches. People were tear down others. There was excessive territorialism. Googley culture, although it changed over time, did promote cooperation and constructive criticism. Post-Mortems emphasized what went wrong and what could be done better, not who went wrong. Other teams were often, if not always, eager to partner or share their work.

Work location flexibility, the cafes, all of it was very good.

Now, I did perceive a cultural decline, I think it was sometime around the launch of Google Hangouts, I started sensing a more bean-counting approach, I think because the Seattle office brought in a bunch of MS managers in too short a period of time for them to absorb Googley culture. At one point, the initial launch of Hangouts didn't have presence indicators, and when employees brought it up, one response was "You are not the audience". As if presence indicators are something only elite engineers want, and not regular folks. This was totally antithetical to way products like Gmail were built, out of personal desire and need.

I didn't work in Cloud, but I suspect Thomas Kurian brought a more Oracle "Sales Engineer" driven approach, and that too can change culture. Might be bad for culture, but good for external customers.

One of the issues over the years that I feel an acute sense of now that I'm looking for a job again, is that Google invented a lot of technology early internally, from Borg to Map/Reduce/etc. Eventually, the outside world cloned these, and when they became on-par and standardized, at that point I really think Google should have switched their internal stack to the OSS equivalents. For example, Google still builds products on the internal Borg system, rather than using GCP/Kubernetes/Terraform/etc. If GCP/Kube is missing functionality to run say, Maps or Gmail, then perfect, that indicates a good driver for improving the external facing product. Working on some of Google's tech stack feels like an alien world compared to working on stuff outside.

In ML at least, there's synergy, as Tensorflow and JAX are used internally and externally. But in terms of major systems, there needs to be a lot more of this. Blaze was opened as Bazel way too late for example, should have been done years ago.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by dekhn on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:42PM (#35250589)
I worked for Google for 10 years- at first in a great but intense (overworked) SRE team, then later as a SWE running my own project (again intense and overworked, but totally self-imposed) and then on various ML and 3D printing teams. By and large it was great, but it got worse over time (increasingly clueless managers with night-school MBAs) and more toxic.

Occasionally I'd see memes or posts from other teams that described business practices I couldn't believe (like, "I have to stay at the office until my manager leaves or I'll be fired, and he doesn't leave until 8PM so I dont' see my family much") which didn't make sense until I learned that entire teams were H1-B visas reporting to managers who applied caste in their jobs in the US.

Absolutely nothing I've seen compares to borg or a full TPUv4 cluster.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by cromwellian on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:57PM (#35250834)
Wow, I'm shocked to hear that. Was this at a US office? I know some overseas offices have different culture. I guess it's not unprecedented. My wife (eng manager) resigned from Google around 2015 I think, in part because Google Cloud had brought on a new boss in a re-org who was a McKinsey-and-associates person, and her boss tasked her mostly with making spreadsheets of business processes, because that's the format she was used to doing all her work in (spreadsheets). She went from managing Chrome engineers and sitting in on meetings to discuss features, to doing spreadsheets. :(

There was definitely a decline over the years, I was probably lucky in that the teams I joined (Infra, Gmail, AI) were run mostly by engineers and pretty cool people.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by dekhn on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:49PM (#35251569)
Mountain View. In fact during the nest debacle there was a whole office building of people doing nothing with a clock on the wall which was "how long until Tony Fadell no longer controls you" counting down the days.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by eitally on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:36PM (#35251391)
I worked in Cloud from 2015-2023. I was personally hired by Amit Singh, who was the first "CEO" of "Cloud", back when it was just "Google Apps" + GCS/GCE/GAE. About 8 months later Diane Greene was brought in to scale the business because the org under Amit was too googley. Literally. Google's legacy culture of engineering meritocracy and ICs who vote with their feet on the "best" projects was not conducive to becoming an enterprise technology company. Diane brought in Diane Bryant as COO (from Intel) and PH Ferrand as sales president (from Dell), and while PH gave it a good try on the GTM side, Diane left after barely 6 months and there just wasn't enough enterprise experience across the org to make things work. Diane was likely brought in at least partly because she is googley, and her VMWare history probably looked like enterprise software success, but she was too googley to turn the ship and he org flailed for a couple more years. Then the board appointed TK, who absolutely knows 100% how to sell to enterprise. He spent 2 years almost exclusively hiring senior staff from outside: Microsoft, SAP, AWS, IBM, Salesforce, Oracle, etc, and rebuilding something that looks roughly like if Microsoft went back in time 20 years.

The upsides are that the business has grown mightily and Cloud is now almost exclusively market driven, at least on core products/services. The downside is that he broke the culture and alienated thousands of googlers whose advancement opportunities were essentially eliminated. Because of the hiring needs, the bar is much lower now, cronyism is prevalent, and politics+bureaucracy get in the way of progress.

During my years at Google, I sat in The Quad, Tech Corners, Moffett Park, and then back at Tech Corners, and spent time in many of the rest of the bay area offices. I will state with confidence that the Cloud offices do not feel "googley" when you walk around the cube spaces. There are few decorations, no buzz, not many people who appear to be enjoying themselves, very few tech talks, guest speakers or events, etc. Just taking a walk around the MP, Matilda or TC campuses and then visiting YT in San Bruno or one of the Android teams in MTV is a stark difference.

Cloud is not googley. Let's see if the consumer-oriented PAs can keep that alive.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by dack on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:07PM (#35250061)
it was definitely a great place to work in it's heyday 10+ years ago, as I believe most of the FAANG companies were. It was so nice back in the day having companies you knew would be great if you could just get into them. Are there any companies like that these days?
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by eschneider on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:15PM (#35250175)
There are _definitely_ great companies out there, depending on what makes a place great FOR YOU. Working on great products with smart people? Yeah, there are places out there like that, and not always in the 'obvious' places. Great compensation? Yeah, there are places/industries that still offer that. Getting everything combined with one employer? That's more of a unicorn problem and you might have to compromise on something.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by nebula8804 on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:12PM (#35251053)
Can you name some? It always seems like some sort of open secret until its too late. There was some discussion about Oxide Computers being one of these companies.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by eschneider on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:31PM (#35251327)
I've been working mostly with embedded/IoT/backendCloud stuff lately, with a focus on embedded/IoT stuff and having spend about a month this year interviewing, the quality of companies and projects out there vary VASTLY. I ended up joining a manufacturing company that's adding some specialized robotics...stuff to their product line. Cool stuff and in a product domain I know a lot about. Great people, too. I heard about these guys because my former boss worked with them all before their start up got acquired by the MfgCo a while back. Definitely not the folks you'd peg for doing quality tech work, but they are. Compensation wasn't the best offer I landed, but it's good enough and I feel like I'm working with adults who know what they're doing and that's worth a lot to me.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by nradov on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:12PM (#35250120)
If that's what you want then you can always start one.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by ahsteele on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:18PM (#35251144)
Yes I would say that working in the United States at a Federally Funded Research and Design Center https://www.nsf.gov/statistics/ffrdclist/ are great companies if only you can get into them.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by thwayunion on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:35PM (#35251374)
Also as long as you don't mind below market rates and job security tied to federal budget allocations. Or your paycheck disappearing for an unknown period of time whenever there's divided government.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by tempsy on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:04PM (#35250004)
never heard of Google being a place people were "overworked" at all, not compared to Amazon, at least, or as hyper-competitive as Netflix.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by rootusrootus on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:03PM (#35249981)
With enough total comp you can be my Beloved Employer.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by kneebonian on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:06PM (#35250043)
No, that wasn't always the case, it's the same thing that happenned with MS. Back in the late oughts and early 2010's Google was a fantastic place to work based on the reports I've heard, that was considered work nirvana. They were the ones who introduced things like catered lunchs, and a lot of other amenities that many people consider now standard fare in many tech shops.

Based on what I heard it was a wonderful time, you got to spend all day working on interesting problems, with super smart people that were at the peak of their field, money was coming in hand over fist, and the people running the show had an understanding of engineering.

The problem is that success attracts leeches, you start getting lots of MBA types, PMs, bean counters, etc. Then things went downhill. But it wasn't always this way, it just so happens that once you become successful enough you will attract people that aren't interested in what you do, but in getting a piece of that pie, and those people and that thinking and mindset will ruin any organization.

P.S. It's an interesting line to draw between being overworked by a boss that is forcing you to spend 60 hours a week chained to a desk, and loving what you do so much that you are happy to spend 60 hours a week on it, just because you derive that much satisfaction from it.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by candiodari on Friday March 24, 2023 @04:15AM (#35286392)
But now the company has shown that it will use layoffs. So now Google is threatening the livelihoods of it's employees.

So most everyone is a leech now. Not because they want to or it's in their character, it's just something that will at least give you some basic safety.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by yibg on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:46PM (#35250654)
For a while now Google has been seen as the place you go to coast, at least if you're not gunning for promotions.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by linguae on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:05PM (#35250946)
(Disclaimer: I was a software engineering intern at Google during the summers of 2013 and 2014.)

In the 2000s and the first half of the 2010s, Google felt like the dream place to work. Yes, a lot has been said about the perks and the generous pay, but another thing that made Google appealing was its cutting edge projects. I was a huge fan of Google Inbox (sadly long discontinued). As a graduate student researching storage systems and who enjoyed reading the MapReduce, BigTable, and Spanner papers, being able to work on Spanner as an intern was a dream come true. I also loved all of the internal support I received as a developer, from the amazing internal infrastructure to the various internal tutorials. I never felt siloed off from the rest of the company, compared to other employers I've had. It was an amazing place to work and I'd rank it as my second-best work experience (my best being eight months I spent at Fujitsu Laboratories in Kawasaki, Japan where I worked in a storage lab on an SSD cache....that was a downright magical experience), though granted as an intern I was shielded from the performance review process and on-calls, so I can't comment about these things.

I would love to work for a team similar to the teams I worked on during my internships at Google, as well as the general feeling of 2013-14 Google. However, I'm under the impression that Google's culture started changing a lot during the Alphabet reorganization and the rise of Sundar Pichai as CEO. I don't know if there's a place in the Valley these days that captures the feel of pre-Alphabet Google; it seems to me that the Valley itself has changed a lot (and for the worse) since roughly 2015, but that's another discussion for another time.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by Yoric on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @04:51PM (#35252367)
If you find such a place, don't hesitate to spread the word :)
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by jimjimjim on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:21PM (#35251194)
As a viewpoint from outside of the fang(whatever), I've always felt (and heard) that google was the best of the bunch in terms of employee opinion of the organization.
Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by cmrdporcupine on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:21PM (#35251196)
As a Googler for 10 years, I'd say -- on the whole, yes, well loved. But steadily worsening over that 10 year period. And, no, most people I knew were not overworked. Not at my site, anyways. And certainly not compared to what I saw from people I knew at Apple or Amazon.

I had my beefs with the place always, and I was like a square peg round hole there -- BUT ... Not even talking about the pay -- above average -- benefits were amazing. Culture when I started was very engineering driven. Mostly a very respectful professional environment apart from one asshole TL I had to deal with, but I was able to route around him after a few months. Good mix of age ranges and not biased against middle aged or older like many other workplaces in our industry.

I didn't like the work / projects I had to do there. I didn't like the promo process. I didn't like the way projects were managed. But I liked the company ethic overall (obviously I always had issues) -- but it degraded every year I was there. But not because of overwork etc but because of bureaucratic dysfunction and ethical lapses.

Re:Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid... by zaphar on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @08:09AM (#35259839)
I was there roughly about a decade ago. At that time Google was a fantastic place to work. I didn't have toxic teams nor was I asked to overwork. I left the office at 5pm nearly every day. Google at least in the Chicago office deserved it's reputation as the best place to work in tech.

I still know people there and talking to them it does seem like there was a dramatic shift over the last 5+ years or so. I don't think it can claim the same culture that it had when I was there.