News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Vindication of Ask Jeeves by harry8 on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @05:12PM (#35075466)
Search appears to be dead.

Recent example. I've got a pine64 a64 board with an ES9023 audio "POT" daughter board that runs and boots linux using armbian fine. Doesn't know about the ES9023 audio DAC, spdif and i2s(?) rca output. Ok so first thing I think of is, what kernel module is the driver for it so I know if it is even available or do I need to compile a kernel.

Sure pine64 documentation is woeful unless you want to read schematics or something so it could have been there, but it isn't. This should not be a hard question to answer with a search engine.

pine64 a64 audio es9203 linux kernel driver

Try it. Watch google do the wrong thing no matter what you do. Quote. allintext: you name it. It's nuts. Google wants to show you what it wants, not what you want. That appears to be what it is. You want to find something, get stuffed. Google is no use to find things. Google is good to show you things it chooses in the general area of your interest. Ok but that is not a "search" engine. It's a recommendation system, fine if that is what you want but a flipping diaster of orwellian proportions if that recommendation engine is the best we have for search and we haven't noted it and responded.

I'm more likely to get the answer faster posting about how garbage google search his than repeatedly trying different google "tricks" just crazy.

So yeah the answer I really want is what else can we use that actually does search?

Re:The Vindication of Ask Jeeves by Nition on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @05:36PM (#35075735)
What's the ideal result you'd want for that search?

This is what I get: https://i.imgur.com/t0roTR2.png

Re:The Vindication of Ask Jeeves by harry8 on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @05:39PM (#35075766)
So the question I want to answer is "What is the name of the kernel module that drives the es9023 daughter board on the pine64 a64"

Which of those results are you recommending as the answer?

edit: completely and totally prepared to accept I'm being a moron. The name of the driver, the link where you got it and how you got the link from google and I will decry it loudly here.

Re:The Vindication of Ask Jeeves by chiph on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @05:53PM (#35075913)
I gave ChatGPT a try - it just tells you to use lsmod and modinfo
Re:The Vindication of Ask Jeeves by harry8 on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @06:01PM (#35075983)
So google is as uselss for actual search as chatgpt nowadays...
Re:The Vindication of Ask Jeeves by norvvryo on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @07:57PM (#35076973)
Bing Chat suggests the "snd_soc_pcm5102a" and "snd_soc_hifiberry_dac" drivers in creative mode, "snd_soc_es9023" in balanced, and failed to return results in precise. I doubt that's accurate.

I tried using Startpage and DDG to see if I could do any better. I mostly found people complaining that their ES9023 POT wasn't working.

PINE64's forum search returned a few topics with half-answers. Apparently a distro called "Volumio" works? There's a report of someone having success after modifying asound.conf on Debian Stretch.

This leads me to believe that there's not much useful information about the POT, or that it's being posted somewhere that doesn't get indexed.

Re:The Vindication of Ask Jeeves by Nition on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @06:02PM (#35076000)
You're not being stupid, I couldn't find that either.

Although I do notice you wrote 9203 instead of 9023 in your suggested search. I get slightly more 9023-specific results with 9023 there: https://i.imgur.com/V5ty2In.png

I do think maybe you're expecting a little too much of any search engine for such an obscure query.

Re:The Vindication of Ask Jeeves by harry8 on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @06:08PM (#35076062)
Typo fixed.

That's not obscure imho. What kernel driver do I use for this hardware is /exactly/ the kind of search google built its reputation on back in the old days when they did search.

The shock for me is I really /expect/ that to be easy becuase so very many similar searches have been, using google search, before. I've noticed it getting steadily worse along these lines in ways it really did not used to be. I've noticed it being because it wants to recommend not search. Seems others are noticing the same.

What alternative strategies do we have for search where we used to rely on google and now cannot?

Re:The Vindication of Ask Jeeves by vlovich123 on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @06:56PM (#35076447)
I think what OP means is that there may not be a webpage answering this in the first place and thus there’s nothing for Google to index and return. Now of course, a sufficiently smart AI could know how to answer your query directly even if there’s no answer to your question made online. I don’t think the current batch of AI technologies can do that reliably.

Edit: also doing a search for “kernel module es9023” yields enough hints that to me indicates that there isn’t support for it even without it being a daughter board and thus there is no module. So the reason you’re not finding an answer is because there isn’t support for it and there’s no results confirming this 100% because it’s a very esoteric niche question. That you think it’s not is perhaps an inability to estimate how many people might be trying to run audio on this combination of hardware.

Re:The Vindication of Ask Jeeves by harry8 on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:30PM (#35078027)
Sure, reasonable inference except due to related reading I'm 100% sure a module exists. And works. What is it?
Re:The Vindication of Ask Jeeves by vlovich123 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:19AM (#35079578)
lsmod + process of elimination and/or dumping the symbols. Are you also sure it's a loaded module rather than just being compiled into the kernel?

If you figure it out and update this thread, I'm sure Google will have an actually useful answer for the next person.

Re:The Vindication of Ask Jeeves by harry8 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @05:50AM (#35080051)
the hardware is NOT seen by the kernel. Does the kernel have the driver at all or do I need to compile a new kernel?

Ok so what is the name of the module that has the driver?

I'm sure that it ain't that hard to find out. I'm sure google with some google-fu used to give you an answer to exactly this kind of question in no more than 5 minutes of googling. 10 at most. I'm sure the driver exists.

Try it. Really. Watch google repeatedly drop and change your keywords, claim it hasn't then return pages with crucial keywords absent.

It's recommending. It's not searching. There is a difference and for this kind of thing it sucks very hard. You must have examples you've seen. This isn't my first it just came up in the last week so I picked on it here.

Re:The Vindication of Ask Jeeves by vlovich123 on Friday March 10, 2023 @03:09AM (#35091811)
What makes you think there is any support for this hardware? By all accounts reports on the internet indicate that there isn’t any support so you’re asking Google for evidence of existence for a thing that doesn’t. And the topic is nice enough that it can’t find clear examples of counterfactual. This is also a bad use of Google. For something like this why not ask on the LKML? Something like this is perfect for that.
Re:The Vindication of Ask Jeeves by harry8 on Saturday March 11, 2023 @11:47PM (#35116773)
Ask people who know on lkml. Yeah sure google is no good to find this out. It used to be and that has changed. Which is my point.

> What makes you think there is any support for this hardware?

Because I tracked it down reading forum posts, lkml, armbian docs, etc. Timeconsuming. Good test that google was no good for any of you either.

Google does recommendation, not search. It has happened and you don't have to like it.