News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by twodave on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:15AM (#35010661)
I was expecting to read some story about criminal exploitation, but this sounds like it's just... completely above-board? As a few other commenters stated, the model hasn't explicitly stated whether she supports the use of the photo or not. Even if she did explicitly come out and say she doesn't like people using it, she doesn't own the rights to it.

I'm fine with (and happy for) people going above and beyond to respect someone else's dignity, but this is less about ethics and more about one person's potential regret over a business transaction. Just because you regret doing a deal doesn't mean others are unethical for benefiting from it. When you're using your own body in a business transaction (of _any kind_) you should really think through the possible consequences. Whether it's getting a tattoo or putting your kids on TV or selling photos to Playboy, those all have ramifications you won't be able to control very well later on.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by gbanfalvi on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:28AM (#35010842)
> When you're using your own body in a business transaction (of _any kind_) you should really think through the possible consequences.

Yeah, when she was modelling for playboy she should've thought "what if a nerd somewhere takes this photo of me and unknowingly turns it into a commonplace testing asset in an industry niche in 50 years that doesn't even exist in my current time?"

More seriously, the original copyright owner (the photographer? playboy?) probably didn't license it for use as a visual benchmarking asset for graphics algorithms.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by HPsquared on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:39AM (#35011000)
Does that make it the first instance of Swedish computer piracy?
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by twodave on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:44AM (#35011075)
That class of thinking is exactly what she should have considered, though I'd have phrased it more generally: "These photos will not be under my control, therefore they could show up anywhere at anytime in the future, and there's potentially nothing I can do about it."
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by dahart on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:13AM (#35011455)
Why are you doubling down on your assumption that this is about Lena without you knowing what actually happened? What makes you assume she didn’t know full well the image was not under her control? What makes you assume control over the image is even a relevant issue here?

The issue and the debate surrounding this image has almost nothing to do with how Lena feels about the image, and was neither initiated nor pursued by her. She happens to support the movement now, which does strengthen it slightly, but that’s a minor footnote, and not the driving force here.

Furthermore, the movement is not a legal action. Arguing that someone can’t do something legally about it is irrelevant. It’s always legal to ask. It is time the image be retired, so what’s wrong with saying so?

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by NovemberWhiskey on Friday March 03, 2023 @12:21PM (#35012471)
Her request is politely-phrased and reasonable. I don't think there's a legal or ethical issue, but respecting the wishes of others when it costs you nothing is just kindness.

However, the way that some have seized on it, and then interacted with others in their communities is ... neither polite nor reasonable.

e.g. https://github.com/phoboslab/qoi/issues/35

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by twodave on Friday March 03, 2023 @12:40PM (#35012727)
> Why are you doubling down on your assumption that this is about Lena without you knowing what actually happened? What makes you assume she didn’t know full well the image was not under her control? What makes you assume control over the image is even a relevant issue here?

Three loaded questions in a row. I think you're reading more into my comments than I stated or intended. I'm not assuming anything, just answering a question and pointing out that regardless of whether she thought it through or not, the the photo was not produced or distributed unethically. The title is literally "Ethically Sourced Lena Picture," which implies the original was sourced unethically. That's all I'm arguing. The words we use matter, and I'd like to be able to point out when the words don't match reality without folks thinking they need to give me a lesson in empathy.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by dahart on Friday March 03, 2023 @03:13PM (#35014434)
Hehe it’s funny to complain about perceived lessons right after saying “That class of thinking is exactly what she should have considered.”

What I think I hear you saying is you don’t like the article’s title (an article that wasn’t written or endorsed by Lena) perhaps because it implies (without stating explicitly) that the original picture was unethical. The new one can be ethically sourced without the old one being unethically sourced. It is an assumption on your part that anyone said anything about the original image being unethically “sourced”. If you want to say that words matter, it definitely makes sense to double-check if your interpretation of words is accurate, and whether you’re taking them literally or projecting assumptions, especially when you, as you’ve said, lack context.

The bigger picture here is that the “ethics” of the situation aren’t related to Lena’s choices, which you’ve assumed and claimed and stated explicitly multiple times now. The ethics in this debate are surrounding the ethical use of pinup images in educational and work settings, and is not related to the sourcing of the image specifically aside from it being published in a soft core magazine which makes it symbolic of the lack of tact when using it for scientific or educational purposes.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by twodave on Friday March 03, 2023 @06:16PM (#35016305)
Yes, you’re correct. The title sucks.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by NovemberWhiskey on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:50AM (#35011158)
>More seriously, the original copyright owner (the photographer? playboy?) probably didn't license it for use as a visual benchmarking asset for graphics algorithms.

The rights owner (Playboy, in this case) is on record saying they made a conscious choice not to enforce their rights to this image.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by danuker on Friday March 03, 2023 @03:34PM (#35014663)
Indeed, the first thing I did when I found the image as a teen was look for the rest of it.

It acts like free advertising.

Sadly it is against the model's wishes, so I'd feel bad. I will use the ethical replacement from now on.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by runjake on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:31AM (#35010873)
> As a few other commenters stated, the model hasn't explicitly stated whether she supports the use of the photo or not.

Yes, she has. It's at the bottom of linked article:

    Lena added: “I retired from modelling a long time ago. It’s time I retired from tech, too. 
    We can make a simple change today that creates a lasting change for tomorrow. Let’s commit 
    to losing me.”
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by dahart on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:49AM (#35011144)
She supports the movement (started by other people) to retire the image from tech, but she wasn’t particularly bothered by the use of the photo, she has said so in multiple interviews. “In 1988, she was interviewed by some Swedish computer related publication, and she was pleasantly amused by what had happened to her picture.” http://www.lenna.org/
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by TheCleric on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:43AM (#35011899)
Because we all know that opinions are static and can't possibly have changed over the span pf 35 years.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by dahart on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:54AM (#35012068)
Of course opinions can change. I’m not exactly sure what you’re reacting to, but are you saying that Lena’s opinion has in fact changed?

It can also be true that she is both proud of and unbothered by the image, and also supports the movement to retire it from tech because of the social implications. Both opinions can be true at the same time, right? It is not a requirement that she hold any regret for her to be in favor of scientists making more professional choices and setting a better example, right?

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by thepasswordis on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:26AM (#35010822)
She wasn't upset at the photo being used, she was upset at the idea that it could discourage women from working for a tech company.

But that isn't universally true either. This is like a conditional hypothetical. If this hypothetically this is causing women to not work for tech companies, then in that case she could hypothetically not like that.

This is somebody (the OP) trying to use a drummed up controversy to promote themselves. It's gross.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by smcl on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:51AM (#35011169)
I don't think Morten is trying to promote himself any more than any post on a personal blog is, humorous or otherwise. It's not like he is trying to springboard into a modelling career or anything.

To me it seems that he doesn't seriously believe his photo will become the new "Lena", but he is still making a very clear statement: "you can use any other image, in fact here is one that is a drop-in replacement, it has a similar aspect ratio, style and colour balance to the original. You have no excuses now, move on like Lena asked."

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by zzo38computer on Friday March 03, 2023 @06:20PM (#35016337)
> you can use any other image, in fact here is one that is a drop-in replacement, it has a similar aspect ratio, style and colour balance to the original.

OK, so those similar things, can be helpful. Also it is available in sizes bigger than 512x512, which is also something that was criticized that Lena picture is not bigger than 512x512. However, looking at the pictures, the colours do not really look like similar to me. Also, in the suggested new picture, it look like someone else in the background of the picture too.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by mLuby on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:27AM (#35010833)
May I suggest more empathy for your fellow humans?

We aren't good at weighing long-term consequences, especially when we're young (as in the model's case) or in financial need (IDK if that was a factor here; it wouldn't surprise me).

Contracts between parties of such unequal bargaining power can't be ethically valid IMO, whatever legally validity they may claim.

Likewise, 20y+ contracts involving individuals aren't wise. (Fine for organizations like businesses and governments though.)

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by NovemberWhiskey on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:38AM (#35010978)
You need to consider the possibility that this isn't actually the predominant mores of our society - which sticks closer to "you should stand by your agreements" than "agreements between parties of unequal bargaining power are invalid".

To bring your two examples together: I don't think it's a commonly shared opinion that 30 year mortgages are unethical.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by twodave on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:38AM (#35010986)
May I instead suggest avoiding asking loaded questions? Nothing I said precludes me from having compassion for this person. My point is that it's just not an ethical concern.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by O__________O on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:36AM (#35010952)
>> Fine for organizations like businesses and governments though.

Curious, would it be possible for you to expand on this?

To me, if anything, one generation committing to a future that another will be responsible for is just as ethically problematic, if not more, given the overall impact.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by HPsquared on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:43AM (#35011053)
Anyone getting married, buying a house or having children enters into a long contract, often at a relatively young age. Are those unwise? (It's arguably the case today, I suppose)
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by wahnfrieden on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:19AM (#35010722)
you're confused between what's legally permitted vs what's ethical. something being legal doesn't prevent anyone from protesting or doing something about it, even if they had accepted a legal risk.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by NovemberWhiskey on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:22AM (#35010775)
What's the moral principle at stake here that drives this into the ethical domain?
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by ip26 on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:36AM (#35010950)
Privacy? I don’t know, I’m not a legal scholar, but it seems clear to me that if someone wants old pictures of themselves removed from circulation, it is ethical to consider it.

Our legal and ethical systems both try to avoid permanently chaining you to decisions you regret.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by sllabres on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:50AM (#35011154)
I haven't read about the background story and the new website but I hadn't thought that she thinks so especially I have read [1] some years ago. But as said I don't know the new developments regarding the famous photo.

[1] https://www.wired.com/story/finding-lena-the-patron-saint-of...

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by abofh on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:24AM (#35010796)
Consent
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by daneel_w on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:28AM (#35010835)
Whose consent? The model's, who never owned the rights to the photograph, or Playboy who does? Both parties gave consent to a million readers across the world to see the full picture.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by CharlesW on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:38AM (#35010969)
This is not how photo licensing works. Photos don't magically become public domain because they've been published. There was never any license for it to be re-published and re-distributed in the context of test imagery.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by throw009 on Friday March 03, 2023 @06:01PM (#35016203)
So you're saying that we must ethically source images because it hurts playboys bottom line.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by daneel_w on Saturday March 04, 2023 @10:08AM (#35021285)
The "turmoil" around the use of this image was never about legality, licensing or royalties. By agreeing to the contract, and by publishing the picture, the publisher and the model gave their "social consent" for everyone to see it. In a fit of moralism the model had a change of mind about the picture; but likely not about her economic gain.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by bobleeswagger on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:29AM (#35010850)
What does consent have to do with a commercial photo shoot in a public magazine?
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by thfuran on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:24AM (#35010795)
There doesn't have to be one in this specific case for their claim to be true.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by twodave on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:22AM (#35010765)
I don't agree, since she was paid (and presumably she could attempt to buy the rights back if she felt really passionate about this). An example of an actual ethics issue would be e.g. the NCAA barring athletes from profiting from their name, image and likeness for so long.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by nemo44x on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:27AM (#35010829)
Aren't most of "ethics" just concepts created by existing power structures to justify and maintain their legitimacy? Does loading your opinion with "ethics" make it any more valid?
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by wahnfrieden on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:32AM (#35010888)
it's more about whether you respect someone's ability to have their own ethics, not which one is more correct. OP says the person's thoughts should be dismissed as irrelevant because of IP ownership law imposed by the state.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by luckylion on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:49AM (#35011151)
She's been a model for much of her life, presumably making a good living from being the face of Kodak ads. It's doubtful that she doesn't believe in IP ownership law, given that she's actively used it to make money.

Additionally, she seems to have changed her mind in 2019. At the beginning of the year, she was "really proud of that picture", at the end of the year she asked for it to be retired. I guess some activists talked her into being a victim all those years.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by drabbiticus on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:43AM (#35011901)
I wouldn't be surprised if in certain social groups or contexts there are people who choose to toss the word "ethics" around very loosely and completely incorrectly. However, there is an entire serious study of ethics and ethical frameworks that is not simply about reinforcement of existing power structures and I would encourage you to broaden your education.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by nemo44x on Friday March 03, 2023 @06:45PM (#35016535)
Of course. But self apparent ethics are used a lot to justify arbitrary things.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by metalforever on Monday March 06, 2023 @08:07PM (#35050163)
Hi, I saw your other post about the co op programming collective . I'm having some of the same feelings and i was hoping you would want to tell me about that . If you do , hit me up on discord at metalforever#4052
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by dahart on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:45AM (#35011080)
> this is less about ethics and more about one person’s potential regret over a business transaction.

Why do you believe this, and do you have any evidence to support this claim? Are you not aware of the history of this image?

“Retiring Lena as an image used in coding goes beyond copyright, consent or ethics. It is a required step to help women feel more welcome in tech.” https://pursuit.unimelb.edu.au/articles/it-s-time-to-retire-...

I don’t believe that Lena herself has expressed regret over the business transaction, nor was she even bothered much by the use of the image in tech. I believe I read that Playboy considered action on copyright grounds, but decided not to pursue them. You can verify these things via many sources, the link above contains several, as well as the Wikipedia article on this image. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lenna#Criticism

This is neither about Lena’s choices nor is it about protecting her dignity. It’s about our choices and protecting our dignity.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by twodave on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:06AM (#35011375)
Evidence? Why would I need any? There is no unethical origin of that photo, as the article claims there is. The burden isn't on me to prove non-existence, that's silly.

But fair enough, I've clearly missed a bit of context. I think my overall point still stands, though. Though I personally think calling that cropped photo "pornographic" is a stretch, it's not an image I would have selected or personally find appropriate. Truthfully, I didn't even realize it was from Playboy until I clicked a link in the article. It's still not a question of ethical origins vs not.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by beepbooptheory on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:24AM (#35011626)
In general, try and do some minimal research about the topic you are commenting on before coming in and speaking with authority about what is or isn't the case, especially about something somewhat sensitive and (unfortunately in this case) politically charged. It helps keep the quality of the conversations here somewhat acceptable, and promotes intellectual rigor and curiosity where its needed most. Its not a huge deal, but it can make a big difference.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by twodave on Friday March 03, 2023 @12:54PM (#35012885)
I never spoke with any authority. I'm just another name on the Internet. In my originally comment I intentionally didn't speak in concrete terms about whether it's appropriate or not for that photo to be used (I actually personally believe it isn't appropriate). I simply stated based on my reading (which was enough to satisfy me that Lena Sodersburg wasn't exploited by Playboy) that the photo isn't unethically-sourced as the article title implies, and that that fact doesn't actually hinge on whether she changed her mind later or not or whether people have a problem with its use today or not. I'd suggest you read my actual words and not try to attach more meaning than there really is.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by dahart on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:17AM (#35011520)
You assumed and claimed falsely that Lena regrets the “business transaction” with the photo. I asked for evidence of that. You claimed this wasn’t about ethics and framed it as only about Lena. I asked for evidence of that. You could maybe use some evidence on account of my belief that your claims above are not true.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by twodave on Friday March 03, 2023 @12:44PM (#35012776)
That's not true. I qualified the statement with "potentially" because I don't know whether she regrets it or not. The article title implies the image was sourced unethically, and my whole point was whether she regrets the photo or not today has nothing to do with whether it was of ethical origins.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by dahart on Friday March 03, 2023 @03:32PM (#35014638)
Your top comment is making assumptions with or without the qualification. Even the suggestion that there’s “potential” regret is an assumption. It’s fair for me to point this out since I already knew that wasn’t true, there was no such potential.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by twodave on Friday March 03, 2023 @06:13PM (#35016285)
Well, at least we are speaking the same language, finally. Only I think we just genuinely disagree on some definitions. To me, it could be written “unethical to use in a professional setting” and I’d agree wholeheartedly. To me, this is the crux of my comments—where they got the image has little to do with how and to whom it is displayed. I’ll clarify further by saying the only reason I mentioned regret vs not is in connection with that word “source” and had less to do with the specific situation.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by chasing on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:46AM (#35011104)
People who sell photos of their bodies should be allowed to make ethical arguments or have opinions outside the narrow confines of their contracts. Even if those pictures are naked pictures.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by twodave on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:14AM (#35011475)
They can. It still doesn't make the use or origin of those photos unethical.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by jtriangle on Friday March 03, 2023 @05:26PM (#35015880)
The picture is not a naked picture, it is a crop of a photo in which the subject is naked, but cropped in such a way that does not portray any nudity.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by chasing on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:52AM (#35011195)
> Just because you regret doing a deal doesn't mean others are unethical for benefiting from it.

Everything else aside, this is simply inaccurate. Contractual deals can totally be unethical for all sorts of reasons. When there’s an extreme power imbalance, for example. As one might see between a very young woman and a large and powerful company.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by twodave on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:12AM (#35011442)
I didn't say it _can't be_ unethical. I just said it isn't necessarily. Ethics is a fairly narrow definition, and I'm not sure you can apply it as broadly as, "Anytime one party has leverage over another, there's an ethics violation." I'd be willing to consider it, but in this case I don't see where anybody's wishes were explicitly violated or any contract was executed in bad faith...
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by iaseiadit on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:04AM (#35011359)
The image is offensive because, as an photo sourced from a “men’s magazine”, it’s a reminder that mostly men worked on developing image compression and jpeg technology in the past, and this could make women feel left out or uncomfortable today. Seems motivated by political correctness, not any actual injustice, but perhaps it is time for a new image after this many years.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by peyton on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:21AM (#35011586)
It’s pretty misinformed to suggest mostly men worked on JPEG technology.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by bee_rider on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:58AM (#35012140)
Could you inform us? This seems interesting!
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by pseudalopex on Friday March 03, 2023 @09:36PM (#35017563)
> The image is offensive because, as an photo sourced from a “men’s magazine”, it’s a reminder that mostly men worked on developing image compression and jpeg technology in the past, and this could make women feel left out or uncomfortable today.

Where did you get this idea? The continued use of the image in professional contexts discomforts people because the photo and the magazine were created for men's sexual interests. And there is little technical reason to use it now.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by drabbiticus on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:32AM (#35011729)
It feels like you and many other commenters have missed the broad general point to focus on the proverbial trees. I am replying to this comment because it is at the top of the HN comments at the time of this reply.

It is a part of computing history that computer scientists at a respected educational institution chose to use a cropped version of a nude Playboy image as part of a test suite for the development of JPEG. Part of that history is that in the 1970s someone felt it was appropriate to openly bring a copy of Playboy into the office and the response to that was to use something from it for an image test suite [1]. You are personally welcome to feel about it however you will.

However, many women are stating that the continued inclusion of a Lena image in test suites and as an important part of computing history makes them feel unwelcomed in tech spaces. As a hypothetical, perhaps you are a straight male. Imagine for a moment that computer science was instead historically dominated by gay men, and that they had decided to use images from gay pornography as part of the JPEG test suite. Suppose that gay men continued to be highly represented within the computer science workforce, and that in order to learn about JPEG compression, you also had to be confronted by those images in a computer science lecture hall in 2023 while surrounded as a straight individual by a room full of gay men. Suppose you hear even one classmate who feels comfortable, in this professional setting, commenting that "they could use some company like that around here" and hearing a few classmates chuckle around that.

Computing and computing literacy are such useful skills today. There are a myriad of tasks where even basic programming literacy would allow you to automate things and make you more efficient in your endeavors. More broadly as a society, we are leveraging machine learning models in so many contexts, and these have been shown to encode the societal biases which were present in their training sets. Representation across all axes of identity allow everyone an equal footing to advance in this technical skillset and also increases the chances that we identify when computing technologies are encoding bias in harmful ways. These women are saying that there are many things which can be done to improve the representation of women within tech spaces, and that removing Lena from curriculums and test suites does zero technical harm while increasing inclusivity. That is the ethical judgement at stake - to what extent do our current practices harm inclusivity and affect the likelihood of encoding harmful biases in the technology we develop now and in the future?

[minor point - if you are a legal stickler, use of the Lena image was also done in infringement of copyright. This is such a non-point in the actual discussion of the campaign, but it seems like a lot of comments basically fall along the line of "this is legal so whatever" and if you want to argue on this perceived technicality, it isn't even correct.]

[1] http://www.lenna.org/pcs_mirror/may_june01.pdf

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by chillingeffect on Friday March 03, 2023 @12:20PM (#35012455)
>Imagine for a moment that computer science was instead historically dominated by gay men, and that they had decided to use images from gay pornography as part of the JPEG test suite.

Mott and Bailey. This image is not pornography. It's a tasteful head shot. You're introducing any discussion of pornography.

>[minor point - if you are a legal stickler, use of the Lena image was also done in infringement of copyright.

If you are a legal stickler, or even just support basic rights, fair use is integral to the research process. [1]

[1] https://lib.asu.edu/news/research/why-does-fair-use-matter-r...

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by drabbiticus on Friday March 03, 2023 @01:19PM (#35013184)
> Mott and Bailey. This image is not pornography. It's a tasteful head shot. You're introducing any discussion of pornography.

Mott and Bailey. I can also name drop logical fallacies to no purpose. This image, though cropped, is from Playboy and the full image features a clearly nude women shot from the back and exposing her buttocks. Your quibble over a specific categorization again misses the forest for the trees. Women are saying that this image makes them feel uncomfortable due to its origins, and there is no technical reason that it needs to remain in the test set or the curricula. There are many suitable alternatives that would not have this problem.

>>[minor point - if you are a legal stickler, use of the Lena image was also done in infringement of copyright. > > If you are a legal stickler, or even just support basic rights, fair use is integral to the research process. [1]

Honestly the smart thing to do here is to not engage with your point, as again, it is minor and not actually relevant to the thrust of the conversation. If you want to treat my decision to not push further into this as a moral win, enjoy it.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by chillingeffect on Saturday March 04, 2023 @12:27PM (#35022587)
You are obviously quite wrapped around the axle here. Though you may not like it, the logical fallacy applies here as you're the one introducing criteria that make people feel bad. The full image is not something here in the room with us. It's something in your mind that you're transmitting to everyone else to help you come with the world.

If you and everyone would else would stop running around traumatizing people, "HEY this picture makes me feel bad and it should make you feel bad, too," we'd all feel a lot better. But just a suggestion: perhaps you would feel a lot better if you examined why this picture triggers you so badly? What is it inside you that makes you react so strongly? Did your family have moral issues about women getting money from men for showing their bodies off?

> it is minor and not actually relevant to the thrust of the conversation.

You brought it up, "Doc"! Another perfect example of a Mott and Bailey. Again, look into your personal psychology and family system. Narcissistic projection like this is a typical symptom of a crummy upbringing. In short, learn what things you can change (yourself) and what things you can not change (A woman's decision 50 years ago to get money for images of her body). Taking care of your "stuff" will make you a lot less reactive and more persuasive.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by drabbiticus on Saturday March 04, 2023 @01:04PM (#35022932)
> You are obviously quite wrapped around the axle here

I have a viewpoint and I am expressing it, in accordance with free speech. I'm sorry that my viewpoint make you "feel bad". I'm sorry that you had such a strong reaction to this image of the author, published in their own expression of free speech. Everyone could use a bit of self-examination, and I would suggest that some examination of why this article has led to such an emotional response in yourself is similarly worthwhile. Your personal attacks on my "narcissistic projection", "crummy upbringing" and being "wrapped around the axle" only serve to heighten the emotional stakes of the argument and are not a discussion of the relative merits of the issue.

I have no qualms about sex work and find stigmatization of such work distasteful. Nonetheless, a society in which women are being policed for their wardrobe in a professional settings and also confronted with images sourced from erotica in a professional setting is hypocritical. Many women are saying that this image is unwelcoming and that they feel it is exclusionary. Playboy is exclusionary and explicitly stated in its first issue that it was not for women, and it's very hard to argue that the Playboy centerfolds were not intended in large part to cater to a male fantasy. They are saying that an action can be taken which does no technical harm to the merits of JPEG compression technology and would have appreciable gains from an inclusionary standpoint.

Again, I'm sorry that them expressing their viewpoint is so distasteful to you and has evoked this response in you.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by chillingeffect on Sunday March 05, 2023 @02:23PM (#35032975)
ah, "I know you are but what am I" ...Whatever!

> I would suggest that some examination of why this article has led to such an emotional response in yourself is similarly worthwhile.

Honestly I care so little I literally passed out, but I did inquire into myself as to why I even bothered writing back to you. And you know what came up? I feel bad for the people in your life who have to put up with you. And then I realized you're not hiding behind your keyboard when you talk to them, using an obvious troll account on HN like you are, just look at your post history.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by drabbiticus on Monday March 06, 2023 @05:02AM (#35039264)
Time and time again, you resort to name-calling and insults rather than focus on issues. You call into question my character and integrity rather than grapple with the issue or argument. You use logical fallacy terminology with limited understanding of their actual structure and misapply them in argumentation.

You may be a kind and intellectually considered person in other aspects of your life, but this is not an example. May kindness find you, may people give you grace, and may you be a source of warmth to others.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by chillingeffect on Monday March 06, 2023 @11:27AM (#35042924)
Yeah, I challenge you to list my supposed name-calling... besides you "Doc," heh.

And I challenge you to list the insults... I'll wait! Anyway, you're presupposing I'm using those to win some kind of argument... which underscores you projecting your lack of comprehension surrounding logical fallacies onto me.

And obvious troll is obvious. A 9 year old account with 17 karma. You just dip into this account t o be nasty without anyone knowing who you are. Look at your history: no other comments, no submissions, just one favorite, this thread here, so you can spew vile without getting recognized by the rest of the world.

You asked me to look into what drove me to write what I did, and I did just that and you overlooked it, saying I'm calling into question your character and integrity. But that's outside the scope of any "issue" or argument. I'm done talking about that with you. I'm just following up on what you're requesting and you're trying to turn it back on me.

>logical fallacy terminology

sorry for the big words? maybe look them up?

> You may be a kind and intellectually considered person in other aspects of your life, but this is not an example.

I'm not required to be kind to everyone all the time and certainly not to an HN troll. Delete your account and get real.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by drabbiticus on Monday March 06, 2023 @06:31PM (#35049372)
Your response is utterly baffling and I feel as though I am in some sort of parody.

>sorry for the big words? maybe look them up?

It's not that I don't understand the motte and bailey fallacy, it's that you are misapplying when discussing my posts. In a motte and bailey, the person making an argument would like to advance controversial claim B, but when B is attacked, they will defend claim A while continuing to advance or believe claim B. A is generally a non-controversial and trivial statement. What do you believe is the motte, and what do you believe is the bailey in my argument?

I have chosen at times to focus on what I believe is the main issue, namely that there is an ethical question around inclusivity and the ways in which it shapes access to and development of future technology. This is the argument I am advancing, and one that is informed by a compassionate desire to believe people who say that something makes them feel excluded. If I choose not to be derailed by quibbles over technicalities of categorization that do not change the fundamental nature of my claim, that is not a motte and bailey.

A more correct use of motte and bailey could be easily applied to your own arguments. Your motte A is that a digital image is a collection of pixels, and that any context, history or provenance is something that people bring with them. Your bailey B is that context, history and and provenance should have no bearing on whether people feel excluded or on administrative decisions surrounding images. A does not imply B, yet you repeatedly use A to defend B.

> You just dip into this account t o be nasty without anyone knowing who you are

Can you give an example of where I have been nasty? I literally wished good things for you in the last post and have done my best at every point in this conversation to turn the other cheek. In contrast, you have - insulted my "crummy upbringing" - called into question the "moral issues" of my family - have argued I am "running around traumatizing people" - characterized my statements as "narcissistic projection" repeatedly

>You asked me to look into what drove me to write what I did, and I did just that and you overlooked it >Honestly I care so little I literally passed out, but I did inquire into myself as to why I even bothered writing back to you. And you know what came up? I feel bad for the people in your life who have to put up with you. And then I realized you're not hiding behind your keyboard when you talk to them, using an obvious troll account on HN like you are, just look at your post history.

Your conclusion is that what drove you to write these posts is that you feel bad for people who have to put up with me. I can only comment that there is a failure of self-reflection occurring.

>And obvious troll is obvious. A 9 year old account with 17 karma

This is my main, I'm just not very active on HN. People do have a range of behaviors, and even though you appear very active on this alt account of yours, I am not similarly active or engaged with this site despite this being my main. Very often, I am happy to learn from the interesting conversations without feeling a need to comment on my own. Your assumption that the account on which I am posting is an alt is a projection of your own desire to separate your views on the "chillingeffect"[1] from your main. In general, it feels as though you have trouble acknowledging that people have habits and views which diverge from your own, and in this case have reacted with anger rather than intellectual curiosity.

>I'm not required to be kind to everyone all the time and certainly not to an HN troll. Delete your account and get real.

I really truly believe that you would benefit from discussing this thread with someone you trust in a safe space. That could be a domestic partner, a family member, a councilor, a priest, or a co-worker. Just someone whose judgement and morals you admire. Someone who will understand that one interaction does not define the entirety of your identity and who believes in your innate goodness. Give it some time to cool off and come down from the feelings of anger that you are expressing here, and be the person you want to see in the world.

It may be helpful for you to consider this excerpt from Psychology Today:

|The precursor of anger in mammals is a perception of vulnerability plus threat. The more vulnerable people and animals feel, the more threat is perceived. The function of anger is to protect vulnerability and neutralize threat.

|In humans, the threat is almost always to the ego (how we want to think of ourselves and have others think of us). Anger neutralizes ego-threat by devaluing, demeaning, or undermining the confidence of the person perceived to be threatening.

[1] https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/897/chilling-ef...

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by throw009 on Friday March 03, 2023 @05:59PM (#35016192)
> As a hypothetical, perhaps you are a straight male. Imagine for a moment that computer science was instead historically dominated by gay men, and that they had decided to use images from gay pornography as part of the JPEG test suite.

If a straight man was to complain about too much gayness in the work place it would be a hate crime.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by drabbiticus on Friday March 03, 2023 @06:44PM (#35016522)
I'm sorry that you feel that way.

In this hypothetical situation where straight men had historically struggled to break into the ranks of successful computer scientists, it's likely that gay men would similarly feel that if they were to complain about too much straightness in the work place it would be a hate crime.