News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by driscoll42 on Sunday March 19, 2023 @11:16AM (#35219804)
Strange how you don't comment on the many more Russians that Putin has murdered by his unprovoked war of aggression as well.
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @11:27AM (#35219910)
Strange how you automatically feel the need to support one side and can't see the horrible outcome this has been for all parties. This could have been resolved through diplomacy. You never see the term even mentioned anymore.
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by luckylion on Sunday March 19, 2023 @11:28AM (#35219931)
> This could have been resolved through diplomacy.

Yes, by giving Ukraine to Russia.

We know how it works if you try to appease fascists, come on.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @11:45AM (#35220136)
This is a more complex than that. I don't like the invasion, but its not like Russia has no vital interests in the area that is right on their border. And they have occupied Crimea in the past going back to 1776. I'm just saying they have as much national interest as the West does. Israel Prime Minister claims they had a deal that was agreed to but Biden administration turned it down.

It's also the responsible thing to do to look at the prospects of forcing a war though, when the Urkainians are so heavily outgunned. 200,000 Ukrainians have died in this fight. Maybe 50,000 Russians have died (its hard to find out specifics). The US wants to fight this war on the cheap with the Ukrainians taking all the casualties so that Americans won't have to. That is pretty deplorable to me.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by luckylion on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:35PM (#35220710)
Of course Russia has vital interests all around it: everyone does. But it doesn't follow that "therefore Russia should be allowed to annex everything around it".

Again, we know that playbook, it has played out before in Europe. Today it's Ukraine, tomorrow it's Poland, and your arguments will still be exactly the same: Russia has vital interests in Poland, Russia has occupied Poland before, Poland is outgunned, and why would we care about Poland, really?

And then it's Germany, at which point, again, nothing has changed. Britain and France might use their nuclear deterrence when it's their turn, but if they listened to you, they'd probably say "do we want to end humanity just because we don't like Russia to rule over us? Surely not, humanity is too important to be destroyed over Russia's vital interest to annex whatever is next to Russia" and roll over.

It would end only when Russia invades the US or China, because neither will allow it if their nuclear weapons are still available by then.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @01:31PM (#35221410)
Stupid comment.

Ukraine is hopelessly outgunned. they are being led into a meat grinder. Thinking you can win a war by supplying it with weapons so that only Ukrainians will have to die, while you profit enormously from the weapons sales, and also let them take out your major geopolitical rival, is nothing short of dirty handed. Its downright sleezy, in my opinion.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by mopsi on Sunday March 19, 2023 @01:39PM (#35221510)
> Ukraine is hopelessly outgunned.

That hasn't been true since HIMARS arrived last summer. Now there's parity, and Russian war correspondents report that in some sectors Ukraine even exceeds Russian capabilities. In coming months, we'll see how the "hopelessly outgunned" army will do with more modern weapons in the upcoming spring counteroffensive. All we know right now is that the Russian winter offensive was a spectacular failure: worst casuality figures since the war began and nothing to show for it.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by luckylion on Sunday March 19, 2023 @03:24PM (#35222540)
You're making assumptions about me based on your projections. They're wrong.

I don't profit from any weapon sales, and it's the Ukrainians who want to fight. I'm certain especially Western Europe would've been much happier if Ukraine hadn't resisted and Russia could've swallowed them (your preferred option), because it would've meant no annoying break with your main provider of gas and oil.

But here we are, and some people are still claiming that Russia has the right to terrorize its neighbors because hurr durr Red Army strong.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by yesenadam on Sunday March 19, 2023 @03:24PM (#35222543)
> Stupid comment.

Please don't talk anything like this in future on HN, thanks, regardless of what the other person says. You wrote similar things several other times on this page.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by dang on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:23PM (#35223792)
You've posted dozens of flamewar comments to this thread and broke the site guidelines egregiously. That's abusive, regardless of how wrong other people are or you feel they are or how right you are or you feel they are. We ban accounts that do this. I'm not going to ban you because everyone goes on tilt sometimes, but if you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and take the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd appreciate it.
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by CamperBob2 on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:13PM (#35220423)
Your casualty figures don't seem to line up with most other sources. Any citations?
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:25PM (#35220590)
The sources are all over the place, but they all seem to be horrific. There are estimates that Ukrainian deaths so far could be anywhere from 100K to 200K.

Russians have lost a lot too. But the only thing we know is that they are depressingly high.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday March 19, 2023 @01:08PM (#35221121)
> The sources are all over the place

You gave specific figures. From which source, and why choose that one?

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by schuyler2d on Monday March 20, 2023 @08:59AM (#35230831)
What about Ukraine's national interest? Where does that fit in?

What about the Eastern European countries' interests whose combined economies eclipses Russia?

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by misnome on Sunday March 19, 2023 @11:55AM (#35220235)
One side could unilaterally end the war in one word.

Strange that it’s only in the interests of that side that people call for this.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:23PM (#35220559)
that's not how the world works. Peace deals can happen, but everyone has to put everything on the table. When people dig in and are stubborn, that's when we get hundreds of thousands of deaths.
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by mindslight on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:39PM (#35220773)
* * *
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by jcranmer on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:58PM (#35221000)
> When people dig in and are stubborn

Such as when you decide to announce a rushed annexation of your enemy's lands after your army suffers the biggest rout of the 21st century? While claiming that this war isn't about trying to annex your enemy's lands, after all...

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by seattle_spring on Sunday March 19, 2023 @11:59AM (#35220270)
Just curious, what are your primary sources of information that have shaped your opinions and perspectives shown in this thread?
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:08PM (#35220376)
Quite a few. I try to listen to what everyone is saying. It always makes me nervous when the media seem to march in lockstep.

Looks into what David Sacks has been saying. He got into it on the ALL-in podcast a couple of weeks ago, but you can find him on Twitter. He says the corruption in Ukraine right now is off the charts. Higher than anything in any corrupt Latin American country. Its difficult to decipher what is going on in Ukraine right now, because there's so much propaganda from all sides.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:38PM (#35220750)
* * *
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @01:25PM (#35221333)
No idea what a random forwards is.

Look at what David Sacks has been saying. There are many benefiting from this war. Neither Russia nor ukraine are on that list.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:27PM (#35223834)
> Look at what David Sacks has been saying

Is that your top 3, your "listen to everyone" ? One guy. That does not even answer the "top 3" question meaningfully.

One guy: David Sacks; a Paypal and Thiel aligned guy, who unironically calls Russia's invasion "Woke War III" ? Not a geopolitics guy, just a a rich "culture war" guy? This has less than zero credibility to me.

While I am sorry that your information diet is so poor, both in quality and in variety; but I have no interest in you recommending the same to me. Sort yourself out first.

> No idea what a random forwards is.

Do you follow the youtube algorithm then? That would explain this amateur hour.