News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by wood_spirit on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @12:10PM (#35057900)
It’s sad but he’ll probably forever now be remembered as “that guy who got publicly fired on Twitter by Musk” rather than Iceland’s person of the year 2022 and all the great philanthropy he’s done :(
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by vaidhy on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @12:19PM (#35058059)
I wonder if that will be the new badge of honor
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by rideontime on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @12:45PM (#35058471)
It already is, in some people's opinions.
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by capableweb on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @12:44PM (#35058459)
No, he won't. Things like this are "hot news this week" while the other things are accomplishments in life. He'll surely be remembered for the much more important things he has done and the much more important things he'll do in the future.
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by mr_woozy on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @12:52PM (#35058557)
Icelander here, we're all a bit chuffed at the moment that the world is recognizing what a cool individual he is. We already knew it here.
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by archagon on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @01:39PM (#35059250)
Personally, I just learned about a really interesting new person to follow. (Too bad he’s not on Mastodon.)
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by runarberg on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @02:29PM (#35059991)
He was already a celebrity in Iceland. So much so that he acted in the end of year comedy show (which is the nr. 1 television event in Iceland) despite not being an actor (which is rare; kind of like appearing in the Superbowl for Americans, or Eurovision for Europeans [although now I wouldn’t be surprised to see him there also next May]). In one recent event he had the president come and vandalize a poster for his ramp project with a spray can, striking out 1000 ramps and spraying 1500 rapms over it.

Internationally he might be most known for this, but in Iceland he is known for far more. I have no doubt people will laugh with him in the next end of year comedy show about this incident, and then continue supporting him in his disability activism.

Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by rvbissell on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @03:39PM (#35060877)
I dunno, "Publicly fired by Elon!™" is a strong resume flex.
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by peyton on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @12:11PM (#35057917)
Ok it does sound like he was coasting.
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by 206lol on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @12:16PM (#35058028)
The guy seems incredibly driven, doing all sorts of stuff to improve access for people with disabilities, for instance. I'd assume Twitter was dysfunctional before this guy was.
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by brigadier132 on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @12:14PM (#35057984)
I believe him when he says he was asking for work and nobody gave him anything to do. I've had that happen to me many times at the "best" tech companies. Yes not having work to give people is a valid reason to lay someone off but not to publicly humiliate them and be cruel.
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by yardie on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @12:20PM (#35058076)
Twitter acquired his company and kept him on as an employee. A lot of times founders end up having to coast because the buyer is still trying to sort out how to merge the tech. The founder is basically on garden leave/on-call tech support until a strategy is in place. Some never get there, vest a few years, and start a new company.
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by wjnc on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @12:41PM (#35058403)
They kept him on as ‘senior director’ in his words. I think the senior directors in my company are quite capable as senior directors setting strategy, priority, creating valuable work environments and sometimes add some value in tactics and logistics. Never, ever are they to do any work. Don’t let them touch customers, processes or god forbid use any tooling. It’s been decades for the most of them. De facto demotion is a sorry excuse for firing with a good package. Notable exception for the phase nearing retirement where awesome firms put these types in risk management and audit.
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by vaidhy on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @12:18PM (#35058049)
Really?? It sounds like he was managing teams rather than being an IC..
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by yunohn on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @12:15PM (#35058007)
I think you're describing all managerial positions if you think he was coasting.
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by bmitc on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @12:49PM (#35058522)
There were front page posts on this earlier today, but both were flagged and buried by Hacker News.

Thread on person of the year: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35056098

Thread on Twitter saga: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35055839

Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by mustacheemperor on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @01:18PM (#35058937)
Disappointing to see they were flagged, but moreso to see the apparent ratio between downvotes and negative comments on those threads.

Apparently a large subset of the community felt those posts should be removed from the front page, but didn’t feel obliged to explain why. It’s like Elon is becoming a radioactive element for this community’s health too.

Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by mschuster91 on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @01:58PM (#35059544)
People are sick and tired about constant news about Musk's latest crap antics, just like with Trump - basically, at least here in Europe, you can't go to bed and wake up without yet another newsflash of either a large Twitter outage or Elon Musk shitposting again.

I get why people are exhausted, but the desensitization is dangerous on its own - when there are no consequences, people escalate their behavior... and Musk already has intervened to make Starlink less usable for Ukraine. I don't want that to continue.

Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by 93po on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @02:12PM (#35059769)
> Musk already has intervened to make Starlink less usable for Ukraine.

and here you are perpetuating the fake shit about Elon that gets everyone engaged. Elon doesn't want Starlink to be directly used on weapons to kill people. Would you also fault the World Nuclear Association for being willing to provide uranium to power Ukraine, but refusing to provide the same material for nuclear bombs? He has a right to determine whether he wants his technology to be used directly for offensive war efforts. He is still providing Starlink for general military operations and communications. He just doesn't want it directly enabling weapons.

Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by mustacheemperor on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @02:18PM (#35059843)
Ukraine wants to use Starlink to make war, so when Elon intervenes to prevent the use of Starlink for certain applications in making war, he is making Starlink less usable for Ukraine.

You're raising an argument for why it is in your view justifiable for Elon to do this, but that doesn't make the basic elements of what the commenter above said false.

Nuclear weapons are far more destructive, and indiscriminately destructive, than the use of satcomms with conventional weapons, so I think that choice of comparison is hyperbolic and unreasonable. This seems more like Garmin sending GPS units to Ukraine but refusing them to be issued to tanks, and as much as Elon has the right to determine the use of the technology his firm is donating to Ukraine, people have the right to criticize his choice to do that. Ukrainians will die because of this decision, and it is fair for people to criticize the choices that lead to that result.

Edit: I can't reply any further so I will just reiterate in reply here. Ukraine is using starlink for war, so making starlink unusable for weapons is making it less usable for Ukraine's use case, defending their country from invasion. How you choose to morally equivocate the invaders to the defenders is your decision, but it doesn't make what the commenter above said "fake" and it doesn't insulate Elon from criticism over his own decision.

Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by 93po on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @02:25PM (#35059927)
It's not "less usable for Ukraine". It's working perfectly fine for Ukraine and Elon is going through massive efforts to ensure this. It's less usable for weapons. What the parent comment said was outright misleading to the point of basically being a lie.

> Ukrainians will die because of this decision

And Russians would die if he made the other decision. Even if Russia is on the wrong side here, killing a bunch of 20 year old soldiers while they sit around in mud doesn't help much. They're still humans and I also wouldn't want any part in killing humans.

Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by KptMarchewa on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:50AM (#35069602)
>It's working perfectly fine for Ukraine

No, because Ukraine needs to kill russians and destroy their war machine. Musk's actions prevents this.

>And Russians would die if he made the other decision.

Great!

Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by mustacheemperor on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @02:34PM (#35073686)
>Even if Russia is on the wrong side here, killing a bunch of 20 year old soldiers while they sit around in mud doesn't help much

Ah, I can reply now. You added this to your reply after I made my edit to my own comment responding to your earlier remarks, so I'll make my additional reply directly here.

This view of war reads like naivete to me - the naivete that can develop if you've only learned about war on TV and on Wikipedia, from far away where everything is abstract. I would invite you to talk to some veterans of war, victims of invasion, refugees from combat zones, and consider revising your perspective.

My in-laws who fled century-old farms in face of an invading army would strongly disagree with your view on what would or would not help end this war. Abstract moral relativism over individual soldiers hasn't saved any children from being kidnapped to Russia.

Assuming you enjoy a comfortable existence in a first world country, you unfortunately play an indirect part in killing humans every day. Our first world system drives less fortunate humans towards death every day to operate, and the people who really, deeply do not want any part in that are spending their lives working for the less fortunate in places outside the first world. But by advocating against the measures Ukraine could use to defend itself, you are playing your own part in allowing Russia to continue mounting a bloodthirsty war of conquest.

Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by walrus01 on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @02:48PM (#35060233)
> Elon doesn't want Starlink to be directly used on weapons to kill people

The starlink "star shield" program with the US DoD says otherwise. Every satellite company wants a piece of the DOD's many billions a year spent on geostationary and other services, launches.

Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by Thlom on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @05:16PM (#35075509)
Military has been and always will be the milking cow for satcom operators. Every single satcom operator in the world is squeezing as much money from military contracts as possible. But usually they buy satellite capacity wholesale and lands the traffic on their own line cards in the teleport and is not using what can only be described as a consumer service. Maybe the allied countries should help Ukraine get proper satcom so they are not at the mercy of Musk whims.
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by wedn3sday on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @03:21PM (#35060634)
>> He has a right to determine whether he wants his technology to be used directly for offensive war efforts.

Perhaps this is laudable if true, however I havent seen this actually used in any justification for not allowing the use of starlink (by people involved, not internet commentators). Its also a bit of a stretch to call anything the Ukrainians do here as "offensive war efforts" when they're defending themselves from annihilation. Who-invaded-who is kind of an important part of this story.

Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by djmashko2 on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @03:23PM (#35060660)
Pretty disappointing to see all of these stories being dropped from the front page.
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by dang on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @04:03PM (#35061177)
They were flagged—correctly—by users. More at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35060935.
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by bmitc on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @04:08PM (#35061238)
One of the posted articles had nothing to do with Elon Musk. It still got flagged. So I disagree that it was flagged correctly.
Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by dang on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @04:09PM (#35061260)
It has everything to do with the current rage drama ̶,̶ ̶a̶s̶ ̶e̶v̶e̶r̶y̶o̶n̶e̶ ̶k̶n̶o̶w̶s̶.

One test for this would be: is the discussion substantially different in that thread? The answer is clearly no.

Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by bmitc on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @04:19PM (#35061401)
Is there not a distinction between the post and the discussion? Because ...

> It has everything to do with the current rage drama, as everyone knows.

no, I didn't know that until there was a comment about it and another post on Hacker News. The discussion I saw seemed within reason.

Re:Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site by dang on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @04:28PM (#35061512)
You're right—sorry! I've scratched that bit now (it wasn't necessary anyhow)