News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by ibejoeb on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:04PM (#35172311)
Hell of a license:

----

INVESTIGATIONS, MONITORING, & NO OBLIGATION TO PRE-SCREEN CONTENT. Zed may, but is not obligated to, investigate, monitor, pre-screen, remove, refuse, or review the Service and/or Content, including Your Content and User Content, at any time. By entering into the Agreement, you hereby provide your irrevocable consent to such monitoring. You acknowledge and agree that you have no expectation of privacy concerning the transmission of Your Content, including without limitation chat, text, or voice communications. In the event that Zed pre-screens, refuses or removes any Content, you acknowledge that Zed will do so for Zed’s benefit, not yours.

----

Irrevocable consent.

Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by maxbrunsfeld on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:22PM (#35172512)
Thanks for pointing this out. Our whole terms-of-service is just standard boilerplate provided by our lawyers, but this part doesn't really apply to Zed. Obviously, there's no "content moderation" for project code that you collaborate on with Zed.

We'll look into adjusting this to make it clearer that we don't do anything remotely concerning or invasive.

Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by Meekro on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:26PM (#35172578)
I'm glad to hear you'll be addressing this. To an unsophisticated reader like myself, it sounds like you guys are planning to examine the code I edit in Zed, maybe even keep copies of it. Aside from the general creepiness, many programmers are bound by contract to protect their employer's codebase.
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by ibejoeb on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:30PM (#35172636)
Thanks for addressing it.

Also: the thing looks really compelling. I would really like to try it out. But I can't use it. Not with irrevocable consent. If I make something that turns into billions of dollars...well, there are people that would exploit these terms. It's an absolute no-go.

> Obviously, there's no "content moderation" for project code that you collaborate on with Zed.

Not only is it non-obvious, it's explicitly stated that you can do what you want with any content that you are exposed to, which is all of it, because you've granted yourself the ability to surveil everything. And not only what the "Application" or "Tool" sees, but by any means available to you by the "Service."

Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by jgalt212 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:26PM (#35172576)
Fair enough, but why not push back on the lawyers before pushing the publish button, and spare yourself from a possibly inauspicious start?
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by throwawaysalome on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:43PM (#35172844)
Because most reasonable people don't cavil about self-evident boilerplate.
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by version_five on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:10PM (#35173250)
This sounds like a jab at people that are raising this as a concern. Maybe I'm looking at it wrong.

What I've seen is that lawyers or anyone drafting agreements generally likes to overstate their position, or put another way take as much as they can get away with. It's rarely done with explicit malicious intent, more with negotiation in mind. Ask for more than you want and then go back and forth to arrive at something that works.

It's just sort of an added bonus if people agree with the terms.

So anyway, it's incumbent on those negotiating and agreeing to contracts to read what they're signing up for and discuss to arrive at an actual agreement that serves everybody. What happened in the discussion above is actually a great example of that happening, even if it was inadvertent.

Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by temporary22 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:44PM (#35173700)
And this is NOT self evident boilerplate. It's quite the opposite, and I do not believe any company would get a product out without reviewing the T&C.

So, the terms were at least approved by some, and are now being revised because somebody pointed the problems out in a public forum.

Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by foxandmouse on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @05:27PM (#35174959)
When you go to a tailor for a custom suit, do you double-check that he's taken accurate measurements?
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by jgalt212 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @05:37PM (#35175071)
I do check that it fits and that he's delivering what I've asked him to deliver. And if I don't know what a good custom suit should be, then I should not buy one, or I should seek assistance in its purchase.
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by igetspam on Thursday March 16, 2023 @08:12AM (#35180883)
I don't own a custom suit but I assume I'd be in the room when they were taking my measurements and I my eyes would be open, so I could see the tape. And then I'd try it own before agreeing to taking it home. I'm not sure which side of the argument your analogy is on.

I do a lot of back and forth with our lawyers on terms. I read all of it and give feedback.

Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by foxandmouse on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @05:23PM (#35174918)
Thanks for the refreshing honesty! The law industry already seems to use (dumb) automation, no wonder they're so afraid of AGI replacing them.
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by foolswisdom on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @06:01PM (#35175344)
I can sorta believe that this was provided by lawyers without proper review, because writing this

> In the event that Zed pre-screens, refuses or removes any Content, you acknowledge that Zed will do so for Zed’s benefit, not yours.

is such an outrageous thing to write in the terms. On the other hand, claiming this is standard boilerplate strains credulity.

In any case, seeing this definitely colors how I see the rest of it.

Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by nicoburns on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @07:03PM (#35175895)
You might also want to consider only asking the user to agree to it when initiating use of the collaborative service rather than when they install the app.
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by zamalek on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @07:29PM (#35176121)
> License: Zed will do so for Zed’s benefit, not yours.

Never in my life have I seen such a boisterous "fuck you" in a legal document. Who are your lawyers, and what on Earth (or off Earth for that matter) are they smoking? In what alternate reality is this a "boilerplate" EULA?

I mean, holy shit.

Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by zamalek on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:15PM (#35172434)
Privacy issues aside, this makes it unusable in a professional setting. Maybe this is a feature for monetization?
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by bluelightning2k on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:08PM (#35172369)
Wait WHAT. That sounds like an April fools license...
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by version_five on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:10PM (#35172401)
Not in anyway justifying it, but is this for some kind of "social" feature or does it actually relate to code you write?

I wonder if this is for some kind of content moderation law compliance? It's a shitty licence but exactly the behavior that's incentivized by governments imposing content moderation rules

Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by ibejoeb on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:26PM (#35172572)
Regardless of intent, the way it is written is that the "Service" is what you're agreeing to, and that includes license to run a single instance of the "Application" and the "Tool" on a single device that you own.

It's incompatible with pretty much any activity. It also includes great stuff like:

> you agree to (a) provide true, accurate, current, and complete information about yourself as prompted by the registration form (the “Registration Data”), and (b) maintain and promptly update the Registration Data to keep it true, accurate, current, and complete.

> You agree not to create an Account using a false identity

Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by TedDoesntTalk on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:40PM (#35174407)
So when I move, I have to update Zed with my new address or what? My license is legally invalid? I'm in breach of terms of service?
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by ibejoeb on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:55PM (#35174592)
Yes.

"If you provide any information that is untrue, inaccurate, not current or incomplete, or Zed has reasonable grounds to suspect that any information you provide is untrue, inaccurate, not current or incomplete, Zed has the right to suspend or terminate your Account and refuse any and all current or future use of the Service"

(Oxford commas, bruh.)

"you acknowledge and agree that you shall have no ownership or other property interest in your Account, and you further acknowledge and agree that all rights in and to your Account are and shall forever be owned by and inure to the benefit of Zed."

Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by u320 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:26PM (#35172570)
Yes this is for stuff you upload to their "service" whatever that is. It has nothing to do with the editor itself.
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by ibejoeb on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:33PM (#35172687)
Can you please point out where you find this exclusion? You may be right, and it's hard to examine with the dual numbering system in there, but I've been through it and I don't see anything other than "everything is ours."
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by jdc0589 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:08PM (#35172382)
yea, thats gonna be a no for me dawg
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by kybernetyk on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:31PM (#35172654)
Luckily I read this comment before starting the thing. (I as always clicked "agree" on the license/TOS screen).

Into the ~/.Trash it goes.

Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by babelfish on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:21PM (#35172508)
That sounds unconscionable, wonder if it would hold up in court (my guess is not).
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by kybernetyk on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:33PM (#35172689)
But do you have the funds/time to find out?
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by babelfish on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:35PM (#35173571)
I do, but I wouldn't use this editor based on the ToC alone.
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by waynesonfire on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:11PM (#35172421)
Thanks for saving me time.
Re:Zed, the new code editor from Atom developers, has entere... by nathansobo on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @05:44PM (#35175149)
Hey, we're actively working to get in touch with a new lawyer to help us do a better job with this. I agree this isn't cool. I was rushed to get the launch out and didn't review the terms carefully enough. We will try to do better going forward. Our goal is to be respectful.