News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by consumer451 on Friday March 03, 2023 @04:17PM (#35015121)
I found this answer pretty interesting:

> DavidGan1x

> I seem to remember seeing the transcripts for the Baroque Cycle were all handwritten. Are you still handwriting your books and if so, what advantages do you think it has over using a computer?

> NealStephenson

> Mostly handwritten, yes. It's slower, and so each sentence spends longer in the buffer before it gets written out, so first draft quality is higher.

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by boomboomsubban on Friday March 03, 2023 @05:22PM (#35015846)
I find the combination of using emacs daily with handwriting his books bizarre. I'm sure it's that he separates the two activities, but it's funny to go "OK, I'm going to abandon the super optimized text editor I'm using to go write text for my job."
Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by lelandfe on Friday March 03, 2023 @05:30PM (#35015934)
People are funny. I have an awesome to-do tracking setup, with everything I need bound to global hotkeys.

Yet I still find myself reaching for my legal notepad to scrawl out rough ideas.

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by vorpalhex on Friday March 03, 2023 @06:12PM (#35016279)
Yup, same here. I have the best note taking and task management apps money can buy (imo) but I still use dot grid legal pads for many things. I find I use the two sets of tools very differently, despite seeming redundant on the surface.
Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by ploum on Friday March 03, 2023 @06:46PM (#35016538)
I’m myself a writer, geek and my hobby is developing free software. I do every text/blog post in Neovim, including emails with Neomutt. I do everything in console. Using the bépo layout (which is dvorak for French).

I write my books, my journal and my zettelkasten with an Azerty mechanical typewriter.

I think I do really understand his philosophy…

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by nerpderp82 on Friday March 03, 2023 @08:22PM (#35017184)
Is it a version of the Knuth airgap? Single tasking with few distractions?
Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by kbenson on Friday March 03, 2023 @08:49PM (#35017323)
There could be many things working at once. Constraints often yield surprising benefits through innovation or forcing things to be distilled to the core important bits. In Stephenson's case, if he happens to record core info and not necessarily the full sentence he will write, which he can then finagle the right structure and prose for later, maybe that allows for better flow.

If that's indeed what he's doing, it might be like writing pseudo-code and then going back and translating it into the programming language medium of choice. The benefit of writing in a journal is that it's probably easier to do on a sunny day at the beach in the sand than it would be on a laptop or tablet. Also maybe seeing old ideas crossed out on paper helps later when looking back over it to get you into the same headspace.

Sometimes we over-optimize for aspect of a task (such as getting ideas down quick) in a way that's detrimental to the process itself when we step back and look at the whole.

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by ploum on Saturday March 04, 2023 @05:41AM (#35019913)
All of that.

And the simple fact I posted the previous comment is the proof I’m procrastinating my next chapter ;-)

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by robbintt on Saturday March 04, 2023 @01:05AM (#35018625)
what is the knuth airgap?
Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by techdragon on Saturday March 04, 2023 @02:21AM (#35018961)
Donald Knuth, Turing Award winner, author of the The Art of Computer Programming, original author of the TeX computer typesetting system, and many other impressive works. Is well known for not using email. https://cs.stanford.edu/~knuth/email.html

I suspect this is what they are talk about.

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by s1artibartfast on Friday March 03, 2023 @07:44PM (#35016954)
Interesting that you find it bizarre when he clearly states his rationale. The intention is to put mechanical constraints on throughput and make it take longer.

It seems like a matter of picking the right tool for the job.

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by boomboomsubban on Friday March 03, 2023 @08:28PM (#35017212)
I can understand the rationale and still find it bizarre. I'm not criticizing his process, it's odd and unexpected to me.
Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by s1artibartfast on Friday March 03, 2023 @08:49PM (#35017321)
Thats fair. I guess I just know a lot of people who use analog or less technological methods for process/quality reasons, so it is less strange to me.
Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by consumer451 on Friday March 03, 2023 @07:48PM (#35016978)
I understand what you are getting at, but I find it more inspiring than bizarre.

I am inspired by the fact that this man is able to use the correct tool for the particular job.

I am also inspired by the self-awareness required to make such a call.

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by enneff on Friday March 03, 2023 @08:03PM (#35017061)
From previous interviews I have seen him say his process for writing those books was to hand write them for the first draft and then transcribe them into emacs as part of the editing process. Seems pretty sensible to me; get the thoughts on the page without an easy way to fuss over the exact prose, and then labour over the exact structure and phrasing later.
Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by cableshaft on Friday March 03, 2023 @06:20PM (#35016336)
I wrote my game design journals by hand for a while. I didn't find the quality to be better necessarily, but it did allow for me to draw diagrams inline whenever I needed to so it was nice for that.

And I liked that I had a physical artifact afterwards, especially since the writing had a bit of visual personality while computer text does not.

But it takes forever to write by hand. I'd spend like 8+ hours a week just writing that journal, and I'd often have a cramped hand afterwards. Still did it that way for a couple years, though. And I still like referring to them from time to time.

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by nestorD on Friday March 03, 2023 @08:48PM (#35017319)
I have heard Neil Gaiman say something similar. Writing by hand is slower and you end up having to type it which pushes you toward cutting things down and streamlining the prose.
Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by foota on Friday March 03, 2023 @09:01PM (#35017398)
Neal Stephenson must have exceptional handwriting endurance then.
Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by beambot on Saturday March 04, 2023 @02:48AM (#35019065)
Looks like average productivity for major authors is roughly 2000 words per day -- or 6-7 pages.

https://wordcounter.net/blog/2017/12/04/103207_the-daily-wor...

Michael Crichton at 10,000 words is a crazy outlier.

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by em-bee on Saturday March 04, 2023 @03:34AM (#35019267)
i can't write more than half a page without my handwriting getting sloppy. especially because it is slow, i am tempted to write faster, and soon the result becomes unreadable.

so yes, anyone doing this must have good discipline in handwriting

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by unnah on Saturday March 04, 2023 @11:14AM (#35021876)
Did you do your schoolwork on a computer? It's not that many years ago that a school exam could mean writing multiple half-page answers by hand, and you would also write multi-page essays by hand.
Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by em-bee on Saturday March 04, 2023 @01:41PM (#35023251)
no i didn't. but i never had good handwriting. and once i got out of school i was working with computers all day, so somehow it must have gotten worse since then. i think the main problem is some kind of impatience getting something written down, which i guess i developed after getting used to writing on a computer. in other words i am simply out of practice
Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by lproven on Saturday March 04, 2023 @01:47PM (#35023303)
I remember him saying in an interview long ago that he wrote with a fountain pen.

I changed countries and career paths about 8 years ago, and for a while, over the next 3 roles, it involved large amounts of note-taking. Tens of pages of notes per day, every day, for weeks at a time.

I switched to using fountain pens too, and found it hugely increased what you call "handwriting endurance". I can write for an hour or more with a fountain pen, without pain or difficulty or cramping.

(I am in my mid-50s now, and this was in my late 40s. That means that part of the time at school we had to use fountain pens. So it was a switch back for me.)

With ballpoint pens, be they cheap and nasty or premium high-quality ones, you can press hard. This tires the hands and causes cramps.

You can't do that with a fountain pen. It damages the nib. You have to press lightly on the paper and that makes you write better. It also encourages good cursive letter forms, which evolved for a sharp nib on paper, which snags in certain directions, also less of a problem for ballpoints.

I mostly use Pilot V-Pen disposable fountain pens. They are exceptionally reliable, the whole barrel is full of ink so they last much longer than a cartridge or reservoir pen, and they don't leak even in a backpack that's treated roughly.

I recommend trying them. It's worth the effort. It works.

Ballpoints, however fancy, are only for scribbling quick notes. A proper pen results in better writing, and writing better.

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by lawlorino on Saturday March 04, 2023 @02:58AM (#35019112)
This is pretty interesting, I've noticed I find it easier to recall information if I've written it down by hand instead of typing it on a computer. I wonder if it's a similar mechanism to what Neil and Neal find with writing - it means the thing you want to express spends longer in the brain's buffer and this leads to several benefits at the cost of it being slower.

Probably goes without saying I might be talking out of my arse here but it's interesting to think about.

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by maroonblazer on Friday March 03, 2023 @09:09PM (#35017438)
I love Stephenson, but I think he's deluding himself. The "buffer" is the brain. The point of writing is to get it out of the brain. Otherwise, to quote Forster: "How do I know what I think, until I see what I say."
Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by veidr on Friday March 03, 2023 @09:28PM (#35017532)
Yeah, but for me (and I think most people, although I suspect there's a lot of diversity from person to person) what comes "out of the brain" is noticeably different when writing by hand.

Most of us can type a lot faster than we can write with a pencil. I doubt it is just the difference in speed (and I think Stephenson is simplifying here, not really saying that is the only difference), but that's part of it.

A sentence written by hand has often been drafted, considered, and revised before it actually makes it to the paper. Whereas for somebody who can type, the first sentence that hits the page is often literally the first draft of it, as originally thought.

(I still cannot imagine writing an entire novel this way myself, though...)

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by sink on Friday March 03, 2023 @09:16PM (#35017472)
With all due respect, I think it's strange to critique something as deeply personal as a technique used in creative writing.
Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by maroonblazer on Friday March 03, 2023 @09:25PM (#35017512)
I'm not criticizing his technique, I'm criticizing his rationale.

If instead he'd said something like: "I just like the feel of pen to paper." Or "I've tried both pen/paper and a computer and there's something about using a computer that just doesn't work for me." that would make more sense. But this notion of a 'buffer' just doesn't.

Perhaps "deluding" was too pejorative; I'll grant that.

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by s1artibartfast on Friday March 03, 2023 @09:54PM (#35017684)
I think you are missing the point. Of course the buffer is the brain. the idea is to give the brain more time to process.

If you write a sentence per hour and a sentence per second, they will have different quality levels.

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by maroonblazer on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:54PM (#35018002)
I'm arguing that all of that processing happens prior to you picking up a pen or taking to a keyboard to write. I'm disputing the claim that there's materially more 'thinking' happening in the second or two longer it takes one to write a sentence with a pen than with a keyboard.
Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by s1artibartfast on Saturday March 04, 2023 @01:00AM (#35018605)
If you have ever sat down and written or typed for a hour straight, it will become clear that the thinking/processing wasn't all done beforehand. Thoughts can lead to new ones and flow from one to another.

Either way, in the absence of very compelling counter evidence, I'll defer to the expert opinion of the author on how their brain works

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by safety1st on Saturday March 04, 2023 @03:09AM (#35019171)
There's evidence that when you're studying something, taking notes by hand promotes long term retention of information better than typing them out. That is a case where the act of writing itself influences the thought process, and the use of one writing instrument or another influences it differently. It's wholly reasonable to believe that the choice of writing instrument may influence the thought process in other ways, too, and Stephenson has struck upon the instrument that works best for him.

Edit: the other salient concept which comes to mind is Marshall McLuhan's idea that "the medium is the message." McLuhan definitely believed that if you go and say something over broadcast media vs e.g. printed matter, what you say comes out very differently. Both the content and interpretation are influenced by the medium. He would probably agree there is a difference between typing and handwriting, too.

Edit2: there's at least one study which has found that handwriting engages more of the brain than typing does: https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/new-study-suggests-handwriting...

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by upsidesinclude on Saturday March 04, 2023 @10:30AM (#35021500)
Just give it a shot before your next reply.

It isn't something you have to do, but then it's clearly not something you do.

Re:I am Neal Stephenson, sci-fi author, geek, and [now] swor... by jakupovic on Saturday March 04, 2023 @05:07AM (#35019711)
Neal Stephenson is a product of handwritten school era. He Learned to think on paper. I am nowhere near but when I really need to learn something new or compose I reach for my notebook.