If that alone gets you thrown in jail, then you're going to be jailing a lot of innocent people. On the other hand, if that does not get you thrown in jail, then one can simply claim to have forgotten the password without repercussion.
Personally, I'd rather let people hide evidence by encrypting it than jail people for being forgetful, since those seem to be the only two choices.
I'm thinking about the case where a person never even knew the key to what they have. The example is a business laptop being carried through customs, that was encrypted by someone else, who will decrypt it upon your arrival (or something similar)
2. I would seriously reconsider the decision to carry unknown contents through customs.
My ISP does this billions of times per day.
head -c 1048576 /dev/random >not_encrypted_I_promise
I can't prove that file isn't actually encrypted data. Are we going to throw people in jail for possessing random data without a justification?i think for his question to even be made, it was assumed he was being accused of possessing encrypted something.
Let's attach the old guy from france that got into the 3 strike law without even having a computer at the time. Now let's say instead of getting the IP of that old guy from france, the police got the IP of the comment above yours, from let's say mr Buttle. Now they confuse him with Mr Tuttle and assume he has encrypted criminal data. but all they could find on his computer is the file "not_encrypted_i_promise".
he is then throw in jail because he failed to provide the password. His infective defense was that he was "playing" with philosophical questions regarding encryption.
ignore the mistaken identity, was just a means to reach the false/wrong accusation resulting in the experiment he just did convicting him.
the guy has a file that is pure garbage. not encrypted.
the law officers THINK it's encrypted. the judge orders him to give the key. ...there's no key. it's honestly garbage data.
That's what make encryption special. It were a safe, the police could crack it open somehow. with encryption, they can just claim it's too advanced to be cracked and that will be treated like you are lying.
You have no need to prove it isn't actually encrypted data. All you must do is debunk whatever evidence they provide that it is encrypted. The prosecution must present compelling evidence that it isn't random data.
Seems to me that the only way to reasonably apply "innocent until proven guilty" there is to only convict if they know what the encrypted contents are, and if they can already prove that beyond a reasonable doubt, why do they even need you to decrypt them for you? Conversely, if they don't know the contents, then they may well be innocent, and the password innocently forgotten.
According to the article, Judge Blackburn's reasoning was that if defendants can be required to produce other documents, the existence of which is known, they can be required to "produce" encrypted documents via decrypting.
I certainly don't want to see mandatory decryption, but at the same time it doesn't make sense to let an accused completely skip out on discovery by simply truecrypt-ing the evidence either.