Why? HTM bonds are not cash so they are not interchangeable. This is like if you were forced to accept a 10 year IOU in place of cash from your employer.
Banks exist at the whim of the gov't, it can require things for stability.
With your proposition, I think it would be a terrible idea and reduce stability. I don't see how letting Banks unload bad assets on each other does anything to help the situation. The Bad Assets just follow the customer wherever they go and some unlucky Bank get stuck with them when the customer converts their cash to something like stocks or buys a cheeseburger.
At best, you have just turned bonds into the same thing as cash, defeating the purpose of bonds to begin with. You buy a bond and are paid interest because you can't use it as cash.
At worst it would be chaos. Everyone buys bonds and holds them when the value is good. When the value is bad, everyone forces each other to take over their bad Investments.
What is the difference between what you are saying and just buying back the bonds before maturity?
Anyway, governments do usually have all kinds of lines of credit against bonds. And when there is a difference, it's for the benefit of the government.
Or the bank could have bought TIPS instead, I guess.
AFAIK, the thing the FDIC does is confiscate banks. Do they do anything else?
In this case, all depositors with no limit.
They don't lend money, don't put money in it, don't do anything else. They take the bank for themselves, and then proceed to pay the depositors.
Yes, the Fed basically did this.
See the recently (Sunday) announced "Bank Term Funding Program", which basically says if banks hold securities from the Federal government, the Federal Reserve will accept it as collateral for a loan, the collateral valued at par.
https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/mone...
The Proposal is closer to the idea that you should be able to pay your cash debt with stock valued at your purchase price, and not at the current market price.
It would mean that a bank that owes another bank $100 could instead pay with Bond currently valued at $50, and then go out on the market and buy two identical new bonds with the money they saved.
The repo market is vast and generally massively liquid; trillions of dollars of funding per day.
Or that the bank should be able to say "depositor X transferred $100 million to Chase, so we sent Chase a wire for $10 million and treasuries marked HTM worth $90 million" or something.