News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by justinclift on Saturday March 18, 2023 @07:58AM (#35208333)

    Did you know that out-of-the-box, Edge will transmit the content of
    your text boxes on web pages to the Microsoft Editor service for the
    purpose of grammatical suggestions? I have no idea how this concept
    got past legal but hey, it’s on by default now.
Holy shit. :(

At what point are some of the major government legal departments actually going to step up and sort this shit out?

It is so, so, so, so, so far past overdue. Yet nothing. :(

Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by ChuckNorris89 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @08:17AM (#35208460)
Chrome does the same thing for textboxes if you use enhanced spell checking.

>Enhanced spell check Uses the same spell checker that’s used in Google search. Text you type in the browser is sent to Google.

Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by imajoredinecon on Saturday March 18, 2023 @09:49AM (#35209108)
The difference is that Google has come under enough historical privacy flak that they now aggressively privacy red-team new functionality like this and do things like make it opt-in.
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by justinclift on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:49AM (#35210056)
That seems new?
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by Nextgrid on Saturday March 18, 2023 @09:53AM (#35209141)
Is there an actual example of what these "enhanced" spell-checkers provide over basic ones that run locally? To me it seems like spell checking is a problem that Word from over a decade ago solved well enough (and ran fine on that era's hardware).
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by delecti on Saturday March 18, 2023 @10:57AM (#35209601)
A normal local spellcheck requires you to be much closer to the word than an "enhanced" one. As an example, if I search Google for "nucrusift" ("microsoft", but typed with my right hand one space to the left, a fairly common category of typo IME), it suggests a search for "Microsoft". The built-in spellcheck in Chrome (which I'm using to type this comment) does not offer any suggestions to correct "nucrusift".
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by pseudalopex on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:27AM (#35209839)
iOS's local spell check suggested Microsoft.
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by delecti on Saturday March 18, 2023 @12:42PM (#35210604)
I just tried for myself, and that was the keyboard's auto-complete, not the OS's spell-check, a subtle but IMO important difference. I think it's reasonable to expect the keyboard to catch that kind of typo, given it inherently has to do that kind of fuzzy logic to determine words anyway.

When I entered that same string into iOS Safari in a text box replying to your comment, deliberately bypassing the keyboard's auto-complete, it had no suggestions.

Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by pseudalopex on Saturday March 18, 2023 @01:06PM (#35210896)
Marking unrecognized words, suggesting spellings, and auto correct are 3 different features if you want to split hairs. The distinction is not relevant to the claim a layout aware suggestion could not be produced locally.
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by delecti on Saturday March 18, 2023 @03:32PM (#35212312)
I didn't say it could not be produced locally. I was just providing "an actual example of what these "enhanced" spell-checkers provide over basic ones that run locally." I'm merely speaking to what is, not what could be.
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by pseudalopex on Saturday March 18, 2023 @08:20PM (#35214613)
I didn't say you made the claim. It's funny how words we choose can imply things.
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by Someone1234 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:59AM (#35210146)
They use ngrams[0] and provide much more current dictionaries that won't flag non-dictionary words that are popular phases (think Urban Dictionary-like words/phases). The closest thing to something like Grammarly, Microsoft Editor, or Google's Enhanced spell check that you can run locally is Language Tool's local HTTP (java) server[1] combined with the Language Tool extension, and installing an ngram database[2]. But that won't give you the up-to-date phase information and you'll get red-squiggles under common phases that aren't dictionary words yet (e.g. Fluffernutter, Copypasta, Deplatform, et al).

Is it worth using these services given the privacy implications? Only you can answer that. I personally wish we had better local offerings, but I just don't think anyone wants to fund it when there's almost no revenue to be made.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N-gram

[1] https://dev.languagetool.org/http-server.html

[2] https://dev.languagetool.org/finding-errors-using-n-gram-dat...

Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by 5- on Saturday March 18, 2023 @04:26PM (#35212790)
what about that newer dictionary cannot be provided by a download?

your browser probably updates itself every week or so.

there is absolutely nothing about these kinds of services that require running them on someone else's computer, save for conspiratorial reasons.

see also: machine translation (apple offline translate, firefox translations et al work just fine on your machine).

Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by binarycrusader on Saturday March 18, 2023 @08:34PM (#35214705)
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by Ygg2 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @08:57AM (#35208714)
> At what point are some of the major government legal departments actually going to step up

Why would they? It's cheap intelligence on their opponents. Bypasses those pesky constitution laws. Win-win.

Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by favaq on Saturday March 18, 2023 @10:03AM (#35209201)
It helps to read TOS/EULA/etc. If you agree to something then you shouldn't be complaining about it.
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by alpaca128 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @10:18AM (#35209334)
No. In many places getting consent by deceptive/malicious means is illegal, and EULAs cannot override laws. That's why Google's cookie popups now have a "reject all" button after a $170 million fine.
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by macintux on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:08AM (#35209691)
10 years ago it would take a month of workdays. I have to imagine it's much worse now.

https://www.techdirt.com/2012/04/23/to-read-all-privacy-poli...

Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by favaq on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:54AM (#35210097)
Then don't use the software, you can't just sign a contract and then back off because you didn't have time to read it before you signed it.
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by justinclift on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:59AM (#35210147)
Interestingly, when I booted up a Win10 VM (with internet access) a few weeks ago some Edge window appeared, took over the screen, and wanted to force me to go through their preferences/setup wizard.

By "force" I mean "giving no other options". No "skip", "do it later" (or similar), and no way to quit.

Had to outright kill the task in the windows process manager, as there's zero chance I want anything to do with Edge.

So "don't use the software" is workable for people who know how to kill tasks.

But MS will be pulling that shit on average consumers too.

Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by omoikane on Saturday March 18, 2023 @12:08PM (#35210233)
There is a website that summarizes terms of services:

https://tosdr.org/

The about page says it started in June 2012, shortly after that techdirt article.

Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by justinclift on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:50AM (#35210072)
Oh, there's no chance in hell I'll ever use Edge personally. Learned a long, long time ago not to trust MS.
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by otikik on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:56AM (#35210118)
Well I have an EULA in my living room closet that allows everyone who wants to complain. If you don’t agree you can find my closet and write your name on the exception list. You must use Cyrillic letters.
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by pongo1231 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:20PM (#35211695)
Yes, let us let tech giants freely see how much dystopian shit they can get away with without any kind of pushback because their ToS has a vague remark at page 30 that might grant them the ability to do so. That is the kind of future we want.
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by CatWChainsaw on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:32AM (#35218321)
I think you realize how unrealistic and out of touch that is, and just take pleasure in being a pill.
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by throwbackhere on Saturday March 18, 2023 @10:59AM (#35209617)
Your comment reminded me of the new grammar checking feature on my phone. It better not be what I think it is.

EDIT 1: I just checked and, fucking hell, it's grammarly! Samsung sneaked in an update that was silently leaking everything I wrote to fucking grammarly. This can be disabled by pressing the gear button and accessing the hidden writing assistant menu.

Good hardware is not worth risking my private information. Samsung, this will be the last time I buy a phone from you.

EDIT 2: Couldn't find anything about this on Samsung's website. Found more information on grammarly: https://support.grammarly.com/hc/en-us/articles/440798862017...

Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by kzrdude on Saturday March 18, 2023 @12:33PM (#35210494)
Thanks for the notice, so that I could turn it off. My kbd is Gboard though, so it should be unaffected, by that particular thing. I would recommend Gboard. I use it for better multilingual support.
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by PufPufPuf on Sunday March 19, 2023 @06:31AM (#35217670)
If you don't want your text sent to a corporation, I don't think Gboard is the answer
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by kzrdude on Sunday March 19, 2023 @07:04AM (#35217818)
I think it has settings for that
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by jasonlotito on Saturday March 18, 2023 @05:53PM (#35213464)
> Samsung sneaked in an update that was silently leaking everything I wrote to fucking grammarly.

It's not leaking if it's intentional. Leaking makes it sound like it was mistake.

Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by web3-is-a-scam on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:06AM (#35209671)
Why would governments be opposed to free mass surveillance. Microsoft is one of the biggest cronies in Washington.
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by justinclift on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:55AM (#35210107)
It also surveils politicians, higher end public servants, and other law-involved decision makers who you'd think would have a problem with it.

Maybe there's a blackmail and bribery department looking at what those people have been writing? (/s)

Lets see if that "backlash against big tech" thing actually goes anyone. One can hope. :)

Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by phendrenad2 on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:54AM (#35217507)
Most people want free grammar-checking, what are you suggesting exactly?
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by deafpolygon on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:26AM (#35218281)
Well, here is what Microsoft says on the privacy for this service:

> By default, Microsoft Edge provides spelling and grammar checking using Microsoft Editor. When using Microsoft Editor, Microsoft Edge sends your typed text and a service token to a Microsoft cloud service over a secure HTTPS connection. The service token doesn't contain any user-identifiable information. A Microsoft cloud service then processes the text to detect spelling and grammar errors in your text. All your typed text that's sent to Microsoft is deleted immediately after processing occurs. No data is stored for any period of time.

So, they don't keep any data using this.

But it's unclear since they also do text prediction; which can be toggled separately in Edge.

> If the Use text prediction toggle is turned on, Microsoft Edge sends the text in the text box, your top language from the browser setting, and a text box identifier to a Microsoft cloud service over a secure HTTPS connection. The text box identifier is not associated with your account. The Microsoft cloud service processes the text to generate a relevant text prediction. Typed characters and text predictions are cached for up to 30 days, for service quality and performance improvement purposes only.

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/privacy-whi...

Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by justinclift on Sunday March 19, 2023 @09:04AM (#35218528)
> A Microsoft cloud service then processes the text to detect spelling and grammar errors in your text. All your typed text that's sent to Microsoft is deleted immediately after processing occurs. No data is stored for any period of time.

Interestingly, if they also share the text with third parties, then every one of those statements could still be completely true.

Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by deafpolygon on Sunday March 19, 2023 @01:53PM (#35221658)
Do you think they are being deceptive?
Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by justinclift on Sunday March 19, 2023 @09:24PM (#35226049)
Who knows for sure as to the current state of things, and what they may do in future.

But, it's the kind of hole in their wording they could drive a truck though. ;)

Personally, I'd be very surprised if they're not using people's written text as training data for various "AI" efforts. Let alone sharing the data with other parties.

Watching MS operate for a couple of decades has shown that if they see an opportunity to do something shitty, they'll probably take it. o_O

Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by deafpolygon on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:49AM (#35227755)
Well, if we're going to do that.

Apple has shown that they'd willingly help themselves to your data, while protecting you from others accessing it. Who knows what Apple will do with it? For all we know, iCloud Drive is now E2EE because they've figured out a way to ingest metadata and other information about your file as they store them. I mean, we don't know for sure if it's encrypted before being stored or not. All we know is it is now encrypted if you turn it on and Apple has no access to it. But to say nothing of it before or after. (/tinfoil on)

I'm not a Microsoft apologist, but I don't think they'd need to lie: "No data is stored for any period of time."

Anytime they've done shitty things, they have more or less been caught.

> if they also share the text with third parties

Legally, they have to share whether this data is being shared with third parties. It's about all we can do these days - for all you know, HN is collecting data on your activity and selling it to third parties for extra $. (Unlikely, but if we're gonna put our tinfoil hats on... no one is beyond suspicion! /s)

In any event, I know what it's doing and I'm not under any illusions that this is a privacy issue. I only use it to write things that will end up in public spaces anyways (such as HN, or Reddit). Any of my more private type of writing is done with offline tools.

Re:The dark defaults of Microsoft Edge by hulitu on Monday March 20, 2023 @07:50AM (#35230202)
> At what point are some of the major government legal departments actually going to step up and sort this shit out?

At the point when their love relationship with US will end up in divorce. So not in the near future.