Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use
by ilyt on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:40PM
(#35235444)
Or vice versa - when you only modify answer a bit ? I guess it would be derivative work ?
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use
by wongarsu on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:58PM
(#35237695)
It would be derivative work, which is copyrightable in the US. But you have to modify it enough to hit some threshold of originality.
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use
by CuriouslyC on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:26PM
(#35235172)
If you try to sue someone for copyright infringement and they demonstrate that what you're claiming is infringement is solely the result of model output, you're going to be out of luck, and honestly I don't think that's a problem - if your creation is so derivative that a model produces it via a reasonable prompt it probably doesn't deserve protection. Using prompt interrogation on a specially fine tuned model in an attempt to end-run a reasonable copyright is a different matter, but I don't think that'd be worth the effort for anyone to actually do.
If a copyright precedes the existence of a model, the model was trained on that code and someone distributes code from the model that is a near-verbatim reproduction, that's a different story (in large part because getting that near verbatim reproduction would probably require willful intent rather than just being accidental)
Re:Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use
by SllX on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:10PM
(#35235972)
Can you explain to a court why it is “generating” the original from scratch from a prompt and not simply retrieving the input and printing it to screen?
Just out of curiosity.
I don’t think the owner of the copyright loses copyright simply because something else output a copy of his work. Maybe it is “generated” but the copyright holder still has his rights per copyright statutes and you would still be violating those rights by distributing your own copies from the AI output.
Let's take that to the next step - what happens if ChatGPT happens to get trained on something that is copyrightable - then a prompt script can be used to reproduce the original - does that mean the original is now considered not protected by copyright?
This is a lot more murky than "show me the prompts/parameters" and it's not protected by copyright.