News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by tomhallett on Monday March 20, 2023 @12:20PM (#35233902)
Has OpenAI said anything (in their TOS/etc) about who owns the copyright/ip on the code that it generates? I know it’s a legal minefield of a question, just curious if they have said “we won’t sue you if you copy/paste this code in your app” publically or anything.
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by bloak on Monday March 20, 2023 @12:26PM (#35234020)
Semi-serious: Perhaps they are scared of even mentioning copyright in case it makes their own infringement "wilful".
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by CuriouslyC on Monday March 20, 2023 @12:36PM (#35234220)
The USPTO has already ruled that stuff created solely via prompt to a model with no modification is not copyrightable.
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by spacebanana7 on Monday March 20, 2023 @12:46PM (#35234417)
That might be the case in theory, but if a university can't tell the difference between AI generated essays/books and human generated ones the how could the courts?
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by CuriouslyC on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:01PM (#35234730)
If someone tries to sue you for copyright infringement on a model output, you can just produce the parameters to the model that produced the output and the case will be thrown out pretty much instantly.
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by r00fus on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:13PM (#35234906)
What happens when you incidentally created something very similar to something ChatGPT could produce - does that mean you can't enforce copyright on it? (as someone could automate a prompt engineering process to create a near-copy of your original work?

Let's take that to the next step - what happens if ChatGPT happens to get trained on something that is copyrightable - then a prompt script can be used to reproduce the original - does that mean the original is now considered not protected by copyright?

This is a lot more murky than "show me the prompts/parameters" and it's not protected by copyright.

Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by ilyt on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:40PM (#35235444)
Or vice versa - when you only modify answer a bit ? I guess it would be derivative work ?
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by wongarsu on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:58PM (#35237695)
It would be derivative work, which is copyrightable in the US. But you have to modify it enough to hit some threshold of originality.
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by CuriouslyC on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:26PM (#35235172)
If you try to sue someone for copyright infringement and they demonstrate that what you're claiming is infringement is solely the result of model output, you're going to be out of luck, and honestly I don't think that's a problem - if your creation is so derivative that a model produces it via a reasonable prompt it probably doesn't deserve protection. Using prompt interrogation on a specially fine tuned model in an attempt to end-run a reasonable copyright is a different matter, but I don't think that'd be worth the effort for anyone to actually do.

If a copyright precedes the existence of a model, the model was trained on that code and someone distributes code from the model that is a near-verbatim reproduction, that's a different story (in large part because getting that near verbatim reproduction would probably require willful intent rather than just being accidental)

Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by SllX on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:10PM (#35235972)
Can you explain to a court why it is “generating” the original from scratch from a prompt and not simply retrieving the input and printing it to screen?

Just out of curiosity.

I don’t think the owner of the copyright loses copyright simply because something else output a copy of his work. Maybe it is “generated” but the copyright holder still has his rights per copyright statutes and you would still be violating those rights by distributing your own copies from the AI output.

Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by codyb on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:28PM (#35235222)
Aren't these models constantly updating though?
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by bioemerl on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:08PM (#35234835)
This feels like it could easily be abused if you can get a model to output code that is "pretty close". You could use it to try and invalidate human written copyright as well.
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by spacebanana7 on Monday March 20, 2023 @05:08PM (#35238748)
My understanding is that LLMs are generally probabilistic so repeating the inputs won’t produce the same output.
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by nerdponx on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:45PM (#35235524)
This will be reverted by a federal court and/or Congress as soon as Disney gets involved, or at least relegated to an unenforceable legal footnote.
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by chongli on Monday March 20, 2023 @12:34PM (#35234175)
I think courts have started to find that the output of AIs like ChatGPT can’t be copyrighted at all because it isn’t human expression.
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by Terretta on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:17PM (#35234990)
As anyone well-informed how LLMs work will tell you, it's not violating any copyright or IP, because these answers are coming from a probabilistic walk through condensed remix of learning, not the sources themselves.

Another way of thinking of it is compressed knowledge, with learned structure, and an ability to pick likely words to describe that structure rather than an ability to use original words.

The compression ratio of the source corpus versus the model demonstrates it doesn't have all the source material, ipso facto, results are not infringement.

As an easy to understand analog, if you grab a Shutterstock photo, change it from 100% quality to 5% quality, the file size drops to 100th of the original and on display, none of the pixels are the same. While it may be the same general concept depicted badly, it is certainly not the original and clearly isn't copyrightable.

(Note: That last paragraph is firmly tongue in cheek /s ... I've used the "uniqueness (originality) is compressed out, what remains as learned is fair use" argument in the past, but on further reflection about the interaction of creativity and structure, I'm not sure it stands, especially at temperature 0 aka zero creativity.)

Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by tsimionescu on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:25PM (#35235147)
It should be noted that the GP was asking a different question - they were asking whether OpenAI might have any claims of copyright over the output of their model, so that they might sue you for using the output of their model for your own business.
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by madamelic on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:04PM (#35235861)
The current ruling for AI generated images is that they cannot have copyright by anyone because copyright only covers human-generated works.

If a human didn't create it, it can't have a copyright.

Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by throwbadubadu on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:20PM (#35236170)
Hmm.. so there is also procedural computer art, writing code to produce nice images. Also not copyrightable? At least the code?

I draw an image. I write some lines of code that draws an image. I write many lines of code that do something, gather something, and then draws an image?

I just wonder how one can reasonably draw hard lines (and now I don't mean art :D) in the future.. there are so many ridiculous incarnations of copyright and patent fights already out there..

Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by layer8 on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:44PM (#35237506)
The principles are quite clear: Copyrightability is based on how much originality of a work is attributable to a human (because copyright law is limited to human creations). See [0]. In case of dispute, this has alway had to be assessed by a court on a case-by-case basis, there were never hard lines.

In the context of using AI or coding, the question is how much creative control you have over the output. When writing code to draw an image pixel by pixel, then you have full control, probably even for procedural art when you devised the algorithm completely on your own. When using an existing library that can draw crayon strokes or produce nice water color fills, there is less attributable to your own creativity. Similar for AI, where it will have to be assessed how much of the creativity is attributable to the human-invented prompting (likely not much) vs. to the AI.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threshold_of_originality

Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by bumby on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:38PM (#35237419)
Humans can claim processes as intellectual property though. The question in my mind is: if I develop AI that to perform some specific task (like image generation), does that constitute a specific patentable process? And thus, if you use that process without compensation, are you stealing my intellectual property?
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by Ekaros on Monday March 20, 2023 @05:14PM (#35238858)
Shouldn't this depend on the licensing terms of the AI you are using to generate the content. I haven't read the various terms of current offerings. But it is probably not unreasonable to include bad terms in there...
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by bumby on Monday March 20, 2023 @05:21PM (#35238949)
Maybe, assuming you are using a third-party's tool directly. But I guess I was thinking more about the issue of someone creating a process that is more easily replicable.

There are lots of instances of fairly fragile architectures that work really well in a particular application, but if you change some small part of that architecture, they fail. Now say I spend a lot of research time identifying that architecture and maybe even patent it as a process. I could even publish the methods of exactly what that process entails and somebody could copy it an use it. But I think that would be illegal (assuming AI can be patented in this way).

Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by acuozzo on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:06PM (#35235894)
Copyright covers "derived works", no?

Training an ML model doesn't seem to fall under the established exceptions which qualify as "fair use".

Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by basch on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:14PM (#35236047)
Fair use is a judgement. Fair use is an affirmative defense (admitting guilt, but saying you should be allowed to, like self defense.) A judge looks at the work and the framework and decides if fair use is an acceptable defense to infringement.

Given most of what we are talking about would fall under the output being used commercially, lets look at the end of of fair use test.

> the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and

>the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.

Unless your opponent is using a model exclusively trained on Twilight to output a Twilight sequel before you the author, you are going to have a have a hard time saying they used a large part of your work and that it directly displaces a sale of your work.

A collage of word samples from millions of works is going to fall under fair use. If the model did a good enough job of compressing your work in its entirety, and it outputs that copy, you might have a case.

Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by thwayunion on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:14PM (#35236049)
The OP was asking a different question with a different answer -- OP wanted to know if novel ChatGPT output is copyrightable, not whether existing copyrights might cover ChatGPT outputs. That said...

> The compression ratio of the source corpus versus the model demonstrates it doesn't have all the source material, ipso facto, results are not infringement.

What?! This is not at all how copyright law works and that's also not at all how LLMs or compression work! You're wrong about both the law and the technology!

Just because the model can't losslessly reproduce the entire training dataset doesn't mean that the model can't losslessly reproduce copyrightable fragments of the training dataset.

And the law truly doesn't give a damn that a verbatim copy of a piece of code or sequence of paragraphs came out of a model instead of a copy/paste from github. If it's the same basket of bits, or close enough in certain cases, it's covered by copyright, full stop.

> As an easy to understand analog, if you grab a Shutterstock photo, change it from 100% quality to 5% quality, the file size drops to 100th of the original and on display, none of the pixels are the same. While it may be the same general concept depicted badly, it is certainly not the original and clearly isn't copyrightable.

As an easier to understand analog, if you grab a BITMAP of a Shutterstock photo and convert the file type to a reasonable JPEG (lossy compression!!!), tht's very clearly still covered by the copyright on the .bmp.

Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by Terretta on Monday March 20, 2023 @08:53PM (#35241112)
You seem to have missed "Note: That last paragraph is firmly tongue in cheek /s"

Firmly tongue in cheek sarcasm, as in, this is obviously wrong.

Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by dragonwriter on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:18PM (#35236133)
> The compression ratio of the source corpus versus the model demonstrates it doesn’t have all the source material, ipso facto, results are not infringement.

Or, why making and redistributing a JPEG of a copyright-protected artwork is not infringement.

Results decidedly not guaranteed if you try this “a copy with lossy compression is not infringement” argument in an actual court of law.

Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by Terretta on Monday March 20, 2023 @08:54PM (#35241120)
> Results decidedly not guaranteed

You've replied in the spirit intended. :-)

Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use by nick_urban on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:37PM (#35235384)
Yes.

OpenAI ToS 3(a):

"OpenAI hereby assigns to you all its right, title and interest in and to Output. This means you can use Content for any purpose, including commercial purposes such as sale or publication, if you comply with these Terms."